Everything posted by TheShootist
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
I thought I addressed this, maybe it was someone else. Years before the ratification of the Constitution, about 150, Militia were organized throughout the colonies. They were defined as all able-bodied men, generally from 17-60 depending on the state. All others, with the exception of some public officials and certain merchants whose business would be essential for continuity, would contribute in a fashion. All able-bodied men, unless exempt by statute, would be required to keep and bear the arms of a soldier as the statues defined; rifle, pistol, sword, tomahawk, and at least 20 ball, patches, and a pound of powder. If an able-bodied man could not afford a rifle, (not a musket), he would either be lent one from the Militia armory, or his master, that is to say his employer, would purchase, or give him one. Women would perform such tasks as making patches, gunpowder when necessary, and anything else required to maintain a functional Militia. As you read through this you will note that it encompasses the entire community in some manner. As Patrick Henry stated when confronted with the prospect of giving the federal government the only authority to arm the People; “The great object is that every man be armed. Everyone who is able might have a gun.” The 2nd Amendment does not simply define a right, but rather a duty imposed to guarantee all right to be "unalienable." Here is an article I wrote that might interest you; Stand Your Ground BTW, I've written several more on the topic.
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
Here is one of my articles read it and let me know if you change. Stand Your Ground
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
Would you like to bring a case? This requires quite a bit of explanation that starts at Article 3 that the congress has changed without an amendment. I have a plan to start, and if I can get substantial support from people such as yourself we can put it into the works. No. I'm not Dr. Vieira, but I am fairly knowledgeable on the subject.
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
That's pretty close, but the requirement would be for able-bodied men. Other's could contribute by helping an able-bodied man who couldn't afford an assault rifle purchase one. That is actually in the state militia statutes. Here's one of my articles; Stand Your Ground
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
No the right and the duty are synonymus, but 99% of the so-called pro-2nd community don't want anything to do with the duty that protects the right. Your individual right is linked to the body that is there "to execute the Laws of the Union", so that government is unable to even pass laws restricting your right. The misunderstanding comes from the fact that no one reads the Constitution, and the myriad of state statutes surrounding this subject. Here is one of my articles; Stand Your Ground
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
I focus on the Militia because it is all the People with the constitutional authority "to execute the Laws of the Union, suppress Insurrections, and repel Invasions." George Mason, author of the 2nd, rhetorically asked, "What is the militia? It is the whole people." We have a fairly large segment of the population that is trying to either limit, or remove the right. Opinion: A gun owner’s call for banning assault weapons As it stands now, do you know what percentage of the population has lost their right to keep and bear arms as the Founders intended? If you don't count police and military, it is 100%. Why would I focus on a loosing battle, when the solution was given to us by those who wrote our founding documents. Militia is mentioned 4 times in the body of the Constitution, and the pro-2nd community focuses on one aspect. Here is one of my articles that might give you some answers; Stand Your Ground
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
As I see so many times, no one understands the nature of the system that we've allowed to grow. You simply can't bring a case to the court. There has to be a basis for doing so, and you have to have support. There are many factors, and the money is a very big issue unless you're going to do all the work on your own. As a matter of fact SCOTUS passed a rule several years back that does not allow those who are not sworn before the bar to argue a case. There are hours, and hours of work that go into a case. However, when it comes down to the argument of Militia, the problem is not lawyers bringing it, it is the community in general. Example; Since 911, that is a 16 year span, the total number of people who have served in the military is 2 MILLION. You would think in a nation of more than 300 MILLION people that has just been attacked that they would be lining up. Then there is the general pro-2nd crowd who always deflect to things like, what have you done. To put that aside for the time being, I'm a veteran, I've written numerous articles on the 2nd, I've spoken on it even though I hate public speaking, I contact representatives on a constant basis, and I've asked them to debate me in an open forum. Just last week I called my congressman to challenge him to a debate. And in order to start the ball rolling, I've written the governor, and made application under Title 38A: 1-2 Composition of Militia; “such other persons as may upon their own application be enlisted or commissioned therein in accordance with federal or State law and regulations.” I've asked others to join me to gain some momentum, but I've yet to garner any support. I thought it was simple enough so that I could BRING a case, but truth be told for all those who support the NRA, and GOA, they will not come forward on the first 13 words of the amendment. As a matter of fact the issue is not bringing cases, it is the fact that this community will not perform any function of the responsibility imposed. The 2nd is part of a rubric that the Founders put together in order to guarantee that the People could not be disarmed. It requires that all able-bodied men between the ages of 17-45 keep in good working order a military rifle, with sufficient ammunition, and that THEY TRAIN ON A REGULAR BASIS. Once people hear that, all the excuses and arguments come out for an unorganized militia, and the historically incorrect nonsense that comes along with deflecting the fact that people are more inclined to do nothing, and leave it up to the next guy. I've posted a bunch of questions on here about the supposed unorganized militia. As a matter of fact I've asked those questions of a number of so-called pro-2nd people. I even asked them of someone who claimed he knew more about the topic than me. Do you know how many people have even attempted answering? NONE! Go up some comments the questions are there. But the most poignant question is, why argue about organizing, arming, and train "according to the discipline prescribed by Congress"? For those who claim to have read the Heller decision, does the court actually say that it is a right, or a privilege that the state may regulate, and in fact out of existence?
