Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Constitutional challenge to part of New Jersey's gun carry law rejected

Featured Replies

give it to me straight.. what are the chances we get concealed carry in nj?

Nobody knows. I would say that there is a slim chance that we do. A bit better chance that we get open carry. But still a very slim chance.

  • Replies 84
  • Views 8.9k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • YankeeFan
    YankeeFan

    No ifs, ands, or buts about it.     New Jersey F******G SUCKS!

actually it looks like muller vs manza may be in the 3rd circuit already, i didnt realize.

if you google 3rd circuit court of appeals second amendment, this is the first hit http://blog.californiarighttocarry.org/?page_id=110

It's not like we have a sticky about it or anything.

 

Listen to the orals. If the courts rule against us you know it's judicial activisim. Unfortunately I think it may boil down to that.

That might be correct, but who is going to spend all that money and time getting the 3rd circuit court of appeals?

 

The Second Amendment Foundation, ANJRPC and others.

 You ARE aware that Neither Heller OR MCDonald had ANYTHING to do with CCW right?  Both cases had to do with all but complete BANS, and neither case addressed anything more than the ability to possess a handgun in your home.  Heller DOES apply to NJ, but Heller doesnt have a DAMNED thing to do with CCW.

 

We don't know that, and this is what we're trying to find out. This is why the cases are in the circuit courts and ultimately SCOTUS.

 

They could drop the language they have now, and have a requirement that if you have ever had a moving violation or parking ticket, you cannot have a carry permit as you clearly have demonstrated a blatant disregard for the law. They'd be much more likely to get away with that, except it would exclude most everyone, including folks they currently hand them out to. 

 

They might face bigger problems with that, as it is much more strict than what is required for LEO who can carry by statute. NJSP requires that you have fewer than 5 violations within 2 years.

The thing is NJ is not disallowing us our 2A rights. They are just not allowing us to CCW. There is a difference. That is why they can claim they are not violating the US Constitution and list themselves as a "shall issue" state when we all know well and good that the average Joe cannt get a CCW permit. I think it sucks, but that is how the NJ Courts interpret the law.

 

NJ is shall issue for FID and may issue for CCW.  Shall issue means the default answer is "yes"; that the state has to issue unless they can prove good cause to not issue.  May issue means that the default answer is "no" and the applicant must prove why they are worthy.  NJ may have trouble showing that they have not set that bar too high and becoming a de facto no issue state. 

Never happen.

 

MD will go next. That leaves Hawaii and jersey. Nobody cares about Hawaii. But they would go before jersey, if they ever do.

 

BTW - Puerto Rico will go in the next few years.

Never happen. MD will go next. That leaves Hawaii and jersey. Nobody cares about Hawaii. But they would go before jersey, if they ever do. BTW - Puerto Rico will go in the next few years.

 

I'm confused. This isn't in context.

What will never happen?

 

MD already lost their appeal. In fact district was a win and the circuit reversed. Cert is pending but is unlikely to be granted. 

 

I'm confused. This isn't in context.

What will never happen?

 

MD already lost their appeal. In fact district was a win and the circuit reversed. Cert is pending but is unlikely to be granted. 

 

 

 

There are only three states that generally don't issue now that Illinois fell - NJ, Hawaii, and MD.

 

MD will get it.

 

Never happen for NJ.

 

You guys are jumping the gun on IL. , I will wait until the dust settles to see what they "really" get......  I am betting it is no better then us

 

 

How much $?

 

They are going to be better than a lot of Shall Issue states, even for non-residents.

   

 

 

There are only three states that generally don't issue now that Illinois fell - NJ, Hawaii, and MD.

 

MD will get it.

 

Never happen for NJ.

 

MD won't get it. Their case was already ruled and the circuit court of appeals upheld their discretionary may issue and reversed the district court. The only way for MD to get shall issue judicially is for the case to go to SCOTUS and if it goes to SCOTUS NJ will get it too. They have until 6/21 to petition. Likelihood is that the SCOTUS will deny cert like they did with Kachalsky (NY). 

 

Also, MD's argument was that they already allow people to carry long guns so they satisfy the 2A and heller.

 

Here's a summary of the 2A cases in the circuit courts:

 

http://www.comm2a.org/index.php/41-projects/current-projects/148-rtc-leaderboard

Mark my words.

 

I will for NJ but not for MD. 

 

MD won't get it unless it goes to SCOTUS or they have a brand new case. 

 

So MD is out for now unless they do it through legislation. 

 

I will for NJ but not for MD. 

 

 

 

Then you learned nothing! Everybody knows about NJ :)

 You ARE aware that Neither Heller OR MCDonald had ANYTHING to do with CCW right?  Both cases had to do with all but complete BANS, and neither case addressed anything more than the ability to possess a handgun in your home.  Heller DOES apply to NJ, but Heller doesnt have a DAMNED thing to do with CCW.

