Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Marauding Mob Of 50 Teen-Aged Girls Beats Down 2 Nyc Cops

Featured Replies

I think that IF an officer had shot one of them that there would be enough of a case of disparity of force to mount a defence. Its not as simple as taking a beat down. There is a great concern for an officer when they go down in this type of situation that their weapon will be taken and used against them. That is what creates a reasonable escalation of force for an out of control mob imo.

 

that is the exact point I brought up earlier.. could not agree more..

 

+1

  • Replies 60
  • Views 2.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • does a mob of 50+ people attacking you represent a credible threat to your life?   in my book it does.. so yes..

  • the article is unclear as to if only 4 were arrested and charged.. or if that is all that was involved.. I find it slightly hard to believe 4 or 5 kids were able to attack and take down two cops..  

  • What? No way. This is fake. In the thread about open carry I was told that people do not attack police officers because they have radios, parners, bulletproof vest, helicopters....   This must be

Guys, this is all speculation of how the officer went down etc...we all know that the media embelishes stuff.

True. Of course if it happened nothing like what the article said, it would render most of the posts irrelevant. I don't think anybody is suggesting that it would still apply otherwise. Even if it did happen differently, are opinions would still hold in a hypothetical scenario that this initial story provides.

What? No way. This is fake. In the thread about open carry I was told that people do not attack police officers because they have radios, parners, bulletproof vest, helicopters....

 

This must be photoshopped.

 

 

Yea, because angry mobs and lunatics are the only people out there. :icon_rolleyes:

What the hell happened to the pepper spray on this account?

 

Who knows, with the whole OWS pepper spray incident the officers may have had orders to not carry pepper spray any longer. IMO pepper spray and tasers would have been helpful in this situation though the water cannon certainly achieved the appropriate response IMO.

 

Had the officers used deadly force, we know what would be going on right now. The media would be conducting a public opinion inquisition, opposers would be shouted down, facts would be buried, etc. The use of the fire department was appropriate, swift, effective, and (IMO) perfect. Matt6669 posted on facebook that America and our politicians have become soft. We are nowhere near the generation that endured and survived WWII. We (in general) are a bunch of pussies. These kids will go home, likely their parents will not even be notified, the parents will not even notice their kids are wet, and if they do and actually ask a question, the parents will be horrified at the "disparate use of force by the jack booted thugs in authority". My parents, and my grand parents, would have asked me first (if I were the one arriving home wet and explaining this situation) "What the hell did you do to deserve getting hosed by the FD?" Self responsibility is non existent in the ME generation. The believe their actions have no consequences. Or that their actions were someone else's fault.

I disagree with Anthony,

 

These are 50 kids and females. I think there is a certain level of threat before you start shooting. I think it's obvious that level wasn't reached.

 

Staten Island is a small place with 3 pct's. I am sure another patrol car was close by. That area is not a good area and is usually patrolled.

 

On the contrary, Staten Island is a very LARGE place with ONLY three precincts. I am sure that another patrol car was NOT close by. Certainly, the area is patrolled. But, there isn't a cop on every corner....that's for sure.

  • Author

30% bleach mixed in with that water cannon would have been a nice touch! Just sayin.

 

bah, raw sewage would have been better.

From NY Post:

 

"The melee unfolded around 3:30 p.m. on Harbor Road shortly after Angel Reyes, 19, and his fiendish friends showed up to threaten a 15-year-old girl who had refused to help Reyes in a fight at Port Richmond High School, where they are students, sources said.

 

“I’m gonna f--- you up,” Reyes, 19, allegedly barked while aiming a BB gun at the victim.

 

Two cops from the 120th Precinct responded, but were outnumbered and quickly knocked to the ground and kicked in their heads by Xiomara Reyes, 17, Anthony Concepcion, 17, Taniqua Pearson, 20, and Marisol Lugo, 31, court papers state.

 

The firefighters came to their aid and the assailants, Reyes and a 15-year-old girl who allegedly hid the BB gun in her backpack were cuffed at the scene."

