Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Herman Cain is anpther guy I would never vote for (2A related)

Featured Replies

My link

 

He is way off the reservation. He says

a)he supports 2a

b)the federal govt shall not make any laws infringing the right

but then

3) its a state issue and they should be able to make laws and restrictions. The entire northeast would be screwed.

 

Cain out for 2A

Mit out on Romney care

Pawlenty out for supporting Cap and Trade

Newt out for believing the global warming hoaz and calling for action

 

These are my litmus tests, I hope Perry runs, I need someone to vote for.

From a Federalist standpoint Cain is ABSOLUTELY CORRECT..It's not the job of the POTUS to make state laws, as logn as he supports the 2A on the Federal level, then he's doing the job correctly. Even the Heller and McDonald cases affirmed the rights of the states to enact Reasonable LEgislation in regards to firearms. The fight NOW, is to determine the bounds of what is "Reasonable".

  • Author

From a Federalist standpoint Cain is ABSOLUTELY CORRECT..It's not the job of the POTUS to make state laws, as logn as he supports the 2A on the Federal level, then he's doing the job correctly. Even the Heller and McDonald cases affirmed the rights of the states to enact Reasonable LEgislation in regards to firearms. The fight NOW, is to determine the bounds of what is "Reasonable".

 

I would want to make sure he agrees the 2a applies to the states and that he would req laws to be narrowly tailored.

 

"reasonable" is very amorphous and I dont trust my local legislature a lick. If something is reasonable, more than 51% of the legislature would have to agree to it, as it woud be obvious. How about a 75% supermajority requirement on gun laws and tax raises.

BCeagle - you really don't understand the concept of state's rights do you? Which do you think is easier, getting 50 states to agree on something or getting the US Senate and House to agree on something?

 

In the case of NJ we often feel that state's rights sucks. HOWEVER, state's rights is what allows different states to have different laws. The point of having a Union of States was so that you COULD go to another state where you felt the laws were more advantageous to you.

 

What you are advocating is actually putting even more power in the hands of even fewer people. It seems great when you are for the idea they are pitching - it sucks wind when you are against an idea. Case in point - federal assault weapons ban... Which would be better, NJ disallowing mags over 15 rounds or the federal government disallowing mags over 15 rounds? (certainly, neither is better, but if I have to pick one, then it's NJ disallowing - I can move to nearly any other state where it's not an issue).

 

IMO - you are way off base on Cain, but you are entitled to your opinion, however misguided it may be.

  • Author

Actually, I get it more than most and I am really insulted by the comment. I would wager I know more about it than you. Maybe you dont get what I am saying.

 

I am fine with the state making the individuals laws for each state, but you need the federal govt to extend the 2A to all states. We are screwed in NJ without the federal govt and Supreme Court putting some limits on the state. If it wasnt for federal protections NJ probably would have outlawed all firearms if they could. You can't just expect people to move from state to state to have their civil rights protected. You dont need 50 state to agree on something you just need one state to take away the rights of their citizenry. In NJ w/OGAM we were at the mercy of one party.

 

Cain just abdicating to the states is a cop out. He should have came out and said I support the 2A, GAO and NRA, I oppose additional laws at the federal level, I oppose the AWB etc. I liked the guy when he 1st started but I have seen him in enough interviews to know he doesnt have a plan and is only into sound bites. He has not specifically addressed gun show loopholes, the Protection in Lawful Commerce Act, or other specific gun laws. His website does not even have a section to address 2A. I dont need a vague guy.

Being from the recent mindset of F-it I'm trying to get out of Jersey, perhaps I've come at it a bit strong.

 

In any case, it's currently a states rights issue until it's not. I can expect people to move from state to state for various reasons. FL currently has a net loss of population for the first time in (I think) two decades. Should we just be one country with one set of laws from sea to shining sea? It's a stretch to say that NJ is being limited by the Supreme court or the federal government - they still don't recognize Heller nevermind McDonald...

 

I'm glad you're really insulted - it means we're having a good discussion instead of just having some pablum on an internet forum. :icon_rolleyes:

 

 

By the way - who are you currently impressed with? Right now, I don't see any winners emerging so, it may all be a moot point.

