Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Family members can apparently use other family members guns in Home Self defense

Featured Replies

I dont know if this has ever been asked (im sure it has ) and its a little off topic but when i take my wifes gun to the range with out her am i committing a crime?

  • Replies 63
  • Views 13.3k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

Most Popular Posts

  • Irrespective of whether or not a spouse using your weapon during an emergency/life or death situation is technically an illegal transfer, wouldn't the legal defense of "duress" be an acceptable defens

  • according to the NJ2AS meeting where Evan Nappen was our speaker, it would be considered an illegal transfer if she used your gun in a home defense situation. Unless you have something in writing from

  • I seriously doubt it's ever been pursued or that it ever will be. My wife knows how to use my guns, if someone breaks in when I'm not there, woe unto them. I'll worry about an ahole prosecutor afte

I dont know if this has ever been asked (im sure it has ) and its a little off topic but when i take my wifes gun to the range with out her am i committing a crime?

 

 

Yes. Don't do that

The relevence to the current discussion, Mikee, is that I think these are cases that we would say look legal and in the right just like we would about the transfer discussion. But NJ tends to not see it in this light.

Yes , neither of those stories has to do with the situation I proposed to the State Police and an attorney.

 

In the LI case , the gentlemen fired warning shots outside based on verbal threats. In the NJ case it does not clearly say someone's life was in danger ..sounds like a fistfight ..sounds like the brother grabbed a gun and went outside with it and waved it as a deterrent . Hey , it worked.

 

I do not recall any situation in NJ where a woman was home alone during a home invasion and shot the intruder with a gun. Not saying it did not happen , I would just think it would be high profile nationwide news , much like the recent mother in OK who defended herself and her baby.

 

I do recall home invasions in NJ news ..grandmothers beaten up , rapes .However , none where the threatened resident shot her attacker. I also recall domestic violence cases where spouses used guns on each other. So to my knowledge there are no cases suitable for appropriate comparison .

 

My case I asked about involved : I am home alone , felt my life and my children's lives were at stake , am I am in trouble if I use my husband's gun? The answer was no. If I shoot someone who is obviously robbing my TV..that is a legal problem regardless of who owns the gun. I am talking someone breaking into your home to harm you .

 

In my scenario I proposed , my husband is not home . My first line of defense/deterrent , which is my two large dogs that take up the first floor , have been neutralized and did not get the job done Or maybe they are in the yard ( perps case homes) . I have no opportunity to grab my kids and run out of the door. If I have had the opportunity to call 911 , I don't have time to wait for the police because they got IN my home . Maybe I have retreated upstairs or a bedroom where there is a phone and where the guns are kept.. because I have no access to the exits . I get my husband's gun out of our safe and I fire because they are still trying to get to me or my children. That is exactly what happened in OK. She was allowed to shoot her attackers , and even though our laws are more strict , I would be allowed to shoot the attacker as well in a situation where I had no retreat and my and maybe my children's lives are in danger.

 

There is no law that specifically states I can't use my husband's gun in my own home in self defense , it does say I can posses ANY gun in my home. It is such a gray area , yes. But even the most liberal of judges would not commit career suicide on finding some way to vilify a scared mother cowering in a room with her children while attackers are trying to get to her , who used her husband's gun to save her and her family.

 

I would be shocked to see a case where a wife used her gun against a home invader in her own home even get to the indictment stage , never mind a going to trial . I would expect a police investigation , with no subsequent charges against the wife filed , in the situation I described.

 

I'm not talking about a kid running out and saying say hallo to my little friend because his brother is in a fistfight on the lawn. If the threat is on my lawn and I am in the house , I'm calling 911.

I spoke with the Detective at my local PD and a buddy in NJSP yesterday independently and asked them both this question (issue of spouse using husbands' gun if he's gone, incapacitated, etc) - as we would be in the same boat at my house. Both indicated they could not ever envision a scenario where their respective units would charge someone in the home - provided they met the criteria of the law - attempt to retreat, fearful for life, etc - that there would be no issue with someone defending themselves and they would not foresee criminal consequences for that. Civil consequences from their family of the burglar likely as I think we'd all expecdt, but not criminal charges from the PD. Don't know about extrapolating that to every town in NJ, but both also reminded me the law and jurors often refer to the 'reasonable person' standard, and what would a reasonable person do, etc within the interpretation of the law.

