Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Probably gonna be put on walking post for sticking up for fellow gun enthusiast..

Featured Replies

I think that is just tin hat rhetoric. You can't establish PC after the request. The police need PC before the request. That said, just respectfully and politely decline.

 

Thats an interesting remark. But how do you determine when pc was determined? Does leo have to disclose pc to you prior to him asking to search? If not it doesnt mean a thing because at any time after the question all leo has to say is " I noticed so & so before I asked thats why...".

  • Replies 112
  • Views 4.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • BlueLineFish
    BlueLineFish

    I may be taking a risk here with my opinion but here it goes. As a fellow LEO what I would have done is after subject was loaded into the bus I would have taken the homeowner aside and verified the fi

  • I'm kind of perplexed by this whole thread. First, checking the guys "papers" does not determine if the gun is legally owned. It's a pointless exercise.   Second, the desire to ensure that you don

  • Do you search vehicles you pull over for speeding just in case they have something illegal in the car to cover your own a**? What if you pull over a car and don't search it what if they go on to do so

" You can't establish PC after the request."

 

I dont think I agree with this statement. If I ask to search your car because your giving off odd behaviors, which doesnt establish PC, and you decline, and I shine my flashlight into your back seat and see a bloody axe and a severed head, I think PC is established and will hold up.

" You can't establish PC after the request."

 

I dont think I agree with this statement. If I ask to search your car because your giving off odd behaviors, which doesnt establish PC, and you decline, and I shine my flashlight into your back seat and see a bloody axe and a severed head, I think PC is established and will hold up.

 

Your first PC would have been odd behavior, probably not meeting the criteria for search. A severed head in plain sight is totally enough, but different PC.

I have a simple question here. If someone who is not a prohibited person has a gun in their own home, there is no requirement for paperwork. Maybe he bought it with a PPP years in the past but hasn't got a copy handy, so he can't produce it. So an LEO asks for paperwork and the guy says "I have no idea what you're talking about." What comes next? Taking his gun is theft.

I would have no idea what I would even show if asked to "see my papers," on my Glock. I was told when I moved here by my local PD that I didn't need any paperwork. My NYC permit has since been returned and it had my serial # on it.

 

Being asked by the police to see papers on my handgun after being told by the police I did not need any would certainly make me act a little strange, as in "huh? - am I in some sort of Orwellian- Khafkaesque nightmare?"

 

It would seem to me that if the Sergeant really wanted to cover his a** and knew anything about the law he could have easily asked "let's see if this man is a prohibited person or not," and do his own checking. Not saying it is 100% right in the circumstances, but at least he wouldn't be asking for something that may not exist.

I think that is just tin hat rhetoric. You can't establish PC after the request. The police need PC before the request. That said, just respectfully and politely decline.

" You can't establish PC after the request."

 

I dont think I agree with this statement. If I ask to search your car because your giving off odd behaviors, which doesnt establish PC, and you decline, and I shine my flashlight into your back seat and see a bloody axe and a severed head, I think PC is established and will hold up.

 

Agreed. My point is that simply declining a request for a search does not (should not) establish PC. I should have worded it as you can't establish PC after the search.

I am in a quandry too if this ever happened to me. I moved here from another state and have NO paperwork for any of my guns What 'paperwork' was he seriously asking for? What would have happened if the homeowner could not produce any like myself?

If the police ever request to search your vehicle, the answer should ALWAYS be a resounding NO.

I am in a quandry too if this ever happened to me. I moved here from another state and have NO paperwork for any of my guns What 'paperwork' was he seriously asking for? What would have happened if the homeowner could not produce any like myself?

 

 

All the more reason to get to know the NJ firearm laws and your (lack of) rights under them. As long as your guns AND mags are NJ legal your "worst" fear is to be hassled by ignorant leos, biased judges and opportunistic prosecuters.

 

 

 

All the more reason to get to know the NJ firearm laws and your (lack of) rights under them. As long as your guns AND mags are NJ legal your "worst" fear is to be hassled by ignorant leos, biased judges and opportunistic prosecuters.

 

Which could lead to some expensive lawyer bills and jail time. Awesome that even doing the right things could ruin your life. I mean odds are that it won't happen. Sad that it could happen though.

