Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Concealed Carry Reciprocity Advocates Could Get Major Win With New House Bill

Featured Replies

Congressional support is growing for a bill that would force all states to honor concealed carry permits issued in any other state, allowing citizens to take their firearms across state lines.

 

If passed, the National Right-to-Carry Reciprocity Act of 2011 would be a huge win for Second Amendment advocates, giving a gut punch to many state and municipal gun control efforts.

 

Originally introduced this past February by Rep. Cliff Stearns (R- FL) and Heath Shuler (D-NC), The Right-to-Carry Reciprocity Act now has 241 co-sponsors in the House, making its passage there likely.

 

A companion bill is soon to be launched in the Senate, and if it gets enough Democrat support to avoid a filibuster, it would probably pass there too.

 

The bill, H.R. 822, essentially says: If Florida awards you a concealed carry permit, every other state has to honor it, with narrow exceptions. This will greatly lessen “may issue” politics and bureaucratic obstructionism across the country when it comes to gun rights.

 

For those who live in notoriously anti-gun areas like New York City, it appears one would still need a permit from your home state to concealed carry within that state if the bill passes. Individual states will still be allowed to regulate concealed carry permits for their residents.

 

For example, If you live in New York, things could remain complicated. You would need a New York permit to carry concealed in the Empire State. If you received an out-of-state permit from Florida, that permit would allow you to carry any other state in the country, except your home state (New York), Chicago, and D.C., which do not allow for concealed carry under any circumstances.

 

National Carry?

I would be very surprised if this actually passes through, although I would be very happy. I think I should start applying for my FL carry permit...

  • Author

I would be very surprised if this actually passes through, although I would be very happy. I think I should start applying for my FL carry permit...

 

It is very simple and they are turning them around in 2-3 weeks....they are friendly and eager to help. We went to the OBX in July and I carried the entire time I was there....it felt SOOOOO good. In Walmart, stores, beach, etc. At first I felt like I was doing something wrong, then it just felt right after a few days. I miss carrying....I felt like I was walking around with a "back up" plan. Comforting to know if something went completely wrong, you have an out. I guess I'll have to go into PA for a few days...

 

If you received an out-of-state permit from Florida, that permit would allow you to carry any other state in the country, except your home state (New York), Chicago, and D.C., which do not allow for concealed carry under any circumstances.

 

National Carry?

 

Watch the "may issue" states go "no issue" if this passes. If all they have to do to prevent carry is eliminate the very few who have CCW but are not current or former LEO, the "may issue" fiction will disappear. Not saying this is a bad thing, just a necessary outcome for anti-gun states.

Watch the "may issue" states go "no issue" if this passes. If all they have to do to prevent carry is eliminate the very few who have CCW but are not current or former LEO, the "may issue" fiction will disappear. Not saying this is a bad thing, just a necessary outcome for anti-gun states.

I think it's perfectly fine if that happens. In the short run, yes it's bad. But you're talking about a minority here.....I think the majority of the states will continue business as usual. Once those states go "no issue", it will be a MUCH easier victory in court.

Congressional support is growing for a bill that would force all states to honor concealed carry permits issued in any other state, allowing citizens to take their firearms across state lines.

 

If passed, the National Right-to-Carry Reciprocity Act of 2011 would be a huge win for Second Amendment advocates, giving a gut punch to many state and municipal gun control efforts.

 

I dunno about the wisdom of using Federal power to usurp State and local power.

 

 

The enumeration in the Constitution' date=' of certain rights, shall not be construed to deny or disparage others retained by the people.[/quote']

 

The powers not delegated to the United States by the Constitution' date=' nor prohibited by it to the States, are reserved to the States respectively, or to the people.[/quote']

Wisconsin is now on board. Ohio and Louisiana have signed a concealed carry reciprocity agreement. It appears that more states are getting in line to have the National Right to Carry bill of 2011 actually be effective. Just need to get NJ on board.

Get ready to eat your holster then cause last i heard they had 243 co-sponsers , way more than the 218 needed !!

Get ready to eat your holster then cause last i heard they had 243 co-sponsers , way more than the 218 needed !!

 

So it's going to pass the Senate and Obama is going to sign it into law?

The thing is, most states have shall issue so to those senators, it's not that big of a deal, even if they are democrats and in fact, it's in the best interest of their constituents. It's only the zealots like Frank the mummy and Diane Feinstein who would only be happy with the complete prohibition of firearms.

 

Captain zero wouldn't sign it, but that's a separate issue.

The thing is, most states have shall issue so to those senators, it's not that big of a deal, even if they are democrats and in fact, it's in the best interest of their constituents. It's only the zealots like Frank the mummy and Diane Feinstein who would only be happy with the complete prohibition of firearms.

 

Nobody says that on TV, so I doubt the reasoning.

 

Captain zero wouldn't sign it, but that's a separate issue.

 

That's a 2/3rds separate issue. No way in Hell a veto is overturned on this.

SO if this passes does that mean if you have a FL ccw and live in NJ you could carry here?

SO if this passes does that mean if you have a FL ccw and live in NJ you could carry here?

 

 

I have not read it but everybody says it won't count in your own state. Sounds like No.

 

Plus, this won't become law this year. And everybody in Congress knows it. So, it's a political stunt.

SO if this passes does that mean if you have a FL ccw and live in NJ you could carry here?

