Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Citizens vs. State of New Jersey

Featured Replies

Does anyone know of or has tried filing a suit against the State of New Jersey for infringement of the Constitution? Of course, I'm talking about the right to bear arms. If not, I would love to get together with fellow citizens and possibly file a class-action suit and see where it goes.

 

Any legal experts see the viability of such action?

there's no money in it, hence no lawyer will take it ;)

find a way to make money on it - then lets do it - anybody here traumitized because of long waiting periods or been assaulted waiting for a permit ?

find a way to make money on it - then lets do it - anybody here traumitized because of long waiting periods or been assaulted waiting for a permit ?

 

Wouldn't that be the sht if someone was assaulted on day 35 of waiting for their permit...

  • Author

I'm willing to look over laws and articles with an attorney friend of mine. If anyone is seriously interested, we need to formulate intelligent persuasions (not the usual hard-lined rhetoric) and find any/all cases who have relative precedents.

or just find a lawyer who is into guns who would donate his time :)

We would need at least one person that has actually suffered in order for a federal court to hear the case. Federal courts are prohibited by the Constitution from hearing hypothetical cases.

 

The next part is to show that the state of New Jersey is to blame as the proximate cause of that suffering.

  • Author

I'm going to head down to Caso's in Jersey City and talk to the guys down there this weekend. Before the statewide one-handgun-a-month thing passed, Jersey City implemented their own one-per-month. Caso's took Jersey City to court, won, and won again when Jersey City appealed. Probably a good place to start research.

 

http://www.1010wins.com/pages/4281679.php?

 

New Jersey Court Weighs Jersey City's Handgun Limits

 

TRENTON, N.J. (AP) -- The New Jersey Supreme Court heard oral arguments Monday in the legal battle over a Jersey City ordinance limiting handgun purchases.

 

The legal discussion revolved around whether the 2006 ordinance improperly pre-empts existing state gun laws by limiting handgun purchases to one per person each month. At issue is the ability of urban communities such as Newark, Camden and Jersey City to reduce gun-related crime by more closely regulating handgun purchases.

 

Supporters of the Jersey City ordinance say urban areas need tighter handgun sale standards to prevent surrogates from buying weapons for criminals. Opponents claim existing laws offer sufficient protection and the Jersey City ordinance unfairly punishes law-abiding citizens to advance a national gun control agenda.

 

``There's just too many guns out there,'' said Jersey City Mayor Jerramiah Healy. ``There's no legitimate reason on earth why anyone needs to buy five handguns a month.''

 

New Jersey residents currently must obtain a permit from local law enforcement before buying a firearm. They can buy as many as they wish provided they pass a law enforcement review that excludes applicants with criminal histories and mental problems.

 

Attorney Frank Pisano, who represented the Association of New Jersey Rifle and Pistol Clubs, told the court that collectors and investors often need to buy many handguns simultaneously when a valuable gun collection becomes available. And he said it's unreasonable to suggest people providing criminals with illegal handguns would be willing to undergo a lengthy permit review by law enforcement.

 

``There's no rational basis for this ordinance,'' Pisano said. ``It targets the tool and not the criminal.''

 

``It's 100 percent politics,'' Frank Caso, owner of Jersey City's only operating gun store said of the ordinance. ``It doesn't make any sense to punish legal gun owners for the actions of criminals.''

 

Jersey City attorney Bill Matsikoudis told the seven members of the state's highest court that Caso's Gun-O-Rama Inc. sold weapons used in 87 gun crimes from 1989-1997 and made 166 multiple gun sales from 1995 to 2000. He blamed gun industry lobbyists for blocking passage of a state bill limiting handgun purchases to one per month. It's stalled in the New Jersey Senate after being approved by the Assembly.

 

Healy said he'll issue an executive order directing his city's police not to approve more than one handgun permit a month for each applicant if the Supreme Court rules against the ordinance, which never has been implemented. It was defeated in state court Dec. 13, 2006 and lost a subsequent appeal in September 2008.

 

Bryan Miller, executive director of Ceasefire NJ, said his organization supports the ordinance. However, he said what's really needed is a statewide law that mirrors it. Otherwise, illegal handgun buyers will just move to neighboring cities to make purchases for criminal use.

 

``Cities like Camden and Newark have no gun shops within their bounds, yet suffer mightily from gun violence,'' Miller said.

 

Supreme Court Judge Barry Albin drew laughs at one point when he asked Pisano to walk him through the existing permit process as a typical law-abiding citizen seeking to buy four guns simultaneously.

 

``So I want one for my bedroom, one for my living room, one for my bathroom while I'm taking a shower and one for my kitchen while I'm cooking,'' Albin said. ``What happens?''

