Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Mountainside Judge dismisses DWI against NJSP trooper

Featured Replies

http://www.nj.com/news/index.ssf/2011/08/judge_dismisses_drunk_driving.html

 

The police and judiciary don't do themselves any favors with this crap. Letting bad apples slip through the system hurts the moral capital of the good officers who simply want to do their job and serve the community/state.

 

While he is facing some internal punishments, they will be undoubtedly less harsh than if any of us civvies were caught and charged for the same reasons.

 

Like you and me, but better... right?

Before this gets into a cop bashing thread, there are many, many, many cases where non-LEO DUI arrestees have gotten off. Will THEIR jobs be in jeopardy? Not saying either way whether it is right or not, it is what it is. This officer will be punished far worse than any non-LEO will ever be.

  • Author

Before this gets into a cop bashing thread, there are many, many, many cases where non-LEO DUI arrestees have gotten off. Will THEIR jobs be in jeopardy? Not saying either way whether it is right or not, it is what it is. This officer will be punished far worse than any non-LEO will ever be.

 

As he should be. Given the expense of his salary, pension, equipment, privileges, and the fact that he is not only knowledgeable of the law, but should also be an example of it, he should not only have the book thrown at him, but be barred from any and all forms of civil service.

 

These cops shouldn't be coddled, they should be punished in a manner far worse than you or I. Especially since they are abusing the authority the public entrusts in them. Not doing this simply diminishes the moral capital held by the state and hurts their claim to the authority entrusted to them. In the end, even the appearance of letting him off easily is a net-loss for the public good.

Except alcohol and drug problems aren't treated as actual irresponsible acts for LEO's....they're treated as personal problems. Rather than simply kick them off the force, the attempt is made to rehabilitate the person. Everyone deserves a second chance right? If someone has a legitimate problem, I see no issue with trying to help them get past it.

  • Author

Except alcohol and drug problems aren't treated as actual irresponsible acts for LEO's....they're treated as personal problems. Rather than simply kick them off the force, the attempt is made to rehabilitate the person. Everyone deserves a second chance right? If someone has a legitimate problem, I see no issue with trying to help them get past it.

 

Aw. How cute.

 

Do you get a 2nd chance when you get a DUI? Do I? "Oh, I'm sorry your honor! I didn't mean to hit a car and run away while under the influence! I'll pinky swear to not do it again!"

 

Whatever happened to holding these pukes to a higher standard eh? These guys ARE NOT ABOVE THE LAW. They should be punished more severely than you or I would given their positions of authority and power.

They should be punished more severely than you or I would given their positions of authority and power.

Okay so let me get this straight.....you think that because it is their job to know and uphold the law, they should be punished more severely? So by that logic, someone who is sheltered and ignorant of the law should be given a slap on the wrist? You're dictating how severe the punishment should be based on the actors standing in society. That's COMPLETELY stupid.

  • Author

Okay so let me get this straight.....you think that because it is their job to know and uphold the law, they should be punished more severely? So by that logic, someone who is sheltered and ignorant of the law should be given a slap on the wrist? You're dictating how severe the punishment should be based on the actors standing in society. That's COMPLETELY stupid.

 

Yes. Not only is there job to uphold the law, but to be an example of it. As police officers, they are given quite a bit of treasure and authority to carry out their duties. With that authority comes a certain responsibility as they are given the public's trust. If that trust is broken though, then the punishments must be severe to restore that trust.

 

As for those who are supposedly sheltered and ignorant, they would be punished just like any other citizen. I never said regular people should get off with a slap on the wrist, but that police be punished more severely. I don't know who taught you reading comprehension to misconstrue what I said into anything other than that.

 

Remember: they serve us, not the other way around.

Yes. Not only is there job to uphold the law, but to be an example of it. As police officers, they are given quite a bit of treasure and authority to carry out their duties. With that authority comes a certain responsibility as they are given the public's trust. If that trust is broken though, then the punishments must be severe to restore that trust.

 

As for those who are supposedly sheltered and ignorant, they would be punished just like any other citizen. I never said regular people should get off with a slap on the wrist, but that police be punished more severely. I don't know who taught you reading comprehension to misconstrue what I said into anything other than that.

 

Remember: they serve us, not the other way around.

My reading comprehension is just fine. What you were saying implied that one's knowledge and standing with the law should dictate their severity of punishment when they break the law. That's not reading comprehension, that's more like implication comprehension.

 

I also have to disagree with what you're saying. What an officer does while on duty, and off duty, are two separate things. If a police officer is found driving while intoxicated while off duty, then it should be treated as if I were found driving intoxicated. Their job should not be in jeopardy for what they do in their personal lives, just like mine shouldn't be. I'm not saying that a police officer should simply receive a slap on the wrist......however they also should not receive anything more than a regular civilian would.

