Everything posted by AVB-AMG
-
Girl Takes Graduation Pic with Gun... (Article)
^^^^^ Smart Husband...! AVB-AMG
-
New Moderator - Mrs Peel
@Mrs. Peel: Oops.. that is the 3-band model that is only available and legal outside of NJ.... Shame on my sloppiness... Here is a NJ-legal, one-shot version that she may use under strict supervision and after successfully passing the mandatory training course: AVB-AMG
-
Formal Instruction?
FYI - I was hoping to take the S&T 1-day class on CCW, that has historically been offered on a Saturday in April. Unfortunately, when I recently called and spoke with Joe to express my interest and enroll, he said he had a conflict for that date and will be rescheduling the CCW 1-day course to a date sometime this fall. Stay tuned.... AVB-AMG
-
New Moderator - Mrs Peel
@Gunsrlegal: As the founding and first member of the double-banned club, you will be demoted to only being able to fire this: AVB-AMG
-
Emergency Bug Out
Yes, but it was also very easy to get rather carried away as one thinks of more and more possible situations you may encounter..... That is what happened to me. AVB-AMG
-
Emergency Bug Out
I agree with many of the previous comments in this thread and have revisited and updated a post on this topic that I made several years ago. In northern NJ we have lost electrical power, land-line telephone, most cell phone service and cable tv/telephone, multiple times in the past 20 years, primarily due to strong wind, ice and snow storms. The worst by far was Storm Sandy where our outage lasted 13 days and, like for many here, that was our “wake up call”. Today, while I realize that you cannot plan for every possibility, you can anticipate a number of the most likely emergency situations and the best options on how to respond. This analysis is based on one asking a number of important questions in advance and then considering how that will affect you and your most likely answers are and subsequent actions to take to deal with it: - What exactly happened? (This may not be something that you will find out for a while) - What are the results of the emergency event? (Failure of electrical power, contaminated water, no cellular service, nuclear fallout, martial law imposed, etc.?). - Where are you when “it” happened? (At home, at work, driving your car somewhere, traveling?). - Where did the emergency event occur? (The proximity to the event and where you and/or your family are at that time?) - Did you have any advanced warning and if so, how much? (Most likely for a severe weather storm event or health pandemic) - Do you decide to stay in your home or evacuate to some other place? (Depends on advanced warning, congested traffic conditions, gasoline availability, etc.) Type of disaster: I am concerned that the combination of natural and man-made carbon dioxide and methane gas being released into our atmosphere that is contributing to the acceleration of global climate change and what that may mean for the frequency and severity of our weather systems and events. Also, disaster can occur from not just Mother Nature, but from a terrorist-generated event, either physical or cyber, affecting our power grid, water supply and communications systems. Or it could be a health pandemic that rapidly spreads, forcing people to stay at home. Another worst-case scenario would be attempting to deal with the aftermath of a single or multiple EMP attack on our country that destroys the capability of almost all electronic equipment to function. In addition, a national and/or international economic crisis could also perpetuate a rapid downward spiral of our society, pushing us into another Great Depression with grave consequences for all of us. If the inequality of the classes continues to broaden, it could eventually lead to progressively worse protests, demonstrations, riots and escalating civil disobedience and unrest that may potentially become something much worse for the existence of our country as we know it. Finally, I share the concerns advocated Elon Musk and the late Stephen Hawking about how we all need to become aware of, understand the ramifications and be wary of the potential negative effects of the progress of artificial intelligence (AI) in our society and what that could mean for mankind… Stay / Bug-In: I am assuming that in most emergency events that we would be able to stay in our home and ride it out for approximately two (2) weeks. Our “lesson learned” from Super Strom Sandy was/is that we now have a minimum of 2 weeks’ worth of unrefrigerated canned food and water, along with an alternative food cooking/heating option. When the weather report indicates a possible strong storm approaching our area, I will fill up all of our vehicles gasoline tanks, as well as 5-gallon gas jug. I also fill up a 10-gallon water container and get a sufficient amount of cash from our bank’s ATM. In the worst-case scenario, we also have multiple firearms, sufficient ammunition and the knowledge and practice on how to properly and