Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

SAF v NJ (MULLER et al v. MAENZA et al)

Featured Replies

  • Replies 1.3k
  • Views 178.5k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • WTF guys. Does nobody understand that probably 90% of members on the site are subscribed to this thread?! That means that 90% of members get an email EVERY SINGLE TIME someone posts in this thread.

  • Before you do. Zero chance is my opinion.

  • Definitely well thought out. But this was brought up a couple days ago in the other thread.

Posted Images

I think they have 90 days to decide whether to grant or deny cert

 

Ryan, I'm lost.  SCOTUS denied hearing the case.  Gura said "pretty please" and SCOTUS said "let us think it over".  And now we're waiting to find out.  Do I understand correctly?

Depends if the Sultan's wife leaves him and SCOTUS is petitioned to hear their divorce proceedings. :rolleyes:

Ryan, I'm lost.  SCOTUS denied hearing the case.  Gura said "pretty please" and SCOTUS said "let us think it over".  And now we're waiting to find out.  Do I understand correctly?

 

SCOTUS denied cert on the Maryland case, Woollard vs. Gallagher. The NJ case, Drake vs. Filko, was granted the delay Gura asked for and we're still waiting for cert on that one.

SCOTUS denied cert on the Maryland case, Woollard vs. Gallagher. The NJ case, Drake vs. Filko, was granted the delay Gura asked for and we're still waiting for cert on that one.

Why did Gura need the delay?  

Why did Gura need the delay?  

 

I have no idea but I suspect it's some strategy he has in mind. They never reveal their hand. These guys are playing chess, not checkers and are always four moves ahead. 

 

My guess is that there's another case he wants to shake out before this one is heard. Peña with the California handgun roster I've been told may have something to do with the timing.

I have no idea but I suspect it's some strategy he has in mind. They never reveal their hand. These guys are playing chess, not checkers and are always four moves ahead. 

 

My guess is that there's another case he wants to shake out before this one is heard. Peña with the California handgun roster I've been told may have something to do with the timing.

 

thanks for keeping us updated.  it seems you are well aware of the process.  it gets really confusing to us that dont quite understand the scheduling and formal "requests" that have to be made.  

Looks like the due date for the petition for a writ of certiorari is the day before the conference.

 

From SCOTUSblog:

The Justices’ next Conference is scheduled for January 10, 2014. Our list of “Petitions to watch” for that Conference will be available soon.

 

From SCOTUS:

