Everything posted by Newtonian
-
CC coming to NJ?
Of course. We already "have" CCW. Every news source reported that "Illinois is the only state not to allow concealed carry." They were right. So what's the deal on reciprocity? Seems that would be an interesting route to pursue nationally. NJ does, after all, issue some permits to big shots. If we had national reciprocity, NJ would be forced to recognize licenses from PA, WV, FL, etc. I don't have stats, but I'd bet that 25,000-50,000 NJ residents currently hold out-of-state licenses. Maybe even 100,000. Reciprocity would reduce NJ carry laws to that of the least-restrictive state issuing non-resident permits. Unless reciprocity would be limited to resident permits, it would blow NJ's "may issue" out of the water, don't you think?
-
CC coming to NJ?
I read somewhere, 5-6 years ago, that if a certain number of states passed concealed carry laws that the remaining states would be required to pass them as well. Sounds sort of kooky. How this could be enforced is beyond me. Has anyone else heard of similar fairy tales?
-
2nd Gun - Pistol Permit Question
You might be surprised to learn that despite its recent flirtation with insanity, and the fact that Ct. is by law a "may issue" state with respect to concealed carry (on paper just like NJ), in actual practice almost nobody is turned down for a carry permit. So despite magazine limits and other nonsense, 95% of the things that can get you three years in prison in our state have no legal consequence in Connecticut -- provided, of course, that you go through the process. I learned just last week that the same is true, more or less, in most upstate (non-New York City) New York counties. Getting CC up there takes about six months. There are residence and training requirements, and a lot of hoops to jump through, but almost anyone can get one. Some counties confer a restricted carry license (hunting, fishing) that is easily upgraded; others issue unrestricted, i.e. Pennsylvania-type licenses. NJ, DC, and HI will soon be the only states that are essentially non-issue. Not sure about California. It's ironic, sad, pathetic, that when most Americans talk about 2nd Amendment rights they mean a whole universe of things that are completely foreign in NJ. Here I'd be happy with being able to make an "unreasonable" trip to the bathroom on my way to the range, or to refill my thermos.
-
Not the typical "first gun" question
If money is an issue as you state, you pretty much have to go with a .22. The conversion kits, and the guns that work with them, will cost you about as much as two quality used guns. Even if that were not so, you will find the larger calibers are way too expensive to shoot with any regularity. My firearms instructor once told me that buying a firearm is the least expensive part of shooting. 9mm ammo costs about 30-35 cents per round, and those magazines empty mighty fast. .45ACP goes for 40-45 cents per round. A trip to the range will cost you $100-$250 between range time and ammo. You can get .22lr for eight to ten cents per round if you hunt around. That will cut your ammo costs by 75%, but you're still talking $50-$60 per trip. Or you can join a range for $200-400 per year, depending on where you live. In other words, the higher calibers will set you back $1200-$3000 per year, assuming one range trip per month. More experienced posters than I will tell you if that's "enough." If you live with other people, particularly little ones, you definitely should take a home defense class before keeping a .45 ACP cocked and locked in your night table. That will set you back about $200 more. See what I'm talking about? I bought my first handgun about 9 months ago. I still have not got around to home defense mode because I have three people running around here, coming and going at various hours, and I have not taken a home defense class. In short, don't blow the rent money to satisfy a caliber fetish. The odds are overwhelmingly against ever facing a home defense situation. It's a lot harder to defend yourself from a cardboard box after you've been evicted or foreclosed. Also, unless you live in a neighborhood populated by two-headed fire-breathing zombies on bath salts, you'll be able to stop or disperse almost any asshole with 12 rounds of .22 long rifle. I'm probably inviting a flame war with that comment but that is my relatively uninformed opinion.
-
Christie vetoed-- A-3668/SCS for S-2467, 2471 -ABSOLUTE – Prohibits investment by State of pension and annuity funds
I predict he will veto everything, with the possible exception of the mental health provision. CC's presidential aspirations will not go very far if he is viewed as unfriendly to the 2nd Amendment.
-
Sweeney Bill Passes -- My Letter to the Governor
Unless he does the right thing, CC has no chance in republican primaries held in gun-loving states. OTOH, should he miraculously win the nomination, he has an excellent chance to win the general election. Specifically because of his RINO status. Speaking of animals, a caller on an NPR talk show today called him "porcine."
