Anyone's entire handgun line up all the same caliber?

[sroc112 24]

I have been looking around for a new .45 caliber gun but really having trouble finding one that i love. It seems all the guns i like are only in 9mm with the occasional coming in .40 as well. Im on the fence of just giving in and getting one of the 9mm that i like, but that would then mean my 3 handguns would be all the same caliber, 9mm.

 

Anyone here have a collection that consists of all the same caliber? I do really like the handful of 9mms that i have been looking at and know i will enjoy it. Just dont want to regret not getting a .45. (Selling the one .45 that i do have)

[InFamous 311]

All of mine are in 9mm. H&K P7 PSP, H&K VP9, S&W 9 Shield. Also my wife's EAA Witness Pavona is also 9mm. The next handgun I buy though will most likely be a 1911 in .45 or a .357 revolver. 

[Malice4you 627]

My collection is currently 4 different (handgun) calibers (2x .22 [does that count?], 3x 9mm, 1x .40, and 1x .45).  While I enjoy the variety, I will say it would be nice to have a single caliber so I could stockpile just that one.  That said, I highly doubt I will ever get down to a single handgun caliber - I like having options - if anything, I'm hoping to add at least a 10mm and perhaps eventually 5.7x28.

 

One thing I remember from the panic - 9mm [and to a lesser extent, .45] was fairly hard to come by at a reasonable price (at least locally), while I saw .40, .357sig, and 10mm were at least in stock (or stuck around longer).  If you consolidate and there's another shortage, might crimp your style if you don't reload or don't have a big stockpile.

[TokenEntry 293]

My collection consists of two calibers, 9mm and 45 ACP.

 

9 mm:

Glock 19 - 2nd gen

Beretta 92 FS SS

45 ACP:

Colt 1911 SS - 70 Series

HK Mark 23

 

Regards,

 

TokenEntry

[fatty 241]

9mm and 45acp for me as well

 

a P226 and a 1911

[The_Matrix 105]

I have too many calibers.  Its a headache to keep track, but well worth the headache 

[GRIZ 3,369]

I have about 9 or 10 different calibers of handguns. Different calibers for different things. A 357 Magnum is about the best do it all caliber IMO.

[Krdshrk 3,877]

Mine was all 9mm, then I got a .22LR... then I got a .38/.357 revolver... and then a .40 S&W Slide/Barrel for one of my 9mm's.... but past that, no other major calibers.

[MartyZ 692]

I have VP9(9mm), USP 45(.45), and S&W 686-4(.357). Sold the 96A1(.40), just wasn't crazy about it. My next purchases will be a S&W 629(.44) and another USP 45 or HK45 or a VP45 if H&K ever makes one. I love .45 and need to get more. I like having multiple calibers but if you notice the theme here, I do have some brand loyalty

[maintenanceguy 510]

.22lr, .22mag, .380, .9mm, .45lc.

 

I see nothing wrong with buying all the same caliber.  The guns I happened to like were different calibers but if I liked guns that all came in 9mm, I see no problem.

[InFamous 311]

My original thought process when first starting out was to keep all the same caliber but each gun has a different use. This would just cut down on what I'd have to stockpile as far as ammo is concerned. Now that I have the basic "needs" or uses covered, I feel I can and will branch out to different calibers and get the mainstays first (1911 .45 and .357). Then who knows...maybe a .380 pocket pistol? 10mm? Also considering .22LR handgun. 

[PK90 3,570]

30+ firearms in 20+ calibers

 

Sent from an undisclosed location via Tapatalk.

[InFamous 311]

I think it's obvious that the more firearms you own the more variation you will have in your caliber line up. I'm assuming he's asking those with less the 5 or so handguns if they're all the same. I would expect anyone with 10+ handguns to have multiple calibers. Maybe the OP can specify a bit more but that's just my take.

[JohnnyB 4,322]

.22 .25 .380 .38 .357 9mm .40 .44. .45

I believe in diversity!

[Zeke 5,504]

The bad about same caliber as wife.

"Wtf are all me booolits?"

[InFamous 311]

The bad about same caliber as wife.

"Wtf are all me booolits?"

