January 16, 20233 yr 2 hours ago, DAHL said: I don't believe that a court date has been set for judge Bumb to rule on the combined cases of Koons vs Reynolds and Siegel vs Platkin but I'll guess that it will later this month. Did anyone see a date? Next is TRO for the other sensitive areas contained in Siegel and was just filed with Bumb, may or may not need another hearing for that. After a ruling is made on that a date will be set for injunction hearing.
January 18, 20233 yr 1 minute ago, Mike77 said: Any update on siegal platkin? Or if Bumb has it? I was about to ask the same thing…it’s gone quiet lately.
January 18, 20233 yr Judge Bumb has it. Last thing I see is the State requested a new date for a Hearing. https://www.courtlistener.com/docket/66677439/siegel-v-platkin/?mibextid=Zxz2cZ
January 18, 20233 yr On 1/16/2023 at 3:04 PM, Spartiati said: Next is TRO for the other sensitive areas contained in Siegel and was just filed with Bumb, may or may not need another hearing for that. After a ruling is made on that a date will be set for injunction hearing. There will be a hearing, has to be. The next set of sensitive places, the state will have to meet the burden of Bumbs ruling in Koons and provide supporting evidence. Bumb can't just rule on the other areas without arguments from the state or plantiffs, and while I'm sure Bumb would prefer written arguments at this point, the states going to demand wasting the courts time.
January 18, 20233 yr 1 hour ago, JackDaWack said: There will be a hearing, has to be. The next set of sensitive places, the state will have to meet the burden of Bumbs ruling in Koons and provide supporting evidence. Bumb can't just rule on the other areas without arguments from the state or plantiffs, and while I'm sure Bumb would prefer written arguments at this point, the states going to demand wasting the courts time. Yes I will agree that a hearing will take place in the next few weeks. What I love about this is that the tyrants in the state will need to defend a law that denies vetted, and trained peaceful citizens from exercising their 2nd amendment rights. Point is the state has no defense. They are just there to try and force their prejudiced perverted socialist belief system on you and me. ALL other states respect the right to keep and bear arms. NY and NJ are the only holdouts but........ in the end they will LOSE..
January 18, 20233 yr 13 minutes ago, DAHL said: Yes I will agree that a hearing will take place in the next few weeks. What I love about this is that the tyrants in the state will need to defend a law that denies vetted, and trained peaceful citizens from exercising their 2nd amendment rights. Point is the state has no defense. They are just there to try and force their prejudiced perverted socialist belief system on you and me. ALL other states respect the right to keep and bear arms. NY and NJ are the only holdouts but........ in the end they will LOSE.. Maryland too!
January 18, 20233 yr 37 minutes ago, DAHL said: ALL other states respect the right to keep and bear arms. NY and NJ are the only holdouts but........ in the end they will LOSE.. Eventually, yes. I think NJ/NY are going down in flames soon.
January 18, 20233 yr Here is a question, why is NJ lucky to get a TRO to allow us to carry, by NY, it keeps getting knocked down?
January 18, 20233 yr The Siegel TRO hearing is set for Thursday, Jan. 26 at 11:30 am. Quote TEXT ORDER The Court will hear oral argument on the pending Motion for a Temporary Restraining Order by the Siegel Plaintiffs on Thursday, January 26, 2023, at 11:30AM. The hearing will take place in Courtroom 3D, Mitchell H. Cohen Courthouse. So Ordered by Judge Renee Marie Bumb on 01/18/2023. (Costigan, Roberta) (Entered: 01/18/2023) Also there appears to be a new attorney representing NJ. Don't know if Angela Cai will still be in the mix or not. https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.njd.506026/gov.uscourts.njd.506026.37.0.pdf and https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.njd.506033/gov.uscourts.njd.506033.43.0.pdf
January 18, 20233 yr 2 hours ago, DAHL said: Yes I will agree that a hearing will take place in the next few weeks. What I love about this is that the tyrants in the state will need to defend a law that denies vetted, and trained peaceful citizens from exercising their 2nd amendment rights. Point is the state has no defense. They are just there to try and force their prejudiced perverted socialist belief system on you and me. ALL other states respect the right to keep and bear arms. NY and NJ are the only holdouts but........ in the end they will LOSE.. That's what the demand of a hearing is for... if the "facts" stood up it wouldn't be required. But the state can only make oral arguments to twist their position enough times it might make sense. 1 hour ago, Mike77 said: Here is a question, why is NJ lucky to get a TRO to allow us to carry, by NY, it keeps getting knocked down? 2nd court of appeals is a bunch of douchebags that's why And Alito basically told them so...
