Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Rally in Phila... can I legally carry?

Featured Replies

Just wondering and I probably will not carry, but am I allowed to carry legally during a rally in Philadelphia outdoors? Obviously concealed with Florida CCW. Chances are I will not, but if I catch "wind" of possible dangerous opposition then I will. I do not want to name the rally at this point, but it is a "conservative" event.

yes

 

BTW, PAFOA is a great place to post questions like this. You always follow the laws of the state you are carrying in, so a PA board would be the best place to inquire about PA law. Just be prepared for 10 page legal arguments :p

I thought Philadelphia passed some type of ordnance that it was illegal to carry in Philadelphia with an out of state carry license. I understand that it is unconstitutional, but do you really want to be the one who tests it?

I believe the bigger concern with carrying in Philly is the fact that there is practically a school on every corner and out of staties have to follow a certain feet rule from every state. I havn't actually looked into this but have heard a few people on this forum mention this as a downside to carrying in Philly.

  • Author

I thought Philadelphia passed some type of ordnance that it was illegal to carry in Philadelphia with an out of state carry license. I understand that it is unconstitutional, but do you really want to be the one who tests it?

 

I believe that is for PA residents (only) that have a FL carry and not a PA carry. There was a case where a PA resident was denied a PA carry but had a FL carry from earlier. Since he was a PA resident he had to show his PA ccw which he did not have.

I believe the bigger concern with carrying in Philly is the fact that there is practically a school on every corner and out of staties have to follow a certain feet rule from every state. I havn't actually looked into this but have heard a few people on this forum mention this as a downside to carrying in Philly.

 

 

law says you are expempt from the 1,000 foot gun free zone if you hold a license in that state.

 

The way reciprocity works is your license counts as that states license. Think about it, its illegal to carry concealed in PA without a PA LTCF. Licenses in the reciprocating states count as a PA LTCF.

 

So the argument is up in the air and not conclusive as to if the florida counts or not as far as the expemption goes

yes

 

BTW, PAFOA is a great place to post questions like this. You always follow the laws of the state you are carrying in, so a PA board would be the best place to inquire about PA law. Just be prepared for 10 page legal arguments :p

 

 

Normally, I'd agree with this. But in this case PAFOA would say you could do it but couldn't legally get the gun from your home to PA...as your planned trip is not to a NJ exemption. Like this thread

 

I thought Philadelphia passed some type of ordnance that it was illegal to carry in Philadelphia with an out of state carry license. I understand that it is unconstitutional, but do you really want to be the one who tests it?

 

It's not that it's unconstitutional...it's that it violates the PA Preemption law.

Two notes:

 

1) I believe the new Philly law does not just single out PA residents - it applies to anyone carrying on a license from a state in which they do not reside. As originally proposed, it was only to apply to PA residents - I don't think that was the final version. I may be wrong, but it's a moot point as it violates PA pre-emption. If you are carrying concealed, there would be a slim chance you'd become a test case, and it is doubtful that the DA would prosecute - they know it's illegal, they just do it anyway. Philly feel-good moment.

 

2) The within 1000' of a school law, unless you have a resident license, has never been tested. It was thrown out once and rewritten, but no one has ever been prosecuted under this law. I believe that as the law is written, they have to prove intent. Not something to worry about either.

 

I won't go into Philly unarmed.

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

Normally, I'd agree with this. But in this case PAFOA would say you could do it but couldn't legally get the gun from your home to PA...as your planned trip is not to a NJ exemption. Like this thread

 

Technically covered under FOPA. Legal where you start, and legal at your destination. Just have to adhere to FOPA transportation rules until you get into Free America.

Technically covered under FOPA. Legal where you start, and legal at your destination. Just have to adhere to FOPA transportation rules until you get into Free America.

True, and couldn't you plan to go to a range in PA on your way to the rally, then your certainly covered.

