Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

SAF v NJ (MULLER et al v. MAENZA et al)

Featured Replies

Wow. Already talking about what we are carrying. How many guns they are allowing on the permit. Qualifying costs. Haha. Optimistic few days here. Let's get to the 21st first

 

My thoughts exactly.  I don't want to set myself up for a possible let down ;)

  • Replies 1.3k
  • Views 177.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • WTF guys. Does nobody understand that probably 90% of members on the site are subscribed to this thread?! That means that 90% of members get an email EVERY SINGLE TIME someone posts in this thread.

  • Before you do. Zero chance is my opinion.

  • Definitely well thought out. But this was brought up a couple days ago in the other thread.

Posted Images

I have a feeling that, if we get CCW, we'll see the price of required training skyrocket due to the law of supply and demand. I hope I'm wrong but I fear I'm not.

 

 

This signature is AWESOME!!!

 

Maybe, maybe not.

Anthony of GFH just made it FREE for members of his range.

 

I am hoping ANJRPC will also make the quals available for range members at Cherry Ridge. What better way to stick it to NJ than helping people get licensed. I would gladly go through the instructor certification and volunteer my time. 

Wow. Already talking about what we are carrying. How many guns they are allowing on the permit. Qualifying costs. Haha. Optimistic few days here. Let's get to the 21st first

 

You have a point! But I like to be optimistic... Besides, it looks like Judge O'Scannlain is playing chess with the Peruta decision and Kamala's motion to intervene. 

I have a feeling that, if we get CCW, we'll see the price of required training skyrocket due to the law of supply and demand. I hope I'm wrong but I fear I'm not.

 

 

This signature is AWESOME!!!

Really, cause I suspect you will see lots of training of trainers unless being blessed as sufficiently credentialed is overly complicated. Heck, even then, it might be more likely with grass roots pushing to make flaming hoops an easily ticked box on a form.

How so? Was he the guy that wrote the majority opinion on peruta?

 

Yes, and I have a feeling he wants to see Drake granted. 

Really, cause I suspect you will see lots of training of trainers unless being blessed as sufficiently credentialed is overly complicated. Heck, even then, it might be more likely with grass roots pushing to make flaming hoops an easily ticked box on a form.

 

There a few of them. Same trainers who do RPO quals. 

the consensus I have gotten from some lawyers is that the SCOTUS could essentially gut NJ laws...to the point of elimination of permitting, FPID cards and the AWB. NJ is in serious jeopardy. If the SCOTUS applies the "common use"  clause enumerated in past rulings, the AWB is done, magazine limits are done and their "carefully crafted Scheme" of permitting is in jeopardy of being struck down. The foundations of all NJ gun laws are "justifiable need" and the fact that NJ out right bans firearms, allowing them only by exemption is NOT gonna be lost by the courts. Remember, NJ is/was the start point for all other gun laws in the USA.

 

That would be like the last scene in Return of the Jedi, after the evil empire has been defeated. The Ewoks wil be dancing in the streets with the rest of us!

Somehow I find it hard to believe that SCOTUS will do anything other than answer the very specific question posed to them. But I hope I'm wrong.

Somehow I find it hard to believe that SCOTUS will do anything other than answer the very specific question posed to them. But I hope I'm wrong.

 

That is probably what they will do. IF they even take the case. 

Somehow I find it hard to believe that SCOTUS will do anything other than answer the very specific question posed to them. But I hope I'm wrong.

There are two questions:

 

"QUESTIONS PRESENTED

1. Whether the Second Amendment secures a right to carry handguns outside the home for selfdefense.

2. Whether state officials violate the Second Amendment by requiring that individuals wishing to exercise their right to carry a handgun for self defense first prove a “justifiable need” for doing so."

My reading and understanding of SCOTUS rulings re: 2A are this:

 

A state must allow the serfs to carry in some form, either OC or CC.

There can be regulations, but they cannot be onerous nor effectively exclusionary (like justifiable need)

Private enterprises are allowed to ban weapons (any weapon, including CC firearms).

 

My mind is that SCOTUS will hear the case, order NJ to either allow OC or remove "justifiable neeahd" from CC and will give a time-frame, just like IL, which had 120 days, if I remember correctly.

 

My mind is that SCOTUS will hear the case, order NJ to either allow OC or remove "justifiable neeahd" from CC and will give a time-frame, just like IL, which had 120 days, if I remember correctly.

 

I see no reason for a time frame other than immediately with NJ. Chicago had no CC laws on the books, they were given time to create some. NJ has the laws, they just need to remove the justifiable need clause.

Somehow I find it hard to believe that SCOTUS will do anything other than answer the very specific question posed to them. But I hope I'm wrong.

Well, specifically gut the laws? Not likely. Gut essentially all of NJ laws? Possibly. Primarily due to the fact that NJ law operates from the assumption that exercising the 2nd amendment is illegal, and then carves out exceptions to that, thus forcing an affirmative defense to exercise an enumerated, incorporated right. This is not generally accepted for an incorporated right. They might address this directly, but I doubt it. If they were to step beyond the narrow question at all, my suspicion given their statements of not wanting to have every technicality be a scotus issue, is that they may very well set forth a more specific legal test. So far, every anti ruling has pushed the limits of intermediate scrutiny specified in heller. Drake doesn't even pretend to rise to the level of intermediate scrutiny. Depending on what kind of test they spell out, it could imperil a lot of anti laws like the various AWBs or mag capacity limits, for NJ a well spelled out test placing the level of scrutiny at the high end of the intermediate level could make every nj law challengable based on how the law is constructed. That doesn't mean the net affect wouldn't pass scrutiny, just that if it breaks the root of nj gun law that the 2nd is illegal to exercise EXCEPT... The entire nj gun laws will have to go back to the drawing board.

as I said...NJ is in DEEP if they do take the case...and they will have to. There has NEVER been such a grouping of amicus briefs done by so many states to ask...there has never been ANY challenged NJ laws brought to the SCOTUS. Remember, ALL the federal AWB crap was directly copied off NJ awb...most all states gun control laws were derived from NJ Laws. NJ is the BIG one...they can smash the whole foundation of these laws and they would be moot since the legal concepts they were built on are struck.

