Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Newtonian

Members
  • Joined

  • Last visited

Everything posted by Newtonian

  1. I'd been meaning to take that course for 25 years. Had I done so back then I would have had hives. I can barely keep up with the hobbies I have. I'll go to their meetings (one is tomorrow) and help out at their hives but leave the heavy stuff to people with more vim and vigor. I can ask my mother in law, who lives in Ramsey, if she wants a hive. She has a perfect place for two or three.
  2. I just last week completed the course at the Sussex County Beekeepers Association. I would like to but I would hate for it to turn into another one of those things that I put off to "next week." It's not cheap to get started either. I was thinking maybe of just getting one "nuc" hive though.
  3. Well then she's not in conservatorship is she?
  4. They should make this guy the NJGF poster boy. Shoots himself, gives some creep the combo to his gun safe, goes out and trashes a bar, then takes an official NRA Home Economics class. But goddammit he has his rights. Well, almost: Hopler ... was allowed to keep his permit on the condition he fire weapons only in the presence of an adult trained in the use of firearms. This condition still stands. What a shame. Hey Darren, why don't you send this guy your optician's phone number so he can have 20-20 vision like you. Funny how people read things differently. He shot himself while "cleaning" a gun because he couldn't see that round in the chamber because he was...not blind? How many of you have shot yourselves while cleaning a gun? I can picture it now, "Mildred stop bugging me I'm cleaning my damn guns! Mildred if you nag me one more [BANG]...Mildred. MIL-DRED goddammit where are you? If you don't answer me I'll shoot." This is a guy you should really and truly never never believe when he says, "Don't worry, it's unloaded." I can hear distant NJGF voices regarding less serious situations (most recently the "girlfriend" who was afraid of guns but wanted one, strangely): "That #$&@*$ should not have a gun." I know for a fact this guy has just two beers a night. That's all he needs to wash down a quart of gin. "What was that safe combination again? Nevermind can't see the dial anyway, I'll just leave the danged thing open." "Hey officers these thirteen guns lying around next to ammo strewn all over the f-ing place are too stored safely! They're close to my safe. Safe. Safe-ly. Get it?" "You're picking on me because I'm blind you islamaphobe!" (burp)
  5. Hey I came around on the law. It's a bad law but therein is something to think about. At the range we go through all kinds of ritualistic safety stuff, which is good, then your hero advocates giving guns to the blind. Again I point out -- and I'm trying to be gentle here -- if your wife has problems with something as basic as writing and cashing checks, if she's disabled enough to collect, then either you or the agency that awarded her benefits have something to think about. You can't have it both ways. That's why I suggested your example was a bit strange. I don't like arguing this because it's personal and very painful to you (and frankly none of my business) but you keep goading me. As for the guy with the grandfather who is around the same age as my 91 year old sharp as a tack father: people don't give up personal stuff like writing their own checks (or wiping their own asses -- not being facetious) because they're lazy or bored. They do it because something not-so-pleasant is going on. Unless it's absolutely necessary it's a very bad idea to take tasks like that away from old people.
  6. Yeah, I didn't want to pick on him or his wife but he goaded me so I responded. Read what he wrote about her maladies. To me she's definitely high risk of hurting herself or others. Her conservatorship status to me concedes quite a bit. And as I mentioned if she's too debilitated to work... But there are all sorts of cases and I don't want to judge hers or any individual's, which is why I say go for it if you like. We don't have all those silly rules for individual cases but for generalities. When someone is convicted of aggravated assault and spends 3 years in prison we don't have a special hearing to deprive him of his right to own a gun or open a barber shop or for that matter to vote. We consider certain events to be predispository or whatever the word is. I realize I was "for" the law initially but I backed down on it as a legal matter. That doesn't change my view on conservatorship and guns.
  7. You are correct. The government must prove otherwise. When you designate yourself as being too incapacitated to do your finances is that proof. We can argue whether it's 100% justification -- I think it's probably not -- but I'm still waiting for an example of where it would not be.