I spoke with the Detective at my local PD and a buddy in NJSP yesterday independently and asked them both this question (issue of spouse using husbands' gun if he's gone, incapacitated, etc) - as we would be in the same boat at my house. Both indicated they could not ever envision a scenario where their respective units would charge someone in the home - provided they met the criteria of the law - attempt to retreat, fearful for life, etc - that there would be no issue with someone defending themselves and they would not foresee criminal consequences for that. Civil consequences from their family of the burglar likely as I think we'd all expecdt, but not criminal charges from the PD. Don't know about extrapolating that to every town in NJ, but both also reminded me the law and jurors often refer to the 'reasonable person' standard, and what would a reasonable person do, etc within the interpretation of the law.

 

What thread are we in? My head hurts.

Im not a lawyer nor did I stay at a holiday in but the transfer law seems to indicate the only place a transfer is legal is at the range in the presence of the owner.....

 

2C:58-3.1. Temporary transfer of firearms

1. a. Notwithstanding the provisions of N.J.S.2C:39-9, N.J.S.2C:58-2, N.J.S.2C:58-3 or any other statute to the contrary concerning the transfer or disposition of firearms, the legal owner, or a dealer licensed under N.J.S.2C:58-2, may temporarily transfer a handgun, rifleor shotgun to another person who is 18 years of age or older, whether or not the person receiving the firearm holds a firearms purchaser identification card or a permit to carry a handgun. The person to whom a handgun, rifle or shotgun is temporarily transferred by the legal owner of the firearm or a licensed dealer may receive, possess, carry and use that handgun, rifle or shotgun, if the transfer is made upon a firing range operated by a licensed dealer, by a law enforcement agency, a legally recognized military organization or a rifle or pistol club which has filed a copy of its charter with the superintendent and annually submits to the superintendent a list of its members and if the firearm is received, possessed, carried and used for the sole purpose of target practice, trap or skeet shooting, or competition upon that firing range or instruction and training at any location.

I spoke with the Detective at my local PD and a buddy in NJSP yesterday independently and asked them both this question (issue of spouse using husbands' gun if he's gone, incapacitated, etc) - as we would be in the same boat at my house. Both indicated they could not ever envision a scenario where their respective units would charge someone in the home - provided they met the criteria of the law - attempt to retreat, fearful for life, etc - that there would be no issue with someone defending themselves and they would not foresee criminal consequences for that. Civil consequences from their family of the burglar likely as I think we'd all expecdt, but not criminal charges from the PD. Don't know about extrapolating that to every town in NJ, but both also reminded me the law and jurors often refer to the 'reasonable person' standard, and what would a reasonable person do, etc within the interpretation of the law.

 

Just make sure you dont say burglar to anyone if this ever happens in your home. Lose the word from your vocabulary :) Intruder , attacker , assailant , home invader , would be rapist , would be attacker.

 

It is amazing how mere lexicon can create a case where one did not exist. I can see it in the civil law suit by the attackers family lawyer " you said you felt you had to shoot the "burglar" if he was just a burglar , why did you feel your life was threatened ? "

 

I would only ever fire a weapon if I felt my or my kids life was in danger , but accidental use of a term can put doubt into the case , unfortunately.

And for the record, as I said earlier in this thread:

 

Protect yourself first and foremost.

The relevence of the other cases is that there ARE those in positions of authority who WILL side against you even if your in what we would consider reasonable circumstances.

Im not a lawyer nor did I stay at a holiday in but the transfer law seems to indicate the only place a transfer is legal is at the range in the presence of the owner.....

 

2C:58-3.1. Temporary transfer of firearms

1. a. Notwithstanding the provisions of N.J.S.2C:39-9, N.J.S.2C:58-2, N.J.S.2C:58-3 or any other statute to the contrary concerning the transfer or disposition of firearms, the legal owner, or a dealer licensed under N.J.S.2C:58-2, may temporarily transfer a handgun, rifleor shotgun to another person who is 18 years of age or older, whether or not the person receiving the firearm holds a firearms purchaser identification card or a permit to carry a handgun. The person to whom a handgun, rifle or shotgun is temporarily transferred by the legal owner of the firearm or a licensed dealer may receive, possess, carry and use that handgun, rifle or shotgun, if the transfer is made upon a firing range operated by a licensed dealer, by a law enforcement agency, a legally recognized military organization or a rifle or pistol club which has filed a copy of its charter with the superintendent and annually submits to the superintendent a list of its members and if the firearm is received, possessed, carried and used for the sole purpose of target practice, trap or skeet shooting, or competition upon that firing range or instruction and training at any location.