safely store them and if need be, to use them effectively for self-defense. In this relatively short scenario, we would help our friends and neighbors to the best of our ability, taking a "we are all in this together" attitude. Leave / Bug Out: If we chose not to stay in our home and/or a mandatory evacuation is required, we have a Plan A and a Plan B on where we would go, or at least try to go. This begins with having one vehicle, fully fueled with all-wheel drive and good tires with room for us and key items. We have prepared key survival items in “Go Bags”, (that actually turned into multiple bags and now is our “Go Luggage”), along with a list of items to take in case we need to evacuate our home. The degree of the emergency will be predicated on the extent and severity of the power outage or unexpected situation. Is it limited to being local in our neighborhood or town, or just in our county, or is it broader, i.e. state-wide or say the northeast U.S. or the entire country…? That reality will certainly influence one’s “bugging out” options and whether realistically it makes sense to even leave your home to attempt to go someplace else. Keep in mind that we are living in NJ, the most densely populated state in the country. So it is best to assume that all roads will be experiencing very heavy traffic that will be crawling along or clogged with many others in their vehicles with the same idea. What happens when you run out of gas? Will you possibly be worse off in that situation, if you have yet to reach your desired destination? Where is your destination? A second home, rural cabin, friend’s home, hotel/motel, campground? A rational weighing of the options, accepting the realistic chances for success and all of the various possibilities of what could go wrong, will be necessary to make the best possible choice of what to do. After 2 weeks: Ultimately, I think most of us should be fine for up to two weeks without electricity. During that second week, let alone beyond, the main concern will be for obtaining all forms of food and potable drinking water. Many people, primarily city-dwellers, who do not have the space to stock up and store an adequate supply of both will be the first to panic. They will run out sooner and when they become desperate they will start by looting local stores and then things will rapidly deteriorate and general respect for civil order and law-abiding society will crumble. This will result in gang rampages through apartment buildings, targeting the elderly and defenseless first to rob whatever food and supplies they can get. While we in suburbia think we are far enough away from this mob scene, we may be kidding ourselves. Most suburbs are not realistically defendable from the onslaught of desperate refuges from the more urban cities and ring towns and will be overrun by these people seeking safe food and water and will do horrible terrorizing things to others to obtain them. Desperate former urbanites will become the real zombies attacking others, first in the suburbs and then in the more rural areas. Even with firearms and ammunition, the number of these desperate people will overwhelm most family’s ability to defend what little they have left. Keep in mind that not everyone is predisposed to preparing in advance for a long-term crisis without electrical power. Not everyone has the physical and financial resources to prepare for these “what if” scenarios and they will become equally desperate, just as fast as their urban brethren and may be knocking on your door, or worse, sooner than you think. Bigger Questions: As far as the extreme “preppers” seen in these silly television programs and YouTube videos, I always ask myself what are they going to do once they eventually run out of their incredible stock of supplies in 6,9, 12 or 18 months? If our society breaks down to such a degree that our population is in a mass panic, with chaotic disorder being the norm, where rule of law has disappeared and civilization as we have come to know it no longer exists, who would want to live in that type of world? What’s the point? Survival for what purpose? At that point, let’s all enjoy each other’s companionship, both intimate, social and intellectual, augmented by some of the finer man-made luxuries, such as some fine liquor, non-spoiled food, cigars and other selected pharmaceuticals and make what little time left in this world as pleasant as possible. As others have stated, I also believe it is prudent that we all prepare for surviving and protecting our respective families for a reasonable amount of time after some form of disaster. There are plenty of real and possible man-made and natural threats to our families, state and country, some within our control and others beyond it and future generations will have a bigger challenge. I strongly believe that it is important that we not live our lives in a state of perpetual paranoia, fear, dread or depression, due to thinking about "what bad things could possibly happen". I realize that the odds of them happening anytime soon are quite small. So, I just try to remind myself to be most thankful for what we have, including our health, family and what we have all worked hard to achieve and obtain. I appreciate waking up every day realizing that it is another opportunity to learn and enjoy ourselves and others while we are alive and, if possible, contribute something that in some way is or will be beneficial to our society that will last once we are gone. AVB-AMG
