Everything posted by Malsua
-
COE swap
That is a temporary transfer. There is no loan/borrow language in the statutes when it comes to handing a gun to someone. It is either a temporary or permanent transfer and different rules apply to each situation. I was specifically talking about under 18 and hunting. A 14 year old may hunt without supervision but cannot own a gun yet, so they may have an unsupervised temporary transfer. The youth hunting exception is this:
-
First visit to the range - I'm hooked!
Congrats! It's much cheaper when you shoot your own gun. You can shoot 9mm for $10/box. .22 is even cheaper. You can also join a range that doesn't charge hourly fees so you're not pressured and on the clock.
-
CCW in PA, transporting to state line
You clearly cannot distinguish that I am talking about a legal distinction, not a practical one. As has been repeated ad nauseum, that because I'm trying to clarify WHAT THE LAW SAWS, not how it is interpreted by police or how it is followed by citizens, that somehow I'm some kind of coward, jumping at my own shadow. That somehow you can never leave the state with your property is again something I never said. You yourself repeated this canard a few posts up. If it's a fruitless debate, so be it, I assert the question is not satisfactorily answered. That it is not enforced is immaterial to the question. As for knowing who people are, people here know me, in person. You ascribed all sorts of behavior to me based on an question that you seem to think has been satisfactorily answered.
-
CCW in PA, transporting to state line
That's probably for the best. When someone can't understand a concept it makes them confused and angry.
-
CCW in PA, transporting to state line
Once again, someone misses my point. Re-read my posts.
-
The Range Idiot Song
Heh, that's pretty funny watching that military guy with the mohawk and what appears to be an airborne logo on crooning about range safety. He's pretty talented for what it is.
-
COE swap
If the other guy was not a NJ resident, you taking possession of the firearm would be an unlawful transfer(indictable offense). If the guy was a NJ resident, you were legal to take possession using a COE. If the person is going away for 6 months, I hope it was a deployment, not an incarceration because if it's the latter rather than the former, he may have trouble ever taking legal possession. If he does not have a FPID, he may not legally take possession of a firearm in NJ. No, you cannot just rip up the COE. There is no loaning/borrowing of firearms in NJ(there are some caveats for under 18 hunters). It is either a temporary or permanent transfer with different rules applying to either case.
-
Laws on possession of a pellet gun?
You're missing the key ingredient here. The kid possessed the handgun, unlawfully. The gun was in his car. If the police had found him at his home, the gun would not be unlawfully possessed. If you buy a pellet gun legally in a different state and bring it to NJ, it is legal to possess. The same rules apply to a pellet gun as apply to a handgun or long gun. The same transport laws apply, which is how Narcisco got tripped up. If the hand pellet gun above was purchased or obtained legally outside of NJ, there is nothing to do. Ownership is legal. Treat it like you would a .45 and you're good to go.
-
Do You Remember When??
I lived out in the country. I remember being bored out of my skull more times than I can count. until I was 12ish, I had two neighbors around my age. Both were about a mile away(opposite directions). I had horses, goats, chickens and other animals. I spent a lot of time cleaning up after them. I spent time in the woods doing nothing but wishing I was somewhere there was something fun to do. I read a lot. I'm glad we have the internet.
-
CCW in PA, transporting to state line
"going directly to a range till you cross the border than staying 5 days" they say DIRECTLY to and from.. it's no longer enforceable due to lack of jurisdiciton
-
CCW in PA, transporting to state line
You've made this argument before but I don't understand how you get there. You are traveling to a range, you are covered under a NJ exemption, end of story. The exemptions don't mention that your ultimate destination has to be within NJ. It just mentions exempted activity.
-
CCW in PA, transporting to state line
Because the laws have been clarified concerning airports. http://www.anjrpc.org/resource/resmgr/docs/travelwithguns.pdf
-
CCW in PA, transporting to state line
Just for giggles, I posed this question to NRA-ILA. If they respond, I'll post it. I don't think anyone expects NJ law to apply once you are not in NJ. I don't think anyone suggested as such. We're talking about the gray twilight from the time you are on a public street until you enter freedom. Must you be NJ Legal(under NJ laws, fed laws aside) 100% of the time during your journey? I would love for the answer to be a definite NO. Not a probably no, not a maybe no, not a "it would be ridiculous if it's not no", I want a definite NO!. heh
-
CCW in PA, transporting to state line
I agree. So what does that mean in the larger sense? How do they differentiate? Does this mean it disallows Fopa protections in the origin state or simply that an officer has to rely on the totality of the circumstances and determine you were coming from home? Which is it? It could be either unless we can find some clarity somewhere. I do know that some folks were arrested in NY at the airports and that the PAPD were told to knock it off by the US Attorney general. I don't know if they were NY residents or not, I do not believe they were. Edit to add: This could also suggest that if you are not 100% legal in NJ at any point during your NJ journey, you fail FOPA protections. The only way to be legal inside of NJ is within the exemptions.