From a Federalist standpoint Cain is ABSOLUTELY CORRECT..It's not the job of the POTUS to make state laws, as logn as he supports the 2A on the Federal level, then he's doing the job correctly. Even the Heller and McDonald cases affirmed the rights of the states to enact Reasonable LEgislation in regards to firearms. The fight NOW, is to determine the bounds of what is "Reasonable".

 

The term "reasonable legislation" (or "reasonable regulations," etc.) does not appear in Heller. "Reasonable... regulations" does appear in McDonald, but not in the holding. It only appears in dicta as a reference to an amicus brief while shooting down (no pun intended) the defendant's assertion that the Second Amendment should not be incorporated, or should be only partially incorporated so that states could still have "reasonable regulations." This method was thoroughly and completely rejected. The closest that Heller and McDonald come to saying anything about "reasonable legislation" is as follows (from McDonald):

 

It is important to keep in mind that Heller, while striking down a law that prohibited the possession of handguns in the home, recognized that the right to keep and bear arms is not “a right to keep and carry any weapon whatsoever in any manner whatsoever and for whatever purpose.” 554 U. S., at ___ (slip op., at 54). We made it clear in Heller that our holding did not cast doubt on such longstanding regulatory measures as “prohibitions on the possession of firearms by felons and the mentally ill,” “laws forbidding the carrying of firearms in sensitive places such as schools and gov-ernment buildings, or laws imposing conditions and qualifications on the commercial sale of arms.” Id., at ___–___ (slip op., at 54–55). We repeat those assurances here.Despite municipal respondents’ doomsday proclamations, incorporation does not imperil every law regulating firearms.

 

What's more important is the following quote from Heller:

Putting all of these textual elements together, we find that they guarantee the individual right to possess and carry weapons in case of confrontation.

 

The "reasonable legislation" or "reasonable regulation" assertion appears nowhere in Heller, yet we hear it all the time. The latter quote... not so much, yet it says so much more about the decision.

 

It would serve us all well if we would stop using the term "reasonable" since it is not a term used in either decision to describe the allowable legislation and it is not a legal standard. And we should immediately and vigorously point out to anyone who claims such a thing that it is patently false and point out the actual quotes, which are irrefutable.

 

Whenever someone tells me that Heller says we can have reasonable legislation, I ask them what page of the decision that's on. That usually ends the debate, because it doesn't exist.

 

The term "reasonable legislation" (or "reasonable regulations," etc.) does not appear in Heller. "Reasonable... regulations" does appear in McDonald, but not in the holding. It only appears in dicta as a reference to an amicus brief while shooting down (no pun intended) the defendant's assertion that the Second Amendment should not be incorporated, or should be only partially incorporated so that states could still have "reasonable regulations." This method was thoroughly and completely rejected. The closest that Heller and McDonald come to saying anything about "reasonable legislation" is as follows (from McDonald):

 

 

 

What's more important is the following quote from Heller:

 

 

The "reasonable legislation" or "reasonable regulation" assertion appears nowhere in Heller, yet we hear it all the time. The latter quote... not so much, yet it says so much more about the decision.

 

It would serve us all well if we would stop using the term "reasonable" since it is not a term used in either decision to describe the allowable legislation and it is not a legal standard. And we should immediately and vigorously point out to anyone who claims such a thing that it is patently false and point out the actual quotes, which are irrefutable.

 

Whenever someone tells me that Heller says we can have reasonable legislation, I ask them what page of the decision that's on. That usually ends the debate, because it doesn't exist.

 

That EXACT wording was used during the verbal discussions by Chief Justice Roberts as well as by Justice Alito. While it doesnt appear in the written decision, that verbiage was brought up by several parties during the argument, and it WILL come up as each new case is brought before SCOTUS. Also the term "Reoasonable" is used heavily in the way Laws and Policies are written, so the term is not inconsistent.

That EXACT wording was used during the verbal discussions by Chief Justice Roberts as well as by Justice Alito. While it doesnt appear in the written decision, that verbiage was brought up by several parties during the argument, and it WILL come up as each new case is brought before SCOTUS. Also the term "Reoasonable" is used heavily in the way Laws and Policies are written, so the term is not inconsistent.