 

The article also says they were all arrested for weapons, intimidation and gang charges.

 

Not quite 50 teenage girls with guns and knives... though teenage girls are pretty scarry, with their slang and pop music and iPhones and all...

 

Also, if you think cops should just open fire and kill lots of people to send a message, there are some places in the middle east you might want to check out ;)

 

Personally I think the response was beautiful.

On the contrary, Staten Island is a very LARGE place with ONLY three precincts. I am sure that another patrol car was NOT close by. Certainly, the area is patrolled. But, there isn't a cop on every corner....that's for sure.

 

Having grown up there, worked in and all over SI for my entire life, it's smaller then you think. I am well aware of the pct's and the way they patrol. The work in a grid and in this area, there is a lot of drugs. It's not a good area and usually has more of a police presence. Staten Island is only 17 miles long by like 11 miles wide. That is not big. I agree 3 prct's is not a lot for the amount of people but they are actually building the 4th right now and it's very close to where this happened. They have a Satelite Pct that is not far away from where this is also.

Seems as though we will disagree about the level of PD presence on The island as a whole. Furthermore, the area surrounding Port Richmond high school is hardly the top priority for the 120 with Park Hill, and Saint George to patrol.

 

I feel I'm equally qualified to have an opinion having lived on SI for the majority of my life.

 

 

From NY Post:

 

"The melee unfolded around 3:30 p.m. on Harbor Road shortly after Angel Reyes, 19, and his fiendish friends showed up to threaten a 15-year-old girl who had refused to help Reyes in a fight at Port Richmond High School, where they are students, sources said.

 

“I’m gonna f--- you up,” Reyes, 19, allegedly barked while aiming a BB gun at the victim.

 

Two cops from the 120th Precinct responded, but were outnumbered and quickly knocked to the ground and kicked in their heads by Xiomara Reyes, 17, Anthony Concepcion, 17, Taniqua Pearson, 20, and Marisol Lugo, 31, court papers state.

 

The firefighters came to their aid and the assailants, Reyes and a 15-year-old girl who allegedly hid the BB gun in her backpack were cuffed at the scene."

 

The article also says they were all arrested for weapons, intimidation and gang charges.

 

Not quite 50 teenage girls with guns and knives... though teenage girls are pretty scarry, with their slang and pop music and iPhones and all...

 

Also, if you think cops should just open fire and kill lots of people to send a message, there are some places in the middle east you might want to check out ;)

 

Personally I think the response was beautiful.

 

the article is unclear as to if only 4 were arrested and charged.. or if that is all that was involved.. I find it slightly hard to believe 4 or 5 kids were able to attack and take down two cops..

 

and I never said cops should open fire to send a message.. I said if an officer is attacked and has no other option.. they should use the tools at their disposal to defend themselves...

 

you and your child are surrounded by 6 people... they knock you and your child to the ground.. and are kicking the **** out of both of you.. you have a gun.. do you use it.. or roll over and play dead... something tells me all of the sudden your answer changes..

and I never said cops should open fire to send a message.. I said if an officer is attacked and has no other option.. they should use the tools at their disposal to defend themselves...

 

you and your child are surrounded by 6 people... they knock you and your child to the ground.. and are kicking the **** out of both of you.. you have a gun.. do you use it.. or roll over and play dead... something tells me all of the sudden your answer changes..

 

A lot of people like to fantasize about being placed in impossible hypothetical situations where the only way out is to kill somebody. The last time I stopped into Engage Armament (http://www.engagearmament.com), I overheard the following statement, from a customer:

 

“So I’ve got a Glock, and if there was a perp in my house and I had to take a hostage rescue shot to save my son, I really want a silencer because I don’t to blow out his hearing, but I’m worried I won’t be able to see my night sights over the diameter of the silencer – what should I get?”

 

The salesman played along with this fantasy. For me, I can't say, because it's just not my thing, sorry. But back to Staten Island, I wasn't there, so I don’t know what happened.

