Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

The "Center Mass" myth and ending a gunfight

Featured Replies

Maybe its just me and Im grumpier than usual today, but the article strikes me as stating the obvious and putting a little creative interpretation in there. I guess what Im trying to say is that I dont need anyone to tell me to keep shooting the threat if he continues to be a threat. I guess I would like to think that anyone that has a firearm for defence or offence for that matter intrinsically knows this. I think he is trying to pigeon hole concepts into absolutes. I havent come across any trainers speaking in absolutes. I have never heard any of them say if you hit BG in CM with X he will go down for sure. About the only shot I know of that gives this guaruntee is the apricot shot. But that is a highly unlikely shot and so we focus on something that has a higher probability of actually hapening and thats a CM hit. This is why I have no problem with 9mm actually. I want as many chances with a reasonably effective cartridge to hit something vital.

 

At any rate thanks for sharing the article.

the article strikes me as stating the obvious and putting a little creative interpretation in there. I guess what Im trying to say is that I dont need anyone to tell me to keep shooting the threat if he continues to be a threat. I guess I would like to think that anyone that has a firearm for defense or offense for that matter intrinsically knows this.

I would like to think that this is obvious but unfortunately many do not see things that way.

 

I have seen a poster on here say that if anyone broke into his house he feels that he is a good shot and will just shoot the intruder in the leg to stop him.

 

I also see many people exclusively practice a predetermined threat response that they assume will end a fight, such as 2 rounds to a predetermined zone on the target.

 

Where I disagree with the author is his assumptions near the end of the article where he states how many rounds may be needed based on caliber. I would rather the simple concept of just keep shooting until the threat is stopped.

Joel, I think your right. There is so much pre programing of notions from so many different scources (probably mostly tv) that it may indeed be an issue that what should be obvious no longer is due to the muddying of the waters so to speak... It does seem to counter his own point to place a potential number of rounds reletive to the caliber for effectiveness thus perpetuating the notion there is such a thing.

There was an interesting article on ChuckHawks written by a vetted member of Delta about a similar topic. He basically said that the old doctrine of 2 to the chest and 1 to the head was outdated (obviously). The current rational (according to him) was if you're getting 1 bullet, I'm giving you 2 bullets, and if I giving you 3 bullets I'm give you a fourth. AKA shoot until the threat is no longer just that. The author mentioned that the application of this idea helped to bring about the switch from 2011's to Glocks.

 

With regards to the article posted, my feeling is that if in a gunfight one follows a set course of action and waits for the results, they're already lost. The dynamic, creative, and adaptive mind is the one likely to emerge the victor.

I sort of share some of Joelk & Shane's thoughts. Two other things stood out to me with the 'number of hits' section.

 

1) "We tell our military folks to be prepared to hit an enemy fighter from 3-7 times with 5.56 ball, traveling at over 3,000 feet per second...."

 

Is that actually true? I'm skeptical

 

2) "With handguns, and with expanding bullets, it is even more unpredictable, but through years of study I have developed a general formula, subject to the above mentioned unpredictable circumstances."

 

"2-3 hits with a .45

4-6 with a .40

5-8 with a 9mm "

 

"With a revolver, the rounds are not necessarily more effective but I would practice shooting 3 in a .38 or .357 merely because I want 3 left for other threats. Not that those next three won’t follow quickly if the target hasn’t changed shape around my front sight blade. A .41, .44 or .45 Colt I would probably drop to two. Once again, they are not that much more effective than a .45 Auto but I don’t have the bullets to waste."

 

I feel like he's using the word "formula" because he thinks it'll make his advice seem more credible, but the figures he's sharing don't read like the output of a true formula, so it just makes it seem like he created the 'data' as opposed to discovering it through research.

 

Also, deterining how many shots of each caliber is likely to stop a gun fight is a notion he himself has ALREADY discredited by that point in the article.

 

I mean, I'm not calling the guy an idiot, but I just don't know how useful the information he's offering really can be to someone. Are there people with a poor grasp of terminal ballistics that might benefit from some of what's discussed in the article? Sure. Are such people likely to read the article & take it's advice under consideration? Probably not. They're generally ignorant for a reason. While a certain percentage may eventually do some research & come around, I don't see this authors take on the subject as particularly unique or more able to shed light on the subject than any other currently available articles/studies on defensive shooting/ammunition/etc.

 

P.S.: No insult intended to OP for posting article. Just wanted to throw out some thoughts on it.