-
Emergency Bug Out
If anyone is interested, I have a very detailed, extensive list of what I decided to include in our "GO BAGS". That project sort of snowballed and we now have more than one GO BAG. Actually, we have five (5) GO BAGS filled with different items, so I just refer to them now as our GO LUGGAGE.... (Send me a PM if really interested in this list). Clearly all of these GO BAGS would go into our all-wheel drive, fully gassed "evacuation" vehicle, since all of the sherpa paid help will have abandoned us in an SHTF situation. But they also are a dedicated resource if we most likely determine to BUG IN and stay in our home, depending on what resources and utilities are still available. AVB-AMG
-
Girl Takes Graduation Pic with Gun... (Article)
@Mrs. Peel: You knew exactly what you were doing... Therefore, it is not the fault of @Krdshrk, since he just beat the rest of us to it.... A provocative photograph of a young tanned, attractive woman with sexy tight abbs and a handgun tucked in her waistband..... What's not to like...? You know that as much as we attempt to be civilized, mature, erudite, gentlemen, all of us guys have a portion of our brains that have not really evolved over 100's of years and at times we act just like dogs..... (We just do not express it out loud, like you know who did on the bus with B.B....) AVB-AMG
-
Girl Takes Graduation Pic with Gun... (Article)
@High Exposure & @fishnut: Damn....! That was fast.... I have no idea if you guys are correct but will trust both of your keen eyes and identification ability and believe you guys are correct, unless someone else can prove you wrong... Thanks... AVB-AMG
-
Girl Takes Graduation Pic with Gun... (Article)
Of course, I assume the Trump shirt..... Ok, so to all of you handgun experts, what is the make and model of the handgun tucked into the waist of her white jeans? AVB-AMG
-
Alternatives To Facebook
@Zeke: Since you asked, I have never had, nor do I think that I ever will subscribe to purely social media platforms such as Facebook, Twitter or others that are like them. I have never felt the need to use those services to communicate with my friends and relatives, since email and texting with them has proven to be perfectly sufficient for me. I have never understood the willingness of so many people who do subscribe to these services to either unwittingly or naively share their very personal information and data on a platform that has long been known to mine that information and sell it for a profit. Now, having said that, I do use LinkedIn professionally as a network of business associates. I have found that it is a good way to maintain less frequent contacts, as well as to scope out potential customers work and education history, prior to meeting with them. Finally, of course, I also frequent NJGF, which in one way, is an alternative to Facebook, with a narrower, more special interest focused audience and forum for what at times may possibly be more enlightened public discourse, (or not). Facebook is operated as an anti-competitive monopoly. It relies on software and practices that disallow theoretical competitors from directly interacting with it, thereby locking out other personal social media businesses from partaking with members of that lucrative market. The truth is that Facebook has been getting away with murder for quite some time. It's a lot easier when there are hardly any regulations over them and their management does not care whether they are damaging the fabric of our society, as long as the money keeps rolling in, which it certainly has over the past 14 years. One could argue that this is the price that we pay as a society for having greed the prime motivation in our economic system. We saw that greed in action with the mortgage/housing collapse and financial industry meltdown in 2008. I agree with the opinions on this topic expressed in this thread by @Howard, that there needs to be accountability for truth telling and that means imposing some appropriate level of federal regulation. To that end I would also suggest that content needs to be designated as either "fact" and/or "opinion". Providers violating those designations would be booted off the platform and/or fined in ways that would impose a legitimate deterrent. We know that Facebook’s management either ignored or was oblivious to how foreign entities manipulated the service in the 2016 Presidential election. According to Roger McNamee, an early Facebook investor and Board member, both Mark