 

However, my answer does not change: anytime a potentially life-threatening situation is resolved with both 1) no loss of life, and 2) justice being served, then amen. The hood rat perp trash are going to jail. Nobody died.

 

NYPD and NYFD: job well done.

 

 

Original Article:

http://www.nypost.co...px6GyHTduvnhSWK

 

Article quoted:

http://www.nypost.co...eEAbplYogzBpL9I

Seems as though we will disagree about the level of PD presence on The island as a whole. Furthermore, the area surrounding Port Richmond high school is hardly the top priority for the 120 with Park Hill, and Saint George to patrol.

 

I feel I'm equally qualified to have an opinion having lived on SI for the majority of my life.

 

Concern, yes but the same car patrol's both park hill and stapleton. As far as port richmond, they don't get that much attention because it's mostly illegals. The harbor projects are no different from park hill really. I remember delivering mail there before I quit. Had some thugs try to mess with me. It was check day for the scells. They were all yelling to leave the mother effing mailman alone becauuse they want they check. lol Funny as hell.

A lot of people like to fantasize about being placed in impossible hypothetical situations where the only way out is to kill somebody. The last time I stopped into Engage Armament (http://www.engagearmament.com), I overheard the following statement, from a customer:

 

“So I’ve got a Glock, and if there was a perp in my house and I had to take a hostage rescue shot to save my son, I really want a silencer because I don’t to blow out his hearing, but I’m worried I won’t be able to see my night sights over the diameter of the silencer – what should I get?”

 

The salesman played along with this fantasy. For me, I can't say, because it's just not my thing, sorry. But back to Staten Island, I wasn't there, so I don’t know what happened.

 

However, my answer does not change: anytime a potentially life-threatening situation is resolved with both 1) no loss of life, and 2) justice being served, then amen. The hood rat perp trash are going to jail. Nobody died.

 

NYPD and NYFD: job well done.

 

 

Original Article:

http://www.nypost.co...px6GyHTduvnhSWK

 

Article quoted:

http://www.nypost.co...eEAbplYogzBpL9I

 

they were very lucky...

 

individuals who found no harm in gathering on someones front lawn with the sole intent of harming them..

individuals who brought a weapon and had no issue brandishing it..

individuals who collectively assaulted uniformed police officers..

 

sorry.. but I don't want any of those assholes to gain access to a firearm lost by a downed officer.. when you carry a gun.... your single biggest concern better be retaining that weapon.. because the second you lose it.. who knows what kind of hell you just allowed.. so IMO (agree to disagree) yes.. the officer was justified to use deadly force..

 

and as I said to you.. you are in the exact same position.. armed.. you are getting the **** kicked out of you..

you do nothing? guess what.. in most states.. a normal citizen in that situation would be justified to shoot..

do you believe that being outnumbered and getting kicked while on the ground.. by people who were assembled for the sole purpose of causing violence.. is really not a reasonable threat?

 

if I am in a situation.. where deadly force is reasonable.. I feel the police should be empowered to make that same decision.. these people put their lives on the line every day.. why should they be forced to be abused and assaulted that is absurd..

 

I am willing to bet.. right or wrong.. if MOST of the people on this forum were armed.. and saw this transpire..

they would get involved..

for the record.. I live no fantasy.. I have no desire to shoot someone.. in fact.. I dread the thought..

but I carry a cell phone.. in case I have to call someone.. I carry my wallet in case I have to buy someone.. and well I carry a gun in case I am attacked in a way that I feel my life or the life of my loved ones is in eminent danger.. it's not an accessory.. it is a tool..

 

in this situation.. great.. it ended well... everyone went home alive.. I still disagree.. the outcome does not IMO justify the risk taken...

“They had bats, they had the kind of bars you lock car steering wheels with, running up the block.”

The situation took an even more serious turn when one thug in the crowd of about 40 flashed a firearm, she said.

“My mom was screaming, ‘He’s got a gun! He’s got a gun!’ ” said the girl. “One of them was sticking their tongue out, and they had a blade on it.’’