Cops should not be held to a stricter standard but should be punished. I think the treatment cops get are because of the union and every group shows favoritism towards fellow members. Try to get a union worker in most professions fired and see how hard it is to accomplish.

  • Author

My reading comprehension is just fine. What you were saying implied that one's knowledge and standing with the law should dictate their severity of punishment when they break the law. That's not reading comprehension, that's more like implication comprehension.

 

Nope, one's authority within the law is what matters. Those responsible in carrying out the duties required in our system of law and order have no excuses to break the law whether in uniform or out of uniform.

 

I also have to disagree with what you're saying. What an officer does while on duty, and off duty, are two separate things. If a police officer is found driving while intoxicated while off duty, then it should be treated as if I were found driving intoxicated. Their job should not be in jeopardy for what they do in their personal lives, just like mine shouldn't be. I'm not saying that a police officer should simply receive a slap on the wrist......however they also should not receive anything more than a regular civilian would.

 

Then I guess we agree to disagree. Given their positions of authority and their place in our system of law and order, they should serve as examples for the rest of us. If they can't live up to what's expected of them as police officers (on or off duty), then maybe they should be fired or just quit. Increased responsibility should come with increased authority.

 

For example: if a Congressman or Senator cheats on their taxes, they should face jail time or even harsher punishment then you or I. Especially since they're the ones responsible for levying taxes upon us. Same with the President.

 

It's called moral capital, and it's just as important as the money sitting in the nations' treasury.

Ok this has gotten into a little battle but not a bashing thread, at least not to the extent that it is disruptive.

 

While some say the anyone in law enforcement should be held to a higher standard, well I do feel that the LEO personally should hold themselves to a higher standard, I do not think we need 2 sets of punishments for LEO vs non-LEO.

 

Like a coin, there are 2 sides and somewhere in the middle is the truth in most cases. Now before any of us post a bash or a strong comment lets really look in the mirror first and be realistic. Now as far as drinking is concerned, well lets be real, I'd bet at one time or another if you have ever had a drink, I'd bet if stopped you could have been jammed up and your life changed and many of the things we do and take for granted changed.

 

Just remember how many time you have sat down and had 1 beer and thats all, for a lot of people in the lower weight bracket 2 may put you over the limit, 3 and you could be toast in the eyes of the law in regards to BAC levels. Not condoning anything, just pointing out that there may be a lot of kettles calling the pot black here.

 

Harry

My humble opinion is that anyone working in LE MUST be held to a higher standard. I submit that the system its self believes this to be true. What other job has you go through extensive background checks and a psychological panel? Among the obvious reasons there are also fundamental reasons as well. Lets use a prosecuter for example. Prosecuter Jones is a crack addict. He has been found to be high as a kite. It was also learned that to support his habbit, he would let people off for a bribe. To keep appearences and convictions up it was also learned that he manufactured evidence against those that didnt pay. Now, even the case that was not tainted in any way has a great risk of being overturned because he was the prosecuter. So the rapist or murderer that belongs in prison may now go free. In my mind its the risk for this greater damage because of the position your in that drives the higher standard. Think about it. The DUI penalties are different for a CDL holder. So even truck drivers are held to a higher standard and suffer greater penalties even if they arent operating a commercial vehicle at the time of the DUI.

  • Author

Ok this has gotten into a little battle but not a bashing thread, at least not to the extent that it is disruptive.

 

While some say the anyone in law enforcement should be held to a higher standard, well I do feel that the LEO personally should hold themselves to a higher standard, I do not think we need 2 sets of punishments for LEO vs non-LEO.

 

Like a coin, there are 2 sides and somewhere in the middle is the truth in most cases. Now before any of us post a bash or a strong comment lets really look in the mirror first and be realistic. Now as far as drinking is concerned, well lets be real, I'd bet at one time or another if you have ever had a drink, I'd bet if stopped you could have been jammed up and your life changed and many of the things we do and take for granted changed.

 

Just remember how many time you have sat down and had 1 beer and thats all, for a lot of people in the lower weight bracket 2 may put you over the limit, 3 and you could be toast in the eyes of the law in regards to BAC levels. Not condoning anything, just pointing out that there may be a lot of kettles calling the pot black here.

Harry

 

Except us "little people" aren't in charge of enforcing the law. And we're most definitely not immune from it. The difference is: when a cop drinks and drives, it hurts the public trust in the institution of law and order. Regardless if he was on duty or off, the justice system needs to retain the moral high ground and hold those responsible for enforcing the law to a higher standard than the rest of us.

 

How often do we see this? A cop driving drunk, abusing steroids, losing their gun, or acting above the law? How often do we see these guys commit crimes that would royally hurt you or I, but they are only given a slap on the wrist? How often does that shake the public trust in their institution?

 

The system needs to be corrected.

Devs normally I agree with you. But on this you are wrong. The Constitution does not allow for separate classes and if you punish one class over another that is what you create.

