Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Zombie Carbine. .223 vs .30-06 or .308

Featured Replies

As I see it, the .223 gives you the ability to carry more ammo due to lower weight than the ,30 cal rounds, and .223 is still effective out to 250 yards. In a true SHTF situation, the extra range of .30-06 or .308 would be wasted in NJ in my opnion. I'd like to hear other thoughts on the matter though.

As I see it, the .223 gives you the ability to carry more ammo due to lower weight than the ,30 cal rounds, and .223 is still effective out to 250 yards. In a true SHTF situation, the extra range of .30-06 or .308 would be wasted in NJ in my opnion. I'd like to hear other thoughts on the matter though.

Ha, this should be under Ray's awesome thread of awesomeness. As for .223, I'm not sure of its exact ballistics. 5.56, and the M16/M4 family's maximum effective point range is 500M-- max effective area range is 600M. The max effective point range of the M16 is 550M, area range is 800M. And yes, Army boards ftw!

Most engagements happen under 150-200M for the military (with exception of DM's) because there are usually bigger booms to handle it if its any further. Since we're talking about a SHTF situation, the name of the game is deterrence and not contact. And because of this, if the zombies or whatnot are further then spitting distance, might as well just avoid them instead.

 

As for the weight, definitely man. There's actually a great thread on zombiehunters.org: http://zombiehunters.org/forum/viewtopi ... 16&t=57550

People were seeing how many rounds were in one pound for a wide array of rounds.

What I would be interested in is possibly the 5.45 considering its light weight and comparable knock down power. As for me? I'll stick with my .223/5.56.

semi auto 308 NO QUESTION

 

reason?

it can serve EVERY role.... will DESTROY at close range but is still effective out to 800yards... can setup optics on quick release AND some type of reflex site on quick release so you could go back and forth depending on the environment.... while im no expert i have seen several videos in which the 223 round was put up against various forms of cover and just could not reliably penetrate the cover and target.. i dont see that happening with a 308...

 

and the 308 is still common enough to "find" in a situation where organized society no longer existed..

I'm a fan of the .308, but I think where it fails is its weight (without magazines). I think the data showed that for one pound of .223, it would include around 37 rounds, while .308 would only be 19. 100 rounds of .223 would equal to around 2.7lbs, whereas 100 rounds of .308 is around 5.2lbs.

In terms of ballistics, though I'm no subject matter expert, .308 is superior... but in the SHTF scenarios, there would be an array of variables.

Regardless, its user preference right? :D

I'm a fan of the .308, but I think where it fails is its weight (without magazines). I think the data showed that for one pound of .223, it would include around 37 rounds, while .308 would only be 19. 100 rounds of .223 would equal to around 2.7lbs, whereas 100 rounds of .308 is around 5.2lbs.

In terms of ballistics, though I'm no subject matter expert, .308 is superior... but in the SHTF scenarios, there would be an array of variables.

Regardless, its user preference right? :D

 

 

the thing about the 308 is this.. in a purely hypothetical SHTF situation where im shooting at an "enemy" the 223 may take several shots to neutralize a target behind very light cover, where as the 308 will stop someone hiding behind something as solid as a car door.. lol so while i may not be able to physically carry as much.. i feel like i can count on one hit stops with the 308, where in some situations it may take several shots with a 223...

 

NO i would not want to get shot with a 223 (before someone asks :roll:) but i would not want to get shot with a 22 either..

Most zombie books and movies (as well as most real) firefights take place at short distances. I would go with the smalller round in order to carry more especially in a bug out situation. I personally like the idea of a carbine/handgun combo of the same caliber and that use the same mags, less to worry about when the zombies come. If I can get a secure location that they can't access I'd go for the 308 and the long distance shots.

See, this is where a DMR rifle is perfect. Take a romak, or a true russian dragunov or tigr..... 7.62x54r, and is as versatile from 50 yards to 600. and.... you can put a bayo on it. lol.

See, this is where a DMR rifle is perfect. Take a romak, or a true russian dragunov or tigr..... 7.62x54r, and is as versatile from 50 yards to 600. and.... you can put a bayo on it. lol.

the only issue with that is im pretty sure that running across tons of 7.62x54 laying all over the place will be kind of tough.. lol

See, this is where a DMR rifle is perfect. Take a romak, or a true russian dragunov or tigr..... 7.62x54r, and is as versatile from 50 yards to 600. and.... you can put a bayo on it. lol.

the only issue with that is im pretty sure that running across tons of 7.62x54 laying all over the place will be kind of tough.. lol

 

Not with the hoarders we have here and the popularity of the mosins. =P

 

Just stock up now.... And wayyyyyyyy cheaper than 308.