 

 

Multiple individuals..

Armed..

 

the police should have parked a couple houses down and got out with shotguns to deal with that kind of nonsense..

However, my answer does not change: anytime a potentially life-threatening situation is resolved with both 1) no loss of life, and 2) justice being served, then amen. The hood rat perp trash are going to jail. Nobody died.

 

I agree with you, I am also glad that nobody lost their life. HOWEVER, it was a huge gamble. While waiting for backup to arrive, all it would take is one kick to the head for one of the officers to be killed. They took a gamble by not using lethal force to defend themselves, and LUCKILY neither one of them were seriously injured. It could have ended up much worse though. That's the point, is eliminating the chances of an INNOCENT person being hurt. Those gang-bangers made their choice by attacking cops, any consequence that comes from that is something they have to face.

 

I also couldn't agree more with everything Vlad said.

Gang-bangers? It was a mob, which is far from gang-bangers. That's akin to going to a village in Afghanistan in pursuit of suspected insurgents, and laying down fire on the general population (which, yes, is wrong).

 

With that said, I absolutely support the protection of the first responders and innocent civilians involved, however discretion must always be applied-- and it's not a matter of being PC, but situational awareness. As it has already been pointed out, by firing into a crowd, that would probably escalate the situation exponentially. Sure, that mob might have dispersed, but, as history shows, raised tensions would most likely result in protests that could turn violent not in just the local area-- but nationally, maybe even world-wide (given the power of globalized communication.

It could be argued that this is "hindsight," but I would disagree wholeheartedly as I consider this situational awareness-- having the foresight to realize what one's actions could cause, and how those consequences effect not just the individual, but the community.

The NYPD and FDNY did a commendable job in dis-escalating this situation.

With that said, I absolutely support the protection of the first responders and innocent civilians involved, however discretion must always be applied-- and it's not a matter of being PC, but situational awareness.

 

Agreed. And the one thing that we all do not know is what it actually looked like to the oficers involved. The decriptions we are reading are one thing, but we do not have the ability to see what the respondng officers did. That makes all the difference.

Gang-bangers? It was a mob, which is far from gang-bangers. That's akin to going to a village in Afghanistan in pursuit of suspected insurgents, and laying down fire on the general population (which, yes, is wrong).

If the "general population" in Afghanistan becomes violent, and starts attacking the soldiers, then yes lay down fire. I'm having a hard time understanding how this is a debate.....if a group of people is outnumbering you and attacking you for no reason, how are they not an immediate threat to your safety?

Gang-bangers? It was a mob, which is far from gang-bangers. That's akin to going to a village in Afghanistan in pursuit of suspected insurgents, and laying down fire on the general population (which, yes, is wrong).

 

With that said, I absolutely support the protection of the first responders and innocent civilians involved, however discretion must always be applied-- and it's not a matter of being PC, but situational awareness. As it has already been pointed out, by firing into a crowd, that would probably escalate the situation exponentially. Sure, that mob might have dispersed, but, as history shows, raised tensions would most likely result in protests that could turn violent not in just the local area-- but nationally, maybe even world-wide (given the power of globalized communication.

It could be argued that this is "hindsight," but I would disagree wholeheartedly as I consider this situational awareness-- having the foresight to realize what one's actions could cause, and how those consequences effect not just the individual, but the community.

The NYPD and FDNY did a commendable job in dis-escalating this situation.

 

If I'm on the ground getting kicked and punched to my head and face and so is my partner, the last thing I'm worried about is youtube, twitter and facebook. I want to get home to see my family. And what group of "kids" kicks and punches cops to the ground?

for the record.. I live no fantasy.. I have no desire to shoot someone.. in fact.. I dread the thought..

but I carry a cell phone.. in case I have to call someone.. I carry my wallet in case I have to buy someone.. and well I carry a gun in case I am attacked in a way that I feel my life or the life of my loved ones is in eminent danger.. it's not an accessory.. it is a tool..

