Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Summary of One Gun a Month Hearing 9/24 Trenton, NJ

Featured Replies

Ok. Just got back from this hearing, and when I left, it was still going on.

 

It was literally a who's who of NJ Gun politics. State senators, attorneys, NRA rep, US Shooting Sports rep, a few gun range reps, and a good number of gun store owners. 4 or 5 NJGF members showed up, Ronover, NJpilot, Johnydamnit, and myself... and apparently a few others whom I did not meet. Along in attendance was Smity, representing NJCSD and a few njscd members.

 

The whole point of the meeting was not to discuss the politics of one a month, which is what the common citizens and NJCSD was there for, but rather to discuss the impacts of One a Month as written right now.

 

The panel did ask questions of people, and by the end of the meeting, did know they have to do something regarding the dealer exemptions, to include manufacturers, distributors, etc... and really took an interest to having a way to do an exemption to collectors and competitive shooters. The only question they had is how to define a collector. Similar programs/laws in Maryland and Virginia were brought up.

 

To get into specifics... here are my notes.. out of order.

 

Consignment permits... to get your gun back. It was brought up numerous times how stupid it is to have to get a handgun permit to get your gun back from consignment.

 

From Nappen, he made a specific point of the wording for hte current dealer exemption. As written into law... "licensed retail dealers" are exempt... problem is... NJ law has an explicit definition of "licensed retail dealer" to EXCLUDE manufacturers, distributors, wholesalers.

 

Btw, Nappen made sure to say that his 3rd book is coming out in October. :roll:

 

The whole overtone was how does the state define a collector/competitor... Carol, who is the president of Citizen's Rifle and Revolver club in West Windsor suggested that one way would be to just have someone present a copy of their range membership card along with FID.

 

What I didnt know, is that a licensed firearms range/club, has to by law submit to NJ State police every year, a list of their members.

 

Next... It was brought up that the FID system is repetitive to the NICS system, and was suggested a few times to reform that.

 

C&R... it was mentioned by 2 attorneys and others that a few years back, the NJSP sent out a notice that anyone with a C&R had to register as a firearms dealer with the state, otherwise, they are considered an unlicensed dealer.... yet.. the law as written right now allows C&R exemption... so those two are at confilict with each other.

 

Otherwise.. its a damn shame... a big hearing, meanwhile only 50 people showed up... at the most, and most of them were there to testify. 800,000 gun owners in the state.

a big hearing, meanwhile only 50 people showed up... at the most, and most of them were there to testify.

That's just sad. Not surprising, but sad nonetheless. No wonder we can't make any significant progress here.

:evil: It kinda seemed like they were yessing us to death and taking what everyone was sayin into consideration( yea right!) sorry I couldn"t stick around till the end I had a doctors app. @2:00 plus I couldn't sit there any longer they were driving me nuts!

If it were on a saturday, i bet half of those gun owners would have showed up with the right awarness..

 

Like I've said before, they don't want us to be able to defend ourselves. Why do you think they chose 11am on a work day? Because they know majority of people can't afford to take off. There's power in numbers. If thousands swarmed that little building in Trenton the news would be all over it would affect public support. By limited the numbers you've restricted the power of the people.

 

Some important points that were made the task force needs to consider:

 

[*]FPID's are archaic and redundant. NICS provides an up to date 30 second back ground check at every purchase which is updated every 24 hours. The FPID needs to be updated to reflect that or be removed. If updated the process must also be updated and abide by the 30 day law.

 

[*]C&R permits issued by the Federal Government aren't fully recognized by the state of NJ and owners of that permit are treated as unlicensed dealers by a separate law which conflicts with OGAM which exempts Collectors.

 

[*]The term Collectors needs to be defined and be provided with some kind of NJ recognized permit or FPID endorsement in order to be identified as such.

 

[*]Exemptions must be made for Competitors who have a need to purchase 2 - 10 handguns at one time.

 

[*]Competitors need to be identified by some kind of endorsement. Club Membership ID cards were suggested since Gun Clubs already comply with the State PD regulations and issue Class cards to identify your skill level as a competitor.

 

[*]Exemptions must also be made for Whole Sale dealers, manufacturers, and citizens for Retail Dealers. Failure to do so will artificially create a gun shortage which will effect retail businesses in a negative way and become a defacto handgun ban.

I was in the back by the door, in the striped suit.

I left because it is a total sham. They had better reform the permit system or its just itching to set off a lawsuit.

