Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

So What Companies Actually Make Banned Lowers

Featured Replies

you know....ones that say AR-15 or whatever on them. is the colt 6920 one of them? i see that the california 6920 has stamped m4 carbine or something like that. armalite maybe?

As long as it doesn't say AR15 it should be ok. Some earlier colt lowers are not OK like the Sp1 because they say AR15. The 6920 should be ok if it is ban compliant.

Even if it says AR-15 it is OK, since the list is obsolete with the substantially identical clause. Even if it says AR-15 but does not have 2 or more features, it is not substantially identical to an AR-15. Although, I still wouldnt want to be seen with a receiver stamped "AR-15" since its widely and incorrectly believed that it would be illegal. That being said, I believe only certain colts are marked AR-15. And of course, IANAL.

Even if it says AR-15 it is OK, since the list is obsolete with the substantially identical clause. Even if it says AR-15 but does not have 2 or more features, it is not substantially identical to an AR-15. Although, I still wouldnt want to be seen with a receiver stamped "AR-15" since its widely and incorrectly believed that it would be illegal. That being said, I believe only certain colts are marked AR-15. And of course, IANAL.

 

how do you figure... not saying you are wrong... just asking how you figure...

 

NJ says the following...

New Jersey law lists firearms that are prohibited "assault firearms." N.J.S.A. 2C:39-1w.(1).

 

meaning.. they list guns by NAME.. that are banned..

 

they then go on to say..

 

In addition, the law provides that the term "assault firearm" includes, "Any firearm manufactured under any designation which is substantially identical to any of the firearms listed" in the law. N.J.S.A. 2C:39-1w.(2). Thus, a firearm is an assault firearm if it is included on the list of banned firearms or if it is manufactured under a different designation than a firearm on the list but is "substantially identical" to a specific listed firearm.

We believe "substantially identical" is clear by its plain meaning. The Criminal Code provides that the statutes in the Code must be read "according to the fair import of their terms." N.J.S.A. 2C:1-2c. The Criminal Code explains that where language may be susceptible to different readings it must be construed to "give fair warning of the nature of the conduct proscribed." N.J.S.A. 2C:1-2a.(4), c. Simply put, the phrase "substantially identical" must be given its plain meaning, one that gives fair warning.

The term "substantial" means pertaining to the substance, matter, material or essence of a thing. The term "identical" means exactly the same. Hence, a firearm is substantially identical to another only if it is identical in all material, essential respects. A firearm is not substantially identical to a listed assault firearm unless it is identical except for differences which do not alter the essential nature of the firearm.

The following are examples of manufacturer changes that do not alter the essential nature of the firearm: name or designation of the firearm; the color of the firearm; the material used to make the barrel or stock of the firearm; the material used to make a pistol grip; a modification of a pistol grip. This is not an exclusive list.

A semi-automatic firearm should be considered to be "substantially identical," that is, identical in all material respects, to a named assault weapon if it meets the below listed criteria:

 

A. semi-automatic rifle that has the ability to accept a detachable magazine and has at least 2 of the following:

  1. a folding or telescoping stock;
  2. a pistol grip that protrudes conspicuously beneath the action of the weapon;
  3. a bayonet mount;
  4. a flash suppressor or threaded barrel designed to accommodate a flash suppressor; and
  5. a grenade launcher;

meaning... as I read it..

 

there is a list.. of guns you can not own..

in addition to that.. you may not own guns that are substantially identical..

substantially identical is defined in the following way...

 

if I am reading this wrong.. please set me straight..

A Colt AR-15 with a pinned stock, no bayo lug, no grenade launcher and no flash hider is not substantially identical to the Colt AR-15 listed in the banned list. But, a rose by any other name....

 

I'd avoid a Colt AR-15 lower. AR-15 is a Colt trademark. How is the list obsolete? It's still the law, isn't it?

A Colt AR-15 with a pinned stock, no bayo lug, no grenade launcher and no flash hider is not substantially identical to the Colt AR-15 listed in the banned list. But, a rose by any other name....

