September 26, 200917 yr I own a home in Florida in addition to my home here in the PRNJ. I'm considering buying a Kahr P9 or PM9 for carry there. If I were to buy the gun legally in FL face-to-face from a dealer, keep it down there and never bring/transport/transfer it to NJ, do I run into any NJ issues? I'm pretty sure even NJ's arbirtary and draconian gun laws don't reach all the way down there. But I am looking for informed opinions, cause I don't know and I really don't want to ask local or state police here. Thanks, UN
September 26, 200917 yr by atf guidelines you must stay at least 6 months per year in a state to be considered a legal resident of that state - if you only use florida house for vacations any modern handgun purchase is illegal -
September 26, 200917 yr You would then have to take delivery of said handgun in the state in which you are a resident. This is a federal law. Any handgun purchases across state lines need to go through a FFL in your home state. NJ's pistol permit system doesn't deal with possession. So if you are legally a resident of Florida, and buy the pistol down there. It would then be your property, and you could even transport it back to NJ if you wanted (Unloaded/locked case).
September 26, 200917 yr Author Thanks guys. This buy and keep down there thing is a way to avoid flying with my weapons to FL, for family related reasons. If it were not for that, I'd fly according to the TSA and airline specific regs which I have read thoroughly. I just skimmed the ATF website and found the following which helps to frame the issues to be worked out. From what you all said I gather I must be a resident in a state in which I plan to buy a handgun. So this brings it down to what makes a person a resident. schutzen-jager said the ATF guidlines say 6 months in a state for residency. I'm going to search the ATF site for the specifics of the 6-month guideline, but the ATF site Q&A section says the following: http://www.atf.gov/pub/fire-explo_pub/2005/p53004/q_and_a.pdf (B11) What constitutes residency in a State? The State of residence is the State in which an individual is present; the individual also must have an intention of making a home in that State. A member of the Armed Forces on active duty is a resident of the State in which his or her permanent duty station is located. If a member of the Armed Forces maintains a home in one State and the member
September 27, 200917 yr Could you not just buy the gun here in Jersey, and take it down with you and then just leave it there?
September 29, 200917 yr Author Could you not just buy the gun here in Jersey, and take it down with you and then just leave it there? I may still yet buy the Kahr since it is such a nice carry for FL. If I do it will be here in PRNJ with pistol permit, since I cannot make FL residency based on vacation and property inspection visits alone. Looks like I am going to take it (them) with me, declared via TSA flying rules there and back. Bought in PRNJ, I do not want it out of my personal possession when out of state unless it were in a safe deposit box. I suppose I could do that but I really don't need to explain to NJ-anything where my gun is. Gotta love gun control. Crims don't give a crap about law, to get what they want, but we non-crims (aka law-abiding citizens) have to jump through hoops just to avoid prison. If I could afford to drop out of work now I'd retire to FL now.
September 29, 200917 yr If I were to buy the gun legally in FL face-to-face from a dealer, keep it down there and never bring/transport/transfer it to NJ, do I run into any NJ issues? You do realize that in free states you can buy a gun legally from one guy to the next face to face? Reside there for a period, buy what you want and be done with it. All perfectly legal. More specifically, if you don't plan on bringing the gun to NJ, what's the big deal? You're going to worry about some hypothetical illegal gun charge out of NJ jurisdiction if you have to perf a perp who's intent on perfing you? You own property in Florida correct? You intend to make a home there correct? You're fulfilling the spirit of the law. Lots of folks go to Florida to die...stop at a yard sale, pick up a piece from the recently departed. heh.
September 29, 200917 yr ( "You do realize that in free states you can buy a gun legally from one guy to the next face to face? Reside there for a period, buy what you want and be done with it. All perfectly legal. More specifically, if you don't plan on bringing the gun to NJ, what's the big deal? You're going to worry about some hypothetical illegal gun charge out of NJ jurisdiction if you have to perf a perp who's intent on perfing you? You own property in Florida correct? You intend to make a home there correct? You're fulfilling the spirit of the law. Lots of folks go to Florida to die...stop at a yard sale, pick up a piece from the recently departed. heh." ) you would still be in violation of federal law - face to face transactions on modern handguns are only legal between permanent residents of the same state (gca 1968) - if anything happened + handgun was traced out of state federal + n.j. laws have been broken - - - atf + n.j. state police are more concerned with the letter of the law , not the spirit or intent - it's easier for them to make a conviction on an honest person than on most criminals -
September 29, 200917 yr Author ( "You do realize that in free states you can buy a gun legally from one guy to the next face to face? Reside there for a period, buy what you want and be done with it. All perfectly legal. More specifically, if you don't plan on bringing the gun to NJ, what's the big deal? You're going to worry about some hypothetical illegal gun charge out of NJ jurisdiction if you have to perf a perp who's intent on perfing you? You own property in Florida correct? You intend to make a home there correct? You're fulfilling the spirit of the law. Lots of folks go to Florida to die...stop at a yard sale, pick up a piece from the recently departed. heh." ) you would still be in violation of federal law - face to face transactions on modern handguns are only legal between permanent residents of the same state (gca 1968) - if anything happened + handgun was traced out of state federal + n.j. laws have been broken - - - atf + n.j. state police are more concerned with the letter of the law , not the spirit or intent - it's easier for them to make a conviction on an honest person than on most criminals - This is exactly what I am trying to avoid. The simple answer, for me, is to pack my gear according to the airline and TSA rules, following Federal and State laws. Thanks to S-J and all for your help.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.