My point to the OP wasn't that Heller applies to CCW. He bought up using the individual right argument. This should apply to NJ.

My point to the OP wasn't that Heller applies to CCW. He bought up using the individual right argument. This should apply to NJ.

 

Heller is about the right to keep and bear arms inside the home in Federal enclaves (eg. DC). McDonald v Chicago was about whether it applied to the states.

 

The question left open was whether that applies outside of the home. That was not answered in Heller or McDonald. 

 

Moore v Madigan (the Illinois case) was where they found that it extended outside the home but that is a circuit case and it struck down a total ban like Illinois.

 

Discretionary issue is tricky because Maryland doesn't have de-facto no issue like NJ.

 

If you carry around a lot of cash or checks (business currency) you can get a carry permit in MD. 

You can also carry around long guns in MD. This was in the orals but not in the written decision.

 

But NJ is a different animal entirely. NJ says that we have discretionary may issue when in reality we have almost no issue. This was one of the key questions heard in the orals and why Judge Stark asked how many outside of LEO are issued and why supplemental briefs showing stats were filed. 

 

Absent judicial activism I think we have a good case against NJ. But in reality I think we'll lose 2-1. 

I want to see us win in NJ and MD to lose - that's typically when the Supremes will step in, when there's conflicting decisions between circuit courts.

 

Hey, it could happen, right?  I mean the moon is made of green cheese right???

 

Right?

 

Why are you still laughing?

 

Seriously!

 

Enough now!!

I'll set IL on fire to get jersey.

 

But it doesn't work that way. Jersey never, MD next. Hawaii who cares. That covers all of three.

Mipafox, how many times do I have to tell you that MD lost all of their appeals except for SCOTUS? You really don't know how it works, do you?

 

Let me spell it out for you. The next stop for MD is the SCOTUS and the decision there applies to all the states. Period.

 

Mipafox, how many times do I have to tell you that MD lost all of their appeals except for SCOTUS? You really don't know how it works, do you?

 

Let me spell it out for you. The next stop for MD is the SCOTUS and the decision there applies to all the states. Period.

 

 

At what point will you realize that it is not a matter of mental deficiency or lack of information on my end, but a matter of fact that not every single internet person is necessarily worth my time and I have better awareness? Goodness gracious, you are riding me like a tick. Trust me, I am not in dire need of your enlightenment.

 

You are focusing on a single aspect of a single example of a single linear process in a single venue.

It's actually pretty clear from Heller and McDonald that the 2A applies outside the home even though that wasn't at issue in the case.  They mention carry in conjunction with the 2A right in one spot, and then there is the language about restricting carry in "sensitive place" which strongly implies that the 2A applies in non-sensitive places and that an outright ban on carry -- which is what NJ de facto has even if the statue appears to grant the right -- is unconstitutional.  Read Gura's appellate briefs -- it's all spelled out quite clearly.  More importantly, at least 2 of the 3 3rd circuit judge came out and openly said during oral arguments that the 2A applies outside the home.  Unless they backtrack in their opinion, it appears that the only issue is whether NJ's statute fails under intermediate scrutiny.  I think we have a 50/50 chance of winning at the 3rd circuit.  I'm not holding my breathe, but oh man it would be great to see the sh*t storm that hits this state if the NJ carry statute is ruled unconstitutional and the legislature is forced to put a law in place like Illinois.

Just the idea that a court would apply intermediate scrutiny to a constitutional right is not a good sign.  Intermediate scrutiny requires that the state demonstrate that the current law furthers an important interest of the state. By deciding to use intermediate scrutiny the court is saying that it's okay to violate a right, as long as doing so furthers the states interests.  That alone is a big, big loss no matter what decision is finally made.

It's actually pretty clear from Heller and McDonald that the 2A applies outside the home even though that wasn't at issue in the case.  They mention carry in conjunction with the 2A right in one spot, and then there is the language about restricting carry in "sensitive place" which strongly implies that the 2A applies in non-sensitive places and that an outright ban on carry -- which is what NJ de facto has even if the statue appears to grant the right -- is unconstitutional.  Read Gura's appellate briefs -- it's all spelled out quite clearly.  More importantly, at least 2 of the 3 3rd circuit judge came out and openly said during oral arguments that the 2A applies outside the home.  Unless they backtrack in their opinion, it appears that the only issue is whether NJ's statute fails under intermediate scrutiny.  I think we have a 50/50 chance of winning at the 3rd circuit.  I'm not holding my breathe, but oh man it would be great to see the sh*t storm that hits this state if the NJ carry statute is ruled unconstitutional and the legislature is forced to put a law in place like Illinois.

I wish you were right, but in the majority opinion for Heller, they explicitly stated that the decision applied in the home and wasn't meant to be interpreted for outside of the home.

 

When Scalia said "gun control is coming to the SC," I hope and suspect he meant that they'll hear a CCW case in the near future.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.