 

I'd avoid a Colt AR-15 lower. AR-15 is a Colt trademark. How is the list obsolete? It's still the law, isn't it?

 

as I stated..

substantially identical is only HALF of the law.. you are ignoring the rest of it..

the law starts BEFORE that and literally bans guns by NAME...

 

2C:39-1 Definitions.

The following definitions apply to this chapter and to chapter 58:

............

...........

...........

w. "Assault firearm" means:

(1) The following firearms:

Algimec AGM1 type

Any shotgun with a revolving cylinder such as the "Street Sweeper" or "Striker 12"

Armalite AR-180 type

Australian Automatic Arms SAR

Avtomat Kalashnikov type semi-automatic firearms

Beretta AR-70 and BM59 semi-automatic firearms

Bushmaster Assault Rifle

Calico M-900 Assault carbine and M-900

CETME G3

Chartered Industries of Singapore SR-88 type

Colt AR-15 and CAR-15 series

Daewoo K-1, K-2, Max 1 and Max 2, AR 100 types

Demro TAC-1 carbine type

Encom MP-9 and MP-45 carbine types

FAMAS MAS223 types

FN-FAL, FN-LAR, or FN-FNC type semi-automatic firearms

Franchi SPAS 12 and LAW 12 shotguns

G3SA type

Galil type Heckler and Koch HK91, HK93, HK94, MP5, PSG-1

Intratec TEC 9 and 22 semi-automatic firearms

M1 carbine type

M14S type

MAC 10, MAC 11, MAC 11-9mm carbine type firearms

PJK M-68 carbine type

Plainfield Machine Company Carbine

Ruger K-Mini-14/5F and Mini-14/5RF

SIG AMT, SIG 550SP, SIG 551SP, SIG PE-57 types

SKS with detachable magazine type

Spectre Auto carbine type

Springfield Armory BM59 and SAR-48 type

Sterling MK-6, MK-7 and SAR types

Steyr A.U.G. semi-automatic firearms

USAS 12 semi-automatic type shotgun

Uzi type semi-automatic firearms

Valmet M62, M71S, M76, or M78 type semi-automatic firearms

Weaver Arm Nighthawk.

(2) Any firearm manufactured under any designation which is substantially

identical to any of the firearms listed above.

(3) A semi-automatic shotgun with either a magazine capacity exceeding six

rounds, a pistol grip, or a folding stock.

(4) A semi-automatic rifle with a fixed magazine capacity exceeding 15 rounds.

(5) A part or combination of parts designed or intended to convert a firearm

into an assault firearm, or any combination of parts from which an assault firearm may

be readily assembled if those parts are in the possession or under the control of the

same person.

Words are important gentlemen.

 

Thus, a firearm is an assault firearm if it is included on the list of banned firearms or if it is manufactured under a different designation than a firearm on the list but is "substantially identical" to a specific listed firearm.

 

That "or" means that if a firearm falls under EITHER category, it is illegal. If it said "and", then vlad would be wrong. However, that's not the case ;)

So if I put COLT AR-15 on a crossman pellet gun, its illegal? No, a COLT AR-15 is not substantialy identical to a COLT AR-15 unless it has two or more evil features. It goes both ways. If you have something NOT on the list but has two or more features, it is suddenly substantially identical to every single gun on the list. Remember, these people are not gun experts. They wont study the mechanics of what makes an AR-15 and a SCAR different. If the SCAR has 2 or more features, its whatever they want it to be.

 

What about avtomat kalashnikov type? They arent going to study the mechanics of a rifle to determine who designed it. Can you have a VZ58? Its %100 opposite from an AK. No, if it has two or more features its substantially identical to everything on the list.... What if your rifle is stamped AK-47? Well if it doesnt have two or more features, its not what they determined a kalashnikov type was. Not to mention AK could stand for anything.

 

They determined all the guns on the list had 2 or more features, thus they are on the list unless they DONT have the features, basically. M1 carbine of course is the pink unicorn here.