Zuckerberg and Sheryl Sandberg were well aware of the use of the Facebook platform by foreigners to influence that election, and they deliberately failed to take any actions that would adversely affect their revenue streams. Over a period of 3 months in mid-2016, Mr. McNamee tried to convince both of them to report the facts to Federal officials, and they refused to do so. It is shameful that the actions of Facebook's top executives have consistently shown their unwillingness to take user privacy as seriously as is warranted. Here is a recent interview with McNamee where he states his actions and concerns: https://www.cnbc.com/video/2018/03/22/roger-mcnamee-self-inflicted-wounds-are-killing-facebook.html IMHO, the current business model of Facebook will never align with users' interests. I also agree with what @mossburger said in his post regarding Facebook: “you are not the customer, you are the product”. Facebook's actual customers are the companies/entities that pay them to place advertisements on Facebook. Their company culture has evolved and is now centered on data harvesting with minimal restrictions and has only ever been modified very reluctantly when forced by public pressure. Mark Zuckerberg’s current Mea culpa tour of Capitol Hill and testimony before the Congressional Committees is pure theatrical damage control. Cynically, I would not be surprised if both Zuckerberg and Sandberg fully expected and have planned for some form of regulation over Facebook, which they could deal with, that would also establish one more hurdle for any would be social media competitor. At this point, I think that Facebook needs to replace its business model since as it currently is, it cannot be "fixed". The current model pits the interests of the company’s executives and shareholders against its users. Any major modifications that alter the collection and management of user data will lower their revenues. Therefore, I think the solution may be two-fold: First, Congress should pass legislation to regulate these type of social media platforms, placing stringent boundaries and penalties for breaking them, on their harvesting and sharing their users private information. Secondly, since it is quite apparent that so many subscribers are by now, sufficiently addicted to Facebook, that realistically, they should and would pay to use that service. This major revision of their business model would greatly diminish their reliance on selling the private information of subscribers to advertisers, while still harvesting solid profits. AVB-AMG
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
@TheShootist: Damn...! Look who reappeared with his "ball" and wants to play again in the NJGF playground. Interesting post....and I am accused of being verbose....? Now if you had any semblance of irony, you would have posted your response one week ago today, which was Good Friday. That way at least we could celebrate your good timing to celebrate the "raising of the dead"!. I have already made all of the points that I intend to make regarding my beliefs and interpretation of the 2nd Amendment, as well as the SCOTUS, so I will let others discuss your points, if they so desire. @Mrs. Peel: Better sharpen your keyboard fingers..... Let the games begin! AVB-AMG
-
New Moderator - Mrs Peel
@High Exposure: I dare say that if someone were to walk into the Summit Diner and ask for a pork roll, egg & cheese on a roll, that the waitress or the guys behind the counter would just stop in their tracks, give you a dumbfounded look and shake their heads..... While all of the other patrons sigh and chuckle at the clueless person.... AVB-AMG
-
Things to do in the Outter Banks
@gfl216: Greetings from the OBX.... We have been down here all week at our oceanfront beach house, getting ready for the upcoming rental season. The fresh seafood is delicious and much less expensive than in NJ. We have been coming down here about a half dozen times each year for over the past 20+ years. PM me if you like, for some detailed thoughts, suggestions and recommendations for your July beach vacation. If you enjoy history then I suggest that you read: The Wright Brothers, a 2015 non-fiction book written by the popular historian David Mccullough, which IMHO, is an excellent primer to your planned visit to the Wright Brothers National Memorial in Kill Devil Hills on the Outer Banks. There was a fair amount of beach sand erosion up to the dune all along the Outer Banks shoreline as a result of the four Nor'easters in the span of 3 weeks in March. As a result, the beach width at high tide is much narrower now than in the past. Many of us are currently in the process of rebuilding the beach access walkways and stairs down to the beach that were damaged or destroyed in the storms. One thing we have learned here is that Mother Nature will add sand and take it away, regardless of what we do to combat the process. Prior to these storms, our stairs to the beach were completely covered by sand on the east