NJ patently believes that the R2KBA is NOT a fundamental right...and they even say that in their brief, for the SCOTUS to let stand the foundations of that would be an affront to Heller and McDonald's incorporation into the 14th amendment.

My reading and understanding of SCOTUS rulings re: 2A are this:

 

A state must allow the serfs to carry in some form, either OC or CC.

There can be regulations, but they cannot be onerous nor effectively exclusionary (like justifiable need)

Private enterprises are allowed to ban weapons (any weapon, including CC firearms).

 

My mind is that SCOTUS will hear the case, order NJ to either allow OC or remove "justifiable neeahd" from CC and will give a time-frame, just like IL, which had 120 days, if I remember correctly.

absolutely no need for 120 or even 1 day for state to act, IL had no carry permit scheme, NJ does. The day of the ruling, superior courts (they issue permits) must allow "self defense" as your "justifiable need" in your "letter of need" attached to your application. No further statutes or admin code required.

Much better chance of getting concealed carry rather than open carry in New Jersey. A  properly concealed weapon causes no fear, concern  or alarm with the public; open carry would literally cause hysteria in a state with no prior history of it.

You guys talking about CC or OC, remember that NJ Carry Permit does not make any difference if it is CC or OC. It's just a carry permit, so you can carry it either way.

Much better chance of getting concealed carry rather than open carry in New Jersey. A  properly concealed weapon causes no fear, concern  or alarm with the public; open carry would literally cause hysteria in a state with no prior history of it.

 

It could go either way. Open carry could be seen as a way to discourage people from carrying. Of course, if they restrict us to open carry, I want us all to march on Trenton every month carrying openly, and just carry openly everywhere. Let them realize that their plan is not working. Of course they probably realize this and they will just let it fall to concealed carry... that's if they even pass a law. They might just leave it as-is which means you can choose openly or concealed. 

 

But again, they have to take the case first... let's get there first before we start planning how to carry. ;)

Much better chance of getting concealed carry rather than open carry in New Jersey. A  properly concealed weapon causes no fear, concern  or alarm with the public; open carry would literally cause hysteria in a state with no prior history of it.

 

I can only imagine the volume of calls the PD dispatch would get if even .1% of NJ pupulation was open carrying the day it was allowed.  There would not be enough cops to go on all the calls lol.  It would be hysterical.  They would feel they have to investigate each call to make sure the person had the propper paperwork.  I would imagine the same person causing multiple calls per hour.

 

The cops would pull their hair out.

I can only imagine the volume of calls the PD dispatch would get if even .1% of NJ pupulation was open carrying the day it was allowed. There would not be enough cops to go on all the calls lol. It would be hysterical. They would feel they have to investigate each call to make sure the person had the propper paperwork. I would imagine the same person causing multiple calls per hour.

 

The cops would pull their hair out.

Depending where you're going to OC, I'd suggest wearing a vest under your shirt the first week or two.

I can only imagine the volume of calls the PD dispatch would get if even .1% of NJ pupulation was open carrying the day it was allowed.  There would not be enough cops to go on all the calls lol.  It would be hysterical.  They would feel they have to investigate each call to make sure the person had the propper paperwork.  I would imagine the same person causing multiple calls per hour.

 

The cops would pull their hair out.

I'm afraid many would be arrested too and charged with disturbing the peace or similar disorderly persons offenses.  The view would be it's your fault for causing someone else to be afraid and contact the police.  There are many officers who support concealed carry but there also many, especially those in power, that do not believe civilians should be armed under any circumstance and would throw anything they could at us.  Their theory would be to let the courts figure it out in the mean time they look good to antis.

Funny how time/place/manner makes all the difference. I was at a steel match in NJ, probably 200 people all walking around the 6 lanes with handguns in holsters or at the line making the bang-ding noise. A 20 something local LEO just happen to be patrolling and wandered into the parking area near the competition. First and only time I've seen a cop on the job at our club. He was standing near his squad car surveying the scene. No one gave him much more than a look. Never walked over to the registration table or engaged any of the participants. He's the one who felt out of place, not anyone else.

That is students. Also the final result of that is basically a 50/50 shoulder shrug.

 

Yes, I know. But it's encouraging, rather than just an outright prediction of denial.

Funny how time/place/manner makes all the difference. I was at a steel match in NJ, probably 200 people all walking around the 6 lanes with handguns in holsters or at the line making the bang-ding noise. A 20 something local LEO just happen to be patrolling and wandered into the parking area near the competition. First and only time I've seen a cop on the job at our club. He was standing near his squad car surveying the scene. No one gave him much more than a look. Never walked over to the registration table or engaged any of the participants. He's the one who felt out of place, not anyone else.

sad part is he didn't come over and say 'Hi.' bet if he did, was cool and just shot the shit with some people they'd probably invite him to take a couple plinks. gun people (for the most part) are a really friendly bunch. :)

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.