 

That all being said, you are operating in an extreme gray area if you are driving around with a COLT AR-15 and an M1 carbine in your trunk. While I believe both to be legal, no law enforcement will agree with you and you will spend tens of thousands of dollars defending (overturning AW ban?) yourself.

Words are important gentlemen.

 

 

 

That "or" means that if a firearm falls under EITHER category, it is illegal. If it said "and", then vlad would be wrong. However, that's not the case ;)

 

you get it...

 

They determined all the guns on the list had 2 or more features, thus they are on the list unless they DONT have the features, basically. M1 carbine of course is the pink unicorn here.

 

 

where does the law say that?

 

the law.. as it is literally written says..

 

these guns are banned..

it then goes on to say

guns that are substantially identical are banned...

 

no where does it say named guns are not banned if they pass the evil features game..

unless they actually amend the law.. the law says..

 

named..

OR

substantially identical to named...

 

This. As I said before, the law says that a gun is illegal if it is on the list OR if it has two or more features.

 

Glenn, please use the laws and point out which WORDS lead you to believe your point of view.

Points to re-evaluate:

 

1. Vladtepes > The LAW applies here, not the NJAG Guideline or Admin Code, as you are well aware.

2. Glennp > I believe it is OR and not AND as 2C:39-1w(1) and 2C:39-1w(2) are separate items.

3. IMHO > The list is devided into a) named firearms, b) firearm series, c) firearm types. :roulette:

I agree with vlad and vjf915, anything on the named list is banned by name, meaning that if it has it stamped somewhere on the gun, you are looking for trouble. The NJAC guidelines only cover rules that prosecutors are to follow when trying to charge someone for possession of a AW using the "substantially identical" clause in the AWB statute. If they don't need to use that clause, and are going for the named list, they just have to prove to the jury that the particular gun is one on the named list. When the name is stamped into the side of it, and they show pictures of other similar guns by that name, would you want your life to be in the hands of that jury??

 

NJ v Robert D. Merrill, the case where a NJ judge ruled that "substantially identical" is unconstitutionally vague is our ticket to freedom. This is why the NJAC has the evil feature list. If prosecutors can't go after the gun by specific name, as in the name is not stamped on the gun... they have to turn to the NJAC evil feature list. If they don't, and just try to use the statute's definition of "substantially identical", any defense attorney worth anything will bring up NJ v Robert D. Merrill, the NJAC evil feature list, etc and the case will be throw out based on that precedent and case law ("substantially identical" is unconstitutionally vague).... that is unless the gun fails the evil feature game.

 

Right now we are in a position of status quo regarding our AWB. The unconstitutional "substantially identical" is still on the books, but we are protected with precedent and case law, so much that a NJAC was created to place constitutionality around its usage. The entire AWB should be challenged and thrown out of the books, but right now both sides are content with keeping things they way they are, as both sides fear that they have too much to loose by duking it out. Think China and Taiwan.

  • 2 weeks later...
  • Author

but is the substantially identical list law? or just a guideline that nobody wants to test out because we can still have our stuff with most fun stuff.

but is the substantially identical list law? or just a guideline that nobody wants to test out because we can still have our stuff with most fun stuff.

 

I was always told it is just the guidelines.. BUT "assault firearm" is defined under 2C

 

2C:39-1 Definitions.

w. "Assault firearm" means:

(1) The following firearms:

Algimec AGM1 type

Any shotgun with a revolving cylinder such as the "Street Sweeper" or "Striker 12"

