December 8, 200916 yr This is an interesting. Imagine seeing a deal while on Vacation and actually buying it! Just need to get rid of the frickin NJ pistol permit process. ------------ http://www.cbsnews.com/blogs/2009/12/07 ... erties/ent You can buy a car from an out-of-state dealer and pick it up there. You can buy a house in another part of the country, as speculators unwisely did during the real estate bubble, sight unseen. But even though the Second Amendment protects an individual right to own firearms -- and presumably to buy them -- you can't purchase a handgun while you're visiting another state. A gun rights group has sued the Justice Department to overturn this prohibition, which became law as part of the Gun Control Act of 1968, and the case is now in front of U.S. District Judge James Robertson in Washington, D.C. Narrowly speaking, the Second Amendment Foundation has filed the Hodgkins v. Holder suit on behalf of American citizens who live abroad and would like to buy firearms when they return for a visit (but can't because Form 4473 requires them to list what U.S. state they live in). More broadly, it could restore Americans' right to buy handguns while traveling across state lines as long as they undergo the normal federal background check. Federal law says that, in general, it is unlawful for a dealer to sell a handgun to "any person who the licensee knows or has reasonable cause to believe does not reside in the state." Rules for buying a rifle or shotgun are a little less strict. Attorneys for both sides have been arguing over whether the American expats have suffered enough harm to permit them to sue, a legal concept called standing. The Obama administration claims that they haven't, arguing in a brief: "(Plaintiff's) vague allegation of an intention to acquire a firearm on some future visit to the United States does not give rise to a live controversy as required by Article III of the Constitution." In response, the Second Amendment Foundation points out that the expats tried to purchase firearms in the past but were denied permission. A ruling last Friday by the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia could affect how that question is resolved. Two of the judges on the panel said there was no need to change the current rule on standing; the dissent by Judge Janice Brown said it conflicted with Supreme Court precedent: "Our doctrine thereby enables the government to deprive a plaintiff of pre-enforcement standing simply by being silent or deliberately vague about its intentions. Unless declaratory relief is available, prosecutors can act strategically to protect criminal laws or arbitrary enforcement procedures from judicial review. That is essentially what happened here." For the record, Alan Gura, the attorney who is representing the Second Amendment Foundation, thinks he can win on the standing question one way or another. "In Hodgkins we have enough facts. They tried to buy guns but couldn't. That's more than pre-enforcement standing." While this may be an intricate legal question that only lawyers might fully appreciate, it offers a glimpse into how the legal system operates in practice. Courts don't always reach -- they're often hesitant to reach -- broad questions about a law's constitutionality. Procedural rules are hugely important. In this case, for instance, the Obama administration appears to have taken the position that there's no way for anyone to challenge the 1968 Gun Control Act on Second Amendment grounds unless they're arrested for violating it first. Any volunteers?
December 8, 200916 yr How will you get arrested unless you are sold a gun, unless you cause a ruckus.
December 8, 200916 yr Author How will you get arrested unless you are sold a gun, unless you cause a ruckus. Easy. You inform the police of intent. Go to the gun store and purchase one with cameras rolling. Arrest, bail and and then the lawyers go to work.
December 8, 200916 yr How will you get arrested unless you are sold a gun, unless you cause a ruckus. Easy. You inform the police of intent. Go to the gun store and purchase one with cameras rolling. Arrest, bail and and then the lawyers go to work. isnt going to happen ebcause the FFL wont risk losing his License over it. yeah, YOU may win the case, but BATFE will put the FFL out of business in retaliation. Either way, it's not going to affect us here in the PRNJ even if we DO win this in the Courts because of our OGAM and permit Laws. Unless of course you purchase the handgun, then wait for the 7-whatever weeks it takes to get a permit in before brigning it into the state and voluntarily registering it.... No matter what they do anywhere else, it is going to take someone with deep pockets to fight the state over every aspect of 2C:39/58 even once McDonald V Chicago is a win.
December 9, 200916 yr How will you get arrested unless you are sold a gun, unless you cause a ruckus. Easy. You inform the police of intent. Go to the gun store and purchase one with cameras rolling. Arrest, bail and and then the lawyers go to work. Exactly what KPD said, the FFL will never sell it to you, so you wont be arrested.
December 9, 200916 yr Author I guess I could have described it more cleanly. It would have to be set up entirely from the get go in order to make it an iron clad case. All parties involved including an FFL would be party to it as well as the state police and whoever the hell else needs to be there. The FFL would probably have to have obtained an FFL purposefully for this reason. Someone squeaky clean. It would require vast amounts of green lubricant. The point however is that to make a test case, certain things have to be forced.
December 9, 200916 yr How will you get arrested unless you are sold a gun, unless you cause a ruckus. Easy. You inform the police of intent. Go to the gun store and purchase one with cameras rolling. Arrest, bail and and then the lawyers go to work. isnt going to happen ebcause the FFL wont risk losing his License over it. yeah, YOU may win the case, but BATFE will put the FFL out of business in retaliation. Either way, it's not going to affect us here in the PRNJ even if we DO win this in the Courts because of our OGAM and permit Laws. Unless of course you purchase the handgun, then wait for the 7-whatever weeks it takes to get a permit in before brigning it into the state and voluntarily registering it.... No matter what they do anywhere else, it is going to take someone with deep pockets to fight the state over every aspect of 2C:39/58 even once McDonald V Chicago is a win. Actually the NJ permit law would actually become defunct if this happened. NJ allows you to own handguns LEGALLY purchased in a different state without having to apply for a pistol permit. Currently if you own 3 handguns you legally bought in PA while living there, and then move to NJ you DO NOT have to get a permit for them. The current NJ permit law only works because of our inability to buy out of state. If we could legally buy out of state, there is nothing in the NJ law that would prevent us from bringing it home. If NJ attempted to close that loop hole, they'd find themselves in the same position as D.C. and Chicago and face a mountain of lawsuits.
December 10, 200916 yr That raises a good question: My brother lives in PA and has a few handguns he doesnt want and wants to give me. Can he legally give them to me without going to a FFL.
December 10, 200916 yr Author That raises a good question: My brother lives in PA and has a few handguns he doesnt want and wants to give me. Can he legally give them to me without going to a FFL. Only if you are named in his will and he's departed.
December 10, 200916 yr That raises a good question: My brother lives in PA and has a few handguns he doesnt want and wants to give me. Can he legally give them to me without going to a FFL. Only if you are named in his will and he's departed. Thanks for the quick answer. They're not that nice though.
December 10, 200916 yr Author There's a couple guys on here and that Jim Flynn guy that will do transfers very reasonably.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.