Everything posted by vladtepes
-
forgive me ignorance... would this shotty b legal?
the issue is the law does not state that the grip needs to be separate from anything.. it does not state how it can or can not attach to the gun.. for it to be legal it would need to state that if it is connected to the stock it stops being a pistol grip.... remember we are viewing this as gun enthusiasts not law makers... the word similar is extremely vague.. most would argue intentionally vague.. the word beneath implies something is below something else.. it does not need to be directly below it to be beneath.. if you want to split hairs it is not really behind the action either.. technically of course.. the biggest issue is you are resting your freedom on the fact that it is attached to the stock.. "it is not because of this, which is ultimately it being attached to the stock" but the law does not address that.. a pistol grip can be part of a stock by the way it is worded...
-
forgive me ignorance... would this shotty b legal?
I will go slower.. in the eyes of NJ law it is not a thumbhole stock.. because a thumbhole stock does not exist.. because thumbhole stock does not exist it can not be one in the eyes of the law... that leaves you with it being a pistol grip OR not a pistol grip.... since it meets the criteria of being a pistol grip it is by my best estimation a pistol grip..
-
forgive me ignorance... would this shotty b legal?
ask him what part of the law makes it not a pistol grip... you have an FFL in this thread telling you its NOT legal... so just being an FFL is moot.. what matters is what the law literally says...
-
forgive me ignorance... would this shotty b legal?
if they dont define it.. then it does not exist.. for it to be a loophole they would have to say something like "thumbhole stock - is any stock in which the stock is one complete piece attached to the rear of the rifle" that would create a loop hole because it would take that obvious pistol grip and turn it into a thumbhole stock by being one piece... since that is not the case then the piece protruding off the gun is judged solely on if it meets the criteria of a pistol grip... ask yourself.. you are in front of a jury.. the prosecutor holds of that gun, which he has already demonized.. and then begins to read the definition of pistol grip.. showing that the thing he is holding meets all that criteria... whats your defense? there isnt one.. because it is a pistol grip as pistol grip is clearly defined in NJ law.. "Pistol grip" means a well defined handle check, similar to that found on a handgun, check that protrudes conspicuously beneath the action of the weapon, check and which permits the firearm to be held and fired with one hand. check it is.. as defined by NJ law.. a pistol grip..
-
forgive me ignorance... would this shotty b legal?
I disagree.. completely.. NJ does not define thumbhole stock.. so therefore it is nonexistent in NJ law.. they do however define pistol grip.. and that is by NJ definition essentially a pistol grip.. take notice that the law does not state a pistol grip stops being a pistol grip if it is attached to the stock.. there is simply no mention of stock at all.. "Pistol grip" means a well defined handle, similar to that found on a handgun, that protrudes conspicuously beneath the action of the weapon, and which permits the firearm to be held and fired with one hand.
-
A question for the open-minded Glock appreciators out there
sell your glock 19.. get the 40 S&W model that you prefer.. and get the 9mm conversion parts for that... this will save you money, and still get you the versatility of two rounds VS one...
-
Replica magpul UBR stock
If given the choice of 1) slimming down the front of the rifle to make it more balanced thus netting a lighter overall gun.. or 2) adding more weight to the rear of the gun with a heavy stock thus netting a heavier gun.. I would pick option 1 every time.. especially if I lived in a state where the main adjust-ability of the stock was negated by having to pin it.. paying a premium for a heavy stock that will essentially function like any other pinned AR stock is confusing to me..
- Cat Saves Kid from Dog Attack
-
Cat Saves Kid from Dog Attack
this... cats take as much attention as you want to give them.. if you just let them do their thing and ignore them %90 of the time.. expect them to not care about you much... but if you put yourself in their world.. and interact with them on the regular you would be surprised how amazing they can be.. my cat sits.. speaks.. stands.. on command... he plays fetch.. and he it attached to my side whenever I am home... hes a really affectionate animal.. loving.. friendly.. curls up on my lap pretty much every night while I am on the computer.. if you dont like cats you just have not spent the time to be around one enough..
-
Does anyone carry even though it's illegal?
the difference is clearly simple in my mind... the criminal that robs you is committing a crime that violates the innocent... he is committing a crime against someone that does nothing... and he is making the choice to not "provide for his family" in a legal way... the otherwise lawful citizen is committing a crime due to having no other option for protection.. living in a climate where the government offers no legal alternative.. and if he is to ever use that weapon.. he would likely be using it against someone in the act of self defense... so on a moral level.. the examples are entirely different... I would never group an otherwise law abiding hard working tax payer with the scum common criminal..
-
rail covers
the thing I liked about the Larue over the ladders is they fully cover the rail.. and give a good feel to grab while staying super slim...
-
rail covers
larue index clips are better than anything else I have handled..
-
my ar barrel
ok that makes sense.. I thought he meant the sight was loose AND the barrel was loose..