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
This James Jeager is a film maker who has produced films on government, and its abuses. It's not the loud mouth you see on youtube.
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
I don't want to be argumentative, but in what universe do you believe "that it matters what the words say?" The first 13 words to the 2nd state "A well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State." With the exception of my posts here, who has argued for "the whole people" as the Founders recognized a body of authority trained with the power to control crime on the streets, in the courts, and the legislatures? Militia is a branch of government controlled by the People. As Militia in the state statutes it comes with the authority that we've abdicated to a bunch of unconstitutional law enforcement that protect the state from the People, rather than as was intended by having the Sword in the hands of the People. It is not under the control of the government, it acts in the same manner as the executive, legislative, or judicial with the ultimate authority to define what is, or is not legitimate. Having said that, there is finally some good news coming out of Oath Keepers. I don't know if anyone here has seen a James Yeager film, but he is producing another. Good Guys with Guns. Should the NRA Support a Constitutional Militia? I've made a contribution.
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
I have to ask this question. Do you, or for that matter, any member of the 2nd amendment community believe for a minute "it matters what the words say?" Outside of a very, very few of us, the answer is a resounding no. The Constitution starts "We the People". It does not start with We the Government. The Founders were clear to place the authority "to execute the Laws of the Union" in the hands of "the whole people" as the author of the Second recognized. Where is the difficulty in comprehending this, and the fact that government "exists and acts" for the People? There is such as high level of resistance to understand the fundamental aspects of Popular Sovereignty that it boggles the mind. "We the People"! If government fails to abide by our rules, in what universe does it make sense to go back and tell them you better? I believe it was Einstein who said, "Doing the same thing over, and over, and expecting different results is the definition of insanity." History is clear. There are those who seek power. There are those who have no compunction about perpetrating evil. In the last century, over 250,000,000 people, men, women, children, the elderly, and infirm were subject to brutal annihilation at the hands of someone with the banner of a "government official" to guide the hand that struck down a fellow man. If you think it can't happen here, read all the comments. The majority are supporting government abuse of power by continually quoting statutes, and theories that are actually contrary to the fundamentals of the Second. If its here in this community, what is the opposition planning? Please take the time to read this; "to execute the Laws of the Union"
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
If the notion is that we don't want to buck the system, then we've already lost. The court would have to affirm their previous decisions. Here is a link to the brief I spoke of; http://www.scotusblog.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/08/17-27-cert-tsac-edwin-vieira.pdf In particular, you will note that the court has already opined in Miller that, “the Militia comprised all males physically capable of acting in concert for the common defense”, and that “ordinarily when called for service these men were expected to appear bearing arms supplied by themselves and of the kind in common use at the time”. 307 U.S. at 179-182. You can also read Justice Alex Kozinski's dissent in Silveria v Lockyer. I reference it in the article "Stand Your Ground". It is also noted in both Miller and Heller that the function of the 2nd, if you read the ratification debates, was to prevent congress from disarming the Militia, which is "the whole People."
