I actually think it's a good idea. I'm contemplating getting the yearly pass myself. I commute every day into Penn Station and have to get to a client site or my office within a decent amount of time. Instead of using Subway or Bus which not always is in the area where I gotta go, I could jump on one of the bikes.
Yes, the bikes are heavy. They're not the fastest bikes as well, but I'm ok with that. You also can't take a bike out and ride it all day - there's a 45 minute limit or they start charging you extra... though you could potentially get it stolen if you stop somewhere and don't lock it. The time limit is 30 minutes if you have the daily or weekly passes.