Like I said before, I was so pissed as these elected idiots were not even listening, or have serious comprehension issues, that I went and took one of my permit and picked up a full size 1911, S&W in .45.

 

Its a shame. I did appreciate Senator Karrow giving her passionate disapproval of this law. Cunningham and Madden basically cost Corzine the election. I am voting for full turnover of trenton this nov.

This law needs to be repealed, revoked, if not, I better be able to get my permit in 30 days.

I also want to say that the lack of show up really is a shame. Not to toot my own horn, but I run a very busy insurance business, and I made sure that I was able to show up. I was hoping to walk into a racous room, but I guess the republic is not that mad yet, why? I am not sure.

More people should have came, I fully understand that everyone cannot just skip out for an hour or 2, but as the previous poster added, you have limited the power of the people by not showing up.

If that room was packed to the gills, and it actually made them a bit nervous, then we would not be on here tonight.

Ok, well back to civilization.

That's the way of the Government.....They purposely pick days and times that are not

reasonable for the public to attend. The media will have a field day with the attendance

aspect of the story.

Why do you think they chose 11am on a work day?

 

So only gang bangers and drug dealers could attend. Chances are they're awake and alert by 11 am...

 

I guess they forgot about the 9% who are unemployed ;)

 

The gov't in NJ is a sham. I am seriously considering uprooting my family and moving to someplace where common sense and true American principles prevail. I have little hope that changing the governor will change anything regarding my Constitutional Rights and how they are being violated inch by inch in this 'republic'.

I was there, however I couldn't find my shirt I think I may have left it at my mom's house in Maryland. But Kappen was awesome, he totally handed them their asses as far as legal jargain. Bach was also pretty good, but most of it was about dealers, and distributors. Some guys brought up other things about carrying reform and such, but they didn't want to hear it. They wanted it kept on this piece of the bill only, not other topics.. I was kinda upset that half the seats were empty, goes to prove this state as far as guns is concerned can't be saved.

We were there, and also presented. Unfortunately our message got "lost in the sauce", but you can see our entered testimony on the main site here: LINKY.

 

We'd like to take a moment to publicly thank State Senator Marcia Karrow (District 23) who was terrific, in that she pointed out the "elephant in the room" that we picked up on over a month ago, prompting our petition drive. That of the nine representatives of the Task Force, only one, perhaps two, are known to have pro-gun views disenfranchising us by overwhelming anti-gun bias. If the purpose of the Task Force is to understand the impact that New Jersey's laws have on law abiding gun owners, one would think that the committee would have been comprised with an inverse bias of 7 pro-gun representatives and only perhaps two anti-gun representatives.

 

Other organizations were there seeking exemptions for retailers, wholesalers, distributors, collectors, sport shooters, club members, training instructors, but not a single presenter had our message. That no one group of law-abiding citizens should be entitled to any more or fewer rights than another, and that the only 'exemption' we could recommend would be one for any holder of an FID card.

 

It was also interesting that the committee didn't seem to grasp the notion that this law had a severe impact on resellers, nor the difference between a retailer, wholesaler and manufacturer; and that these groups of distribution partners would be significantly affected. It seems that message got through, and Evan Nappen was very thorough in his presentation providing a very crisp legal argument and remedy for how to create the provision.

 

What the Task Force does with the information is yet to be seen.

 

NJCSD:RK

it is a damn shame that only 50 people showed up. but i understand that people have to work.

 

how many anti's showed up?

 

what did the anti's have to say?

 

problem with NJ gun owners, from the small circle of NJ gun owners I know, nobody gives a shit. :x when I try to discuss NJ gun politics, at NJ shoots, before/during the shooters meetings, nobody wants to hear it. from my experience, when I shoot in PA, they MAKE time for gun politics during the shooters meetings. this is a big difference.

We were there, and also presented. Unfortunately our message got "lost in the sauce", but you can see our entered testimony on the main site here: LINKY.

 

I just read your testimony and I applaud you sir. Truly you are fighting for the rights that so many in NJ are quick to abandon.

We were there, and also presented. Unfortunately our message got "lost in the sauce", but you can see our entered testimony on the main site here: LINKY.

 

I just read your testimony and I applaud you sir. Truly you are fighting for the rights that so many in NJ are quick to abandon.

 

Sadly the testimony sounds a lot better on the website then what was given. There were a lot of long pauses and felt like he was struggling to remember his testimony and make his point which sadly was outside the scope of this hearing. Should this bill exist? Of course not! But its harder to remove a law then it is to pass it or change it and of course this legislation has no intent on removing this law. His testimony was geared towards the removal of this law entirely and argued how its unconstitutional. This kind of testimony is best used in front of several supreme court judges, not a group of 9 individuals comprising mostly of politicians who's goal is to made amendments to this law to basically address the political backlash it's received.