  8. Please humor me then. Give me an example of someone so barred who is not high risk. Or cite a post to that effect. I haven't seen one yet. Tell me the exact condition that caused someone to go into conservatorship.
  9. I agree. And I generally don't like stroke-of-the-pen designations affecting the rights of millions of people. I would prefer family members make this decision but I can tell you, as someone who deals or has dealt with numerous family members in their 80s and 90s, it's very tough for individuals and their families to face the facts of old age and debilitation. Old people become "ribambitti" -- like children, and their offspring (like my siblings) are constantly in denial. I could write a book on our experiences, too many of them negative. I once had to promise an 80 year old friend who had weeks to live and could barely get out of bed to take a crap that I'd help him renew his driver's license. What if he'd asked me to buy him some ammo for his handgun? The fact that between the "system," the individual, and a family member a decision is reached that for whatever reason a person can no longer be trusted to conduct what were at one time extremely private activities says quite a bit. Despite Darrenf's delusions of blind people suddenly seeing again and shooting 1" groups. Jesus. I'm still waiting to hear of specific examples where this situation arises and that person would not be considered high risk for owning a gun. You guys don't answer the question because it's so blatantly obvious that those situations are rare. I can't even think of one, with all due respect to your wife. But like I said, you guys want to give your incapacitated relatives handguns go right ahead and let them have their Rambo moment. Just don't come on here looking for sympathy when something awful happens.
  10. Don't lecture me on rights sonny boy. I'm asking you for an example, like 3 or 4 times. You can't give one. Nobody else has given one. Case closed.
  11. Hey all of you ahead and give your blind grandparents guns. Give your elderly relatives who can't hold a teacup without dropping it a Desert Eagle. And as you've all shown being demented is just a liberal concept so see if you can get NRA to fund a program to give guns to residents of Alzheimer's care centers. Then organize a play day at the home for your kids. You wouldn't want to deny anyone their God given right to defend themselves. I'm still waiting for an actual example of someone who requires conservatorship who should be trusted with a handgun. So far I have one barely believable story of someone forced to sign a checkbox to get benefits (who nevertheless is disabled enough not to work and to collect benefits but not too disabled to...oh fuggedaboudit), and one person who believes that all you have to do to cure blindness is to get eyeglasses. I'll have to mention that to my father, whose maculas are destroyed. Very next time I visit I'll take him to WalMart and get some eyeglasses so his maculas won't be destroyed any more, so he doesn't spill his milk any more while pouring it into his cereal. Which handgun should I get him for his 92nd birthday? I was thinking a nice .44 magnum. Do they make rounds labeled in braille? Oh I forget he'll be able to see if he just puts on his damn glasses. I'll tell you, liberals have no special claim to being brainwashed and clueless.
  12. You're right it's just a meaningless administrative designation. So what if a person can't recognize faces or see what they're shooting at? I sometimes wonder if this site doesn't give off LSD.
  13. I read it and out of respect for you and your wife I did not respond. But if you insist... I mentioned there were many reasons why someone requires a financial conservator. My 91 year old father can add, subtract, and multiply rings around most of us but he's blind. Only you and your wife know the extent of her injury so I won't assume anything from your description except that she's seriously (physically) disabled, probably prone to depression as well. Problems with balance...c'mon. If you think the likelihood of your wife having to defend herself with a handgun outweighs bad stuff happening then give her all the guns you want. If you live in NJ she can only use them at home anyway. Go for it.
