Everything posted by CMJeepster
-
NJ LAWMAKERS ANNOUNCE PLANS TO DESTROY RIGHT TO CARRY
#metoo then I moved here.
-
NJ LAWMAKERS ANNOUNCE PLANS TO DESTROY RIGHT TO CARRY
That's what PA does.
-
NJ LAWMAKERS ANNOUNCE PLANS TO DESTROY RIGHT TO CARRY
Link? I'm interested!
-
Koons vs Reynolds case successful with TRO on NJ Carry Killer Law.
- Defensive firearm use
Homeowner fires shot after man breaks into New Jersey home to steal car: officials (msn.com)- NJ LAWMAKERS ANNOUNCE PLANS TO DESTROY RIGHT TO CARRY
Federal judge temporarily blocks portions of New Jersey's new gun law (msn.com)- Defensive firearm use
Texas homeowner shoots suspected intruder, holds him at gunpoint until deputies arrive (yahoo.com)- Defensive firearm use
California concealed carry holder shoots ax-wielding attacker on his property (yahoo.com)- NJ LAWMAKERS ANNOUNCE PLANS TO DESTROY RIGHT TO CARRY
Because "they" don't want you to have guns, let alone carry guns.- What is your go to EDC blade
On an impulse and your post, I used a credit on my Amazon account and bought one. I've been carrying it for about a week. I'm impressed. This is a blade style that I've not had before, so it's taking some getting used to. Deployment is definitely fast enough for me. I'm curious to see how long I can go without needing to sharpen it.- Koons v. Reynolds + Siegel v. Platkin - Hearing Notes and Transcripts
THE COURT: And while he's traveling. But he's told he cannot, right? MS. CAI: Well, while he's traveling, when he's driving the car, he has the firearm, he can have the firearm within reach, and it's just about whether or not he can have it loaded and unsecured somewhere in the car while he's doing that. And so I think there's perhaps some infringement on the immediate ability to have that firearm loaded and on you. That restriction -- and I do admit that is a restriction -- has been historically upheld. THE COURT: And I appreciate your candor. MS. CAI: Yeah. THE COURT: Yes. ------ Admission that "they're" infringing on a Constitutional right. JFC these people are morons.- Koons v. Reynolds + Siegel v. Platkin - Hearing Notes and Transcripts
MS. CAI: I wasn't sure if there was a -- every permit holder has the same, yes, has the same -- has to follow the same rules. But I think if we look to the rationales that the courts interpreting the historical statutes have justified them, plaintiffs have no responses. So we explain on page 34 of the brief that the journeys regulation was to prevent people from, quote, going about the streets armed in a manner which, if in a sudden fit of passion, might endanger the lives of others. This is the road rage analogue from the 1800s, I suppose. And that's precisely one of the reasons why Section (b)(1) was enacted. The legislature wanted people to be able to transport their firearms between places where they're allowed to carry them, right. So it didn't prohibit having firearms in your vehicle. It just prohibited people from having such easy access to the firearm that if they were in a sudden fit of passion or if there was a car accident or something like that, that it would create danger to others. And so that's the prohibition that exists now and has always animated the restrictions historically. ------ Me: So, the state sees me as a potential rapist because I am male and have a penis?- Koons v. Reynolds + Siegel v. Platkin - Hearing Notes and Transcripts
THE COURT: Do you agree that self-defense is at the core of the Second Amendment? MS. CAI: Of course. THE COURT: So how does someone who has an approved concealed carry defend himself if it's in the trunk, if the firearm is in the trunk? MS. CAI: So, first, Your Honor, the statute does not require that the firearm be in the trunk. It just requires that it be unloaded and fastened in some case. It could be on the -- in the glove box, it could be on the passenger side seat. It could be, you know, in any number of locations where they -- THE COURT: Okay. Fair enough. How does he protect himself with a disassembled or unloaded firearm? MS. CAI: Of course the person would have to then, if it faces a self-defense situation, take it out and load it. But that's the exact prohibitions that states have put forth in history, and those were not challenged as unconstitutional, or at least the plaintiffs have not given us any evidence. And that's because the government, you know, the right to self-defense, as Bruen and McDonald and Heller have noted, is not unlimited in every manner and to every person and to every place. And so -- THE COURT: Do you agree with the plaintiffs that this provision treats every permit holder the same? MS. CAI: I -- yes. THE COURT: Okay.- Koons v. Reynolds + Siegel v. Platkin - Hearing Notes and Transcripts
MR. JENSEN: Well, I think saying that there is no presumption you have a right to carry a firearm in the first place is getting everything exactly wrong. There is a presumption that you have a right to carry a firearm. And the issue is whether or not we have established a sufficiently engrained historical tradition to overcome that. Just -- this is going to sound like a ridiculous example, but that's kind of because it's ridiculous -- a private property owner, like my house, I can choose to exclude all sorts of people. I could choose to exclude people who are gay. I could choose to exclude people who are members of races I don't like. Just to be clear, I'm certainly not doing this. That's not my view. But I would be free to do this. Now, if the legislature enacts a law that says the default rule is that gay people are not allowed in other people's private residences unless they have affirmatively consented in advance, would we even be standing here having this argument? Would this not, on its face, be a law that serves the purposes of suppressing the conduct? Your Honor, unless you have anything further, I'll sit down just because I know we've been here for a long time. THE COURT: Okay. Yeah. Thank you. I want to move to the issue of the transportation.- Koons v. Reynolds + Siegel v. Platkin - Hearing Notes and Transcripts
