Once upon a time, PA honored the Florida non-resident permit. I even wrote to the AG and actually got a signed letter in response. I need to find it and scan it into my computer. They have since changed the reciprocity agreement.
Based on the current law, you should be able to get your PA CCW license without much trouble.
Asking your PD is the best way to make sure you enter the right code on your application. However, that is not the list you need from everything I can find, you need the list of municipal court codes. Both Toms River (1507) which I personally verified with PD and Manchester from the last post are correct in this list.