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
I absolutely hate it when people quote those unconstitutional statutes. It shows a complete lack of understanding of the rule of law, the principles upon which this government was instituted, and an utter disrespect for the basic foundation of this nation. “There is no position which depends on clearer principles, than that every act of a delegated authority, contrary to the tenor of the commission under which it is exercised, is void. No legislative act therefore contrary to the constitution can be valid. To deny this would be to affirm that the deputy is greater than his principal; that the servant is above his master; that the representatives of the people are superior to the people themselves; that men acting by virtue of powers may do not only what their powers do not authorise, but what they forbid.” Alexander Hamilton – Federalist 78. The Supreme Court made this a recognized function of our law In Marbury v Madison, and repeated the warning in cases such as Norton v Shellby County In order for the Constitution to mean anything, it must mean exactly what it says, or it means nothing at all. Since you brought it up please answer some questions; Can the Constitution be changed other than in the manner described in Article 5? Can the definitions of the matters in the Constitution be change to suit whatever agenda a new government deems necessary to achieve whatever goal? Can the meanings of the words in the Constitution as the Founders knew them change, or do we allow them to change to suit our ambivalence? In what universe does the word unorganized put a body of “well regulated Militia” together as a functionally trained unit? The Constitution grants a delegated authority to the Congress to “organize, arm, and discipline”. Where does it grant an authority to unorganze, disarm, and leave the militia undisciplined? Where do you muster when you’re unorganized? Who are the officers that you’ve elected according to state statutes? What arms do you keep and bear in order to comply with the functions stated in Article 1? What are your duties when you show up in this random spot, without proper equipment or training in this emergency that called forth an “unorganized militia?” The Constitution states, “reserving to the States respectively, the Appointment of the Officers, and the Authority of training the Militia according to the discipline prescribed by Congress;” Do the states appoint the officers of the National Guard as the Constitution reads? Is the National Guard a part of the army? Does the National Guard consist of ALL able-bodied men from 17-45 as the statutes provided? Does the National Guard answer to the state or the army? The issue is not whether the government can do this or that. The issues in this area, are many. Here are two; The pretend pro-2nd community has been duped for so long, and failed to make its own investigation as to what is right or wrong that they cannot, and will not admit their complicity in destroying the full tenets of the 2nd. The pretend pro-2nd community will do anything, or say anything it can to abdicate the responsibility under the requirements of law to fulfill the duty of an able-bodied man in “A well regulated Militia”.
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
You can read this. It also comes with a list of books he's written on the Constitutional Militia. https://www.oathkeepers.org/oath-keepers-academy/edwin-vieira/ You're arguing with me, and when I read "collective private militia", I don't know why. There is no such thing in our law as a collective private militia. The Constitutional Militia, as it is recognized in the Constitution, is a state authority controlled by the People themselves. It exists with the force of law. NJ, as did all states, have Militia statutes defining the operation of the body. Militia was not voluntary. I was incumbent on all citizens to participate in some fashion, with the exception of some officials such as judges. It required all able-bodied men to maintain a "rifle" in good working order. Article 1, Section 8, Cls.15: "To provide for calling forth the Militia to execute the Laws of the Union, suppress Insurrections, and repel Invasions" Article 1, Section 8, Cls. 16: "To provide for organizing, arming, and disciplining, the Militia, and for governing such Part of them as may be employed in the Service of the United States, reserving to the States respectively, the Appointment of the Officers, and the Authority of training the Militia according to the discipline prescribed by Congress" The state statutes varied slightly on such things as training and age requirements. Some states required training muster more times than others, while some states labeled able-bodied men as old as 60. As a note here, because it is widely misunderstood; National Guard cannot be militia. In fact the Guard was promulgated under Article 1, Section 10, Cls. 3; "No State shall, without the Consent of Congress, *** keep Troops, or Ships of War in time of Peace". The Guard are army that the states may call upon; See Rudy Pietrich v DOD, or you can read the Dick Act that most people seem not to understand at all as it clearly defines Militia, and a separate entity as the Guard. The purpose of the Militia being placed in the Constitution was to guarantee that the federal government could not disarm the militia, and to make sure that the power of the sword remained firmly in the hands of the states, and therefore the People. Both Miller and Heller note that the purpose of the 2nd was to make sure that Militia could not be disarmed. You can read all about this if you want to take up the task of reading Dr. Vieira's "The Sword and Sovereignty". It is some 2500 pages with, if I remember correctly, about 6000 footnotes on law and history. It is more extensive than the Selective Services documentation on service in the U.S. One more thing. I had a conversation with Alex Roubian of NJ2AS when he stepped in to replace the previous president. I laid this out to him, as I did with his predecessor. Neither one wanted anything to do with it. They both had in their minds, through years of misinformation, this idea of a "private militia" that ran around doing things that were heinous. They could not grasp the lawful fact of the Constitutional Militia even with it right there in the Constitution. Now, if you want to make a contribution I have a game plan that I've tried for a number of years to convince gun owners to implement.