January 18, 20233 yr 25 minutes ago, COD said: The Siegel TRO hearing is set for Thursday, Jan. 26 at 11:30 am. Also there appears to be a new attorney representing NJ. Don't know if Angela Cai will still be in the mix or not. https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.njd.506026/gov.uscourts.njd.506026.37.0.pdf and https://storage.courtlistener.com/recap/gov.uscourts.njd.506033/gov.uscourts.njd.506033.43.0.pdf How long is the current TRO "good" for?
January 19, 20233 yr 2 hours ago, Xtors said: How long is the current TRO "good" for? My understanding is that the Koons TRO is good until the preliminary injunction is decided.
January 19, 20233 yr 6 hours ago, Mike77 said: Here is a question, why is NJ lucky to get a TRO to allow us to carry, by NY, it keeps getting knocked down? NY got some very favorable rulings at the district courts but the state went to the court of appeals and they reversed the lower courts order. NJ has a good court of appeals makeup, more Republican appointed judges than Democratic. So once this gets settled in Bumb's court the state will probably appeal and then we'll see who the three panel court is. Illinois got carry because they drew 2 out of 3 good judges.
January 19, 20233 yr I’m counting on NJ because of that, that it goes thru justice Alito to get to SCOTUS and NJ went full retard on it
January 19, 20233 yr 11 hours ago, Moutinas said: NY got some very favorable rulings at the district courts but the state went to the court of appeals and they reversed the lower courts order. NJ has a good court of appeals makeup, more Republican appointed judges than Democratic. So once this gets settled in Bumb's court the state will probably appeal and then we'll see who the three panel court is. Illinois got carry because they drew 2 out of 3 good judges. Alito basically said the upper courts should let the lowers courts do their jobs first. So I would guess the 3rd Circuit under his purview would decline to do anything until the lower courts case is ruled on. This is only a TRO, these cases will have full review for a permanent ruling. No reason upper courts should start meddling with incomplete lower court orders. Once the district court completes its review and rules, the circuits can step in... Alito is basically saying, why the hell would SCOTUS step in when the district court hasn't even formally ruled on the issue yet? Which was his way of saying the 2nd district overstepped.
January 19, 20233 yr On 1/18/2023 at 12:25 PM, Mike77 said: Any update on siegal platkin? Or if Bumb has it? ANJRPC January 19, 2023. The judge in the consolidated lawsuit challenging New Jersey's carry-killer law has scheduled oral argument of ANJRPC's motion for a restraining order blocking the law for Thursday, January 26, 2023. There are unlikely to be new developments in the case before then. Please watch for follow-up alerts as the lawsuit unfolds. If you are not already subscribed to these free email alerts, click here to sign up -- there will be critical updates and alerts coming in the near future.
January 20, 20233 yr Update on the Siegel TRO hearing: Quote TEXT ORDER Due to a change in the Court's calendar, oral argument scheduled for Thursday, January 26, 2023, shall be held at 9:30AM instead of 12:30PM. Kindly mark your calendars. So Ordered by Judge Renee Marie Bumb on 01/20/2023. (Costigan, Roberta) (Entered: 01/20/2023)
January 20, 20233 yr 4 minutes ago, JohnnyB said: So now it's $400.00 for the permit? What bullshit this is! Agree. On the other side of the coin, it adds undue financial burden to those wanting to carry. More fuel to the fire to get this shit struck down.
January 20, 20233 yr 7 minutes ago, JohnnyB said: So now it's $400.00 for the permit? What bullshit this is! $200
January 20, 20233 yr 7 minutes ago, JohnnyB said: So now it's $400.00 for the permit? What bullshit this is! Money order for $200 if applying direct to NJSP; money orders for $150 + $50 if applying to a municipality. $200 total
January 20, 20233 yr Anyone notice the following is no longer present on that form? Written proof of ownership and qualification with the handgun(s) you intend on carrying. Proof of ownership can be a purchase receipt or purchase permit or a notarized letter of ownership listing make, model, and serial number of handgun(s).
January 20, 20233 yr 12 minutes ago, Displaced Texan said: Still, $200 is fucking nuts to exercise a constitutional right.. Yes, same with references.
January 20, 20233 yr You all know we have court Thursday to remove all that extra illegal requirements?
January 20, 20233 yr 5 minutes ago, EX Carnival man said: So we also don't need to print 3 copies front and back any longer? 2. One (1) State of New Jersey Applications For Permit To Carry A Handgun, form SP642. Must be double sided and notarized.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.