"It depends." The summer after Trump took office, there were 130+ intercepts over the Bedminster golf course within the first couple of months. Too many pilots were remaining clueless, so the Secret Service invited all local private pilots to a seminar in Bedminster. It was fascinating. The head of the presidential protection detail, one of the coast guard chopper intercept pilots, the head of the Allentown TRACON (the big cheese for that sector of airspace) all spoke. There may have been one of the fighter pilots present as well.
Normal intercept procedure for a 'slow' private plane is to scramble a coast guard chopper they base at Somerset airport during presidential visits. It can catch most light planes, but has no trouble slowing down to match their speed. It's got a big lighted sign board on the side, and when it pulls along side it first displays 'tune 121.5' the emergency frequency the pilot should have been monitoring in the first place. They can give instructions over the air, but if that doesn't work, they can also use the sign board to give heading instructions and tell the plane where to land.
If that doesn't work, or if the chopper can't get there in time, they scramble the fighters from one of the NYC area airports. They might be F15's, F16's, or F35's depending on the weekend--they rotate deployments. The lead fighter will slow as much as possible, pull along side to eyeball the trespasser, and try to establish radio contact or use visual intercept procedures Intercept procedures .
If those don't work, they can perform a head-butt maneuver (pass under the target aircraft, then make an abrupt vertical climb in front of the target's nose) or fire flares. So far, one of more of those steps have always worked, but so far they've only been dealing with idiot pilots who weren't paying attention to the Temporary Flight Restriction. The Secret Service guy did say that a shoot-down authorization could only come from one of a handful of people in Washington, one of whom was always available for an instant consult. There is no local authority to shoot down a civilian aircraft.
Once the pilot lands, they are met by local law enforcement (dispatched as soon as the landing location is known), and local law enforcement holds the pilot until the Secret Service arrives. The plane is inspected, and the pilot is taken away for a lengthy interview. The enforcement action taken depends on the severity of the infraction (Nicked the outer edge of the TFR? Barreled directly through the inner 10-mile no-fly zone?), the pilots history (Previous violations? Records show pilot normally gets a flight briefing but didn't today for some reason?). Were there any mitigating circumstances? (GPS satellite out of service? Electronics problems in the plane?)
Penalties range from a temporary certificate suspension (perhaps with a requirement for some re-training), to a much longer certificate suspension, to permanent revocation. I think there is also a provision for substantial fines, but I'm not positive about that. If criminal intent is shown, that's a whole different thing...
Interestingly, a lot of the violations the first year were guys just going up to practice take-offs and landings. Pattern altitude at some of the airports in the TFR is below radar coverage, so guys figured they could stay in the pattern for practice, and never be spotted on radar. The Secret Service guy made clear to us that airborne radar always follows the president. "Taxi around all you want, but if your wheels leave the ground, we'll know it" was the way he put it.