Armalite AR-180 type

Australian Automatic Arms SAR

Avtomat Kalashnikov type semi-automatic firearms

Beretta AR-70 and BM59 semi-automatic firearms

Bushmaster Assault Rifle

Calico M-900 Assault carbine and M-900

CETME G3

Chartered Industries of Singapore SR-88 type

Colt AR-15 and CAR-15 series

Daewoo K-1, K-2, Max 1 and Max 2, AR 100 types

Demro TAC-1 carbine type

Encom MP-9 and MP-45 carbine types

FAMAS MAS223 types

FN-FAL, FN-LAR, or FN-FNC type semi-automatic firearms

Franchi SPAS 12 and LAW 12 shotguns

G3SA type

Galil type Heckler and Koch HK91, HK93, HK94, MP5, PSG-1

Intratec TEC 9 and 22 semi-automatic firearms

M1 carbine type

M14S type

MAC 10, MAC 11, MAC 11-9mm carbine type firearms

PJK M-68 carbine type

Plainfield Machine Company Carbine

Ruger K-Mini-14/5F and Mini-14/5RF

SIG AMT, SIG 550SP, SIG 551SP, SIG PE-57 types

SKS with detachable magazine type

Spectre Auto carbine type

Springfield Armory BM59 and SAR-48 type

Sterling MK-6, MK-7 and SAR types

Steyr A.U.G. semi-automatic firearms

USAS 12 semi-automatic type shotgun

Uzi type semi-automatic firearms

Valmet M62, M71S, M76, or M78 type semi-automatic firearms

Weaver Arm Nighthawk.

(2) Any firearm manufactured under any designation which is substantially

identical to any of the firearms listed above.

(3) A semi-automatic shotgun with either a magazine capacity exceeding six

rounds, a pistol grip, or a folding stock.

(4) A semi-automatic rifle with a fixed magazine capacity exceeding 15 rounds.

(5) A part or combination of parts designed or intended to convert a firearm

into an assault firearm, or any combination of parts from which an assault firearm may

be readily assembled if those parts are in the possession or under the control of the

same person.

Even if it says AR-15 it is OK, since the list is obsolete with the substantially identical clause.

 

This seems to be not true, since we know the recent M1 Carbine copies were legal from the "assault weapons checklist" standpoint, but not legal since they said "M1 Carbine" on them, right?

People gave Leroy Stout crap for his position that AR 15s are in a gray area and therefore, he won't transfer them. When you think about it, he's right.

 

Is an AR15 with no evil features illegal? I'm talking a real AR15 made by Colt. Answer: Yes, because it's on the list. You guys confirmed this above.

 

Now, is a BCM or Stag or Spikes AR15 with no evil features illegal? Why not? It is substantially identical to the Colt AR15 with no evil features...

 

So, we are saying that part of the law no longer matters?

Living in the republic of New Jersikstan I wouldn't test anything with the AR15 on it unless you are willing to press you point in court. I have to agree with Vlad on the banned list or substantially identical to the banned list. Colt AR15 is named as prohibited. I think it's straight forward but why not contact one of the 2A or NRA lawyers in NJ? I think you can get access to the advice if you are a member of the ANJRPC.

People gave Leroy Stout crap for his position that AR 15s are in a gray area and therefore, he won't transfer them. When you think about it, he's right.

 

Is an AR15 with no evil features illegal? I'm talking a real AR15 made by Colt. Answer: Yes, because it's on the list. You guys confirmed this above.

 

Now, is a BCM or Stag or Spikes AR15 with no evil features illegal? Why not? It is substantially identical to the Colt AR15 with no evil features...

 

So, we are saying that part of the law no longer matters?

 

If it is on the named list, it is illegal, as in the name being on the firearm. If it is not on the named list, the test is the NJAC evil feature list to see if it is "substantially identical". If it passes the evil feature test, then it is not "substantially identical" and good to go.

 

The latest BS with the M1 carbine look-alike and I/O AK look-alike revolves around the AG harassing dealers into not selling them, and in a sense placing a defacto-ban on allowing any dealer to sell them in NJ. They are claiming "substantially identical" without using the NJAC evil feature list test. Is it wrong? Absolutely. Basically the AG is flat out daring a dealer to sell these rifles, get arrested/charged, and slug it out in court. There is a good chance the dealer will win, but most likely only after bankrupting him/her and screwing over their NJ dealer status and even their FFL. Too much to loose, too little to gain in the eyes of someone trying to make a living in the already tough business of being a gun dealer in NJ.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.