My best advice came a good few years after I went through BCT when my unit's "BRM/ARM instructor" (of course not an official position, hence the quotations, but he was a combat-exp sniper as well as former member of the Army marksmanship team who was assigned by the BCO to re-train the whole unit in marksmanship) basically told us to throw out everything we knew about marksmanship taught to us prior. When it came to man-sized targets, the most basic and sound advice that still reverberates with me today was "aim small, miss small", which I've noticed is a cliche saying in the shooting community.

He would also share that we, as professional Soldiers, should know the weak points in an opponent, similar to certain martial arts (pressure points, etc), and to focus our conditioning with that mindset.

 

As for the article, it is redundant, but good information. One thing that really stood out for me is when he discussed dynamic training. It's something I know I've said, but for those who depend on a firearm to defend them self, whether concealed or in the home, training should mimic reality. It's neither enough to just have a firearm for your protection, nor is it enough to just shoot at a static target in a static position.

Something about this doesn't click. Of course there are many people with different talking points about defense etc and stress their points in different ways but I feel like he forgot something.

 

You practice on center mass because it is the biggest target, and practicing that is a good practice for when you are absoluelty terrified.

 

Something about talking like you can put one in the brains and skip the center mass is a little too Chuck Norris, if you ask me. And the way I look at it is, hitting the dot in a center of a center mass target is the same as having enough time to shoot a guy in the eyeball and plenty if I wanted to hit a guy a the face. But I am not so full of myself that I think I could do that when someone is shooting back.

 

Center mass is to get hits in a "holy fugg!" fight. That's what I was taught anyway.

For me the point of the article is to not to expect a bad guy to be completely incapacitated from causing me or loved ones further harm after shooting them; also, shooting them more (as much as possible up to the point of keeping a few rounds in reserve for other bad guys) in quick consecutive fashion increases the odds of them NOT being able to continue their aggression.

For me the point of the article is to not to expect a bad guy to be completely incapacitated from causing me or loved ones further harm after shooting them; also, shooting them more (as much as possible up to the point of keeping a few rounds in reserve for other bad guys) in quick consecutive fashion increases the odds of them NOT being able to continue their aggression.

 

I suppose it is at that.

I agree with the premise of the article (center mass is not a guaranteed kill) but in a real gunfight, you have no other choice. It is still best to shoot center mass for one reason, and one reason only...largest surface area. You have the best chance of hitting the guy center mass than if you shoot anywhere else. Hell, dump 3/4 of the mag into him, and one between the eyes since he isn't moving much, but otherwise, aim centermass. Shooting at T11 won't get you very far.

so basically the article said hitting someone anywhere with anything is bad.......and never said where TO aim. he said how many people survived multiple center mass hits, including point blank 357 in the heart.....then said the spine is too hard to hit, and to forget about hitting the head. so where the fyck are you supposed to hit??? all he did was spew out negative comments without ever saying something positive.

 

as far as shooting, do a Mozambique. if his theory holds true so well (doubt it), 2 center mass hits will slow down the attacker enough to line up a headshot.

so basically the article said hitting someone anywhere with anything is bad.......and never said where TO aim. he said how many people survived multiple center mass hits, including point blank 357 in the heart.....then said the spine is too hard to hit, and to forget about hitting the head. so where the fyck are you supposed to hit??? all he did was spew out negative comments without ever saying something positive.

 

as far as shooting, do a Mozambique. if his theory holds true so well (doubt it), 2 center mass hits will slow down the attacker enough to line up a headshot.

 

It's like a Kevin Costner movie or a liberal complaint...talk about whats wrong, lots of noise, lots of drama, but in the end,nothing happens.

  • Author

It's like a Kevin Costner movie or a liberal complaint...talk about whats wrong, lots of noise, lots of drama, but in the end,nothing happens.

 

I thought this and the two comments before it were great!

 

As a relative neophyte shooter, before reading that article I thought that two well-placed COM hits would most likely be enough to stop a threat. What I took from the article is that one needs to keep pumping lead until the threat is neutralized, and that most of the time it will take a lot more than that. Besides, in a real gunfight, I would guess that one can't tell where one's rounds are hitting. I mean it's not like you can look to see where the holes are, like you can with paper. :icon_e_confused:

My only advice on this is what I learned from an old tanker: “Shoot until the target changes shape or catches fire!”

 

 

 

As an old tanker this is how I was trained. Best part of the whole article.

 

 

TC

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.