 

In NJ guns are illegal... For the most part the laws is series of exemptions.... In the law it states as one exemption range gun shop etc... But that is a fraction of the law... The rest of the law is nothing will prevent carrying ANY gun in ones home... Like I said... Someone breaks into your house and has a gun you take it? Illegal transfer? NO of course not

Hey for me its simple. I have no trust of NJ and will try and isolate myself from its idiocy at every turn. But on th subject of this debate and for the purpose of this debate only, I will have to side with what a leading firearms attourney has advised. I still fully expect my wife to take my pistol and do what needs to be done. But in the interest of said insulation, I will be having her get her own permits and pistol. The cost is minimal for protecting ourselves from criminals on both sides of the fence!

But if he was on his own property outside the home, why is this an offense. You're allowed to possess and carry anywhere in your home or property.

 

He didn't use deadly force.

 

 

And for the record, as I said earlier in this thread:

 

Protect yourself first and foremost.

 

 

As a martial arts instructor I know always says during his gun disarming seminars , when somebody inevitably sticks up their hand and asks if they can get in trouble if they take the gun away from their attacker and then shoot their attacker during a struggle - " you might get charged with something , who cares if they charge you with something after you shoot them ? If they get their gun back , you are sentenced to death"

I feel there is something lost in translation here.

 

There is a difference between

 

1. The law.

2. What you could or would be arrested for or prosecuted on.

3. What one feels comfortable doing aside from the law.

4. A misinterpretation of the law.

 

Vlad, what you are saying, is the law, and what any practical, non-biased, person, without an agenda would reason. What Shane is saying, that even with that being the law, it does NOT mean you couldn't be prosecuted otherwise. That happens ALL THE TIME.

 

The point being, know the law, know what can happen regardless of the law, and then act according to YOUR own best interest, separate from the law. Because in the end, it often boils down to something else completely separate from the law but I digress

 

The point actually is, that laws don't matter, only the enforcement of laws as perceived by those in positions of power.

I see the arguments here but what is the big deal with the wife just having a firearm of her own? I understand that if the husband is down for the count and she pick his gun up, but why not have your own gun. renders this whole point moot.

I see the arguments here but what is the big deal with the wife just having a firearm of her own? I understand that if the husband is down for the count and she pick his gun up, but why not have your own gun. renders this whole point moot.

 

Because that isn't reality. Not everyone has a firearm. So that is not a solution to the situation/question. It renders it moot because it is irrelevant. A solution to a situation has to be, you know, applicable.

 

Bad guy breaks into house. Wife uses husbands gun to defender herself. Is it legal? That is the situation. Saying "she should have just had her own gun" is a meaningless comment.

There are some really long drawn out discusionins on some really simple concepts on these boards lately.

 

I can tell you this after reading a few of these threads, I will NEVER, show my wife any of these discussions.

She should never have to think about using one of my firearms where deadly force is applicable. Keep the eyes on the prize - your life. What else is there?

 

I can live with a civil law suit brought about by my wife saving her own life using my handgun. I anything else hasn't got all that much of a point.

Because that isn't reality. Not everyone has a firearm. So that is not a solution to the situation/question. It renders it moot because it is irrelevant. A solution to a situation has to be, you know, applicable.

 

Bad guy breaks into house. Wife uses husbands gun to defender herself. Is it legal? That is the situation. Saying "she should have just had her own gun" is a meaningless comment.

 

I see the debate but I don't believe that is a reality. If the husband can own a handgun, then the spouse can/ should also. While I agree that I would want my wife to use the first weapon to her avail to save herself and then deal with the sh1t storm afterward, I would prefer she be used to using that weapon..

 

based on the OP's question. Is it legal, not from what I have read but we would all preferred to be judged by 12 than carried by 6. I think NJ would find some way to make it worse than it needs to be.

I see the debate but I don't believe that is a reality. If the husband can own a handgun, then the spouse can/ should also.

 

What can or should be the case is irrelevant. I should be able to carry legally in NJ. I can carry in NJ. But how would those opinions help anyone who gets caught doing so? How would the opinion someones wife should have had her own gun help the wife who uses her husbands to defend herself in a break in situation?