-
Does anyone carry even though it's illegal?
this... there are definitely upstanding good people that are otherwise law abiding citizens.. that do carry in certain situations in NJ... I'm sure the mindset is playing the odds... they probably feel that it is extremely unlikely that they will ever even interact with police... and if they do.., it is far less likely that they will be patted down... and given a certain set of circumstances there is more value to them in having a gun available to them.. and still be alive... VS the unlikely risk of getting "caught"
-
my ar barrel
how could your A2 sight be loose and then tight? isnt it pinned to the barrel?
-
New Pump-Action AR-15's
had them forever... they used to be on AK mags... so when I got into ARs again.. I just swapped them over..
-
Will you open carry in PA?
I am unsure of the legalities of open carrying in a car just for the sake of carrying due to the guidelines that are similar to NJ which govern handgun transport... I am not %100 convinced you can "carry just to carry" in other words.. sure.. the law says you can open carry in a car.. but does that trump the exempted locations? meaning can you open carry all over PA with a FL ccw license? or do you still need to be transporting within the exempted location? not sure? with all that said if it is in fact legal.. open carry in PA is a mixed bag... in central PA I have open carried in numerous places of business.. including malls.. Lowes.. target.. various restaurants.. and have never had a single negative encounter... I have never been asked to leave.. or anything like that.. but my understanding is as you get closer to the eastern side of the state you will find far more resistance.. you will find places of business with signage that disallows firearms (and they have the legal right to do so)... so what do you do then? put the gun in your car? are you then simply transporting outside the exemption? and thus breaking the law.. since you are no longer open carrying.. I think that if any of you consider open carrying in PA with the substantial amount of changes that are happening... get some clarification... find out if you are even within your rights to do so... make sure that "open carrying in a car with a valid permit" actually trumps the exemption laws..
-
New Pump-Action AR-15's
just because something is only marginally easier.. does not mean it should be ignored.. if all else is close to equal.. handling a mag that has more area to manipulate should not be ignored.. simply because it does not make sense to you.. this is my rig.. with 30 round mags.. 20 round mags are going to be sitting pretty low.. making the ability to pull them harder.. not opinion.. fact..
-
New Pump-Action AR-15's
I live in PA.. so I am shooting 30 round functioning mags.. but when I shoot I am not fully loading them so I can not anticipate round count to get faster on reloads.. reacting to the gun being empty and not a repetitive count.. so I am handing 30 round mags that are anywhere from full to almost empty... never had any issues.. as for lugging ammo.. I have lugged my share of 30 round mags on a few fairly long hikes.. carrying 150 rounds on a chest rig.. with body armor under it.. and a light pack.. the pack was probably the most annoying thing over the heat... the actual ammo weight was never so significant that it was an issue.. I mean dont get me wrong.. gear is heavy... but 30 round.. or 20 round mag bodies are not going to be the difference if the need ever comes up.. you are talking a few extra inches of plastic.. I do appreciate that you are talking about 30 round mags that can only hold 15... but at the end of the day there is only ONE issue with those... and that is shooting prone.. shooting prone with 30 round mags depending on the target can be annoying... and 20 round mags are definitely better in that situation..
-
New Pump-Action AR-15's
with all due respect.. all I shoot are 30 round mags.. I do run a chest rig and the 30s sit perfectly... I dont own anything under 30 so I can not say for sure that the smaller mags would or would not fit.. what I can tell you is that 30s sit with the right amount of room to grab when reloading from a rig... also this noise that they feel off balance is silly... do your mags change balance as you are shooting... what happens when you are shooting a 15 round mag and get down to the last two rounds? is your gun flying all over the place because it is unbalanced? I will agree that having a mag be longer than it needs to for any cool factor or looks factor.. is silly at best... but with that said I am not convinced reloading from a rig would be ideal with smaller mags..
-
News regarding PA CCW reciprocity
Imo you are totally wrong... This all started with Philly people carrying on out of state permits when philly wouldn't approve them..
-
fid denial
you dont owe anyone an explanation about anything.. your business is your business.. I only read bits and pieces of this thread, but with that said it sounds like you need a lawyer if you ever hope to sort all that out... the only thing that has me confused is how you could forget being denied.. I mean even being that long ago it is a pretty significant occurrence.. but like I said.. you certainly dont owe me or anyone else any kind of explanation.. it sounds like you were young and stupid at some point like the rest of us... the only difference being you got caught.. when was the simple assault.. good luck with it all.. let us know how it pans out..
-
adding a rail to lower handguard
I do not recall having that issue with the Kvar offering.. thing was rock solid.. and I dont recall it getting unusually hot.. good railless handguard..
-
adding a rail to lower handguard
what are the benefits?
-
adding a rail to lower handguard
looks good.. but I bet it gets pretty hot.. I considered the Alpha for my AR and went with something different due to heat concerns..