If you mean a spike aerator, they are virtually worthless. A core aerator is marginally more effective when seeding but keep in mind, aeration of any kind is not intended for the benefit of seeding. Core aeration is to "loosen" compacted soil. As the holes cave in on themselves, the surrounding soil becomes less compacted. You only need to do this on high foot traffic areas, like on a golf course or soccer field. The only other time we haul out the core aerator is new construction where the soil has been compacted by heavy equipment.
A slicer is like a dethatcher, except the blades are fixed and slice grooves into the soil.We use them a lot when seeding. You go over the area to be seeded twice. Once at a right angle to either the street or side yard, then again at an oblique angle, usually corner to corner. Spread the seed with a spreader, and then go over it again with the slicer just for good measure.
An overseeder is sorta like a slicer except it weighs about a thousand pounds (over exaggerating) It is the cadillac of seeding methods. It slices the ground and behind the slicing blades are concave harrows that the seed is dropped into and literally planted into the groves. Pros who do a lot of seeding use overseeders because you only use about a 1/3rd of the seed, and good seed is like, really expensive dude.
If I was you, I'd rent a slicer for the day. You will get much MUCH better results. Remember, DO NOT LET THE WEE SEEDLINGS DRY OUT. Keep the area wet at all times. If you don't have in-ground irrigation, you can buy a programmable timer or two at HD or lowes and have it go on for 5 or 10 minutes every half hour.