In my humble non expert opinion, if you cant prove ownership, the officer can indeed confiscate it because in new jersey all ownership is banned. The burden of proof is on the citizen. The words" posses at your own peril" is where this comes into play. It will then become your burdan to prove ownership and exception(guilty until proven innocent). In the mean time your posession is going to be hockey pucked around the evidence room until you can get in front of a judge to get it back in about 6 months if your lucky. This is why in the other thread I stated that although Im not required to, I carry copies of my PPP when transporting so I can nip it in the bud and prove ownership right ther on the spot so I dont have to fight out proving ownership/exception in front of a judge. IMO this is a dasterdly move by the state because most people ensnared in this perdicament may just decide the value of the pistol is far less than the attourney to reclaim it :(.

In my humble non expert opinion, if you cant prove ownership, the officer can indeed confiscate it because in new jersey all ownership is banned.

 

Point is well taken, but even when I lived in NYC I didn't need a receipt. I had my premise permit with my serial number on it. I had to give that back as part of NYC proceedure.

 

Ain' that screwey? "Officer, I don't have my receipt or PPP because I bought it in NYC in 1999 and they don't require that I have one." Of course it is registered to me, but apparently in the O.P's situation that is not what they were checking.

I can't see how someone would take it as a personal attack if a police officer asked to see their paperwork. All you need to do is simply decline, and that is that. No harm caused by them trying to be thorough. People need to relax.

 

I have been asked for consent to search my car in the past. My reply, "I don't think you have any reason to search my car at this time." Both officers that were present at the scene I'm sure didn't like the answer but they of course complied.

 

Taking it so far as to claim it is an attack on a citizen's constitutional rights just by asking a simple question seems a bit over board, and boderline paranoia to me.

I can't see how someone would take it as a personal attack if a police officer asked to see their paperwork. All you need to do is simply decline, and that is that. No harm caused by them trying to be thorough. People need to relax.

 

I have been asked for consent to search my car in the past. My reply, "I don't think you have any reason to search my car at this time." Both officers that were present at the scene I'm sure didn't like the answer but they of course complied.

 

Taking it so far as to claim it is an attack on a citizen's constitutional rights just by asking a simple question seems a bit over board, and boderline paranoia to me.

 

This isn't about a request, it's about a demand. Big difference.

I can't see how someone would take it as a personal attack if a police officer asked to see their paperwork. All you need to do is simply decline, and that is that. No harm caused by them trying to be thorough. People need to relax.

 

I have been asked for consent to search my car in the past. My reply, "I don't think you have any reason to search my car at this time." Both officers that were present at the scene I'm sure didn't like the answer but they of course complied.

 

Taking it so far as to claim it is an attack on a citizen's constitutional rights just by asking a simple question seems a bit over board, and boderline paranoia to me.

 

That was my point. I would ASK not DEMAND. Those flaming me chose to ignore that point. Oh well. I have decided that I really don't give a **** because nobody here really knows me.

That was my point. I would ASK not DEMAND. Those flaming me chose to ignore that point. Oh well. I have decided that I really don't give a **** because nobody here really knows me.

Not exactly an ideal way to win friends and influence people but c'est la vie........

Looks like i will be spending far less time on here, if at all now, from now on. It's been fun.

 

That was my point...

This site is addicting, huh? :lol:

There will always be a difference of opinion in any forums. Don't let it get to you.

I think what you're seeing is the frustration with the strict gun laws that make common folks like us into "suspects". Add that to a Sgt. giving someone a hard time over a legal firearm...and you see the result.

 

 

 

 

This site is addicting, huh? :lol:

There will always be a difference of opinion in any forums. Don't let it get to you.

I think what you're seeing is the frustration with the strict gun laws that make common folks like us into "suspects". Add that to a Sgt. giving someone a hard time over a legal firearm...and you see the result.

 

I decided that there is no need to punish myself. I am fine with there being different opinions but others don't seem to be ok with my view of a situation. I in no way advocated demanding info but that apparantly didn't matter and many chose to attack my credibility as a LEO. this is something I take very seriously. I too get frustrated with the gun laws because the laws really don't stop the criminals from using them. They just get them elsewhere.

 

That was my point. I would ASK not DEMAND. Those flaming me chose to ignore that point. Oh well. I have decided that I really don't give a **** because nobody here really knows me.