 

Pisano said the fourth permit would be useless under the Jersey City ordinance because it would expire after 90 days.

It all comes down to the whole "Incorporation" issue as with Heller, the 2nd hasnt actually BEEN incorporated as far as the states are Concerned. It's striking out into virgin territory, although as long as you kept it clear of NFA stuff as Gura did in Heller, you MIGHT get SCOTUS to hear it. You'd need a whole Boatload of money, or a REALLY good attorney who's willing to take it Pro Bono, which would be tough because you;re talking hundreds of hours of work on that issue. If i Hit Mega Millions, i'll do it...before i still get the hell out of this place LOL. One of the biggest stumbling blocks is that going right back to the original, the NJ state Constitution NEVER HAD it's own version of the 2nd ammendment. Perhaps our founders here thought that the issue was so simple it didn't need to be put on paper, considering that the confiscation was one of the seminal reasons for the Revolution in the first place. Unfortunately they weren't far-sighted enough to see what politicians here would become.

  • Author
It all comes down to the whole "Incorporation" issue as with Heller, the 2nd hasnt actually BEEN incorporated as far as the states are Concerned. It's striking out into virgin territory, although as long as you kept it clear of NFA stuff as Gura did in Heller, you MIGHT get SCOTUS to hear it. You'd need a whole Boatload of money, or a REALLY good attorney who's willing to take it Pro Bono, which would be tough because you;re talking hundreds of hours of work on that issue. If i Hit Mega Millions, i'll do it...before i still get the hell out of this place LOL. One of the biggest stumbling blocks is that going right back to the original, the NJ state Constitution NEVER HAD it's own version of the 2nd ammendment. Perhaps our founders here thought that the issue was so simple it didn't need to be put on paper, considering that the confiscation was one of the seminal reasons for the Revolution in the first place. Unfortunately they weren't far-sighted enough to see what politicians here would become.

 

Well said and insightful. Everything so far is preliminary, but the way I see it, there is NOTHING that CAN'T be done (I know, double negative). I'm going to take a friend out for drinks and introduce him to the idea of working on this with me pro bono, although he is in criminal law.

 

I was just listening to Sotomayor's confimration hearing, in particular her record on the 2nd Amendment. She does a lot of double talk and covers her ass well. Spoken like a true politician/lawyer. Anyway, references to SC's reversal of DC's handgun ban has given me inspiration and motivation.

It all comes down to the whole "Incorporation" issue as with Heller, the 2nd hasnt actually BEEN incorporated as far as the states are Concerned. It's striking out into virgin territory, although as long as you kept it clear of NFA stuff as Gura did in Heller, you MIGHT get SCOTUS to hear it. You'd need a whole Boatload of money, or a REALLY good attorney who's willing to take it Pro Bono, which would be tough because you;re talking hundreds of hours of work on that issue. If i Hit Mega Millions, i'll do it...before i still get the hell out of this place LOL. One of the biggest stumbling blocks is that going right back to the original, the NJ state Constitution NEVER HAD it's own version of the 2nd ammendment. Perhaps our founders here thought that the issue was so simple it didn't need to be put on paper, considering that the confiscation was one of the seminal reasons for the Revolution in the first place. Unfortunately they weren't far-sighted enough to see what politicians here would become.

 

Well said and insightful. Everything so far is preliminary, but the way I see it, there is NOTHING that CAN'T be done (I know, double negative). I'm going to take a friend out for drinks and introduce him to the idea of working on this with me pro bono, although he is in criminal law.

 

I was just listening to Sotomayor's confimration hearing, in particular her record on the 2nd Amendment. She does a lot of double talk and covers her a** well. Spoken like a true politician/lawyer. Anyway, references to SC's reversal of DC's handgun ban has given me inspiration and motivation.

It doesnt matter what she says NOW..her position as already stated was that the 2nd Ammendment was not an individual right and only appllied to the National guard. Not that anyone really thought there would be anything more than parroting whatever answers she needed to give to get through conformation...

Incorporation or not, the Supreme Court ruled in Heller that reasonable restrictions may apply on handguns, but not outright bans. I highly doubt that the Court would find a one per month limit on purchases to be unreasonable.

 

However, if Nappens' interpretation is correct, and dealers may only purchase one per month from a distributor, then we might have grounds for an unreasonable restriction.

  • Author

What about the business owners in this state? They can't possibly see one handgun per month as good for business. Are they not victims?

What about the business owners in this state? They can't possibly see one handgun per month as good for business. Are they not victims?

 

Sure they are, but compared to the rest of the business base the FFL's in the state are a tiny minority..besides dont you think the Legislature would LOVE to see them all close?

I would hope that they would be scratching for every single tax dollar they could find right now...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.