  14. "Conflict of interest" and "due process" are two of the most misused terms bantered about by armchair lawyers. Due process does not institute or describe a set procedure for getting from point a to point b. The key word "due" does not mean a full court hearing with lawyers and witnesses and a 12-man jury. It means appropriate, reasonable, fitting the situation. I believe age alone and an administrative ruling constitutes "due" process for prohibiting someone at one end of the age scale (toddlers) from having guns, but that obviously does not apply to a 90 year old. Or do you believe we're violating 5 year olds' constitutional rights? That we should have a trial to keep guns from them? I'm not a HUGE fan of the rule/law we're discussing here but there is no doubt in my mind that, in terms of self defense on one hand and accidents/suicides on the other, it's at best a wash. In fact I'll go out on a limb and say that within this group of individuals 3x as many kill themselves as stop a crime with their gun. Age 75+ comprises about 20% of the 35,000 suicides in this country annually yet only 5.1% of the population. Does that tell you anything? Want to discuss the plusses and minuses of suicide? We were arguing a few weeks ago about a fireman in PA who mistakenly believed he was on patrol in Falujah instead of going to work in semi-rural Pennsylvania, who shot a teenaged FD intern in the face. Is it inconceivable that an 85 year old who is too feeble to do their own banking -- who is prone to all sorts of mistakes, accidents, falls, mental lapses -- might be someone who should not have a gun? I'm not saying in every case by any means. I asked you all to come up with a scenario where a person incapable of writing and cashing his own checks would be able to handle a gun safely and all you could come up with was people who did so for convenience. Well hell, I haven't written more than 20 checks for myself in the last 33 years. YUGE difference. Ironically I've written dozens of checks in the past few months for my father, who is blind. C'mon guys, give me an example of someone who is physically or mentally incapable of doing day-to-day finances who you'd feel comfortable giving a gun to. Have your kids stay over for an afternoon at that person's house. C'mon. Stop bullshitting and give me concrete examples. You guys make me laugh with your ACLU references. The ACLU's goal is to destroy America from within. They're smart, cunning, and use the "law" to do their dirty work. Unlike the proverbial broken clock they are NOT right twice a day. You can bet that if they're for something it is wrong, degenerate, and the purpose is to further their agenda somehow.
  15. Listen you. We do have limits on the first amendment, and the third, and the fourth, fifth, etc. We don't allow 5 year olds to purchase handguns do we? Or paroled murderers. Where does it say in the constitution that "the right to keep and bear arms shall not be infringed, except for grammar school kids"? "you've deemed" -- I have nothing to do with it. We elect people to make certain limited decisions for us. For the most part they suck but sometimes they're right. And you can shove your passive-aggressive "deeming." Yes it has to do with judgement. Gun advocates cry from the rooftops that mentally incapacitated people should not have guns. Like the terrorist watch list: we can hold several million hearings or we can pass reasonable restrictions and provide an easy means to obtain an exception. You try to come off as some kind of professional expert. Tell me what do you do for your "clients" that confers such incredible insights into human nature?
  16. Based on my experience people stop doing very personal things like paying their bills (and you can think of at least a dozen more activities) because they're in some way incapacitated. I provided four examples from the four previous-generation individuals in my family: blindness, dementia, confusion/previous suicide attempt, eroded cognitive ability. Significantly higher risk means just that -- my mother, for example, would be much more likely to forget a gun was loaded; my father, being blind, would remember but he can't see what he's shooting at. Etc. IMO neither one should have a gun. This doesn't apply to me but: What does it mean when someone sits in their own poo all day? Forgets how to subtract numbers in their checkbook? Becomes paranoid? Gives their money away to strangers? Signs that something is going on no? High risk doesn't mean they're going on a murder rampage, it means their likelihood of getting into trouble is higher. Why it's not in your father's case is his business and yours. I speak only for my family. What you guys do with your own incapacitated parents is your business. You can buy them razor-blade puppies for all I care.
  17. I am arguing that the criteria set forth in the EO, as I understand them, are a good proxy for someone of a certain age being incapable of handling a gun safely. What are you arguing, that most people who are too feeble to write checks or visit the ban are capable?
  18. The background checks are 98% bullshit. It's the 2% the laws exist for, the people who should not have guns but try to get them. The checks are by no means an insurmountable impediment but they are an impediment. If they weren't we wouldn't complain about them.