I understand that, and I agree with you. Just the simple fact that you are a member on this site you would think other members would realize that you are an enthusiast. I think what you are saying is correct.

 

This isn't about a request, it's about a demand. Big difference.

 

The SGT demanded that the OP retrieve proof. The OP did not "demand" proof of ownership of the homeowner. The homeowner voluntarily displayed it to the officers. I think what the OP did, and what BlueLineFish is saying is to proper way to handle this situation. The SGT did not follow proper procedure in my eyes.

Glad you stuck around Joe, come to a meet-up with me and you'll have a blast!

If I ask and you decide to tell me that answer. Based on the totality of the circumstances I will take you at your word. I have that discretion. Its seems that I am now stereotyped as the cop who could care less about the law and I do what I want because i have a badge. You couldn't be more wrong. I am not looking for your approval on how I do my job because most of you have no idea what the job is like to be on. You want to attack my credibility and i have a major problem with that. Sorry I have an opinion different than the norm but I am allowed to ask what I want when I want. Your choice to answer or not. Think what you want about me. I don't need your approval. OP... stay safe out there and keep doing what you feel is right. I respect the hell out of that. All my other LEO's stay safe as well.

 

After seeing what I am dealing with on this board and how quickly people are attacked for a difference of opinion. How quickly my credibility has come into question from strangers really breeds a lot of resentment for this forum. Looks like i will be spending far less time on here, if at all now, from now on. It's been fun.

 

I'm kind of perplexed by this whole thread. First, checking the guys "papers" does not determine if the gun is legally owned. It's a pointless exercise.

 

Second, the desire to ensure that you don't leave a gun in the hands of a criminal is valid objective. Hence the dilemma.

 

So, I see only one course of action. You know the guy's name and address, why not just run a warrant search on him to see if he is wanted for anything. If he's clean, you have no RAS and you walk away with a clear conscience. If he is wanted or has a history, you now have RAS and can do whatever you need to, again, with a clear conscience.

 

That's the problem. There is no distinction between the law-abiding and the criminals in NJ gun law. That needs to be part of the law, and it needs to be taught to the police. First find out what side he's on, then you treat the person accordingly.

 

The dilemma that all law enforcement officers face is that NJ's gun laws are unconstitutional. If you believe that, then you must believe that an order to enforce them is an unlawful order. So, you can't begin with enforcement of 2C:39-5, since it is unconstitutional. You must begin with identifying whether or not the individual has criminal intent or is a prohibited person. Once you identify the person as a bad guy, then you can enforce the statutes in good conscience. That's the way I see it.

 

BlueLineFish,

Please don't be offended by the impassioned responses. They didn't create this dilemma, and neither did you. It takes vigorous debate like this to try and find the right answer. If I remember my history correctly, there was much acrimony prior to the signing of the Declaration of Independence and the ratification of the Constitution and the writing and adoption of the Bill of Rights. Don't walk away. The need for us to stick together is far more important. You might not like what was said, but, understand that the responses are an indicator that the right course of action has not been discovered yet and look for the answer.

I in no way advocated demanding info...

 

This tempered element of your point of view didn't come across fully in your first post. You mentioned that you would have "verified the firearm was legal" and if the home owner didn't have his papers you would "check back at HQ". Viewed infront of a backdrop of perpetual frustration with how gun owner's tend to be treated in this state, I think many [including myself to an extent] took your post to mean that you consider mere gun ownership as warranting suspicion & further investigation of any party failing to produce proof of lawful purchase/ownership on the spot, hence the negative feedback.

 

You've since clarified yourself a bit and I do get where you're coming from. You're not looking to violate anyone's rights, but at the end of the day you're still just a guy doing a job. Like most people, you have your beliefs, but still can't afford to put your job in jepordy over pure idealism. I get that, and I think others do as well, but we can't help but still feel frustration with the standard operating procedures pushed by police leadership in situations such as the OP's.

A simple solution in my mind would be when you ask for the paperwork, that a follow up statement that it is his right at that time to decide not to provide said paperwork.

 

BLF I simply believe that the general public inherently believes, especially in this state, that they have a legal obligation to comply with the request. We both know that MANY officers use thses thought processes and the general publics lack of understanding their rights against them quite often. Well if your investigating someone to begin with, I understand the situation. However, in a case as described where a citizen has done nothing to bring attention to himself and gave no evidence whatsoever that he had done anything wrong, there should be no reason to start investigating him just because he excercised the right to protect himself.

