Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Washington Ban on Assault Weapons Constitutional, Court Says

Featured Replies

Oct. 4 -- Washington, D.C.’s ban on assault

weapons and large-capacity magazines doesn’t violate the constitutional rights of residents in the U.S. capital, a federal appeals court ruled.

The U.S. Court of Appeals in Washington today also upheld registration requirements for handguns put in place after a landmark U.S. Supreme Court decision in 2008 ended the city’s almost total ban on firearms. The three-judge panel ordered a lower court to further review other aspects of Washington’s gun

control law, such as its limits on multiple purchases.

“The District has carried its burden of showing a substantial relationship between the prohibition of both semi-automatic rifles and magazines holding more than 10 rounds, and the objectives of protecting police officers and controlling crime,” Judge Douglas Ginsburg wrote in the 2-1 ruling.

The challenge to the restrictions was brought by Dick Heller, the plaintiff in the 2008 Supreme Court case , who argued that the District of Columbia’s gun laws are so burdensome as to violate the Constitution’s right to bear arms. The rules are inconsistent with high court rulings, including Heller’s earlier

case, he said in court papers.

 

Fingerprinted and Photographed

Under the statute, residents who want to keep guns at home must be fingerprinted and photographed by the police, provide a work history and describe their intended use of the weapon.

Firearms have to be registered every three years. Guns defined by the city as assault weapons are banned.

Judge Brett Kavanaugh dissented, saying he would have thrown out the ban on assault weapons and the registration requirements.

“This case concerns semi-automatic rifles,” Kavanaugh wrote. “It would strain logic and common sense to conclude that the Second Amendment protects semi-automatic handguns but does

not protect semi-automatic rifles.”

Ginsburg said the court only looked at semi-automatic rifles qualifying as an assault weapon under the law because Heller and the other plaintiffs didn’t attempt to register a

semi-automatic pistol or shotgun.

Heller’s lawyer, Stephen Halbrook, told the three-judge panel during arguments in November that district’s gun regulations are “the most radically restrictive” in the

country. Halbrook didn’t immediately respond to a telephone message seeking comment on today’s ruling.

Work History

Washington also requires residents who want to keep a gun at home to provide a five-year work history and state their intended use of the weapon. Applicants must allow police to run ballistic tests on each gun they register. Magazines that hold more than 10 bullets are banned.

The solicitor general for the District of Columbia, Todd Kim, said during oral argument that the city has the authority to keep tabs on who owns guns within its borders and to keep out certain types of weapons. Kim had no immediate comment on the ruling.

The appeal panel approved what it called basic requirements for handguns, such as providing the city with name, age, occupation, date of sale and residence. Ginsburg said any registration requirements related to “long guns” and “novel” requirements for handguns, such as those requiring re-registration of handguns every three years and requiring the gun owner be fingerprinted and photographed, were sent back to the

lower court judge for additional review.

Heller filed the current challenge in July 2008, just 12 days after Washington lawmakers passed emergency legislation to comply with the high court ruling in his earlier case. A federal trial judge dismissed the new case in March 2010 after finding that the city’s regulations were an appropriate balance between

public safety and an individual’s right to own a gun.

The case is Heller v. District of Columbia, 10-07036, U.S. Court of Appeals for D.C. Circuit (Washington).

Bad lawsuit... this is why things should be left to the SAF, and not amateurs. If this goes to SCOTUS, they can rule in a manner which hurts us instead of helping us.

Bad lawsuit... this is why things should be left to the SAF, and not amateurs. If this goes to SCOTUS, they can rule in a manner which hurts us instead of helping us.

 

This case was brought by Dick Heller, the same guy responsible for Heller vs DC that overturned the DC gun ban in the first place. If anyone is qualified to bring a case like this, he is it, IMO. Remember, lots of lower courts are full of liberals. The other big gun cases were not decided in our favor until they reached the Supreme Court.

Stephen Halbrook is a pretty reputable Constitutional law attorney. He's argued before SCOTUS a few times and he specializes in 2A law. Rest assured, he and Dick Heller know what they are doing and I'm sure they have the full blessing of SAF.

This case was brought by Dick Heller, the same guy responsible for Heller vs DC that overturned the DC gun ban in the first place. If anyone is qualified to bring a case like this, he is it, IMO. Remember, lots of lower courts are full of liberals. The other big gun cases were not decided in our favor until they reached the Supreme Court.

 

Except he's just some dude. SAF handled the majority of the work in DC v Heller. Heck, just look at the write-up on Volokh Conspiracy... it's easy to see why this lawsuit is a bad one because it's all over the place in attacking a wide range or regulations.

 

The slow but steady strategy which the SAF employs is to focus on one or two related regulations, and hammer them. You don't focus on an entire AWB ban... you focus on the ban of the bayonet lug, and once you win there, the groundwork is there to focus on the Flash hider... then the collapsible stock, etc.

Except he's just some dude. SAF handled the majority of the work in DC v Heller. Heck, just look at the write-up on Volokh Conspiracy... it's easy to see why this lawsuit is a bad one because it's all over the place in attacking a wide range or regulations.

 

The slow but steady strategy which the SAF employs is to focus on one or two related regulations, and hammer them. You don't focus on an entire AWB ban... you focus on the ban of the bayonet lug, and once you win there, the groundwork is there to focus on the Flash hider... then the collapsible stock, etc.

 

 

OK, I'm going to eat my crow now, rather than wait. I'll admit, I didn't know the details of this case. I was under the impression that this was the DC carry case, where in fact it is an NRA backed case that focused on the DC AWB... :banghead: While Halbrook is a good attorney, the NRA is the bigger problem here. They need to get out of the lawsuit business, since they only seem to F it up anyway. They should stick to education, publicity, and lobbying/legislation. They are great at all those things, but the need to leave litigation up to the pros (i.e. SAF).

 

I agree completely with you; the best way to eat an elephant is one bite at a time. The NRA's approach mimics what many people on here believe, and that is that because we are right we should be able to get all our rights back all at once, right now. While I think that's the way it should be, it doesn't line up with reality. We didn't get where we are now because our opponents took everything all at once, and we're certainly not going to get it back that way.

at least someone is doing something in the terms of AWB, this has the opportunity to help us

at least someone is doing something in the terms of AWB, this has the opportunity to help us

 

Taking a case to court and losing, especially in front of SCOTUS can do a lot more harm to the cause than good. The AWB is the last thing that should be tackled in the grand scheme of gun infringement schemes. Concealed carry is our stepping stone to get there though, as is a measured approach analyzing legislation line by line and winning the arguments at each step of the way. :)

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.