By page 70, IMO it's very apparent that she's out of her league. THE COURT: So it's still a crime. As I read this, it's still a crime under the de minimis. MS. CAI: No, Your Honor. That's not how I read it. Except as otherwise provided and except as in the case of a brief incidental entry onto property -- THE COURT: Which shall be deemed a de minimis infraction within the contemplation of 2C:2-11. That's a criminal statute. MS. CAI: It's a criminal statute, but it doesn't criminalize your conduct. So it's not -- if you look at 2C:2-11. THE COURT: What does that say? MS. CAI: I don't have that right in front of me, Your Honor. But it makes it -- THE COURT: Do you know? MR. JENSEN: I don't know what that says, no. THE COURT: Well, that says to me that even if it's a de minimis infraction, it's still a prosecution. Because that was my next question, which is if I'm walking, if I have a concealed carry and I'm walking with my child and her ball, and her ball, she kicks it inadvertently onto my neighbor's property who I know doesn't want any firearms, does she leave the ball there? MS. CAI: Well, Your Honor, I think that's not even a question about Section 7(a) -- A724. If your neighbor has already made it known to you that they don't want your firearms there -- THE COURT: Yeah. I leave the ball there.- Koons v. Reynolds + Siegel v. Platkin - Hearing Notes and Transcripts
It's clear to me from this transcript that Ms. Cai is in well over her head and that the State's response to this was incredibly lacking any preparation or basis whatsoever.- Koons v. Reynolds + Siegel v. Platkin - Hearing Notes and Transcripts
"THE COURT: Okay. That's the way it's always been; that a person can go onto property unless there's a no gun posted. So it just seems to me that this is a superfluous impediment that the State is imposing on private property owners. And that tends to be -- and whenever there's a superfluous impediment, it seems to me that that infringes. MS. CAI: If I can -- THE COURT: Help me understand what I'm missing. MS. CAI: If I can give the Court a very practical example. THE COURT: Yeah. MS. CAI: So if I'm a homeowner before Chapter 131 went into effect. THE COURT: Yeah. MS. CAI: And maybe I have little kids. Maybe I have a lot going on in the house, there's contractors coming in and out, I may not be thinking about whether or not the people coming in and out of my house, the plumber, the roofer, are carrying firearms. On the other hand, I may have a very, very strong preference and desire for people coming into my house not to have firearms because -- THE COURT: Then post "no guns allowed." ------ Mic drop.- More ads or is it just me?
Bigly!!!- More ads or is it just me?
Russian hacking...- Koons v. Reynolds + Siegel v. Platkin - Hearing Notes and Transcripts
THE COURT: I do. I think to move things along, I do have some questions. The question I have for you, it seems to me in subpart 24, and this is what I want you to address, is isn't the State turning the presumption of the right to carry on its head? ------ And this, my friends, is the core of the case.- Koons v. Reynolds + Siegel v. Platkin - Hearing Notes and Transcripts
Picked this back up after a long day... "MS. CAI: The reason that the Kansas statute and similar statutes were enacted is that the legislatures at that time correctly recognized that people who are intoxicated or could be intoxicated or go to places to be intoxicated should not have firearms on them. And so we can't, you know, we're not doing an analysis of whether the current statute, Section 15, is narrowly tailored to only apply to people who have already started drinking at the restaurant versus later. That's not what Bruen tells the Court to do. It's whether or not -- THE COURT: So I guess your argument is, is that it is presumed that anyone who goes into an establishment that sells alcohol is going to drink? MS. CAI: No, Your Honor. And that's -- THE COURT: But that's how you'd get there. MS. CAI: No. I don't think that's the logic we're trying to draw. The logic we're trying to draw is historically legislatures have had no problem prohibiting the mixture of alcohol and firearms, period." ------ Slappity, slap, slap!- Koons v. Reynolds + Siegel v. Platkin - Hearing Notes and Transcripts
Page 28 has Cai getting slapped around pretty good.- Koons v. Reynolds + Siegel v. Platkin - Hearing Notes and Transcripts
Page 18: "MS. CAI: So it seems like, you know," I discredit anyone who uses that phrase, especially in a courtroom.- Kulak Arms
Agreed. He's my FFL and has several members here as customers. He also sponsors a few competitive shooters who post here as well.- What happen to the intro post from the guy from NC.
Russian hacking. - Defensive firearm use