side of the dune. As far as shooting sports in the OBX, if you are a hunter and enjoy waterfowl shooting in the fall season, there are several gun clubs that you could look into. I have shot clays, as well as my handguns at the Outer Banks Gun Club, located in Manns Harbor, NC, a short drive southwest from Manteo, which is a decent outdoor set up, but only on days that are not to hot and preferable with a breeze to keep way the bugs. http://www.obxgc.org/ As others here have said, clays and ammo are not very expensive when purchased at the local Walmart on Rt. 158 in Kitty Hawk. While I have stopped and checked out the Gun Shack, located at Powell's Point on the mainland, the last thing I want to do while in the OBX is to go shooting at an indoor range... Spring seems to be arriving late for all of us up and down the eastern seaboard. We have had a mixed bag of weather this week ranging from the mid-40’s up to the mid-70’s this, but have enjoyed some very nice sunrises and sunsets, (see below). AVB-AMG
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
To further this sidebar home defense discussion, that is off track of the tread's topic, let me share a story. As part of my training I took a home defense with a handgun course, In that course, I was taught to ideally have a small, bright LED flashlight in addition to a firearm. That way I could hold the flashlight in one hand and my handgun in the other. In that configuration, we were taught to cross the hand that is holding the flashlight across the wrist of the other hand that is holding the handgun, to better focus both on one point/target. The course instructor said that if so employed, an armed intruder may be temporarily blinded by the bright light from the flashlight, which would allow us to fire the first 1-2 defensive rounds from our handgun to hopefully neutralize the threat. But he also said that it is also possible that the armed intruder could instinctively fire his gun first, aiming his fire towards the light source. After some contemplative thought, I told our instructor and our class that if I was in that situation, I would tell my wife who presumably would be standing behind or next to me, something like: "here honey, hold this flashlight...". Needless to say, the women in that class were not amused by this, while all the guys were trying to suppress their laughter. AVB-AMG
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
@Mrs. Peel: Yes I have trained with a firearm used against moving target, in addition to using a shotgun for sporting clays. I have a very large stuffed animal prize to show for it, that I gave to my wife..... BTW, I forgot to say that is why I have the bottle of bourbon on the bedside nightstand, as the immediate way to calm my nerves and address the adrenaline surge in the case of a break-in. In all seriousness, I have trained shooting moving targets with a handgun and agree that is a real challenge to hit them with a high percentage of accuracy. Natural adrenaline surging during a surprise intruder situation is a very real concern and I do expect that to reduce my effectiveness in my defensive response. But then, just like Donald Trump said that he would have run unarmed into that FL high school to confront the shooter, maybe in the heat-of-the-moment, I would run down stairs, butt-naked, to confront the buggerlers and chase them out the door.... Who really knows how we will react...? AVB-AMG
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
@Bighungry618: I appreciate your acknowledging my lighthearted perspective on this thorny issue. Your approach probably makes more sense from a home defense strategy in an attire-optional sleeping scenario. At least you can have one handgun in each hand vs. me with my one handgun in one hand and you-know-what in my other hand....(heh, heh). I may be advocating a contrarian political opinion and point of view on this forum, but I try to always maintain a sense of humor, realizing that we all are American citizens just doing the best we can and trying to get along with each other.... AVB-AMG
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
@Mrs. Peel: You may be right...or not... I also hope that I, nor any of us, ever has to actually find out. In addition to the naked body defensive strategy, my wife has a stack of unread magazines next to her side of the bed. One idea is that after exhausting the 10 rounds from my handgun, I could throw those magazines at any remaining living and determined buggerlers as they attempt to climb up the staircase to the second floor, while screaming like a wild banchy. I would fully expect that they would slip on those glossy magazines and fall back down the stairs, breaking their necks in the process, thus neutralizing the threat. Mission accomplished! We all do what we feel we need to do for self and home protection. AVB-AMG
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