 

 

You have fallen for a ruse, a switch. Paul Helmke, and others, have taken "if the right is not infringed, then the law is reasonable" (a result, not a test) and have substituted "if the law is reasonable, then the right is not infringed" (a standard which does not exist). I remember the discussion that you speak of. The defendant asserted the former and then I think it was Alito that said, "I wouldn't say it that way. If the right is not infringed, then the law is reasonable." He was refuting the concept. But, the point is that, even though they discussed it in oral arguments, the concept never made it into the decision. "Reasonable" implies a balancing test, which was completely rejected. Balancing tests are not used on any fundamental right and "reasonable" is not a legal standard and cannot be legitimately applied to a fundamental right.

 

Heller does not say that reasonable regulations are acceptable, anywhere. McDonald does the opposite by making the point that reasonable regulations may, and often do, violate fundamental rights and gives DC's handgun ban as an example of what a particular locality may consider reasonable. The point of establishing a right as fundamental is precisely so that legislators cannot infringe upon them under the guise of being reasonable. It is to take away the balancing test altogether.

 

As you engage someone who believes in reasonable gun regulations, it is important to utterly and completely destroy the notion altogether that the term "reasonable" as a legal standard can be applied in any way, shape or form to a fundamental right. There is no battle to determine what is reasonable or not reasonable as reasonable is not and will never be the standard. The question will never be, "is this law reasonable?" The question will be, "does this law infringe upon the right based upon a particular standard of scrutiny?"

 

The notion that either Heller or McDonald allow reasonable gun legislation is preposterous. They both reject the concept altogether, and that is what we must keep stating and restating if we are going to counter the misinformation that is put out there by those who want "reasonableness" to be the standard.

Arguing whether regulation of the 2nd amendment belongs to the Federal or State governments is like arguing which criminal owns stolen property. May I remind you that Heller confirmed with crystal clear certainty that the 2A protects the individual's right.

 

And before anyone takes this "reasonable regulation" concept one step further, I urge you to watch the videos of Daniel Schmutter at the NJ2AS meeting over here on the NJ2AS site. Schmutter does a great job highlighting the absurdity of the term 'reasonable" when talking about a constitutionally protected right belonging to the people. Imagine talking about 'reasonable' regulations on what newspapers can write or what religion you can practice. It's purely a distraction by people who don't want you to have the right in the first place.

who are you currently impressed with?

 

Mike Huckabee, but he ain't runnin

  • Author

From CNN

Herman Cain

 

Cain follows the Republican party line and supports a citizen’s right to bear arms. Only not so much and not so well. In an interview with CNN (above), Cain turned his back on the Supreme Court’s McDonald decision incorporating the Second Amendment (make it trump local and state law). “[Gun control] should be a state’s decision.” Backpedalling and post-gaffe candidate briefing to follow.

From CNN

Herman Cain

 

Cain follows the Republican party line and supports a citizen’s right to bear arms. Only not so much and not so well. In an interview with CNN (above), Cain turned his back on the Supreme Court’s McDonald decision incorporating the Second Amendment (make it trump local and state law). “[Gun control] should be a state’s decision.” Backpedalling and post-gaffe candidate briefing to follow.

 

Link please? And CNN is doing anything they can to steer the primary to one of the unelectables, ie Romney, Gingrich, etc. Sorry BC - I want to fact check the sources, I don't trust any of the media.

  • Author

 

I'm glad you're really insulted - it means we're having a good discussion instead of just having some pablum on an internet forum. :icon_rolleyes:

 

 

 

Thanks, glad to know.

 

I would love Ron Paul to win. I think he is the man, and everyone who takes the time to listen to him tends to like him. Unfortunatly he wont win. I have hopes for his son one day.

I would love Ron Paul to win. I think he is the man, and everyone who takes the time to listen to him tends to like him. Unfortunatly he wont win. I have hopes for his son one day.

 

Ron Paul is about 3.14% too libertarian to win, on top of it, he looks decrepit and not lively. Rand Paul on the other hand - there's a chance, a real chance for that guy.

  • Author

Ron Paul is about 3.14% too libertarian to win, on top of it, he looks decrepit and not lively. Rand Paul on the other hand - there's a chance, a real chance for that guy.