 

Shane

I wonder how much of the us and them mentality is brought into the job and how much of it is developed while doing the job.

It has been my experience that the us/them mentality has 2 distinct scources. One can be the operating environment of the LE agency. The other can be the agency its self. If your working "Beruit" I think that a U V.T disposition is likely to occur. But I have also seen in prevelent in agencies where it just seems to be the rhetoric of that particuler agency. I swear the brass on some PD's watch too much TV because I hear them quoting movie lines straight out of Lethal Weapon 3!!!! From a 10,000 ft view, it seems that if the brass and training officers of an egency are anti, then the "mood" of said agency follows suit. I cant even begin to count how many conversations with LE I have had when the position of said officer was only LE and mil should have guns. I have run into the rare officer that actually listenes to logic with an open mind and understands the arguments. And then there are those that defer to the "well thats how I feel" position with not a single shred of fact or logic to support their position. These are the officers that I believe come from "anti oriented agencies" because I can feel the programming in their position. Its clear their position is not their own. I actually intended to start a thread about the very topic of LE's that hold the position only LE and mill should have guns. Although I hesitate because I do not want an LE bashing thread as that is not my intention. But when you hear a statement like that from a particuler segment repeatedly, it bares looking into the reasoning behind it. I was in one of these debates 2 weeks ago with me Uncle and Godfather who is NYPD. It was pretty in depth and in my opinion he failed to present a single argument and what I heard over and over was "its because Im a cop I feel that way" The one statement he seemed to get rather wide eyed over is when I asked him how he would feel now that he is retired if he was not allowed to carry anymore. He reacted in near horrer saying he would feel unsafe and would be VERY upset. My answer of course was thats how we get to feel all the time. But it really got me thinking. Focusing in on the Mil and LE. Hmmmm So an officer in a state like the peoples republic of new jersey who returns to the ranks of normal citizen when he retires, gets to retain the ability to carry. But someone from the military who may have been all over the world and seen heavy action carrying all manor of full auto weapons and recieving the equivilent of hundreds of thousands of dollars in training, when returned to the civilian world CAN NOT CARRY. So in reality it becomes only LE can have guns in states like NJ. And that got me thinking even further. If your retired LE in NJ, you have to qualify every year to keep your CCW. But if you are one of the few civilian CCW holders in NJ, they dont have this requirement. So this begs the question of why do we have such a mish mash and swinging pendulum of different right for what amounts to all the same American citizens!!!!!! So the war veteran that returned from 2 tours in Iraq as a SF operator and trainer for special forces that came backed and served on local SWAT for 5 years and retired but did not qualify this year because he feels it is a moral issue to have to pay to qualify to maintain his right of self protection CAN NOT CARRY. But the guy that is a friend of the current court or political regime can having never served either mil or LE but knows the right people can without any training etc etc. This just demonstrates how bad the laws and system have become in my mind.

 

To those officers that are pro 2A, I tip my hat to you and give you the recognition you deserve because in your field, I think its a bit of a tough run to hold the opinion you do. Especially if your in an agency with an anti overtone.

Hmmmm So an officer in a state like the peoples republic of new jersey who returns to the ranks of normal citizen when he retires, gets to retain the ability to carry. But someone from the military who may have been all over the world and seen heavy action carrying all manor of full auto weapons and recieving the equivilent of hundreds of thousands of dollars in training, when returned to the civilian world CAN NOT CARRY.

 

I don't want to sound contrary or argumentative but some of the people I served with in Iraq were actual criminals that have not been arrested for crimes they've committed. eesh, I can't think of those guys with a CCW. Not to mention the complete morons. :fie:

My opinion is an officer always has a right to ask. Especially in an instance where a weapon is shown. The purpose isn't always to get proof it is also to see what other info they can gather.

 

I am going to duck now.

My opinion is an officer always has a right to ask. Especially in an instance where a weapon is shown. The purpose isn't always to get proof it is also to see what other info they can gather.

 

I am going to duck now.

 

You better put your body armor on. I forgot to wear mine when I posted and got shot up pretty bad.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.