Zeke: Like you, I am aware of that case and do not expect our local police force to protect me or my family from robbers during an attempted break-in while we are home. In that scenario of a home break-in situation, the local PD will in most cases just be responding to the crime, after the fact, to file a report. It is highly doubtful that they would immediately apprehend the fleeing perpetrators. If, by chance, the buggerlers trip the home security system, then their is theoretically a grater chance that the local PD could possibly apprehend the buggerlers in the act or as they are departing the house. This is one of the key motivating factors for me and others to legally purchase, obtain and learn how to accurately shoot firearms for self/home defense. AVB-AMG
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
@Paulie Buffo: I am by no means an "amazing shot" and recognize that in an actual break-in event, my adrenaline would be pumping fast and that my cognitive and motor skills will be somewhat compromised. I am not looking for a "fair" fight, but do believe that I have a number of defensive advantages to successfully defend myself and family from the most likely break-in scenario involving 1-2 perpetrators. At this point, other than what I listed in my relevant post in this thread, I am not looking for any other additional gun laws to be enacted. From everything I have written on this forum should make clear, please do not make the mistake of lumping me in with the extreme "Anti-Gun" crowd, since I do not agree with them. I am NOT and WILL NOT advocate for the repeal of the 2nd Amendment. Having said that, I think it is quite possible that it could be repealed and may happen at some point in the distant future, but not in my/our life time. AVB-AMG @Mrs. Peel: National historical crime statistics show that by far that the vast majority of house break-ins are by 1-2 unprofessional young thugs looking for easy access inside the home to steal items that they can quickly sell/fence for cash to buy drugs to support their addiction. Home invasions involving 3+ people, as you describe are extremely rare. To be clear, in addition to the loaded handgun, currently with a 15 round magazine, but soon to be swapped out for a 10 round magazine, that is located in a bedside gun safe, I also have two (2) additional fully loaded magazines in the same gun safe. In the case of a break-in, I could take one or more of those additional magazines and put them in the pocket of my PJ's/Lounge Pants, in case I needed additional rounds. I don't think I would need them, but I would have them, just in case. Still, I do not believe that 15 additional rounds (45 minus 30), would really make all that difference in a shoot out with the intruders. If I cannot stop the threat by firing 30 rounds, I don't think I will be able to do so by shooting 15 additional rounds. So that is what I have prepared for. So between my legal purchase, ownership and training with my firearms, along with other home security alarm measures we have instituted, proximity of our neighbors affording audible/visible oversight on our home and the response time of our local PD, I feel reasonably and comfortably safe. My analogy is that if I am flying in an airplane that is about to make a crash landing, it really does not matter if my seat back is in the reclined position or the fully upright position... Realistically, I will probably die either way. Ok,.... I can anticipate someone here asking the question, "what if you are sleeping in the nude when the break-in occurs....then what?" My response is that of course I would be limited to the 10 rounds in my handgun since I would have no pockets for the additional loaded magazines. BUT, I would have the added advantage of the element of surprise of being able to "shock and frighten" the intruders by flashing my nude body at them. Once done, that would be enough to startle, unnerve, and discourage them of further attempts at violent aggression, as well as instinctively drop any of our material possessions and motivate them to immediately flee our house, as quickly as possible, screaming down the street. You see, I have really thought this through.... AVB-AMG
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
@Zeke: You are correct to add this. I was not focusing on stun guns, but that case is certainly applicable and is a further demonstration of the current SCOTUS stand and interpretation of the 2nd Amendment. AVB-AMG
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