Technically covered under FOPA. Legal where you start, and legal at your destination. Just have to adhere to FOPA transportation rules until you get into Free America.

 

The debate is that it is NOT legal where you start. It's not legal to transport in NJ unless you're under an exemption. You'd be covered under FOPA if you were just passing through NJ which makes no sense.

 

For example, if you get stopped in NJ, what is your reasoning for having the gun in your trunk? FOPA? Anyone could use that excuse. Aitken could have said he was headed to PA and FOPA applied. I guess....

 

You know, when people argue back and forth, the law is not clear.

read up on the ordinance, i think philly would accept ccw permits from 6 states. FL wasnt one of them, but UT was. i dont wanna be the test mule for an arrest. i would stop @ a range in PA to say FU to transporting in NJ. just in case.

read up on the ordinance, i think philly would accept ccw permits from 6 states. FL wasnt one of them, but UT was. i dont wanna be the test mule for an arrest. i would stop @ a range in PA to say FU to transporting in NJ. just in case.

 

 

Those 6 states are in there because according to Deputy Mayor Gillson:

 

Committee Transcript

 

Those are the ones that are

3 referenced in the amended bill, because

4 we have reciprocal arrangements with

5 those states and if a person has a

6 license in those states, they've already

7 passed the minimum test. All others are

8 not recognized because we do not have

9 reciprocity with any other states.

 

They are so stupid in that city they don't even know what they are talking about.

Here is a big factor on how you are going to be viewed from the very beginning, what type of rally are you attending and what side are you supporting? Right there is going to begin the bias of your situation.

 

Say you are attending a rally about an Islamic extremist. If you are supporting him, you are going to fail in the eyes of LEO's. Attend the same rally but are across the street, holding an American Flag not looking like a trouble maker and your chances of being harassed are greatly diminished. Rallies are risky to be carrying in. If things go sour, you just might be herded up with everyone and then during the pat-down before going into the Paddy Wagon, you are going to be singled out and sat on the Group W bench for further questioning.

 

Would I CCW in Philly with my FL CCW? Yes I would...have done it a number of times. I am presenting at two speaking engagements coming up in war zones that I wish I could carry, Baltimore and Mexico City.

The debate is that it is NOT legal where you start. It's not legal to transport in NJ unless you're under an exemption. You'd be covered under FOPA if you were just passing through NJ which makes no sense.

 

For example, if you get stopped in NJ, what is your reasoning for having the gun in your trunk? FOPA? Anyone could use that excuse. Aitken could have said he was headed to PA and FOPA applied. I guess....

 

You know, when people argue back and forth, the law is not clear.

 

I would have thought that legal where you start meant your house. I can legally carry in my house, and can legally carry in PA. So according to FOPA, I can travel between the two. I would love to know which of us is correct.

I would have thought that legal where you start meant your house. I can legally carry in my house, and can legally carry in PA. So according to FOPA, I can travel between the two. I would love to know which of us is correct.

 

you got it.. that is how I literally read the law..

 

"Notwithstanding any other provision of any law or any rule or regulation of a State or any political subdivision thereof, any person who is not otherwise prohibited by this chapter from transporting, shipping, or receiving a firearm shall be entitled to transport a firearm for any lawful purpose from any place where he may lawfully possess and carry such firearm to any other place where he may lawfully possess and carry such firearm if, during such transportation the firearm is unloaded, and neither the firearm nor any ammunition being transported is readily accessible or is directly accessible from the passenger compartment of such transporting vehicle: Provided, That in the case of a vehicle without a compartment separate from the driver’s compartment the firearm or ammunition shall be contained in a locked container other than the glove compartment or console."

 

from any place where he may lawfully possess carry such firearm

my home in NJ

 

to

 

to any other place where he may lawfully possess and carry such firearm

PA where I may carry a gun legally in the entire state

 

if you read the law it states pretty clearly.. that you can bring it from state A (where you can lawfully have a gun.. at my home for example) to state B (providing the gun is legal there.. which in this case it is)

 

 

I suggest you reread the item that PK90 posted..

it explains that the law is in regards to transporting your legally owned firearm from one state to another, NJ exemptions are for transporting the gun within the state..

