Well I just picked up 3 permits. One is for my scorpion. Other 2 are up for debate. I can't decide between sti spartan, steyr, sig p229 or 226, governor, beretta 92d, tokarev or p64 radom. Want to see the order people would pick

Using your list, I would put them in this order...

 

STI Spartan

Sig P226

Sig P229

P64

Makarov

Beretta 92D

Governor

Steyr M9

Beretta 92. But not the D model. I would opt for the commercial M9. Just because it's says "US M9" on the slide and because it has that ever so sexy straight dust cover.

 

Although you could find a D model with the straight dust cover.

Just curious... Why the 92D (which is DAO, or at least I thought it was) and not a DA/SA 92? I have shot the 229, the 226 and I own the Beretta 92A1.. and prefer the 92A1 over the Sigs. I just shoot better with the Beretta... so I'd pick that up if it were me. Sounds like you already have a 1911 (Sig Scorpion), so the Spartan isn't really necessary... I don't know much about the steyr or p64. The Tokarev is pretty cool... but I still prefer the Beretta over that. So my final vote is Beretta, as long as you go for DA/SA model!

Just curious... Why the 92D (which is DAO, or at least I thought it was) and not a DA/SA 92? I have shot the 229, the 226 and I own the Beretta 92A1.. and prefer the 92A1 over the Sigs. I just shoot better with the Beretta... so I'd pick that up if it were me. Sounds like you already have a 1911 (Sig Scorpion), so the Spartan isn't really necessary... I don't know much about the steyr or p64. The Tokarev is pretty cool... but I still prefer the Beretta over that. So my final vote is Beretta!

 

 

Because the D model has an awesome looking smooth side slide (no levers).

Because the D model has an awesome looking smooth side slide (no levers).

 

yeah, but DA only... I know the DA on my 92A1 is pretty heavy, even after lightening up with the "D Spring" mod... so that will affect accuracy somewhat.

I am really not a fan of external safeties. I can deal with it on a 1911 but otherwise not so much.

OK... got it. If that's your preference, then I understand. So on the P226 and P229, then you're looking at the DAK's?

If you wanna give the p-64 a try you're welcome to shoot mine. Makes a great little carry gun.

 

If I were you I would be picking up a tokarev and the p-64 baretta would be next in line after those 2 but def not a DAO version.

 

 

yeah, but DA only... I know the DA on my 92A1 is pretty heavy, even after lightening up with the "D Spring" mod... so that will affect accuracy somewhat.

 

Yeah, its a different animal. But awesome notheless.

 

Beretta makes a Type C PX4 that is basically a Type D that is half cocked. That is fairy unique an awesome too.

You don't specify which Scorpian - the 1911 or the P226, which begs the question: If it's the 1911 why would you want the Spartan also? And if it's the P226, why would you want a regular P226? I'd go for a little more variety before I start doubling.

 

Only other ones I'll comment on are the Governor - a solution looking for a problem. And the Steyr M-A1.

 

The Steyr has great ergonomics, a terrific trigger and the sights work really well (trapezoidal). I bought one of these the beginning of December (there is a thread on here about it). I had done my research and noted that they seemed to have problems with FTE's. Read further and determined that the latest generation supposedly addressed those problems, so opted to spend the extra money for one of those (as opposed to the PW Arms imports of a cancelled mid-east military contract - earlier guns - 2004 slides on newer frames, a lot less money).

 

Started shooting it at back-to-bacK USPSA matches. It was terrific....when it ran. Unfortunately, it only saw fit to run on 2 of 11 stages that weekend. Their customer service is good. They sent me a new extractor (which seems to have always been their answer for this problem. Makes me wonder how many designs there have been, or are there only two or three and they just keep sending them out hoping one will work?) I installed the new extractor (PITA) on Saturday, and if the weather cooperates, will be testing the gun on Wednesday with a variety of ammo. Already told Steyr that if this doesn't work, they are getting the gun back and I don't want it back until it runs 100%. Maybe I'll get lucky Wednesday - but I'm not holding my breath. Too bad, because this is a great gun when it works on that, thus far, rare occasion.

 

Good luck with what you choose.

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

I own three of the guns you list, P229, P226, and the 92D. I also have a 92FS Inox but like the 92D a lot more. I like the consistent trigger and shoot it a lot better than a SA/DA pistol.

I am actually leaning towards getting the tokarev and p64 first while they are still cheap. I am stuck on dao because that is what I am used to. I need to kick my OCD aside and move into the da/sa world. Especially since recently shooting a sa and loving it.

The scorpion is the 1911. I was going o get the spartan in 9 mm. The 226 or 229 would be one or the other, not other. I really like the 226 platinum elite

You seem to be missing the Walther PPQ at the top of the list... let me help

 

Walther PPQ

STI Spartan

Sig P226

Sig P229

P64

Makarov

Beretta 92D

Governor

Steyr M9

 

hth

 

:-)

 

TheWombat

You don't specify which Scorpian - the 1911 or the P226, which begs the question: If it's the 1911 why would you want the Spartan also?

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

 

Ummmmmmmmmmmm.... Cause all 1911's have big, brown, puppy dog eyes that can't be resisted and they all need a loving home.

 

C

 

 

Ummmmmmmmmmmm.... Cause all 1911's have big, brown, puppy dog eyes that can't be resisted and they all need a loving home.

 

C

 

After shooting one 1911 I look at it like having one 1911 is like having one pair of underwear. I will have many

After shooting one 1911 I look at it like having one 1911 is like having one pair of underwear. I will have many

 

Don't get me wrong, I was just asking. Your answer makes perfect sense. I have three 1911 platforms now and am waiting on the fourth - so I understand. If you had said they would both be .45's, I might question that decision.

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

I am taking the steyr off the list and adding the the ppq. Been researching the ppq and trigger has me really interested

 

 

Don't get me wrong, I was just asking. Your answer makes perfect sense. I have three 1911 platforms now and am waiting on the fourth - so I understand. If you had said they would both be .45's, I might question that decision.

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

 

Not all the same caliber. Only .45, 38 super and 9mm

p226 scorpion to match the 1911 scorpion

Ok updated list of choices. Tell me what should be next:

Sti spartan 9mm

Stoeger couger 9 mm

Zastava ported carry 9mm

Beretta 92 fs or m9 a1

P226

P229

Radom p64

Polish makarov

Colt delta elite 10 mm

Sig p6

Walther ppq

 

 

Like I said I really can't decide where to go next. The colt is a little pricey right now.

Walther PPS

Ruger GP100

SA TRP

None of those are even an option. I will just buy your trp when you sell it

None of those are even an option.

 

Your options suck

Sig discontinued the platinum elite. It's probably going to be harder to find later on.

I would say the 92FS or the PPQ.

 

The 92FS is an American Icon at this point. Its like a Remington 870 or S&W or Colt Revolver.

The PPQ looks like a cool gun.

Jesus, could you have any more choices!? And they are all completely different pistols.

 

I have an idea. You need to apply for about 8 more permits

Jesus, could you have any more choices!? And they are all completely different pistols.

 

I have an idea. You need to apply for about 8 more permits

 

Like there is anything wrong with that...

Here is my list...

Glock 23

Glock 17

Glock 17L

Keltec PF9---I know...I like it

Ruger MKIII

Maybe, just maybe Walther PPQ