I'm a fan of the .308, but I think where it fails is its weight (without magazines). I think the data showed that for one pound of .223, it would include around 37 rounds, while .308 would only be 19. 100 rounds of .223 would equal to around 2.7lbs, whereas 100 rounds of .308 is around 5.2lbs.

In terms of ballistics, though I'm no subject matter expert, .308 is superior... but in the SHTF scenarios, there would be an array of variables.

Regardless, its user preference right? :D

 

 

the thing about the 308 is this.. in a purely hypothetical SHTF situation where im shooting at an "enemy" the 223 may take several shots to neutralize a target behind very light cover, where as the 308 will stop someone hiding behind something as solid as a car door.. lol so while i may not be able to physically carry as much.. i feel like i can count on one hit stops with the 308, where in some situations it may take several shots with a 223...

 

NO i would not want to get shot with a 223 (before someone asks :roll:) but i would not want to get shot with a 22 either..

 

Just throwing this out there. You can carry a 1000 rds of 22LR and the rifle would be lighter. Add a 22LR sidearm and I think you could defend yourself in any situation.

Just throwing this out there. You can carry a 1000 rds of 22LR and the rifle would be lighter. Add a 22LR sidearm and I think you could defend yourself in any situation.

 

BAD idea..while having a .22 is better than having NOTHING, it's NOT a garuntee to stop an attacker who is Motivated, or drunk/high. If you Do choose to use a .22 for Defensive purposes, you had beter be capable of placing your shots precisely in an area that will immediately disrupt the CNS of an attacker, under all conditions, and under high stress. We trach center mass for a REASON..under combat stress your fine motor control degrades, as does visual acuity.

  • Author
Most zombie books and movies (as well as most real) firefights take place at short distances. I would go with the smalller round in order to carry more especially in a bug out situation. I personally like the idea of a carbine/handgun combo of the same caliber and that use the same mags, less to worry about when the zombies come. If I can get a secure location that they can't access I'd go for the 308 and the long distance shots.

 

What would the effective range be of a carbine firing a pistol round though? Wouldn't you be limited to less than 100 yards?

Carbines in pistol calibers is a good idea, but I think the person would be sacrificing too much in terms of not enough penetration/knock down power and the inability to stretch the shot if need be.

 

Hypothetically a situation, especially for most of us in NJ, would be in relatively small confines. And even in an open space, it would be unwise to use any type of firearm (best to move away from the fight then to be a part of it), in fear of raising the chances of collateral. Hypothetically, I think the max eff range of a carbine in pistol calibers would be fine. But going back to what was said before, to include talk of .223 vs. .308, the operator would lose a lot of knockdown power. Then of course, my experience with long guns in pistol calibers is limited.

Most zombie books and movies (as well as most real) firefights take place at short distances. I would go with the smalller round in order to carry more especially in a bug out situation. I personally like the idea of a carbine/handgun combo of the same caliber and that use the same mags, less to worry about when the zombies come. If I can get a secure location that they can't access I'd go for the 308 and the long distance shots.

 

What would the effective range be of a carbine firing a pistol round though? Wouldn't you be limited to less than 100 yards?

 

 

while i think you could HIT a target at 100yards or less, im not really sure it would be THAT efficient... when i think of my cx4 i generally think man size target 50 yards or under..

I wouldn't engauge anything at or beyond 100 yards. Hitting a head sized target off hand at 100 yards isn't easy. If the zombies are 100 yards away and shuffeling after me, I'll just limp myself away. Hopefully I shuffle faster then they do. I'd keep the shots at 50 yards or less.

I have treated people who have been shot in the head by a 22. Some died, but usually as a result of blood loss or sepsis (neither of which matter to a zombie). I would not use a 22 to defend myself from a zombie hoard (unless I was in a secure location and could waste the time plinking skulls). It's better then nothing, at least it's a club.

I'm a fan of the .308, but I think where it fails is its weight (without magazines). I think the data showed that for one pound of .223, it would include around 37 rounds, while .308 would only be 19. 100 rounds of .223 would equal to around 2.7lbs, whereas 100 rounds of .308 is around 5.2lbs.

In terms of ballistics, though I'm no subject matter expert, .308 is superior... but in the SHTF scenarios, there would be an array of variables.

