Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Newtonian

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Newtonian

  1. I'm sure our paths wouldn't cross on the training circuit, Sheriff. Where I shoot and have taken classes they trust us with actual guns and don't scold us like we're 12 year old shoplifters. I asked a simple question, inelegantly perhaps, of which single solitary safety condition you would always desire. I've gone back and edited the question. Are you brave enough to answer it or do you need a translator?
  2. This is clearly a religion for you. Nobody is pointing shit at nobody. I'm in my goddamn basement with nobody else in the house pointing my gun at a foundation wall with about 300 linear feet of near solid shale behind it. True I like that particular cinder block I aim at -- I like it very much and would hate to destroy it but I'd have to empty a few magazines from one of my Mosins into it to do that. I can't even put a tomato stake into the surface dirt without using a sledgehammer and a steel dowel but ok, 8 feet down I'm going to draw an empty gun from a holster, not even pull the trigger, and kill somebody cooling their feet at the far end of the pond behind my house. What's scary about this exchange is that people who obsess over minutiae, or fret like old Italian ladies over low-risk events, are so brain-drained that they miss some big stuff. I sincerely hope that is not the case with you.
  3. No not at all. What I said was that UNLESS you clear the gun it can never be considered safe. And IF you clear it it is always 100% safe. And unless you trust yourself on that point of safety you have some thinking to do. This is science not religion. We're not talking heebie jeebies at getting swept we're talking about actually getting shot. Think of it this way. Gun loaded/unloaded; finger on/off the trigger; gun pointed at/away from people; operator sober/high on LSD; safety engaged/not engaged. This particular handgun is sitting on shooting bench pointing at you. You can choose just one of those safety conditions to be absolutely positive about. Which one would it be? Be honest. Imagine you walk into a room with a person sitting at a table with a gun in front of him. There is no ammo in the room or in that person's possession except there might be some in the gun. Here are some possibilities: The person is the most perfectly trained gun expert in the world or he's never touched a gun before; the gun is loaded or unloaded; he's touching the gun or not; he's touching the gun with his finger on or off the trigger; the gun is pointed at or away from you; the individual is sober or drunk; the safety on the gun is engaged or not (or doesn't exist). You can choose just one of those safety conditions to be absolutely positive about, to control. All the others will be the worse of the two possible cases. Which one would it be? Which is the only situation, the only condition, that assures you cannot get shot no matter what else happens? Be honest. I take that back you're incapable.
  4. Didn't say SIRT had no value. But there's something to be said for practicing with the actual equipment you use. I didn't realize that would be a heretical statement. I'm sure the blue gun suggestion was made with the most charitable intentions. It just doesn't make sense in light of everything else I read. BTW nobody addressed my point about trusting yourself to clear a gun before playing with it.
  5. These guys must be nuts then: http://store.laser-ammo.com/laser-training/surestrike-38-special-357-cartridge.html "Use Your Own Gun: Improve shooting skills using your firearm of choice so the weight, balance, feel, and all unique characteristics will be the same as when used in live shooting." These guys too: https://www.laserlyte.com/products/trainer-lt-cartridge And what about: http://www.thetruthaboutguns.com/2013/12/foghorn/gear-review-aimtech-laser-training-system/ "The next best thing would be the SIRT pistol system, but that doesn’t let you use your existing gun. For a pro I can see this being a good investment, but for the average shooter you might want to invest in lead instead." And for a below-average shooter? Interestingly SIRTs are recommended for glocks because -- the other laser systems won't work in them because glock triggers don't reset unless they go bang first. So unless you have a striker-fired gun a SIRT doesn't make much sense.
  6. Condition 0 = 4.5 Condition 1 = 11-12 5.5 lb (glock) - 4.5 lb (cz75) = 1 lb 1/11.5 = 0.087 If you "fix" your glock trigger to 4.5, or 4, or 3 (unheard of !!) is it still not condition 0? Like saying "Maryanne doesn't have AIDS, she is merely infected with HIV."