@JimB1: I am all for the Justices of the SCOTUS to take into account the historical context of the period and circumstances when the Constitution was originally written by our founding fathers. IMHO, they should also take into account the current circumstances of our country, as well as all of the progress made over the past 220+ years, understanding how our society has evolved, in the process of forming their opinions in decided their cases. While I believe that our founding fathers and authors of the Bill of Rights and our Constitution were very insightful and forward thinking for their time, there is no way they could have imagined the world that we live in today. Therefore, I think it is understandable that US Supreme Court Justices over the past 230+ years, as well as in the future, will interpret the U.S. Constitution based on current society and cultural sentiment and circumstances and yes, politics. Whether we think their deicisions and interpretations are the "correct" ones or not, will be besides the point, since we will have to live with them. I am not surprised that most folks here on NJGF take the “Originalist” view on how the SCOTUS should interpret the U.S. Constitution, especially on the 2nd Amendment issue. But I thinnk you all should recognize and accept that many others outside of this gun forum prefer the “Modernist” interpretive approach. I think we all need to accept the many folks do have concerns or have some confusion due to the two statements or clauses of the 2nd Amendment. Like many of you, I have had discussions with friends and family about guns and gun ownership in this country. Most of these discussions end up with everyone’s personal interpretation of the 2nd Amendment, which are not always in agreement. Some people focus on the first part and emphasize that it really is intended solely to address the “well-regulated militia” clause and is fuzzy on personal gun ownership, while others focus on the second part about the “right of the people to keep and bear arms”, which they say is very clear. I have found it fascinating to learn that the majority of Americans accepted the first part interpretation up until 2008 when the SCOTUS decided in District of Columbia v. Heller case, in an opinion authored by Justice Antonin Scalia, that embraced and championed the second part, individual rights view of the 2nd Amendment, which has been accepted ever since. What this tells me is that it really will be dependent on the SCOTUS to continue to confirm this interpretation. Or, in some future incarnation of the SCOTUS may possibly rule on a case that reverts back to the first part of the 2nd Amendment, diminishing the personal rights to own firearms or whatever future generations of weapons may become. We just do not know how it will play out over the next 20-30 years. While it is inconceivable to me that our Congress, for the foreseeable future, will repeal or greatly alter the 2nd Amendment, I think it remains a possibility down the road. AVB-AMG
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
Just to be clear, the following is my understanding of the most recent US Supreme Court rulings addressing the 2nd Amendment issue. If I have missed something, please point it out. Thanks…. AVB-AMG In its 2008 decision on the District of Columbia vs. Heller, a 5-4 majority of the US Supreme Court ruled that the 2nd Amendment confers an individual right to keep and bear arms, and that the D.C. provisions banning handguns and requiring firearms in the home disassembled or locked, violate this right. In the majority opinion authored by Justice Antonin Scalia, the Court first conducted a textual analysis of the operative clause, "the right of the people to keep and bear Arms, shall not be infringed." The Court found that this language guarantees an individual right to possess and carry weapons. The Court examined historical evidence that it found consistent with its textual analysis. The Court then considered the 2nd Amendment’s introductory or prefatory clause, "[a] well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State," and determined that while this clause announces a purpose for recognizing an individual right to keep and bear arms, it does not limit the operative clause. The Court found that analogous contemporaneous provisions in state constitutions, the Second Amendment’s drafting history, and post-ratification interpretations were consistent with its interpretation of the amendment. The Court asserted that its prior precedent was not inconsistent with its interpretation. It is important to remember that 4 Justices dissented, each of which signed both of 2 dissenting opinions. One, by Justice Stevens, examined historical evidence on the meaning of the 2nd Amendment to conclude that the amendment protects militia-related interests. A second dissenting opinion, by Justice Breyer, stated that even if the 2nd Amendment protects a separate interest in individual self-defense, the District of Columbia provisions at issue are permissible forms of regulation. The outcome of D.C. v. Heller left some issues unanswered, including whether the 2nd Amendment restricts state regulation of firearms, and the standard for evaluating the constitutionality of other laws and regulations that impact the 2nd Amendment right. These issues will be the subject of future litigation. In 2010 the Supreme Court in McDonald vs. City of Chicago, ruled that the 2nd Amendment right recognized that Heller applies not only to the Federal Government, but also to states and municipalities.