 

In fact here.. if YOUR interpretation of the law was the fact.. then EVERY single person to EVER take a handgun to a range outside the state... and did not go DIRECTLY to the range and then home.. they would be breaking the law.. every competition.. say you have a pistol competition in Arizona.. your logic states unless you go DIRECTLY to Arizona.. and then DIRECTLY home you are breaking NJ law and subject to punishment.. you can not stop.. you can not spend the night.. go directly to the range.. and come directly home.. which is obviously ridiculous.. the law is for transporting a gun within the state..

 

as far as FOPA

 

Accessibility

Gun is locked in the trunk of the car with ammunition separate.. the gun is not accessible therefore satisfying accessibility..

 

Purposes

you are carrying a gun in PA for self defense.. under FOPA self defense is an acceptable reason...

 

 

Lawful Carrying at Origin and Destination

my gun is lawfully owned in NJ and PA recognizes my right to carry.. making it legal there this satisfies legal at start and finish..

 

carrying a gun to PA for self defense is the same as taking your gun to a competition in Wyoming.. if you lug your gun half way across the country and stay for 4 days.. you are hardly going directly to and from the range.. but that is ok... because FOPA protects you.. just as it does with carrying in PA..

Gun shops in Philly have not even followed some of the stupid laws Philly has passed - because they have no weight due to preemption. There was one law they passed (I forget) that the Philly DA said he would not enforce because of preemption. The lines are pretty clear on this. You are good to go with a FL permit in Philly.

 

The other side of the equation is how a Philly cop might treat you. They don't even follow PA or Philly's laws. So you could get your firearm confiscated or worse. And they won't make it simple to get your gun back.

 

Ultimately, there is nearly zero chance of you actually being even prosecuted in court for carrying in Philly on an FL permit. They don't have the authority to do that, and they know it. But I am not a lawyer.

 

I wouldn't OC in Philly under a FL license. That is also legal. But it drastically increases the chances of an LEO encounter, which bears with it all the inconveniences mentioned above with the FL thing.

 

I am of the belief that FOPA will not protect you leaving NJ, and therefore driving to a rally in Philly with a handgun in your car is a felony during the portion of your trip within NJ. People dissagree, and that is a separate subject from the thread topic.

I wouldn't OC in Philly under a FL license.

I could be wrong but....I thought that OC was legal in PA without any license, as long as you are not a prohibited person. Does this only pertain to PA citizens?

I could be wrong but....I thought that OC was legal in PA without any license, as long as you are not a prohibited person. Does this only pertain to PA citizens?

 

OC is legal in PA without a license everywhere EXCEPT Philadelphia.

 

18 Pa.C.S. § 6108: Carrying firearms on public streets or public property in Philadelphia

No person shall carry a firearm, rifle or shotgun at any time upon the public streets or upon any public property in a city of the first class unless:

(1) such person is licensed to carry a firearm; or

(2) such person is exempt from licensing under section 6106 of this title (relating to firearms not to be carried without a license).

I could be wrong but....I thought that OC was legal in PA without any license, as long as you are not a prohibited person. Does this only pertain to PA citizens?

 

You were correct. But you can't transport a handgun in a vehicle without some sort of license unless you are going to and from places similar to NJ. Even locked up in your trunk.

 

Regarding Philly, Philly is a City of the First Class. The only one in the Commonwealth. As such, transporting ANY firearm (even rifles) is pretty close to the rules of possessing a handgun in NJ. Unless you have LTCF. Or LTC/Permit from a reciprocal state. Which the Philly cops don't want to recognize now, even though they won't make a charge actually stick. They can still take your **** (illegally) and probably never give it back unless you pay more than it's worth and wait a long time.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.