 

I think the media took the best shot they could to portray Rand as a whacko when he ran for Senate. It was obvious they were against him, now that he made it this far any dope has a chance to make the white house (looks whos there now)

 

 

I am fine with the state making the individuals laws for each state, but you need the federal govt to extend the 2A to all states. We are screwed in NJ without the federal govt and Supreme Court putting some limits on the state. If it wasnt for federal protections NJ probably would have outlawed all firearms if they could. You can't just expect people to move from state to state to have their civil rights protected. You dont need 50 state to agree on something you just need one state to take away the rights of their citizenry. In NJ w/OGAM we were at the mercy of one party.

 

 

 

I thought we had an Amendment (the 10th) that was there to limit the powers of the federal government, not give them more powers over the states? But then again, it talks about things not in the constitution are reserved by the states, and the thing about bearing arms is in fact in the constitution. So what actually gives either (the federal government or state governments) the power to infringe on our right to keep and bear arms?

 

The federal government 'shouldn't' have to "extend" the 2nd amendment to all states. To bad things didn't work out as intended.

 

After watching part of the NH GOP debate (or whatever it was called), I am quite disappointed and almost ashamed. It seemed like some of the candidates just wanted to talk about themselves (me me me me me). Some had a hard time following simple instructions. Some completely avoided the question to say something else. Almost none of them even tried to keep it somewhat short. I'd be tempted to vote for Cain just because politicians ALWAYS push a personal agenda despite what would actually be better for the country as a whole.

Mike Huckabee, but he ain't runnin

 

I knew there was a reason I liked you..

 

I worked for Mike Huckabee's 2008 campaign in FL, got to meet him personally and talk with him for a while at a fundraiser in Tampa. He is the real deal, and I'm royally pissed that he bowed out this go 'round. He would have beat Obozo in a landslide..

I knew there was a reason I liked you..

 

I worked for Mike Huckabee's 2008 campaign in FL, got to meet him personally and talk with him for a while at a fundraiser in Tampa. He is the real deal, and I'm royally pissed that he bowed out this go 'round. He would have beat Obozo in a landslide..

 

Then that's a total of 2 votes he'd get in Bayonne. Not much more though, this is a "D" town and county. Idiots

Huckabee clearly had some shenanigans going on during the last primary and as a result Mc Cain got the nomination. IMO part of the reason we have Obummer now is because of the shenanigans Huckabee pulled in order to get McCain...

 

http://conservativesamizdat.blogspot.com/2011/04/mike-huckabee-did-collaborate-with-john.html

http://hoosieraccess.com/2008/02/05/romney-declares-shenanigans/

 

So - as far as I'm concerned I'm quite glad he's not running. He's shown before that he can be bought for a price IMO.

I thought we had an Amendment (the 10th) that was there to limit the powers of the federal government, not give them more powers over the states? But then again, it talks about things not in the constitution are reserved by the states, and the thing about bearing arms is in fact in the constitution. So what actually gives either (the federal government or state governments) the power to infringe on our right to keep and bear arms?

 

The federal government 'shouldn't' have to "extend" the 2nd amendment to all states. To bad things didn't work out as intended.

 

After watching part of the NH GOP debate (or whatever it was called), I am quite disappointed and almost ashamed. It seemed like some of the candidates just wanted to talk about themselves (me me me me me). Some had a hard time following simple instructions. Some completely avoided the question to say something else. Almost none of them even tried to keep it somewhat short. I'd be tempted to vote for Cain just because politicians ALWAYS push a personal agenda despite what would actually be better for the country as a whole.

 

The Federal Govt shouldn't have had to extend the 1st, 4th, 5th, 6th, and 8th ammendments either..but through corruption, ineptmness and other issues, Individual states violated those provisions eggregiously enough that SCOTUS felt the need to setp in, as they did with McDonald. Again, Heller and McDonald ONLY Addressed the Total Bans that existed in DC and Chicago, and no other provisions of Gun Control Laws. This is a long, slow involved process..Chess, rather than Checkers. SAF and Gura have a well-thought out plan, and specific goals to be met, but even they say it's a years (Maybe decades) long process. We did not get this way overnight, it took the better part of 6 decades to get here, we are not going to reverse it instantly.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.