That's a good problem to have lol

[capt14k 2,052]

I don't think I have 2 that are the same. Sold .41 RF due to ammo cost. Have .22, .25, .32 short, 7.62x25, .380, .357, 9mm, .40, and .45. Want to add 10mm and .44 magnum.

 

 

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

[T Bill 649]

Only one caliber is dumb.  Cut back to 6 a while ago, but considering adding one possibly two in the future. Kinda against my religion, but I can see reasons.  

[InFamous 311]

Only one caliber is dumb.  Cut back to 6 a while ago, but considering adding one possibly two in the future. Kinda against my religion, but I can see reasons.  

Dumb for who though. People with 1-3 handguns or people with around 10? I can see keeping same caliber for a few guns but I agree when you get over a few you should branch out. Calling it dumb as a blanket statement doesn't make sense IMO.

[oldguysrule649 397]

Besides a M&P 22 and Ruger GP100 22lr, I have three Glocks, a G26, G19, and a G34 MOS; all stock 9mm. Availability and cost of ammo, the need to stockpile only a few calibers, interchangability of magazines and parts, etc were all considerations in my choices.

[Purple Patrick 638]

I try to keep simple 9/357 and I just picked up a 45 because everyone needs a 1911 in 45

 

this signature exceeds the 15 character capacity count

[YankeeSC 1,204]

I started with 9mm and like the idea of variety so now I am looking for a .45, as .40 just seems too close to 9mm to be much of a variety ... however Krdshrk got me thinking that it would be easy and relatively inexpensive to get a .40 barrel/slide for my M&P ...hmmm ... does that mean it can take a .40 magazine as well?   after I get the .45 I am thinking a compact 9mm.

[Slab Sides 20]

I'd have all 45's but no one wants to buy my 9mm.

[Ricky_Bobby 130]

My collection consists of two calibers, 9mm and 45 ACP.

 

9 mm:

Glock 19 - 2nd gen

Beretta 92 FS SS

45 ACP:

Colt 1911 SS - 70 Series

HK Mark 23

 

Regards,

 

TokenEntry

 

 

^This - me as well - I have no use for .40, .357sig, etc - I have a Glock 19, 26, Walther PPQ, a 1911, and my upcoming Sig P320 in .45 -

 

I also have a Taurus .357 Model 605 revolver - but 9mm and .45 are my 2 main staples - If I were to add another .38/.357, maybe a S&W, Desert Eagle (LOL), maybe a Bond Arms derringer, but as of now it remains my odd duck as I'm sticking with the other 2 calibers, definitely not adding another semiautomatic caliber when I can get everything I want and need in 9mm and .45ACP

 

[NJGF 375]

.22 .25 .380 .38 .357 9mm .40 .44. .45

I believe in diversity!

 

I too believe in diversity and I am also a globalist: Austria, Germany, Israel, Italy, and USA.

[Krdshrk 3,877]

I started with 9mm and like the idea of variety so now I am looking for a .45, as .40 just seems too close to 9mm to be much of a variety ... however Krdshrk got me thinking that it would be easy and relatively inexpensive to get a .40 barrel/slide for my M&P ...hmmm ... does that mean it can take a .40 magazine as well?   after I get the .45 I am thinking a compact 9mm.

 

Yes - the M&P 9mm frame can fit the .40S&W magazines just fine.  Same dimensions.  Make sure you get a full .40 S&W Barrel and slide assembly, and use .40 S&W mags.  I don't use it a lot but it works.

[Nucrunner 75]

Little of everything, heavy in 9mm.....

[T Bill 649]

A 22LR, a centerfire (most likely a 9MM) and a 45ACP are minimum choices in my book.  Add a 38/357 Revo and you got the handgun world sorta covered.  

[Vicious 138]

I enjoy owning a plethora of calibers because *places tinfoil hat on head* when the zombies come I can use any ammo I find.

 

In all seriousness though, it is a bit of a pain, but I like to own firearms in the caliber they were designed for or popularized by.

[Pizza Bob 1,488]

Variety is the spice of life. Handgun calibers = 14 / Long gun calibers = 12 / Shotgun gauges = 3 / Black powder round ball = 1