  7. Thanks. That sounds like a plan. I wanted to avoid GFH as well. Seems too industrialized, expensive, and there are personal reasons as well for why I choose not to give them business. I will check out Sights and Trigger. I enjoy driving to MipaLand much better than venturing "down there." I am probably reviled by some in these forums for not letting stuff go, for wanting to have the last word. I apologize, and recognize that you've all been very kind considering my lack of experience yet my strongly voiced "opinions." I'm an old guy who's seen a lot of stuff. "Fake news" is nothing new to me. The purpose of a fair amount of conventional wisdom is not to impart understanding but to control, screw, or extract money from you. That's why I question conventional logic even on topics where I lack direct experience. On the matter of blue guns I do have some thoughts however. I too would be uncomfortable swinging a handgun around with just some drywall between me and my kids or a neighbor. That's why I play with and clean my guns in my basement and never while loaded (either the gun or me) and never point toward the ceiling or windows. But eventually those of you who carry must load your guns no? Where? I laugh when Jerry M. warns about not handling guns in the same room where you store ammunition. Ever notice what's behind him on the shelves as he fondles his hardware or unboxes a new toy? My only point is that ensuring a gun is empty and cleared is the only way to assure no mayhem will ensue. If you do not trust yourself doing that, and don't recognize situations where playing with even a cleared gun while not scientifically unsafe is inappropriate, you have some fairly serious things to consider about gun ownership. If you don't trust yourself to safety check your gun then using a blue gun in what is arguably one of the least likely instances where accidents occur is not going to solve your problem. That sentiment derives not from the NRA or Internet Gunslinger but from Newtonian logic. F=ma.
  8. I thought 1911s were carried in condition 1, cocked and locked. I never heard of anyone carrying a SAO gun with a round in and the safety off, which is standard for a glock (which has no safety). Yet out of the box pulls on a 1911 are 4-5 lbs, which is very close to a Glock's. OK, so a Glock is carried not in condition 0 but condition 0.10. OK, if there's no difference between 11 lbs and 5 lbs why not adjust your trigger to half a pound or 4 ounces or 2 ounces? I was just reading about 3 guys who shot themselves without touching the trigger. Unfortunately the draw straps on their clothing did not follow the 3 rules of gun safety. You can be sure those straps weren't pulling 11 lbs. I began this thread with a sincere question about training for CC. Basic stuff for confidence, things I can practice so I don't kill anybody unless I have to. You guys advised me to enter a competition where people are jumping around pretending they're in Mogadishu, but then to practice drawing at home with a piece of plastic. Anyone but me see the incongruity?
  9. He recently twittered that he will change his mind but only if he receives 500 emails from you.
  10. Whatever, I'm sure they'll take credit for anything good that comes of this.
  11. As I mentioned forget the may-issue states, Illinois. Here are the most likely possibilities for democrats voting for this bill: Nelson (Florida), Donelly (Indiana), McCaskill (Missouri), Tester (Montana), Udall or Heinrich but not both (NM), Heitkamp (North Dakota), Casey (Pennsy), Manchin is probably a lock (W. Virginia). That's exactly eight folks. We need 100% of these guys 'cause no way no how are we getting Senate dems from liberal states, regardless of whether they're shall-issue or may-issue. So realistically this will probably turn out to be a waste of time. Like working for Trump in battleground states
  12. We need 30 more. Forget the may-issue states and VT (that's 12). IMO NH and ME are iffy at best. I'm wasting time here: The vote will go along party lines with 1-2 R's defecting and 3-4 democrats coming on board. 53-47 = we can pound sand. "National Firearm Carry Act of 2018 Saves the Day" -- NRA and NJ2AS take credit.
  13. Only one state AFAIK, Vermont, doesn't issue permits. Some states recognize a VT driver's license.
  14. OK this idea has percolated through my porous brain for a couple of days. Here's the thing. Reciprocity will not pass. It will squeak through the congress but out of respect for their colleagues in NJ, MA, NY, CA and half a dozen other states no democrap except for Manchin will vote for it. They will deflect criticism by telling their constituents in shall-issue states that it doesn't affect them that much, and that they will work on getting more reciprocity agreements (which they won't). Solution: Federal concealed carry stamp available to all firearm licensing authorities. Good in all 50 states. Otherwise all state laws apply. Since all states are now at least "may issue" NJ, NY, etc. can't possibly have a legal leg to stand on in challenging it.
