In regards to not needing batteries... it is similar to saying you have an illuminated scope, and running it without the illuminated reticule. Yes, you can run it without batteries, but why? Batteries, even if you consider this red dot (CR2032), are usually the cheapest part of the equation. I have been keeping track of mine among all of my optics, lasers, and lights, and try to change them regularly. In regards to spending money on a name, that one you are talking about is $240 on Amazon. That is in the realm of a used Aimpoint CompM3... for maybe $30 more. While you might have an argument about spending $500+ on a name, $30 is not a big deal on something that A LOT of people trust over something that really has only been in people’s hands for a little over a month. https://clydearmory.com/agency-trade-in-aimpoint-compm3-2moa-with-gg-g-mount.html And that is from a regular source. AR15.com’s EE can net you one maybe a little less, if the person is going with something different. All depends on how long someone is willing to wait for a good deal. I will agree, some optic choices are crazy. My Leupold Mk4 scope was $899, on a Black Friday sale. A lot, but I’ve seen similar optics go A LOT higher. I went Leupold due to the early 1990s one that was on my Remington when I bought it... and how clear it was (Mk4 is just as clear). ACOGs definitely are priced up there, but also need to consider the material used to construct it. For price, a lot goes into glass, QC, and even specific design elements for the product. Comes down to is if the buyer is willing to pay for it. Some are ACOG guys, others are Aimpoint Micros. Some are PROs. Some are SIG/Holosun. And some are Primary Arms. The only real problem is when you start going into the no-name airsoft stuff or Chinese copies being passed off as Aimpoint or something else. That being said, Chinese isn’t automatically bad (the Primary Arms one is made in China)... just depends on the QC being implemented. I personally liked it when Holosun, and then SIG, started putting out decent, less costly options. I feel the same with this Primary Arms one (hesitation aside, will mention my opinion at the end). The better the lower end gets, either Aimpoint/Trijicon/Leupold needs to lower their price to compete, or make it better. Long run, better for the consumer. No way would I ever be upset for that. I’ve had my Aimpoints for a few years... one I bought new, one was lightly used, and one unused, but in an open box. I’m not getting rid of any of them for a Primary Arms red dot that just came out (I rather see some track record before I invest over $200 in something). If that red dot works out, still no real reason for me to swap my Aimpoints. Overpriced, well that depends on the buyer. If I grab a PRO for $375, I do not feel that is overpriced. It is a quality optic that will last. Obsolete? How so? Because as a sighting system, an Aimpoint isn’t any less obsolete than any other red dot. Nothing that Primary Arms red dot is doing hasn’t been done before, or is a far enough jump that you’ll find Aimpoints being sold off for $100 because of how useless they are. I’m all for hearing about new stuff, even if from companies that I regularly don’t buy, but let’s not get too ahead of ourselves and act like SOCOM is buying these instead of X. Maybe this red dot turns into something along the lines of sliced bread, and it works out about when I decide to toss a red dot on my SUB-2000 (whenever MCARBO releases their mount), it could be an option. Or SIG (like the warranty, but I am also looking into one of their rangefinders... and my father likes the Romeo that I bought him for Christmas a year or two back). Or even a used Aimpoint Micro. Well, maybe scratch that last one... and likely the Primary Arms. And neither has to do with a price or name reason. I hate Micro sized red dots. For me, looking through such a small tube is a hinderance. That is why my Aimpoints are all off the larger tube line. I’ve shot an AR with a T2, and wasn’t a fan. From the numbers I’m seeing, the Primary Arms FOV is even smaller than a Micro. If I’m going that small, I’ll do something along the lines of an RMR... not strictly for quality, but the actual design difference (non-tube over tube).