 

The answer? It doesn't help at all. So yes, that is the reality of the situation and discussion at hand in this thread.

The way the law is written, it's illegal. What is the need for discussion? get her a gun, no need for a discussion!

The way the law is written, it's illegal. What is the need for discussion? get her a gun, no need for a discussion!

 

Using a red herring doesn't win a debate.

 

And the debate is about the legality. If you would look, there are statues that are seemingly conflicting. Some (like yourself), are saying it is an illegal transfer. Others (like myself), are saying it is not illegal. So no matter how many times you repeat yourself, it doesn't magically make the debate over.

 

But you know what, I'll play anyways. I'll go along with it being as easy as getting everybody in the entire state of NJ a gun.

 

Oh wait, this is NJ, and in order to buy a gun you need an FPID, and for a handgun another permit as well. So what do you do in the time between trying to get a gun and actually having one. Say this fictional wife applies for a FPID, and while she is waiting to receive it, her home is broken into? What say you know? You mean even your convoluted argument is flawed further? Weird...

I guess I'll jump in here.

 

While 2C:39-6 does say you can possess ANY gun in your home, it is not the ONLY law in the statutes that applies to firearms. Also, 2C:39-6 only exempts you from 2C:39-5, not 2C:58. So, while you couldn't be charged with unlawful posession under 2C:39-5b/c, you CAN be charged under 2C:58-3.1.

 

They are two completely different statutes and 2C:39-6 does not exempt from the transfer requirements of 2C:58.

 

Whether or not it would ever happen is a different story. I highly doubt any prosecutor would try someone under illegal transfer for an otherwise good shoot, but he could.

 

In short, while the possession (and use) of another's firearm in your house is not illegal, the manner in which you came into possession (the transfer) is illegal.

While I am not arguing with your explanation of the statues, as I am inclined to agree, I am arguing with the logic behind it.

 

As I said before, in other threads, how can the transfer be illegal if the possession is legal on both ends? Statueally (yes, I did just make that word up), it is illegal, but as a matter of actuality, I don't see how it is. I mean, think about it. The only time anything other then reading the words in the statues, that anything illegal is going on, is a period of limbo. Some period of time after (for example) the husband transfers the firearm to his wife, but before the wife receives the firearm from him. Talk about some wacky laws that have no actual translation to reality!

Well lets send this convo straight to the deep end. keep in mind there are gun laws on the books for NJ for items THAT DO NOT EXIST YET!!!!!!

While I am not arguing with your explanation of the statues, as I am inclined to agree, I am arguing with the logic behind it.

 

Law and logic, in NJ especially, seldom accompany one another.

What about the fact that anyone who is in your house with authorization is permitted under the law to use deadly force against an intruder without retreat, or surrender of possession to defend their life and the lives of others in the house.

 

What is this authorized person supposed to use to exert deadly force? harsh language?

A bat, club, lamp, knife, fists and feet, shovel, pitch fork, sword, staff, sais, nunchakus, etc.

I see the main problem in regards to the law is that both individuals left the house and the legal system construes that as one looking for trouble. Now if the individuals enter the home at any point then in is completely different. Just stating some info no opinion on this topic for now

 

I also see problems with the stupidity of the persons arrested in both cases. The guy decides to confront 5 (possibly armed) gangbangers by himself instead of waiting for the police in the first. Then when 20 more show up he decides to crank off warning shots?

 

NJ law is clear on #2. You must retreat if possible from non deadly confrontations. That's what his brother should have done if possible. Seems like the guy was looking for a way to escalate it taking it out into the street.

Why do you trust some of the law but not the other... What is your LOGIC based on? Because nappen said so? Give me YOUR reason for trusting the e exemptions listed but NOT the part of the law that says you may handle any gun in your home... To me you are ok with following the part of the law you are used to... But because the other part is not discussed to death you ignore it... All of the LAW have equal value... The law clearly says ANY gun... Not one you have a pistol permit for... And here is one for you... I move to NJ from a state where ftf Gun sales are ok... I own guns that are not in anyone's name... I shoot an intruder how do I prove it was my gun? Not my wife's? The answer is simple in NJ you may handle ANY firearm in your home...

 

One you took from an attacker..

Your gun when someone tries to stab you..

Your wive's gun when installing those new gun sights...

 

That is the LAW it is written there no twisting.. No interpretation... Simple black and white...I do not understand ignoring one part of the law and ignoring the rest...

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.