  15. My first instructor has been at it for a very long time and has 17 NRA gold leaf clusters and three signet rings. He was obviously being facetious. You don't even recognize you're speaking metaphorically. A "safety" is a mechanical or physical THING that prevents the gun from firing when you pull the trigger. "Trigger control" is not a safety. Mental state is not a safety. Muzzle discipline is not a safety. Awareness is not a safety. Keeping your finger off the trigger is not a safety. By your definition leaving a gun in the safe or unloaded is a safety. No. The little lever on the side that prevents the gun from shooting when you pull the trigger is a safety. And to some degree a very hard trigger pull is a safety. I know this personally because when my carpal tunnel acted up late last year I could only shoot my big revolvers with great difficulty. On a couple of occasions I switched to semi-auto after just a few cylinders. No problem with the semi-autos as long as I racked them. Your beef about condition 0 is the difference between your 5.5 lb trigger and my 4.5 lb trigger. That's about one-seventh of the difference between 11.5 and 4.5, which you say is negligible. If 7 lbs are negligible then 1 lb is infinitesimal. So for all practical purposes your gun is cocked, one round chambered, and the only safety is your other-worldly muscle memory. By definition condition 0. But don't be afraid, embrace it man.
  16. Of course. Problem is that accidents happen and they happen to everybody, particularly the untrained. It's a statistical thing that training can reduce but never completely eliminate. My first handgun teacher laughed when I asked him about the safety on an SW 617. "The safety is the long hard trigger pull." I've subsequently read that 100 times (and I now own a 617 and other revolvers). One of the "accidents" is something getting into the trigger guard, most likely a finger. Except for rare instances of faulty hardware I'd guess that 99.9% of all NDs occur because someone's FINGER was on the TRIGGER. You can jump up and down about the three rules all you like. THat's what human beings do. They put their fingers into small cozy places. That's why we get married. About 750 accidental gun deaths occur each year in the US. 75,000 injuries. Geezus I'm beginning to sound like Mothers Against. I'll bet 90% of those involved a gun in condition 0. To say that, all other things being equal -- equally poor muzzle control, equally stupid awareness of gun being loaded -- a 5lb pull is the same as an 11 lb pull is absolutely ludicrous. Your "under stress" scenario is disingenuous. The blind gunsmith shot himself while he was cleaning his gun. The firefighter in PA was at work showing off his Glock. The black cop in the elevator was straightening out his holster. When you're shooting at someone you definitely don't want the difference between 11 and 5 lbs to be an issue. It is precisely when you're NOT under stress that the 11 lb trigger matters. The bottom line here: you're saying that someone who cannot trust himself to be alone with an unloaded gun, in his basement, who follows the rules, to practice drawing from a holster should nevertheless carry a loaded gun in condition 0 in public. "Practice with your self defense ammo" but practice drawing with a non-functional piece of plastic that is the wrong weight and feel. "Dry fire is a great training method" but "dry draw" is somehow dangerous. Blue guns are valuable classroom situations or to teach beginners basic handling.
  17. Newtonian replied to Newtonian's topic in Rifles
    I'm still mulling this over. I have until early May now to save on a NICS. The thought of another caliber sends shivers up my spine. I'm going to have to start throwing furniture away. OK, and in the hands of an avg-so-so shooter the problem with 7.62x39 is what? Mind you I'm not hitting anything at 500 yards except the ground. Maybe.
  18. I'd have to say yes, if you accept the crazy status quo.
  19. Gotcha 100% but the problem with less permissive standards is it steps on too many toes. Every shall-issue and may-issue state has its own nonsense, from justifiable need to high fees to training. Although I believe in permitless carry an entire legal industry is built on states screwing with us on guns or everything else. It goes beyond reasonable regulation more often than not. Even Vermont, which never had gun laws, prohibits carry in courtrooms and schools. That is the legal climate that will undo this law, not Weinberg kicking and screaming.
  20. Interstate commerce is a frail reed with which to push reciprocity. From what I've seen it can mean anything and nothing at the same time. I'm liking my idea more and more.