 

No. As far as I know and have read, it would allow those who can legally carry in their state of residence to do so throughout the 50 states. Since more than likely you cannot carry in NJ you will not be covered by this proposed law.

No. As far as I know and have read, it would allow those who can legally carry in their state of residence to do so throughout the 50 states. Since more than likely you cannot carry in NJ you will not be covered by this proposed law.

 

Actually, if you have a Fla permit you would be able to carry in 49 states. I think?

Nobody says that on TV, so I doubt the reasoning.

 

 

Yeah, because if it's not on TV, it's not true.

 

Many congressmen from deep blue states were for it last go round, not sure why this round would be any different.

Yeah, because if it's not on TV, it's not true.

 

You are suggestion because states have "shall issue" that their communist legislators will vote for it on a national level. Those people won't even say the word "gun" without the word "control" on TV. So, yes, it means quite a bit.

 

BTW, most states have pro-gun state legislatures but anti-gun federal congressmen due to the voting of the cities. For example, do you consider PA to be pro-gun? Do you want to count on our congressmen to pass this?

 

The supposition that most states are shall-issue and therefore senators will pass a national carry bill is not the way it has ever worked. They are waiting to pass the next assault weapons ban for crying out loud.

 

Many congressmen from deep blue states were for it last go round, not sure why this round would be any different.

 

Last go round?

 

LOL. LOL. HAHAHAA.

 

Are you kidding? That was calculated. The counted the votes and assigned yes and no votes as political favors. It was wonderful cooperation between republicans and democrats. They all agreed to get what they wanted politically out of it as long as the total count was that it would not pass.

 

I haven't been paying much attention this time, but it sounds like you weren't paying much attention last time.

SO if this passes does that mean if you have a FL ccw and live in NJ you could carry here?

No. This has been discussed several times, so I don't remember the exact wording in the bill....but essentially if you have a CCW from your state of residence, then you can carry in any state that doesn't specifically prohibit CCW. I think there's only a couple states that specifically prohibit CCW, NJ is not one of them. Anyone who is a resident outside of NJ, with a valid CCW would be able to carry in NJ. NJ residents with a valid NJ CCW could carry in any state that does not specifically prohibit CCW. NJ residents with a valid out of state CCW could carry in any state other than NJ, that doesn't specifically prohibit CCW.

All i know is if PA residents are gonna come in NJ carrying a conceal firearm and us as NJ residents cant , that is pure BULLSH*T !!!!!!!!!!! :nono:

All i know is if PA residents are gonna come in NJ carrying a conceal firearm and us as NJ residents cant , that is pure BULLSH*T !!!!!!!!!!! :nono:

Just another reason to leave.

No. This has been discussed several times, so I don't remember the exact wording in the bill....but essentially if you have a CCW from your state of residence, then you can carry in any state that doesn't specifically prohibit CCW. I think there's only a couple states that specifically prohibit CCW, NJ is not one of them. Anyone who is a resident outside of NJ, with a valid CCW would be able to carry in NJ. NJ residents with a valid NJ CCW could carry in any state that does not specifically prohibit CCW. NJ residents with a valid out of state CCW could carry in any state other than NJ, that doesn't specifically prohibit CCW.

 

 

slight clarification...you can have a permit from any state to carry in any of 48 states(barring IL, DC) except your home state. A home state permit is only needed to carry in your home state.

All i know is if PA residents are gonna come in NJ carrying a conceal firearm and us as NJ residents cant , that is pure BULLSH*T !!!!!!!!!!! :nono:

 

This, to me is why it's so necessary for this to pass. In my mind, this will give all the 2nd amendment organizations all the traction they need to point out to the state that citizens from other states would have more rights in NJ than their own citizens and would give us HUGE leverage to force the issue - in my mind at least.

 

I hope, really really hope, that this get's attached to Porkulus III (aka ObamaJobsAct)

This, to me is why it's so necessary for this to pass. In my mind, this will give all the 2nd amendment organizations all the traction they need to point out to the state that citizens from other states would have more rights in NJ than their own citizens and would give us HUGE leverage to force the issue - in my mind at least.

 

I hope, really really hope, that this get's attached to Porkulus III (aka ObamaJobsAct)

I'm with you.

slight clarification...you can have a permit from any state to carry in any of 48 states(barring IL, DC) except your home state. A home state permit is only needed to carry in your home state.

I don't understand how you're clarifying what I said. If a FL resident possesses a FL CCW, then they can carry in any state that does not specifically prohibit the carrying of a concealed weapon. If a NJ resident possesses a FL CCW, then they can carry in any state that does not specifically prohibit the carrying of a concealed weapon, except NJ (because they would need to obtain a NJ CCW in order to carry in NJ). And how do you take 50 states, take out IL and DC, and come out to 48?

And how do you take 50 states, take out IL and DC, and come out to 48?

 

 

That's Obama geography/math. Start with 57 states, take away....oh, nevermind :icon_rolleyes:

I dunno about the wisdom of using Federal power to usurp State and local power.

 

I to am a little scared about this.I am afraid we will be giving them the power to put some crazy restrictions on us. I just dont want to see any states giving up their rights to the federal gubment. What will happen to states like Alaska? Will you now need to have a ccw/ltcf to carry there?

This has to be like the 10th time this has been brought up, why so many threads of the same thing? Enough!!!

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.