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
Dr. Vieira has handled landmark cases before SCOTUS in the past. No one goes out and says let me try something here after years of indoctrination as to the 2nd amendment being about individual rights. I've been around for a long time, and I'm in discussion with someone else who is bringing a 2nd amendment case. We've both found that the biggest problem is the 2nd amendment community to begin with. Outside the individual rights theory, no one wants to hear, let alone fund such a case. That point is verified every time I have a discussion on the actual myriad of law surrounding the foundation, and power that the 2nd was added to help make impervious to any legal argument, but not so to ambivalence and ignorance.
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
Its not the plaintiff. It is those who are handling the case, and presenting the arguments. Did you ever read or listen to the oral arguments in Heller? Gura could have ended the entire discussion on gun control when asked by Justice Stevens about the militia. Gura had absolutely no response because the team refused, that's right, refused to prepare for questions along those lines. Gura could have answered in a number of ways. One would have been that Congress have no authority to disarm, or unorganize the militia because the Constitution restricts them from doing anything other than arming, organizing, and disciplining. He could have also pointed out that through deception, and acting contra-constitutional limitations congress changed the dynamic of the Constitution without amendment, and therefore the primary reason for an armed populace.
-
Supreme Court, The 2nd Amendment And The NRA
jackandjill present us with the reasons why we will ultimately loose this fight. Our children and grandchildren will suffer because this generation and the last know nothing at all about law, and the principles upon which this nation was built, but they are sure to disparage those who are attempting to rebuild the republic, and win the fight. I've written quite a bit about why the pretend pro-2nd community wants nothing to do with actually winning the struggle. There is too much at stake as far as contributions, and membership fees. There is also the fact that those who've built a base on a bold faced lie, can't go back and tell the membership that we've deceived you for decades. Then there is the membership itself. Once the actual aspects of the 2nd are explained, and how we will all have to train, they walk away much the same as the people did decades ago when the congress was forced to invoke Article 1, Section 10, Cls. 3.
-
And the floodgates open with the new legislative session in Trenton
The problem is not with the legislature per se. It is with the general public. If we removed the 2nd amendment today, would it matter in the context of the Constitution? No! Does it matter in light of the ignorance surrounding the complexity of what the 2nd entails? Yes! On the one hand, 'Miller' noted that the “obvious purpose” of the Second Amendment is “to assure the continuation and render possible the effectiveness of [the Militia]”. 307 U.S. at 178. Likewise, 'Heller' acknowledged that “the Second Amendment’s prefatory clause” (“[a] well regulated Militia, being necessary to the security of a free State”) “announces the purpose for which the right was codified: to prevent elimination of the militia.” 554 U.S. at 599 For those who've not studied this in depth, and have relied on decades of misinformation, the 2nd is tied to Article 1, Section 8, Cls. 15 & 16, and the pre-existing state statutes that required all able-bodied men to maintain in good working order a rifle, along with other accoutrement necessary to operate as a soldier. The issue at hand is that, in general, the pro-2nd community listens to those who have a vested interest in keeping the struggle alive, rather than putting the issue to rest. Militia is, as George Mason author of the amendment asked rhetorically, "What is the militia? It is the whole people." The whole people operating with the ultimate authority "to execute the Laws of the Union." So the question is whether we should be begging our representatives to abide their oath, or whether we should reclaim our authority by revitalizing the militia, and put the cuffs on them when they violate their oath? There is a method for revitalizing the Constitutional Militia, and it doesn't entail a bunch of yahoo's running around claiming to be militia.