No. 13A468   Title: John M. Drake, et al., Applicants v. Rudolph A. Filko, Judge, Superior Court of New Jersey, Passaic County, et al. Docketed: November 5, 2013 Lower Ct: United States Court of Appeals for the Third Circuit   Case Nos.: (12-1150)
~~~Date~~~  ~~~~~~~Proceedings  and  Orders~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~ Nov 1 2013 Application (13A468) to extend the time to file a petition for a writ of certiorari from November 25, 2013 to January 9, 2014, submitted to Justice Alito. Nov 6 2013 Application (13A468) granted by Justice Alito extending the time to file until January 9, 2014.  

~~Name~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~    ~~~~~~~Address~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~   ~~Phone~~~ Attorneys for Petitioners:     Alan Gura Gura & Possessky, PLLC (703) 835-9085   101 N. Columbus Street, Suite 405     Alexandria, VA  22314   Party name: John M. Drake, et al.

That's when they formally ask for the Supreme Court to hear it or when the Supreme Court says they will or won't hear it?

That's when they formally ask for the Supreme Court to hear it or when the Supreme Court says they will or won't hear it?

It's my understanding that in "conference" they review requests before the court. The filing that Gura has until Jan 9th to get in will be concidered in one of the conferences the justices have, perhaps the first one on the 10th. Could be concidered at a different conference also. The justices never reveal why a case won't be heard, it's anyones guess. If 4 justices vote to hear an appeal then the case gets put on the docket for oral arguments. Based on the decision handed down by the court of appeals, he had until Nov 25th to file. He was granted an extension for filing, Jan 9th.

Will yesterdays ruling in NJ on the two fire marshals who were denied have any bearing on the Filko case.   That NJ is a "shall not issue" and 2A does not apply in NJ.    I thought that was one of the arguments in these NJ cases that NJ claims that they do issue to people when in fact we know they don't.     The number of people denied vs. issued .

There's no telling if it could be but some interesting things came out of that case. My guess is that the state would reference the case in its brief in opposition and the court would consider that as a factor when granting cert. If the case does get taken up, who knows. 

Will yesterdays ruling in NJ on the two fire marshals who were denied have any bearing on the Filko case.   That NJ is a "shall not issue" and 2A does not apply in NJ.    I thought that was one of the arguments in these NJ cases that NJ claims that they do issue to people when in fact we know they don't.     The number of people denied vs. issued .

what happens in NJ in a NJ court (as opposed to a Federal court) is totally independent of SCOTUS. Heller and McDonald dealt with two places that had 100% bans on one aspect of the 2nd Amendment. The NJ courts don't see either of the SCOTUS decisions as changing anything here in NJ because we could buy most handguns and most long guns including transporting them and owning them under the current scheme. Once the definition of "to bear" is defined and located by SCOTUS (inside the house vs. outside the house) then the three branches of NJ government will have to make some changes. What makes Drake v Filko so important to NJ is that it is a NJ specific federal civil rights law suit. The Nappan case is a NJ specific case to be heard in a NJ State court and also could be a game changer although SCOTUS would be a better win overall for all of the USA.

Nappen case is a smackdown waiting to happen by the SCONJ on gun owners...if people can't see that by the way the Courts just defended the carry cases themselves, they are blind 

Nappen case is a smackdown waiting to happen by the SCONJ on gun owners...if people can't see that by the way the Courts just defended the carry cases themselves, they are blind

I think Nappen can give a good canned speech to a crowd of true believers. I am less confident of his courtroom arguing skills. He did not seem like a great off the cuff thinker when I heard him speak.

Seen this posted on FB.

 

http://www.thegunmag.com/supreme-court-asked-to-consider-saf-right-to-carry-case/

 

 

The Second Amendment Foundation and Association of New Jersey Rifle & Pistol Clubs today asked the U.S. Supreme Court to hear the appeal in the challenge to New Jersey’s unconstitutional carry laws. The case is Drake v. Jerejian.

 

so when would we know if the supreme court decides to hear the case? is it like most government things going to take a year? and if they do decide to hear it would it even be heard in 2014?

For me the bigger question is will they take it? It seems to me that eventually they will have to answer the question, and that they have been shopping for a "good" case and rejecting weak cases. I would never dare handicap the odds of  SCOTUS doing anything, but to my untrained eyes that cert looks really solid.  My thinking is if they don't take this one, they probably will never take a carry case.

 but to my untrained eyes that cert looks really solid.  My thinking is if they don't take this one, they probably will never take a carry case.

 

that was my thinking too.  but i thought there was no way they could rule against us in the previous 3 rounds based on reading his submittals and listening to the oral testimony.  lets just hope that if they do take it and we win A.) governor christie is still governor and B.) he still thinks he has a chance at becoming president.  

please correct me if im wrong but my understanding was that there are 2 different ccw, right to bear arms, cases being brought to scotus this year. And from my understanding they will likely have to hear at least one of these cases. Again ianal so please correct me if im wrong.

that was my thinking too.  but i thought there was no way they could rule against us in the previous 3 rounds based on reading his submittals and listening to the oral testimony.  lets just hope that if they do take it and we win A.) governor christie is still governor and B.) he still thinks he has a chance at becoming president.  

that is a key point about CC. If he wants to run for president he needs to do something positive for the 2nd amendment, or there's no way he wins primary's in the deep red states.

 

also not sure if its possible but is there any way the lawyers in this case can get a petition going to get SCOTUS to hear the case? i mean get on every gun forum and get people to sign it, and really push it. Not sure if it would make a difference but seems to me that it cant hurt us.

so when would we know if the supreme court decides to hear the case? is it like most government things going to take a year? and if they do decide to hear it would it even be heard in 2014?

Possibly today. Jan 10 conference.

Possibly today. Jan 10 conference.

i really dont see them reading the 200 pages by today.

This was a great brief.  Gura correctly portrays this as not just about the 2A but also about lower courts' willful disregard of supreme court precedent.  He really pulled out all the stops and made the 3rd circuit majority in Drake look bad.  I'm hopeful that at least 4 justices will want to take this case to send a message, even if they are not eager to wade back into the 2A.

 

And by the way, the brief isn't 200 pages.  It's about 40 or so -- the rest are attachments (such as the lower court decisions).  It took me about 20 minutes to read the brief.

so when would we know if the supreme court decides to hear the case? is it like most government things going to take a year? and if they do decide to hear it would it even be heard in 2014?

http://www.scotusblog.com/case-files/petitions-were-watching/

SCOTUS blog does a great job of updating the goings on. That link lists everything they will be reviewing in conference today. The conferences on the 17th & 24th are not as populated which tells me the justices haven't decided those day's complete agenda yet. The editors of the blog also list "Petitions Not Set for Conference" which already lists National Rifle Association of America v. McCraw and should list Drake soon.

I would imagine most of the justices and their staff follow the lower court cases especially topics that are as active as the 2nd Amendment. As they do not tip their hand, we may never know why the NY & MD petitions were denied cert. If they grant cert for Drake it is my guess that the 4 who voted were waiting for it or one like it.

I learned an interesting lesson at a town meeting a few years ago. A group was trying to develop a piece of land that needed a variance. The project was a low income housing rental adjacent to single family properties. Every person who spoke against the variance gave great reasons why the town shouldn't allow a low income rental. A 20+ year vet of Lakewood PD even spoke up and explained his experience with low income and what it does to a neighborhood. Those testifying all lived in close proximity of the property and would feel the impact. The reasons homeowners gave ranged from crime to drugs. Nothing seemed to phase the officials. The zoning board listened patiently for two hours, never revealing what they'd do. Everything changed when a young mother spoke. She said that the road was busy and there was a blind corner near the property. Her concern was for the children of the single mothers living in the proposed housing. She said they might get hit by one of the cars. The faces of the board immediately changed from comatose to wide eyed. They literally all looked from side to side at each other in a guesture that I took to mean, "did you hear that"? The chairman broke in and announced that they were very concerned for the safety of the children and put the variance to a vote on the spot. In less that 20 seconds we went from endless testimony to petition denied.  If you blinked you missed it, it happened that fast.

My take away was that the board knew and agreed with all the reasons the homeowners did not want a low income project in their neighborhood. They just couldn't publicly agree with it. They were waiting for cover. The safety of the children was all they needed. I believe these justices operate the same way on certain levels. Look at Roberts and how he voted on Obamacare. Even people who side with conservative values can be swayed. You just never know. Maybe this petition has a few hot buttons the fence sitters have been waiting for. Maybe the volume of cases rolling in will finally give someone the cover they are comfortable with. The five who voted together on Heller and McDonald are still seated and we only need 4 to grant cert. We should know soon.

i really dont see them reading the 200 pages by today.

why not.  we all did :D

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.