If it’s good enough for uncle sam it’s good enough for you!!! Fuck that noise. Shit triggers are good for learning techniques to deal with shit triggers and that’s about it. With the milspec triggers you can get a nice broken in one that was pretty nice and is a pretty smooth 4.5lb. Or you can get something that feels like it’s made of gravel and is closer to 12. I’ve gone through the litter more than a few times and the odds of getting the good one is basically zero. My experience is you get something about 7-8lbs and fairly rough.
Which sucks.
So what to get. If you don’t have a big budget or don’t know what you like and want to have something around as you buy and sell the expensive ones until you find just right, there’s the alg coated trigger with the jp springs as mentioned in the thread. It’s basically a worked mil spec trigger without having to pay someone to do the work. This is what I have in my “take a noob to the range” ar.
Personally I would not buy the jp trigger. At this point the level of diy to get it set up is just unnecessary with the drop in kits. As on tolerance stacking and the peak performance may not be there with both safety and reliability. And frankly pound for pound of pull, the drop in modules go lower without being as easy to ad. To get the lighter pulls you are dialing out seat engagement. I’ve done a few of them and continue to not like them personally, but more importantly is the effort to set them up and that for the work I’ve gotten ~3.75lb-5lb when set up to pass my standard safety check. I haven’t met their drop in module.
If you want good and not a drop in module buy geissele. After a bunch of use my sd3g pulls about 2.25lb. Their two stage isn’t bad either. Zero dicking around with adjustments, and I’ve run them in multiple lowers with very similar results.
If you want a 2stage, the hiperfire hipertouch is pretty much the best. You can go really light with really reliable ignition and a positive reset. You can catch some really good sales on these to make them pretty competitive price wise too.
If you want single stage, the top of the line elftman trigger is it. Get out your wallet. Pretty much everything they make is made well, but their budget triggers aren’t good relative value to the competition.
Then there’s the 1.5 stage/1911 style triggers. They usually have a very short, very light first stage. Then a light second stage.
The ar gold trigger was the first of there and is good. I don’t like the very narrow trigger, and it’s a bit floppy feeling from a resting position. But it’s a good trigger and probably one of the better ones for precision shooting imo.
Then there’s my personal favorite. Triggertech. Of any ar trigger, this one has the most positive wall of any trigger I’ve ever met. There’s short, very light take up, a positive wall, and a glass rod break. It also has a positive reset. I’ve got the adjustable that goes down to 2.5lb according to the label, but it’s really more like 2.75 in my gun. I love them, and if you are of the light is dangerous crowd, it adjusts up to 5lb. You will not find a nicer feeling 5lb trigger imo.
That being said there is now the triggertech Diamond ar trigger. It goes down to 1.5lb, and i don’t think I’ve seen a drop in that will be lower. The timer calvin is also 1.5. That being said i have not met one in person. However I’ve seen a lot of complaints of it being kind of mushy and having a weak reset. If you need the lightest for an ar you want to shoot like a precision bolt gun, the timney Calvin is in theory it.
If you have a budget, the cheap rise armament drop in isn’t too bad, and occasionally I’ll see the larue 2 stage is pretty regularly available at $99 and is a solid implementation of an old school national match 2 stage design.
We honestly have more really good ar triggers than we had options for stripped lowers when i started building ars in 2001. The choice for decent drop ins is just insane now.