Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Tennessee woman arrested at WTC Memorial

Featured Replies

This was posted earlier.

Want to hear something even crazier. Police arent allowed to bring off duty weapons into the memorial. If I go off duty I have to check my gun.

 

I will say again, if only our 2A rights were recognized this kind of crap wouldn't happen.

Want to hear something even crazier. Police arent allowed to bring off duty weapons into the memorial. If I go off duty I have to check my gun.

 

That's really stupid considering it would be a prime target for lots of press if a bad guy wants it that way.

The thing is she's in a way being arrested for trying to obey the law. Yes I know she was

not aware of the actual law and she was in reality breaking NYC law, but her intent was to

obey it. Hence a perfect example of how gun laws don't stop criminals they just make law

abiding citizens lives inherently more difficult and in some cases ruin them.

 

Do you think a criminal would see that sign, go to a cop, and say: "Ah man I was gonna go

commit a crime around these parts but I see you have a no gun on premises policy. Can

you please hold this for me until I come back? I will then resume my crimes."

cant nra make some noise and support, arent firearm organization going to show support for a supposedly law abiding citizen that made a mistake.

cant nra make some noise and support, arent firearm organization going to show support for a supposedly law abiding citizen that made a mistake.

 

NRA seems to have 0 presence in states like NJ and NY... which is really annoying for those of us stuck here.

somebody posted ny times says ccw holder are dangerous, gun enthusiast or nra should answer that! the dangerous ones are the gangbangers that are hanging out in the street corners that has a concealed carry weapon with no serial numbers n no permit either, if you know what i mean.

  • Author

NRA seems to have 0 presence in states like NJ and NY... which is really annoying for those of us stuck here.

 

The NRA may not do much, if anything, in our local area but they do plenty on the national level. They’re not stupid; they’re not going to enter a battle they know they won’t win. We need the NJ2AS, SAF, and the ANJRPC (affiliated with the NRA), to continue chipping away at the mountain of BS in NJ. If they continue winning small battles maybe we can get a big enough crack in the mountain that the NRA will see an opportunity to step in and rip that mountain down.

The thing is she's in a way being arrested for trying to obey the law. Yes I know she was

not aware of the actual law and she was in reality breaking NYC law, but her intent was to

obey it. Hence a perfect example of how gun laws don't stop criminals they just make law

abiding citizens lives inherently more difficult and in some cases ruin them.

 

 

 

Do no guns signs have force of law in NYC?

I don't want to inflame anyone by voicing an opinion that would go against the apparent sentiment of this thread, but shouldn't Ms. Graves done a little bit of gun laws research before traveling with her gun interstate, much less to a place like NYC? Her hometown people, in their interviews covered elsewhere on the web, say as much. No wonder NRA wouldn't wade into Ms. Graves's case - her "law abiding gun owner" image is currently suffering a certain flaw, namely the fact that she actually BROKE the law. I am an absolute novice to the firearms enthusiast scene, so my assumptions could very well be wrong, but I am assuming here that the ignorance of the law is NOT the kind of impression the gun advocates want to cultivate.

Correct, but I think the point was more how something as simple as being ignorant of a regional law that is different from where you are from can lead to a potentially felony for doing nothing actually harmful because of asinine laws. But I could be wrong. :D

I don't want to inflame anyone by voicing an opinion that would go against the apparent sentiment of this thread, but shouldn't Ms. Graves done a little bit of gun laws research before traveling with her gun interstate, much less to a place like NYC? Her hometown people, in their interviews covered elsewhere on the web, say as much. No wonder NRA wouldn't wade into Ms. Graves's case - her "law abiding gun owner" image is currently suffering a certain flaw, namely the fact that she actually BROKE the law. I am an absolute novice to the firearms enthusiast scene, so my assumptions could very well be wrong, but I am assuming here that the ignorance of the law is NOT the kind of impression the gun advocates want to cultivate.

 

You are right but it's hard to justify a law where something perfectly legal in PA could land you in prison for years in NJ or NY. Just doesn't make logical sense that something could be so bad in one state and yet perfectly legal in another.

I am an absolute novice to the firearms enthusiast scene, so my assumptions could very well be wrong, but I am assuming here that the ignorance of the law is NOT the kind of impression the gun advocates want to cultivate.

 

You are absolutely correct, which is part of the reason why case law will not prevail for this particular problem. Gun owners are under such pressure to appear as the most strict law-abiding citizens that some would turn against their peers for minor infractions such as this. And yes, this IS a minor infraction-- can you really say a felony sentence and up to 7 years in jail is an appropriate punishment for two people with legally-obtained guns, possessing valid carry permits for their home states (had the requisite background checks) and asked to check their weapons, for crying out loud!

 

Should felonies be handed out to those that hunt without the plug for their pump action? I consider the two to be on the same level. And I still wouldn't try either.

 

But how the gun community behaves doesn't matter. Nobody with a gun permit would be selected to be a juror (conflict of interest), making the chances of a gun owning juror very slim (even if so, he or she would not be a handgun owner) so jury nullification is out.

 

This needs to be turned around legislatively. If enough people that feel strongly about this issue to garner the support of a legislator, he or she had better have quite the constituency in order to stay afloat.

  • 2 months later...

She pled out to a misdemeanor and $200 fine:

 

http://www.nydailynews.com/news/crime/tennessee-tourist-brought-gun-9-11-memorial-misdemeanor-plea-deal-article-1.1046815?localLinksEnabled=false

 

Keep setting those precedents out of staters! Pretty soon they'll be questioning why it's classified as a felony when so many only end up with misdemeanor slaps on the wrists.

Did she get her gun back??

Wow, $200 and that's it, while in the big picture still a bunch of BS, but with the way NYC is, that's a big win and I see as a step in the right direction as far as verdicts go..

Good result for her and it's good to see some measure of restraint here by the prosecutor.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.