Regardless, its user preference right? :D

 

 

the thing about the 308 is this.. in a purely hypothetical SHTF situation where im shooting at an "enemy" the 223 may take several shots to neutralize a target behind very light cover, where as the 308 will stop someone hiding behind something as solid as a car door.. lol so while i may not be able to physically carry as much.. i feel like i can count on one hit stops with the 308, where in some situations it may take several shots with a 223...

 

NO i would not want to get shot with a 223 (before someone asks :roll:) but i would not want to get shot with a 22 either..

There are loads of people that have survived .30 cal wounds throughout history. Counting on caliber vs. stopping hit (CNS) is a mistake IMO.

I love my Cx4 and Px4 as a combo setup. 100 yards is about as far as I can hit something with my cx4, which is in 9mm. I don't plan on engaging zombies past 100 yards, why would I? They can't bit me from that far away!

If I had to shoot past 100 yards my AR in 223 should do the trick.

If I had to shoot waaaaaaaay past 100 yards, then my Ruger M77 in 30-06 should take care of'em.

Whatever you can hit a zombie in the head with reliably, I guess. I don't remember there being anything in zombie flix that was specific about caliber. Maybe .22lr would work. In the Night of the Living Dead, the main guy found a .30-30 lever rifle and used it to off the zombies as I recall. If we are talking about a SHTF situation, I would go with 5.56,it would likely be easiest to find/get/trade for. If that were to happen, I would think a low profile and sharp eyes are the best weapons, backed up with a firearm

i'd go with the AR .223

How about an accuracy international in a 308 or would love a 338 lapua.... for those 1kilometer shots... from the roof of a local walmart or dicks. and in that case... they have a good amount of 308, but mostly 223 and shotgun shells in stock..

 

i think it is time to watch dawn of the dead again.

  • Author
Whatever you can hit a zombie in the head with reliably, I guess. I don't remember there being anything in zombie flix that was specific about caliber. Maybe .22lr would work. In the Night of the Living Dead, the main guy found a .30-30 lever rifle and used it to off the zombies as I recall. If we are talking about a SHTF situation, I would go with 5.56,it would likely be easiest to find/get/trade for. If that were to happen, I would think a low profile and sharp eyes are the best weapons, backed up with a firearm

 

IMO when planning for the Zombie war, you need to plan for a total SHTF situation in addition to zombies. The chances of a SHTF situation is increased several hundred percent when you introduce zombies.

 

zombie.gif

Ahaha, oh man, I need to work on my uppercutting skills for those close combat zombies.

 

Having a diverse bunch of rounds isn't always a bad thing, especially if a person is "bugging in" (staying in a static location). Usage aside (in terms of firearms), it could have a lot of trading value down the road. Having all the ammo in the world is no good if you can't get clean water or the right food.

 

On the other hand, I'll streamline the types of rounds I have because if SHTF, I wouldn't expect to stay anywhere too long (occupational hazard with the world ending and all :roll: ), and trying to lug around five different types of rounds doesn't seem like much fun.

Whatever you can hit a zombie in the head with reliably, I guess. I don't remember there being anything in zombie flix that was specific about caliber. Maybe .22lr would work. In the Night of the Living Dead, the main guy found a .30-30 lever rifle and used it to off the zombies as I recall. If we are talking about a SHTF situation, I would go with 5.56,it would likely be easiest to find/get/trade for. If that were to happen, I would think a low profile and sharp eyes are the best weapons, backed up with a firearm

 

IMO when planning for the Zombie war, you need to plan for a total SHTF situation in addition to zombies. The chances of a SHTF situation is increased several hundred percent when you introduce zombies.

 

zombie.gif

 

:lol: hopefully you have help, so you dont get over ran.

To be honest, I would prefer to be on a roof top with my 22 scope, mosin and M1. I have no issues giving cover.

 

I think a 22 would do well. Sight in, double tap and move on. I am more of an espresso person.

 

2365404742_db828ff1d7.jpg

I know that isn't you celray.

 

1st, rednecks drink mountain dew

2nd, hackensack doesn't have any woods, unless your swimmin in the hackie

3rd, only a fool would shoot with an ipod on, how will you know where the zombies are if you can't hear them?

I know that isn't you celray.

 

1st, rednecks drink mountain dew

2nd, hackensack doesn't have any woods, unless your swimmin in the hackie

3rd, only a fool would shoot with an ipod on, how will you know where the zombies are if you can't hear them?

 

:lol::lol:

 

Not me. I think he is listening to a podcast of the Zombie Apocalypse Survival Times.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.