-
Sweeney Bill Passes -- My Letter to the Governor
Dear Mr. Christie, As you are probably aware, a number of new gun laws, including S2723 / A4182, will soon cross your desk for signature. Since I am not an expert in law, philosophy, or theology I will not embarrass myself by arguing against those bills on the basis of constitutional rights, natural rights, or God-given rights. I hope you veto these bills because they further remove New Jersey from the mainstream of U.S. law. As it is, there are dozens of actions that can send otherwise law-abiding N.J. residents to jail for years, which have absolutely no legal consequences in about 46 other states. For example, stopping to go to the bathroom on your way to the range. Legislators who point to these laws as "a model" for other states are delusional. I do not believe they know anything about gun laws in other states, including many states with Democratic-controlled legislatures. [Long, boring lecture on concealed carry and other reasonable accommodations omitted]. Far from being models, these laws advance the view of most common-sense out-of-staters of New Jersey as a laughingstock. By the way, one need not refer to Arizona or Alaska to hear that sentiment. You need only cross the Delaware, or drive into NY State. Yes, New York. You were once quoted as saying that "New Jersey already has enough gun laws." Your friend Corey Booker has also stated that in his tenure as Mayor of Newark, only one murder (out of about 650) was committed with a "legal" gun. I hope you still believe what you said about N.J. gun laws, and still trust law-abiding citizens of our state to deal with firearms in a responsible manner. Sincerely yours, (Name deleted for obvious reasons)
-
"Golden Bullet" question
Cabelas is selling Remington Golden Bullet .22lr for 7 cents/round. I'd have posted this in the "deals" category but they're limiting sales to 100 rounds and their cheapest shipping option makes it prohibitively expensive. Does anyone have any experience with this product? Golden Bullet .22 shorts make my S&W 617 revolver lock up.
-
NY concealed carry
These stories are ample and obvious. Everyone knows about them. They DO NOT WORK as arguments for changing NJ gun laws. They have no impact on NJ legislators who grew up hating guns, and hating gun-owners. They do not care about home invasions. To them, these are abstracts. They care more about the criminals, the savages who prey upon us, than they do about us. I posted about a month ago about a prosecutor I know who routinely lets illegal aliens go free, while punishing USA citizens accused of the same offenses. It is time to change tactics. These tired old arguments have got us NOTHING, nowhere. We're going backwards. The more we propose then, the worse off we are. Don't you realize this by now??? We have to begin playing a different game. If we don't, if we keep antagonizing these assholes, we're going to wind up with nothing. If you think it can't happen, wait until Fat Boy signs these bills. Then what?
-
NY concealed carry
Why should the process not be impartial? Since when has the judiciary (at any level) been impartial? I do not believe that a judge steering a case to a pro-2A judge would be guilty of anything. I'd like to hear from lawyers on this. I'd be happy if they would steer cases equally, if they liked, to pro- and anti-2A judges. That alone would be progress. We're entered a bunker/captive mentality in this state. Looking for ghosts in all the wrong places.
-
NY concealed carry
You hit the nail on the head. This should be the teaching point, and we should take it up and express it factually but respectfully. We are starting at close to zero. You don't get a kid to eat spinach by yelling at them. We've been taking the wrong approach. The more we yell, the tighter they clamp their palms against their ears, threatening even more "model" legislation. PLEASE: No more yelling. No more fist-banging. No more constitutional or religious concepts that many individuals view as abstract and/or subjective, or just plain ludicrous. Those approaches may have worked in other states, but they are in good part responsible for the current state of affairs in New Jersey. We may think their perspective is ridiculous and anti-fact, but many of our legislators grew up, like me, brainwashed into hating guns. Fear and prejudice are tough things to shake.
-
NY concealed carry
This is what I'm kind of getting at. Identify judges who are pro-2A, and work with them. If they issue enough carry permits, and nothing bad happens, other judges sitting on the fence will see the writing on the wall. I think.
-
NY concealed carry
I'm no lawyer but to me, mandatory training classes for concealed carry seem to be a reasonable accommodation given our (and NY residents') current situation. I realize that individuals in "free" states, and constitutionalists here, will disagree. Vermont, Alaska, and Arizona are doing fine without a training requirement, as are many other states. We don't live in those other states. We live in a state where a trip to the bathroom can get you several years in the penitentiary. We have to be reasonable in our demands. We have to learn from the left, which has reached its position of dominance in states like ours not by pushing for radical change, but through the process of erosion, of slow evolution. Like the proverbial lobster in the kettle. It's a long-term, long-range battle. If we're selfish and rail against liberal politicians, call them names, tell them exactly what's our minds, quote the Founding Fathers, argue the finer points of constitutional law, throw in a reference or two to God, we will get nowhere. We must fight on empirical facts, on ideas of justice and harmony with surrounding states. We must point out that our laws, governing actions with no legal consequences in 45 or so other states, can send good people to jail and ruin their lives and their families' lives. Common sense.