 

Honestly this testimony was taken the least seriously. You could tell just from looking at the taskforce and I don't blame them as it sounded very amateurish especially compared to the other testimonies that were given during the 2 hours I was there. If you don't believe me for the 2 hours I was there I was recording everything with a voice recorder.

ron part of the reason it probably wasn't taken seriously is because when it comes to gun issues, it does not have any support in this state. Now if that hall was packed with people like it should have been, just maybe they would see that we give a shit about our 2A rights... but the lack of participation at these events makes us look like we dont give a shit... why should they take us seriously?

  • Author

Rob's testimony was submitted ahead of time. It really was good, however this hearing was not about if this law is consitutional or not, but the hearing was all about how it will effect all parties involved and how it should be amended. this hearing was not about what we think of the legislature, it is about making the best out of a crappy situation.

 

i believe one of the njcsd members recorded Rob's testimony on video.

 

the panel did want to hear how it adversly effects collectors, and shooters amongs us. but they were not going to listen to anything about repealing this law.

Cemetery: I'll try to upload it tomorrow. Its a BIG file.

 

Maksim: The interest in collectors seemed only to be the conflict with another law. They barely gave a crap about competitors. Some asked questions and could see the validity to purchase multiple handguns at one time, but they could find a reason to say F you wait as well. The only actual aspect they were actually concerned about was Retailers. When the ole'mighty dollar is concerned they listen.

What if we had a petition passed around from gun club to gun club. I bet we could get a least 10,000 signatures if we did that.

http://www.nj.com/news/ledger/jersey/index.ssf?/base/news-14/1253839510220390.xml&coll=1

 

Handgun advocates take aim at new law

Friday, September 25, 2009

Chris Megerian

STATEHOUSE

 

Gov. Jon Corzine's firearms task force heard testimony yesterday from residents concerned about the state's new law limiting handgun purchases to one per month.

 

Gun collectors and advocates have said the law, signed last month, will unfairly restrict law-abiding citizens' constitutional rights. Proponents pushed the bill as a way to slow the flow of guns to criminals and gang members.

 

"The law has been vetted and signed," said Sen. Fred Madden (D-Gloucester), vice chairman of the task force. "Today we're taking testimony to measure the impact, positive or negative."

 

At least 40 people gathered in a Statehouse committee room to speak before the nine-member task force.

 

Jake McGuigan, government relations director for the National Shooting Sports Foundation, is concerned the law will hurt small retail stores.

 

Although there is an exception for licensed gun dealers, New Jersey does not classify manufacturers or wholesale distributors as such, he said.

 

"You're going to be shutting down small retailers and small dealers in the state," McGuigan said. "This law is going after law-abiding citizens and retailers."

 

Lateif Dickerson attended the hearing with his son, Trevor Stevens. Both are firearms instructors in Jersey City.

 

Dickerson, wearing a yellow long-sleeved T-shirt with the words "New Jersey Firearms Academy," said the new law is only "feel-good legislation that won't have an impact on crime."

 

"That's the wrong reason to make laws," he said. "I'd like to see it repealed."

 

New Jersey was the fourth state to approve such legislation, joining California, Maryland and Virginia.

 

The law, which takes effect Jan. 1, prohibits gun buyers from buying more than one handgun during a 30-day period. It exempts purchases by law enforcement officers and antique collectors.

 

Corzine created the task force to recommend changes to the law if it adversely affects gun collectors and recreational gun users.

 

Chris Megerian may be reached at (609) 989-0208 or [email protected].

 

As you can see the only thing they mention is the effects on retailers. Unless it affects the ole' mighty dollar they couldn't give a sh!t.

As you can see the only thing they mention is the effects on retailers. Unless it affects the ole' mighty dollar they couldn't give a sh!t.

 

Isn't that the good ole NJ way.

Tax you until you bleed and then tax you for bleeding.

What if we had a petition passed around from gun club to gun club. I bet we could get a least 10,000 signatures if we did that.

 

 

 

+ 1.... Can we do that? is there already a petition? I wanna sign.

i'll sign the petition, lol i've signed tons of petitions that didn't do anything.. why stop now!!

Maksim, petition? What do you think? Your the boss here.

I bet we could get 10,000 signatures just from members here and all their friends.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.