  21. I just had a brain storm, or brain fart depending on your take. As abhorrent as the notion may sound -- and here I echo Mipa's view that oppressive federal law may serve to relieve oppression within the states -- the solution here may be some sort of national carry license. I know, I know, more bureaucracy, paperwork, federal intrusion. But what if you could, for $39.95 and proof of a valid carry license from any state, obtain something similar to a SS card but for firearm carry? To make this as unobtrusive as possible each state would simply have to change the nonsense they stamp on their cheap plastic card. Or even simpler issue a simple sticker that confers some national or federal carry designation that already exists? Thus a NJ resident holding a Utah or NH permit would have the same privileges as an FBI agent, but subject to state laws on carry into schools, tranny bathrooms, lesbian wedding celebrations, etc. Note the distinction is purely ceremonial, fictional, and utterly stupid but it's the kind of thing that lawyers respect in their own strange way. It's not a Utah license being shoved down Loretta Weinberg's throat, it's a federal license.
  22. I just had a brain storm, or brain fart depending on your take. As abhorrent as the notion may sound -- and here I echo Mipa's view that oppressive federal law may serve to relieve oppression within the states -- the solution here may be some sort of national carry license. I know, I know, more bureaucracy, paperwork, federal intrusion. But what if you could, for $39.95 and proof of a valid carry license from any state, obtain something similar to a SS card but for firearm carry? To make this as unobtrusive as possible each state would simply have to change the nonsense they stamp on their cheap plastic card. Or even simpler issue a simple sticker that confers some national or federal carry designation that already exists? Thus a NJ resident holding a Utah or NH permit would have the same privileges as an FBI agent, but subject to state laws on carry into schools, tranny bathrooms, lesbian wedding celebrations, etc. Note the distinction is purely ceremonial, fictional, and utterly stupid but it's the kind of thing that lawyers respect in their own strange way. It's not a Utah license being shoved down Loretta Weinberg's throat, it's a federal license.
  23. I'm with you. Unconstitutionality in defense of constitutionality is no vice. I'm not being a smartass. I really do not understand the words or their meanings in that context. Mathematically speaking I think they were right about Trump's odds. The numbers were screwy but he had just enough in just the right places, despite at least 5 million ineligibles voting, AT LEAST. You need "facts" to prove I voted illegally. You don't need "evidence" to prove that a human endeavor involving hundreds of millions of events (eligibility, registration, voting, counting) does not involve error. It's a statistical certainty. Plus you have: * 20-30 million foreigners * about 20 million citizen-deplorables (felons, otherwise ineligible, unregistered) * essentially no proof of eligibility required in democrat states * All highly motivated out of stupidity or fear to vote for Fat Legs. * proven fraud in 2012, when the Philly district where the local Republican leader lived did not register a single Republican vote. Imagine not one crack whore or alkie or illiterate individual stumbled into a booth and pulled the wrong lever. Districts in Detroit this year where the number of actual voters was X and the number of votes counted was 10X (one reason the recount was cut short) Miracle.
  24. I would like to pour hot diarrhea on all those smiling deluded old fuckers. They look like pensioner-tard refugees from the education system. Problem here is that, according to the legal fiction that permits regulating 2A out of meaningful existence in NJ, the federalists are 100% correct. Barring a SCOTUS ruling that the plain language meaning of 2A means what it says, Hudson's law is an undue usurpation of states' rights to regulate what is seen nationally as an optional right. It probably won't pass and/or withstand Supreme Ct. review -- even if Trump's guy is sworn in in time -- for that reason. A right-leaning SCOTUS has already decided that NJ's particular legal fiction should stand. Replacing Scalia with the most conservative judge in the universe won't affect the court's makeup enough to cause them to treat lower court intervention in this matter any differently than they did Drake. So if the Senate miraculously passes it -- a long shot considering how many Republicfuckers are against Trump -- we'd have about 13 minutes to strap on our stuff and drive downtown before some federal court invalidates the law. I'm sure the lawyers have their briefs already written. BTW does anyone understand that stupid blurb from "predict-a-gov"? The bill won't pass because "the primary sponsor is a Republican" and "the overall text of the bill does little to its chances of being enacted"? What kind of double-talk nonsense is that? Is this a shadow site for CNN?

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.