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
@JohnnyB: I am not surprised that you and most others here in NJGF side with the “Originalist” approprach to interpreting our constitution. That is fine, as you all are part of the 46% of the U.S. population that holds that view. I do not share that approach, since I agree with the approximate 49% of the U.S. population that takes the “Modernist” approprach to interpreting our constitution. This has been the defecto split reality for at least the past 50+ years and our country has not “ceased to exist”, nor will it. Hence the important significance of who the POTUS is who will be able to nominate new Justices to the SCOTUS when vacancies do arise. I think we agree that that was one of the biggest concerns for voters in the 2016 election. Also, as I have advocated in several other threads here on NJGF, I am all for the idea of instituting a 20 year term limit for all Justices on the SCOTUS. That would help by removing Justices who MAY begin showing signs of dementia as they reach their mid-70’s. It also allows whomever the POTUS is at that time, regardless of party affiliation, to keep cycling new and younger Justices to the court. AVB-AMG
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
@Old Glock guy The Supreme Court of the United States (SCOTUS) is the highest federal court of the United States. Established in 1789, pursuant to Article Three of the United States Constitution. It has ultimate and essentially largely discretionary appellate jurisdiction over all federal courts and state court cases involving issues of federal law plus original jurisdiction over a small range of cases. In United States legal system the Court is charged with ensuring the American people the promise of equal justice under law. The Supreme Court is generally the final arbiter of the law and functions as the guardian and interpreter of federal law including the United States Constitution, but it may act only within the context of a case in which it has jurisdiction. The complex role of the Supreme Court in this system derives from its authority to invalidate legislation or executive actions which, in the Court’s considered judgment, conflict with the Constitution. This power of "judicial review" has given the Court a crucial responsibility in assuring individual rights, as well as in maintaining a "living Constitution" whose broad provisions are continually applied to complicated new situations. Unlike the black & white / absolutist opinions expressed by some here, I am not naïve and recognize and accept that each of the U.S. Supreme Court Justices will interpret the law and Constitution based on their education and work/life experiences and exposure to those who are not from the same class or “tribe”. I also am fully aware that there is a major difference of opinion on how the U.S. Constitution should be interpreted by the Justices. That division of opinion is based on multiple factors involving different demographic groups including taking into account one’s: political beliefs and ideology, level of formal education, race, age, gender and religious affiliation. According to a 2014 poll conducted by the Pew Research Center, they found that about half of the public (49%) say the decisions of the Supreme Court should be based on its understanding of what the Constitution “means in current times,” (modernist) while roughly as many (46%) say decisions should be based on what the Constitution “meant as it was originally written” (originalist). Here is a synopsis of the findings of that Pew study and what each group was sympathetic to listed by percentages: Group Modernist Originalist Democrats 70% 26% Republicans 29% 69% Post-Graduate Degree Education 62% High School Only Graduates 46% 49% Whites 44% African Americans 61% Hispanics 61% White Evangelical Protestants 73% White Mainline Protestants 44% Catholics 42% Black Protestants 37% Traditional Religiously Unaffiliated 63% 34% These differing views of how the court should interpret the Constitution may account for some of the partisan differences in opinions of the court itself seen in over the past 20+ years. So ultimately, the U.S. Constitution means what the Supreme Court Justices says it means based on each of their interpretation. AVB-AMG EDIT: I apologize for the formatting of the chart which does not appear correctly when viewed on a smart phone or tablet.