Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

SAF v NJ (MULLER et al v. MAENZA et al)

Featured Replies

Count me in as well. I believe that a coordinated effort would be the best approach.

  • Replies 1.3k
  • Views 178.7k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • WTF guys. Does nobody understand that probably 90% of members on the site are subscribed to this thread?! That means that 90% of members get an email EVERY SINGLE TIME someone posts in this thread.

  • Before you do. Zero chance is my opinion.

  • Definitely well thought out. But this was brought up a couple days ago in the other thread.

Posted Images

I'm in. Can't hurt to try if we're given the green light.

Guys, I'm all for this strategically when time is due, but one thing to consider is that if you all apply now, they can come back and accept all of ours (for just this one instance) and then claim to the courts (in the current case or in our SCOTUS appeal, if it goes that far) that they accepted 100% of the applications from "common Joe" folks such as ourselves. Then the case gets dropped and we are left with our Justifiable Need clause. When we attempt to reapply in 2 years (or whatever the expiration), we get turned down and it's back to business as usual. Like Frank said, it's free will and I'm not telling you guys not to do it, but please consider how it can be used against us in the long term.

Yes, of course. When the time is right. So I think it's best we hold off for now.

Guys, I'm all for this strategically when time is due, but one thing to consider is that if you all apply now, they can come back and accept all of ours (for just this one instance) and then claim to the courts (in the current case or in our SCOTUS appeal, if it goes that far) that they accepted 100% of the applications from "common Joe" folks such as ourselves. Then the case gets dropped and we are left with our Justifiable Need clause. When we attempt to reapply in 2 years (or whatever the expiration), we get turned down and it's back to business as usual. Like Frank said, it's free will and I'm not telling you guys not to do it, but please consider how it can be used against us in the long term.

 

Yeah I'm thinking along these lines too. That's why the State had the court grant the guy that was kidnapped a permit well into the case. The State knew with him as a plaintiff they had a greater chance of losing. Hold tight.

 

In Gura We Trust

RIGHT MEOW

 

Super Troopers always friggin' kills me when I watch it. My wife just rolls here eyes. She just doesn't get it.

Guys, I'm all for this strategically when time is due, but one thing to consider is that if you all apply now, they can come back and accept all of ours (for just this one instance) and then claim to the courts (in the current case or in our SCOTUS appeal, if it goes that far) that they accepted 100% of the applications from "common Joe" folks such as ourselves. Then the case gets dropped and we are left with our Justifiable Need clause. When we attempt to reapply in 2 years (or whatever the expiration), we get turned down and it's back to business as usual. Like Frank said, it's free will and I'm not telling you guys not to do it, but please consider how it can be used against us in the long term.

 

kwadz,

 

I think you might be misreading our intentions. We're all expressing a willingness to apply and be denied if the legal eagles think it's a good idea. I believe that we all understand that anything we do on our own has the potential to backfire and do more harm than good. But by coming on here and saying that we're willing to apply, if need be, then Frank, Gura, and Bach have an idea of how many of us are out there, should they choose to call on us to apply.

The right time would have been 2010. It's a little late now, the state won't have those "statistics" for a year or two to be ready to submit to the courts. You notice they didn't include 2012.

kwadz,

 

I think you might be misreading our intentions. We're all expressing a willingness to apply and be denied if the legal eagles think it's a good idea. I believe that we all understand that anything we do on our own has the potential to backfire and do more harm than good. But by coming on here and saying that we're willing to apply, if need be, then Frank, Gura, and Bach have an idea of how many of us are out there, should they choose to call on us to apply.

 

If needed, I'll apply too.

The right time would have been 2010. It's a little late now, the state won't have those "statistics" for a year or two to be ready to submit to the courts. You notice they didn't include 2012.

 

If denied, you could present denial paperwork at the hearing. By their stats, 18 out of 20 people would be approved. If we get 100 of 100 people to show denial, it could be a slight favor to the cause.

All,

 

Pls keep in mind, 99.9% of all the already pathetically miniscule civilian CCW's allegedly issued by NJ, are RESTRICTED 'permits' and state right on the permit, "while working only" and "Must be strictly adhered to.." etc.

 

You may not 'neead' ;) a list of CCW denials. Just show the already pathetically minisculed issued CCW's which are all already heavily HEAVILY "restricted" already.

 

Nullifying NJ's own already weak defense.

Dammit! I got Neeead in my brain. Damn that woman!

All,

 

Pls keep in mind, 99.9% of all the already pathetically miniscule civilian CCW's allegedly issued by NJ, are RESTRICTED 'permits' and state right on the permit, "while working only" and "Must be strictly adhered to.." etc.

 

You may not 'neead' ;) a list of CCW denials. Just show the already pathetically minisculed issued CCW's which are all already heavily HEAVILY "restricted" already.

 

Nullifying NJ's own defense.

 

Interesting. I don't remember hearing Gura talk about this in court. Sounds like this would help him slam dunk against NJ saying "the 2A only applies in your house or if you're a security guard" - yeah, right.

 

Maybe the time wasn't right to mention this yet.

Anyone have a clue what the waiting time should be? Ballpark even? Summer? Fall? 2014?

I think the 3rd Circuit opinion will be handed down at the end of the session (Septemberish?), but it's likely to be appealed. So we're still over a year (more like 2) away from a final ruling.

 

So to answer the question before Ray Ray asks, "No, we can't carry yet."

Oral Arguments were in early February 2013. Gura crushed the Ass't NJ AG. Can't believe it would take 7 (Sept) -10 (Dec) months for the 3rd Circuit to make a decision.

Circuit courts of appeals decisions don't need to wait until the end of the session (I'm not sure there is a fixed session for the circuit court of appeals). A decision could come down any time.

Oral Arguments were in early February 2013. Gura crushed the Ass't NJ AG. Can't believe it would take 7 (Sept) -10 (Dec) months for the 3rd Circuit to make a decision.

 

this decision is going to be difficult for the court. The second amendment is 1 sentence long. Even if you had a hard time understanding the intent of that one sentence, there is plenty of supporting information from the writers of the document. The judge is going to have to work hard to write a decision that is contrary to the second amendment that still sounds plausible. I understand why he would drag his feet.

I have no idea why, but I am listening to the oral arguments again. Jesus is this woman unprepared and stupid.

 

Judge: How do you square the guarantee to arms provided by Heller?

 

MBW: I don't think there is a guarantee.

 

Really? The Supremes put it out there, but you don't agree, so it doesn't exist as law?

 

WOW

The judge who seems to be pro 2A is trying to guide her towards proving her own argument and she argues with him. Just WOW.

Stop listening before you find a neead to start talking really funny.

this decision is going to be difficult for the court. The second amendment is 1 sentence long. Even if you had a hard time understanding the intent of that one sentence, there is plenty of supporting information from the writers of the document. The judge is going to have to work hard to write a decision that is contrary to the second amendment that still sounds plausible. I understand why he would drag his feet.

 

I don't see why it's so hard to understand one sentence. The US constitution and the bill of rights was based on state constitutions, many of which state clearly that RKBA is for defense of self and state. In fact some even go as far as to prohibit standing armies unless specifically authorized.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.