 

in this situation.. great.. it ended well... everyone went home alive.. I still disagree.. the outcome does not IMO justify the risk taken...

 

I agree with you... it sounds like that situation sucked bad and could have gone very, very wrong. Everyone just breathes a sigh of relief and says, "wow that was a close one." For all I might complain about the bad cops out there (and there are a lot), I try to remember it's still a tough job... and when I read about things like this I remember why I could never be a cop.

. And what group of "kids" kicks and punches cops to the ground?

 

Hate to lump them into a stereo type, but they are the ones that won't make it far in life, wont last long being if they have that great a disregard of respect for the law and general human decency, they will be killed by others like them.

 

Not saying that the days of years past were a better time, but when you look at society as a whole, the only thing we have advance is technology, not human decency.

." For all I might complain about the bad cops out there (and there are a lot), I try to remember it's still a tough job... and when I read about things like this I remember why I could never be a cop.

 

I wouldn't say a lot, there may be a percentage that are, but as a whole they are a good, and probably deserve a lot more respect then are given by the masses for what they do and what they lay on the line day in and day out. It's the few that that hurt the many. Just look at some of the current and retired LEO's we have here on the forum, every one I have meet are damn good guys in my book and have my respect for not just what they do, but who they are as people.

Gang-bangers? It was a mob, which is far from gang-bangers. That's akin to going to a village in Afghanistan in pursuit of suspected insurgents, and laying down fire on the general population (which, yes, is wrong).

 

With that said, I absolutely support the protection of the first responders and innocent civilians involved, however discretion must always be applied-- and it's not a matter of being PC, but situational awareness. As it has already been pointed out, by firing into a crowd, that would probably escalate the situation exponentially. Sure, that mob might have dispersed, but, as history shows, raised tensions would most likely result in protests that could turn violent not in just the local area-- but nationally, maybe even world-wide (given the power of globalized communication.

It could be argued that this is "hindsight," but I would disagree wholeheartedly as I consider this situational awareness-- having the foresight to realize what one's actions could cause, and how those consequences effect not just the individual, but the community.

The NYPD and FDNY did a commendable job in dis-escalating this situation.

 

multiple individuals.. with weapons.. attacking police officers...

 

call them gang members... call them scumbags.. call them whatever you like.. but an individual does not have to be a "gang banger" to warrant the use of force..

 

I will respectfully agree with all that it was a good day.. and luckily no one died... I just feel like this IS an instance where force was definitely justified.. and exhibiting too much self restraint is going to get you killed... I almost feel that as someone else pointed out.. the NYPD has been whipped down or something.. wasn't it NYPD who was just in the other video while that guy was stabbing the other guy.. and they just stood there... a fear of using force is NOT a good value for PD to have.. as there are definitely some situations that justify it..

multiple individuals.. with weapons.. attacking police officers...

 

call them gang members... call them scumbags.. call them whatever you like.. but an individual does not have to be a "gang banger" to warrant the use of force..

 

I will respectfully agree with all that it was a good day.. and luckily no one died... I just feel like this IS an instance where force was definitely justified.. and exhibiting too much self restraint is going to get you killed... I almost feel that as someone else pointed out.. the NYPD has been whipped down or something.. wasn't it NYPD who was just in the other video while that guy was stabbing the other guy.. and they just stood there... a fear of using force is NOT a good value for PD to have.. as there are definitely some situations that justify it..

 

This weekend there was an escape from Garfield PD..they tracked the Shittum, found him in a garage, and when they opened the door he charged the cops with a shovel, and another tool. Bad guy was shot and killed. Nj.com is overflowing with butthurt of EPIC proportions with the usual "Why couldn't they just wound him" nonsense.

This weekend there was an escape from Garfield PD..they tracked the Shittum, found him in a garage, and when they opened the door he charged the cops with a shovel, and another tool. Bad guy was shot and killed. Nj.com is overflowing with butthurt of EPIC proportions with the usual "Why couldn't they just wound him" nonsense.

 

I do believe that "nonsense" is the key word here :D

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.