Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

LEO or Lawyer question - firearms were taken away by law for non-crime related

Featured Replies

The question pertains to firearms being taken away or asked to surrender because of NON-criminal act. Let’s say defending yourself from imminent harm and danger in your home or someone files a restraining order. A civil complaint or someone pressing charges against you for non-firearm related matter. All non-criminal act or intent.

 

Will the law take away the firearms of the household or individual??? If my firearms were taken will my wife be able to obtain a firearm with her FID in order to have at least something in the household to defend ourselves (maybe bad guy retaliation?). Will she be permitted to purchase after the confiscation or not allowed? Will her firearms be taken (if she has any) b/c she’s in the same household?

 

My question spurred from this news http://mobile.nj.com...ntguid=ENiEbKwJ where relative's firearms were taken as well. And this post http://njgunforums.c...__1#entry443558 where his firearms were taken.

 

Does it automatically apply to household or just individual?

household and anywhere the defendant might have easy access.

 

Easy access sounds a little vague. You could argue that any friends or family could grant him easy access. Would they go so far as to confiscate the firearms of anyone associated with the defendant?

Have I mentioned lately how much I HATE the Statist culture in NJ. :facepalm:

I see something very wrong with this picture. If someone living in my house does something bad, the state has no authority to take my personal guns from me. If it is a concern that the person living with me can have access to them, I would say they no longer live there, throw all their crap on the curb and change the locks.

 

After that if they still take them, hire a good lawyer and go on the sue trail. This should never happen to anyone who can afford a good lawyer, as freedom from government trampling of your civil rights and legal protections is directly proportionate to how much $$$ you have to put up a good fight. Sad.

This kind of stuff makes you think maybe I should only have one gun, instead of a $10,000 collection that can be taken from you for just about anything.

The question pertains to firearms being taken away or asked to surrender because of NON-criminal act. Let’s say defending yourself from imminent harm and danger in your home or someone files a restraining order. A civil complaint or someone pressing charges against you for non-firearm related matter. All non-criminal act or intent.

 

Will the law take away the firearms of the household or individual??? If my firearms were taken will my wife be able to obtain a firearm with her FID in order to have at least something in the household to defend ourselves (maybe bad guy retaliation?). Will she be permitted to purchase after the confiscation or not allowed? Will her firearms be taken (if she has any) b/c she’s in the same household?

 

My question spurred from this news http://mobile.nj.com...ntguid=ENiEbKwJ where relative's firearms were taken as well. And this post http://njgunforums.c...__1#entry443558 where his firearms were taken.

 

Does it automatically apply to household or just individual?

A friend of my wife is currently going through a bitter divorce. Her ex husband filed a restraining order against her so she retailiated against him with a restraining order. The next day she found out that the police noticed that her ex husband legally owned a Beretta 92SF and promptly went to his residence and confiscated the weapon. My wife's friend was quite surprised since she never knew that her ex owned a firearm.

 

Bottom line is that a restraining order would trigger the confiscation of any firearms owned.

  • Author

Good to know... I guess bottom line is "it" can be taken away from you even if you have not committed a crime or someone in your household (or a buddy crashing at your place?) is the subject of focus.

A friend in PA had a "protection from abuse" PFA order slapped on his now divorced and physically violent with arrest record as such and cheating wife, while the wife sought retaliation by also getting a PFA against the husband. They were already living separately for couple yrs now. As soon as it was issued, cops came to my buddy' s house to collect the guns, and to give my buddy some good advice as the cops thought the retaliatory PFA put onto the husband was BS.

 

So, under these and similar circumstances, it can happen.

A friend in PA had a "protection from abuse" PFA order slapped on his now divorced and physically violent with arrest record as such and cheating wife, while the wife sought retaliation by also getting a PFA against the husband. They were already living separately for couple yrs now. As soon as it was issued, cops came to my buddy' s house to collect the guns, and to give my buddy some good advice as the cops thought the retaliatory PFA put onto the husband was BS.

 

So, under these and similar circumstances, it can happen.

 

 

 

This is what I mean. Even with no proof of anything, seems anyone could just say hay Joe over there did such and such, and there goes your guns.

 

 

What was the cops good advice? Never interact with another human if you want to own guns.

What would happen if you had shipped your guns to a relative in another state (before the police came to get them), or maybe you kept them there previously? Let's say, for argument sakes, they you took them to your son's house because you didn't use them anymore and he was going to inherit them anyway? Would they expect you to have them shipped back to your local police station?

  • Author

Seems like the thing to do is buy firearms that you wont mind giving up. Think of disposable. No more expensive or custom firearms! Disposable and reliable like Glocks instead of HK or custom 1911.

 

Will this make me buy less or stop from spending and accessorizing my firearms? Probably not :-(

 

A friend in PA had a "protection from abuse" PFA order slapped on his now divorced and physically violent with arrest record as such and cheating wife, while the wife sought retaliation by also getting a PFA against the husband. They were already living separately for couple yrs now. As soon as it was issued, cops came to my buddy' s house to collect the guns, and to give my buddy some good advice as the cops thought the retaliatory PFA put onto the husband was BS.

 

So, under these and similar circumstances, it can happen.

This is what I mean. Even with no proof of anything, seems anyone could just say hay Joe over there did such and such, and there goes your guns.

 

 

What was the cops good advice? Never interact with another human if you want to own guns.

 

Only if "Anyone" was married to, Dating, had a child with, lived with or was a blood relation to "Joe" Restraining orders require Domestic Violence complaints.

What would happen if you had shipped your guns to a relative in another state (before the police came to get them), or maybe you kept them there previously? Let's say, for argument sakes, they you took them to your son's house because you didn't use them anymore and he was going to inherit them anyway? Would they expect you to have them shipped back to your local police station?

 

I know of at least ONE superior Court Judge that has ordered a defendant to turn a firearm that she owns, that is kept at a residence in another state to her local PD in that state, or be charged with contempt.

The PA cops advice to my buddy was, just DONT go anywhere near your 'wife', once this PFA is lifted, you can have your guns back no prob. While this pfa is active, wherever you go, make sure somehow you can 'prove' it, receipt from store, etc. Incase the crazy wife accuses you of pulling up to her apartment etc...

The PA cops advice to my buddy was, just DONT go anywhere near your 'wife', once this PFA is lifted, you can have your guns back no prob. While this pfa is active, wherever you go, make sure somehow you can 'prove' it, receipt from store, etc. Incase the crazy wife accuses you of pulling up to her apartment etc...

 

Seriously? Guilty until proven innocent?

Seriously? Guilty until proven innocent?

 

To quote a famous band: "The land of the free? Whoever told you that is your enemy."

Seriously? Guilty until proven innocent?

 

Violation of Restraining order = a NO BAIL WARRANT.

It will cost you in the area of $5,000 to get the guns back also. That's what my friend had to pay a lawyer when his were taken.

Isn't an Order of Protection different than a Restraining Order in that it can be filed against anyone?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.