December 14, 200916 yr This should be interesting. http://www.govtrack.us/congress/bill.xpd?bill=h111-197 H.R. 197: National Right-to-Carry Reciprocity Act of 2009 To amend title 18, United States Code, to provide a national standard in accordance with which nonresidents of a State may carry concealed firearms in the State. Be it enacted by the Senate and House of Representatives of the United States of America in Congress assembled, SECTION 1. SHORT TITLE. This Act may be cited as the
December 14, 200916 yr It's be great if this passes. It might because so many states do CCW, the Senators will see this as a benefit for their citizens. NJ, CA, NY et al. will raise holy hell about it.
December 15, 200916 yr Fingers crossed! Most states allow CCW so maybe there is a chance in hell of this passing. Does this bill give us the right to carry in NJ? With NJ being "may" issue and the wording seems to support non-residents, I guess this will only be a step in the right direction?
December 15, 200916 yr didnt the senate version just miss by 2 votes? what would that mean for this one?
December 15, 200916 yr Sorry to be a wet blanket, but why are people vetting so excited aboutthis??? First of all it is a bill to allow ccw by NON residents of a state, not residents. So, if it passes there is the possibility for: a) current NJ ccw holders to carry in any other state that issues ccw permits o its own residents, whether there's a current reciprocity agreement in place or not. b) people who have a ccw permit from their own state will be able to carry in NJ if (note) the meet the same conditions applying to an NJ ccw holder while in NJ. This will be extremely restrictive because NJ is one of the few (only?) states that requires the serial number of a specified firearm to be on the ccw itself. c) neither of these provisions will allow NJ reidents with FL, UT and/or VA permits to carry in NJ so......put your bolsters back in your range bags, guys. It ain't gonna happen with this bill, whether it passes or not. Happyshooting G
December 15, 200916 yr Sorry to be a wet blanket, but why are people vetting so excited aboutthis??? First of all it is a bill to allow ccw by NON residents of a state, not residents. So, if it passes there is the possibility for: a) current NJ ccw holders to carry in any other state that issues ccw permits o its own residents, whether there's a current reciprocity agreement in place or not. b) people who have a ccw permit from their own state will be able to carry in NJ if (note) the meet the same conditions applying to an NJ ccw holder while in NJ. This will be extremely restrictive because NJ is one of the few (only?) states that requires the serial number of a specified firearm to be on the ccw itself. c) neither of these provisions will allow NJ reidents with FL, UT and/or VA permits to carry in NJ so......put your bolsters back in your range bags, guys. It ain't gonna happen with this bill, whether it passes or not. Happyshooting G Wow when did this start? I had a NJ CCW In the late 70's and I don't remember this. But it may have been so and I've forgotten. I'm getting old...
December 15, 200916 yr If you read the provisions, they make no distinction as to the residence of permit holder which means out of state permit holders(regardless of their state of residence) must abide by the federal laws.
December 15, 200916 yr .....but it specifies non residents in the title. Everything flows from that , doesn't it?
December 15, 200916 yr .....but it specifies non residents in the title. Everything flows from that , doesn't it? Non-resident permit holder. It's talking about the status of the *permit* itself. It doesn't speak to the residency of the permit holder even if he/she might be a resident of the state in question. It's about legalizing and making states honor permits from every other state. It sets criteria where the permits may be used. How you got the permit, where you live, makes no difference. If it is legal and a different state honors it, the current state you are in must also. All this is subject to lawyering of course. Worse case would of course be that residents of other states could carry in NJ, but NJ residents couldn't carry in NJ. That might force the law to change in NJ.
December 16, 200916 yr ^^^What ultimately matters is not the academic debates here, but how the courts rule. When the LEOSA (HR 218) passed, giving active and retired LEO's the right to carry nationwide, it took several court cases in NY and NJ to clearly define who was protected under the law and under what circumstances. If this law passes, there will naturally be incidents of people being wrongfully arrested and the provisions of the law misinterpreted, until the courts get involved.
December 16, 200916 yr Unless I'm thinking of another HR bill, my understanding was that the pro-gun side was going to use the 14th amendment to help get this bill passed. The 14th states that no state can abridge the 'privileges and immunities' given by the federal govt. Whether that flies or not it, of course, to be debated by much smarter people than me. Seems to me, though, that it's a good argument.
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.