 

Our Constitution and the Amendments were about limiting government powers especially the federal government.

 

LEO is a profession not a "Different group held to a higher standard". No different than other professions such as doctors, scientists, journalists, etc. So lets say a doctor is performing illegal surgical procedures and is convicted do we hold him to a "higher standard'? Where will it end?

I'm not trying to justify the situation. By all means, drinking and driving is wrong.....no matter who does it.

 

Then I guess we agree to disagree.

I'm fine with that.

Wolfy, your dreaming. The world just doesnt work this way. Society simply wont accept porn stars for grade school teachers, criminals for cops, sexual predators for Gynocoligists, crack heads for judges, NO the only public profesion that does is Politicien LOL.

Shane I did not say I accepted it. I said we should not charge any group with a different set of standards. You are charged because of the crime not what you do.

I said we should not charge any group with a different set of standards. You are charged because of the crime not what you do.

/thread

But there ARE different standards. Your dreaming if you think differently. Look at the CDL example. A truck driver gets 2 DUI's in his own vehicle, not while working. He looses his CDL for life I believe. THIS IS A DIFFERENT STANDARD. You think that a Judge who Judges for a living should not be held to a higher standard for showing bad judgement and breaking the law? You do not see the greater capacity for damage to society because of the responsibility he holds? If you really want to talk about different standards, think about everyone who serves in the Military. Not only do you recieve the punishment from wherever out in the civy community you had an infraction, you will also face military diciplinary action which is almost always harsher including loss of pay, rank etc etc. Again, a higher standard.

  • Author

Devs normally I agree with you. But on this you are wrong. The Constitution does not allow for separate classes and if you punish one class over another that is what you create.

 

It doesn't allow it on grounds of gender, race, or creed. But there is no limitation on punishing folks who hold offices and position of authority. Unless you'd like to point out where in the Constitution that specifically protects against that.

 

Our Constitution and the Amendments were about limiting government powers especially the federal government.

 

No argument there. This also means under the 10th Amendment, the states can also punish LEOs and politicians as they see fit. But then again, even on the Federal Level, there is no limitation on punishing someone given their office.

 

LEO is a profession not a "Different group held to a higher standard". No different than other professions such as doctors, scientists, journalists, etc. So lets say a doctor is performing illegal surgical procedures and is convicted do we hold him to a "higher standard'? Where will it end?

 

Umm, yes.

 

Why wouldn't we? Especially if he was a supposedly trained "professional", why wouldn't we make an example of him. If not to punish him, but to restore public trust in his profession.

 

People need to be accountable for their actions and need to be responsible for the given level of authority they have. Maybe if we had a system which punished those who abused the power bestowed upon them, we would have more honest people in positions of power, and not the dregs we see in uniform and in political office.

Before this gets into a cop bashing thread, there are many, many, many cases where non-LEO DUI arrestees have gotten off. Will THEIR jobs be in jeopardy? Not saying either way whether it is right or not, it is what it is. This officer will be punished far worse than any non-LEO will ever be.

 

In this case, I don't think favoritism was involved. I think they got off on a technicality anyone with a decent lawyer could have gotten off on by calling the stop into question and thus getting evidence thrown out. However, I'm not seeing the case where officers ever get punished far worse than any non-LEO. In fact I have never, EVER seen such a thing. I'd be glad to see an example. At best, they get convicted of the same crime anyone else would, and MAYBE get a sentence in line with a particularly remorseless criminal. For the most part they get a much lighter charge, if any, and lose their job.

 

 

being a cop and getting a DWI must suck big time... what is it like to go to work after that....

 

I'm guessing nothing that would amount to anything more than existing in an annoying workplace till their coworkers got bored of mocking them for getting caught. Beyond that, probably being on the bosses **** list for while, thus requiring the officer to suffer having to actually obey the law and be well behaved for a while. Probably also have to hear it brought up any time their behavior is questioned in the future.

I'm just gonna say this, i know of 3 incidents personally where a Drunk LEO crashed into one of my friends and was told to just leave.... no statements, no nothing, one of them actually put one of my friends in the hospital the accident was that bad. One of them wrote down in the report the female passenger, who was also drunk, was driving and not the male LEO. So i'm actually quite surprised they even charged this guy.

 

Am i for holding them to higher standards, absolutely not, but i am for holding them to the same standard like every other SOB.

 

Now, there isnt a whole lot of info about exactly what happened here, how did the responding officers to the accident not realize he was drunk? did they tell him to just leave? did the guy who got hit smell something funky going on and called in a hit and run? He didn't run from the accident, yet he was pulled over later that night for one reason or the other... He was charged with a dui, he was probably drunk if they brought him to court for it, and i understand taking the stance that it was an uwarranted stop, but to come out and just say he wasnt drunk is B.S., just come out and say you beat the system.

 

Now, i dont want to come off as bashing LEO, but there is truth and reality to what i have said.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.