-
NY concealed carry
Ahh, but I'm not talking about pre-empting state law. Current state law says something to the effect that you make your case for the need to carry, individual judges exercise their discretionary power, and almost always turn you down. Note the recent news stories regarding Illinois, where they say it was the "last state" not to offer concealed carry, totally ignoring the fact that NJ essentially is a de facto no-issue state. These journalists, at least, recognize NJ as a de jure "may issue" state. What I'm suggesting is that counties simply pass legislation defining "need" down to a more basic, fundamental, i.e. constitutional level for their courts. Do counties pass their own laws in this state? I don't know.
-
NY concealed carry
Yes, I wrote correctly. NY as in "New York." I learned just last night that it is relatively easy to obtain a concealed carry permit in upstate NY. Some counties are easier than others. There's something called "restrictive" carry which allows you to carry -- openly, I believe -- while hunting and fishing. However, it seems that with a bit of effort you can get this changed to full (concealed) carry. Some counties will pretty much give anyone a CC as long as they pass the required checks. I was unaware that NY was so lenient in this regard. This is another reason why, in my opinion, the organizations that represent NJ gun owners should abandon arguments related to constitutional or God-given rights, natural rights, self-defense, etc. Yes, those are all valid reasons for changing NJ gun laws. However, they mean nothing to the party that currently controls the legislature. I'll bet most of them are totally unaware of the pervasiveness in the U.S. of CC, and that even in liberal NY state, most citizens outside of NYC (I read that Buffalo is also somewhat restrictive) can obtain concealed carry licenses. Which raises another point: Could counties pass their own CC legislation? After all, NJ is a "may issue" state that does not (legally, at any rate) forbid carrying firearms. In other words, could my rural county instruct judges and police to issue carry permits to individuals who meet certain criteria?
-
News regarding PA CCW reciprocity
Thanks, all.
-
News regarding PA CCW reciprocity
Can anyone suggest a location in northern NJ where one can obtain this training, or the entire package?
-
News regarding PA CCW reciprocity
What qualifies as the "training" requirement for Utah? Would a signed statement from a legit firearms training instructor suffice? It seems that you could save a few hundred $$$ by doing it yourself.
-
Post NICS Wait Time (NO discussion)
About one hour -- probably shorter, as I left to perform an errand. The guy before me in line: 3 minutes.
-
BB/pellet gun
Quiz question: Does anyone remember how/why the Sussex, N.J. police department was disbanded in the early 1990s? And what happened to the crime rate?
-
BB/pellet gun
It's amazing what you can find online. The only exceptions are LEO or events "approved by the town council." Firearms include everything that's considered a firearm in this state, presumably even slingshots although I'm not sure about that. § 109-1Prohibited. It shall be unlawful for any person to discharge any firearms within the Town of Newton.
-
BB/pellet gun
Do discharge rules differ among towns and jurisdictions within the state?
-
BB/pellet gun
So do the same restrictions apply w/ regard to shooting in one's back yard? Distance from neighboring homes?
-
A3666: Prohibits mail order/internet/phone sales of ammunition
That group is pathetic. Instead of lecturing people in a must-issue state that ranks 42nd nationwide in murder rate, why don't they go to other states and urge couples to stay together, not have children out of wedlock, take initiatives to prevent teenage pregnancy, stay off welfare, make sure their kids are doing their school work instead of hanging out on street corners, etc. Oh, I forgot. That would involve actually fixing the problem. And it is not a problem in Maine. Everyone knows what the problem is, and where it resides.
-
Two Sig p238 (1911-type) questions
I've done a lot of research on the Sig P238 (.380 ACP). The experts say it is the smaller brother of the famed 1911 model pistol. Question 1: The P238 is supposed to be carried "cocked and locked." A whole bunch of videos show how to lower the hammer in preparation for making the gun safe. I would be a bit skittish about this. Isn't it possible, with the safety on, simply to drop the magazine and cycle the gun, thereby ejecting the live round with zero chance of firing? Question 2. The P238 is single-action only. You can't have a round in the chamber and rely on a heavy double-action pull to make the gun less unsafe. Instead of cocked and locked, wouldn't it be possible to carry this gun with the hammer down, and to cock it before firing the first shot? Of course, this assumes that you could magically, safely lower the hammer with a round in the chamber. And if so, isn't it too bad the gun has no decocker? I'm new to this type of firearm and appreciate any advice. Of course any reference to "carry," real or imaginary, is purely theoretical. Even if we were permitted to I am obviously not skilled or confident enough.