  19. "Not even close." So very few individuals who have others do their finances are also incapable of handling a gun. And there are people who are so wealthy and busy at age 70, 80, 90 that they let you write checks for them. I know people who are worth oodles and have accountants who don't do that. I know people of modest means who have accountants who don't do that.
  20. If there's no loophole then what is the difference between the current law and universal background checks? Seems to be some thing that they want and we don't.
  21. Sorry I didn't read it correctly. (Puts on thinking cap). Having someone else handle your finances is a fairly reliable proxy for something being seriously wrong with a person. I'm hard pressed to think of a condition that would require a person's child to handle their finances that does not make them an unacceptably high risk for owning a gun. I'll give you three examples. Father is blind so little Sally does his banking. Should he have a gun? Mama thinks a train runs through her living room and gives her SS# to anyone who asks. Gun? Uncle Mike damaged nerves in his hand in an accident. Writing causes unreal pain. Lifting a dinner plate is out of the question. Maybe NRA and the ACLU can team up and design a gun that works through telepathy. Problem is Uncle Mike would need a second person to pick up and aim the gun. As for the ACLU -- not knowing anything else about this legal action, their endorsement is reason alone for opposing it.
  22. My initial reaction was rash. We had a similar discussion regarding the terror watch list. Almost identical in fact. It's complicated. Reasonable people don't want terrorists or people with serious mental illnesses to get guns. Reasonable people also recognize that how we classify people as belonging to either category leaves a lot to be desired. There is also the issue, in an imperfect system, of how many "innocent" people you have to punish to get one worthy result. Reasonable people also realize that that number cannot, can never be zero. NRA doesn't realize that fact. On all these issues, NRA takes the position that it's better for 1,000 lunatics, Alzheimer's patients, or Al Qaeda operatives to have guns than to restrict one law-abiding person's rights. (I wanted to add "toddlers" to that list but I don't want this discussion moved to the 9th Amendment Lounge). The definition of that form of legal thinking is anarchy. If we applied that same standard to crimes the justice system would grind to a halt. No-one would ever be tried, arrested, or even detained lest we violate the rights of everyone everywhere to roam free, lest a single person be wrongly convicted. Relying on self-reporting in the case of old people doesn't work. It took a diagnosis of legal BLINDNESS to get my father to sell his car. My mother still insists she's in charge of her life yet she falls for every scam in the book. Hey if you guys are ok with old people offing themselves or mishandling a firearm and killing an innocent bystander to protect their constitutional freedoms go for it.
  23. I didn't read the law either but if the summary was correct and if the restriction is or has been applied intelligently then no, it's not good. I'm closely watching/have watched four people age. One had alzheimer's and mentioned killing himself several times as he recognized his own physical and cognitive decline. Luckily or unluckily his brain deteriorated faster than his ability to do himself in. He's now dead. Person number two is 81 and suffers a number of maladies, including depression and axiety, and has actually attempted suicide (long ago). She can't handle her own finances or many day-to-day experiences. Her life is mostly enjoyable but I have no doubt that she'd kill herself if she had a gun. Person number 3 is on the verge of mental incompetence. I'm talking twice going to the post office to pay someone $2000 for remotely "fixing" her computer. Person number 4 is 91, perfectly lucid, and wouldn't kill himself in a million years. Do you guys really believe the first three people should have/have had guns? Would you let them drive? Package your ra-ra any way you like but suicide by gun is a huge dark cloud hanging over our gun culture. Its seriousness and sadness need no enbellishment or hyperbole from Bloomberg or Schumer. The numbers are staggering. You yell and scream that all these crimes are committed by crazy people but you stand for the "right" of a mental defective to have a gun. Are you stupid? Did the NRA implant a chip into your brain?
  24. That's the most universally palatable and viable option. A close second is no-frills reciprocity that caters to NJ-like restrictions. Least likely to pass is the one that's supposedly on the table now. As a 2nd Amendment absolutist I will however settle for door #2. I know it's craziness but it gets a very important foot in the door. I'll worry about magazine capacity, hollow points, and any other frills after I'm dead.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.