-
CCW in PA, transporting to state line
It is interesting that upon re-reading the FOPA statutes, the one part that jumps out is this: I'm trying to decypher the above in red but it looks like the "to/from is legal" was to counter that the bill would disallow arrests if he argued he was beginning a permitted transporation. Which sorta suggest to me the bill is not supposed to prevent arrests under the state's laws while beginning a permitted transportation. Now someone in Maryland, who's rules essentially mirror NJ, asked the Assistant Attorney General of Maryland this exact question. You can read the response here: http://www.mdshooters.com/showpost.php?p=850500&postcount=45 You'll note that he states that if you are not within the legal exemptions inside of Maryland, you're violating the law and not protected by FOPA. Not an official position and he also notes there is no appellate case on which to relay. I know you think you've got it all answered, and that's all well and good. You seem to think that arguing this unsettled distinction means I'm running around in fear with my arms raised in the air or something equally ludicrous. If I plan to go to PA and I carry when I do, I can assure you, FOPA and the asinine NJ laws aren't going to weigh on my decision whatsoever. I'll put the gun in the back and go, so can we stop the ridiculous hyperbole? Or not, whatever, have fun with it but I still assert that it's not settled. The argument 495 above, during the debate on the bill clearly shows this was discussed. I want clarification on that point before I can say with certitude that it is covered under FOPA. Enforcement by the state police or Barney fife makes no difference. You can call the state police and they can tell you one thing and a local prosecutor can make you life hell, all the same.
-
CCW in PA, transporting to state line
Or more likely, it's because the case pool will only affect states where ownership of a handgun requires permission, such as NJ. Where travel requires exemptions, such as NJ. Where the prosecutor has an entire laundry list of charges that he can use that are NOT covered under FOPA, so instead of making a federal case of it, he will change the charges to something else and stick it to you that way. It is not defined in FOPA or case law that the Safe Passage provision of the Firearms Ownwer Protection act covers anyone in the state of origin. It just isn't clarified. Suggesting it does cover the state of origin because it's not been tested is foolheardy.
-
CCW in PA, transporting to state line
It's not that there is a refusal to accept that FOPA covers it, it's that it is unknown that FOPA covers it. There is _ZERO_ case precedence. There have been no tests. It is not spelled out in the 1986 legislation anthat clearly denotes that you are covered in your state of origin. FOPA covers _INTERSTATE_ travel. You have not engaged in interstate travel until you have left the state! You may have intent, but you have not. State of destination it much more easily explainable because you are not a resident, origin isn't. Furthermore, the authority under which the Feds claim under this legislation is from the commerce clause, found in Article I, Section 8, Clause 3 of the US constitution. The commerce clause cannot have authority for a resident in his own state before he has engaged in any interstate commerce.(which was expanded in further legislation giving the feds, all sorts of un-enumerated powers). My argument is and has always been that it currently not clarified and the possibility of being charged is not zero. Close to zero? Sure. Zero? I don't think anyone can conclusively say that, despite all the chest beating I see about this topic.
-
NJ2AS v. NJSP update and court documents
My prediction for the day...the state police will figure out a way to kick the can further down the road.
-
More info for a noob
Eddie, What part of the state are you in? You could probably go to a gathering or meet someone to get started. If you're up north, I'm willing to spend some time with you at Cherry Ridge.
-
More info for a noob
You need to be specific. Start with a topic and go from there. Handguns, rifles, military surplus(milsurp), AR, AK, etc. We need to know where you're having trouble. Is it the Acronyms? There's some thread around that have some explanation.
-
National Right-to-Carry Reciprocity Act Scheduled for House Floor Vote on Tuesday-HR822
It's amazing how well those Schoolhouse rock stuck. I too hear that little tune whenever I think about the legislative process. Anyone who was a kid in the mid 70s saw "I'm just a bill" at least once a weekend on the Saturday morning cartoons. Now, if I turn on cartoons anytime, it just seems like everyone is always screaming for some reason. "Oh no, we're out of ketchup" "AAAAAHHHH", our favorite program is delayed 30 seconds "AAAAAAHHHHH". ETC. It no wonder millenials are all screwed up, cartoons have taught them that every slight, every minor inconvenience is worthy of screaming your head off.
-
National Right-to-Carry Reciprocity Act Scheduled for House Floor Vote on Tuesday-HR822
No, it doesn't. It does however say "may possess or carry a concealed handgun in any State, other than the State of residence of the person" I'm not sure how anyone can read that and think it says you can carry a concealed handgun in your own state of residence under this law. Let's simplify it for us NJ people. "may possess or carry a concealed handgun in any State, other than the State of residence of the person NJ"
-
H.R. 822 Live on c-span at 12:00 (11/15/2011)
2/3s to override a veto. 60 vote is cloture. President can veto and it'll probably stick.
-
Watch the live hearing on HR 822 now
Read the Cato institute study on this issue. http://www.cato.org/pubs/pas/pa284.pdf Here's a quote: More training may be worse
-
H.R. 822 Live on c-span at 12:00 (11/15/2011)
Apparently the rules are approved. ------- House approves rule for concealed weapons bill By Pete Kasperowicz - 11/15/11 03:22 PM ET The House on Tuesday approved the rule for legislation that would require states to recognize each other's concealed weapons permits. Members approved the bill in a 271-153 vote in which 35 Democrats voted with every Republican. The House moved immediately to special order speeches, and will take up debate on the concealed weapons bill, H.R. 822, and various amendments, later in the week.