Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

When Handgun Repair = NJ Felony

Featured Replies

Four weeks ago our brand new S&W M&P45 FS went back to S&W because the takedown lever would not stay put, and for general frame-slide misalignment. (The takedown lever issue is widely discussed on the S&W M&P Pistol forum.) Because my FFL is conscientious, he sent the pistol back to S&W for me at no charge.

 

S&W returned the pistol to our FFL today with a letter stating they fixed the pistol by exchanging the frame. Voila: new serial number for us, old serial number destroyed. We had no advance notice this was being done.

 

Our FFL, after consulting with the SP Firearms unit in Trenton, determined that we need another PPP to (again!) transfer our repaired pistol, which is now considered new. And yes the 30 day rule still applies.

 

If I had not had our FFL send the pistol back, and done it myself, I would not have known this. I would have assumed the letter from S&W to be sufficient. Or at the most I would have advised Trenton my serial number had been changed. Silly me.

 

So be advised. If YOU send your gun back to a manufacturer for repair, and they change the frame out (i.e. change serial number) and send it directly back to YOU, you MUST IMMEDIATELY take it to your FFL and have them transfer it to you with the appropriate paperwork. Otherwise, upon discovery, you will be liable for an illegal handgun possession felony.

 

I just thought you might like to know.

I didn't think anyone but a FFL can send a firearm through the mail.

  • Author

The transport is irrelevant. I, and others I know, have returned handguns for repair through UPS or Fedex and received them back directly. All perfectly legal, at least for me.

 

Why? Because none of my (past) serial numbers were changed!

Since the frame was changed. That is the important fact that makes it a new firearm. It has a new serial number.

 

You can ship a pistol or a rifle to a manufacturer for repair or modification. I shipped one the Springfield and another to Smith & Wesson. Go to the FEDEX or UPS sites for the rules and regulations. No FFL, FID or PTP needed.

Had this happen with my G30 back in 2003 with bad frame.. after 4 weeks Glock sent me one with a prefix in front of the SN..

 

Luckily I was on good terms with the secretary in my former NJ township.. :) had it in 2 days..

Are you sure about that?

 

i guess i was wrong.. that is why i said "I THINK" .. :) .... i was told this a long time ago when i sent my beretta to Langdon to get a trigger job done ... but i guess it was wrong info.. nice how they got me for $50 to ship it... f'ers!

I don't think the statutes cover such a circumstance. The PPP is to purchase or receive a HG that you do not already possess. If you took one in for repair, and got one back of the same make/model, status quo is maintained. Nowhere in the statutes does it state you are bound by serial number except for the fact that it is recorded for the mandatory voluntary registration.

 

I think the NJSP is just playing it safe and saying get another PPP so there is an official record on file. Since HG's are "mandatory-voluntarily" registered upon using a PPP, it is truly the safest thing to do. God forbid they slap that frame with your SN on another gun and send it out. Not supposed to happen but mistakes do occur.

....mandatory voluntary registration.....

.

 

I've always considered myself a pretty good user of the English language. Perhaps I am missing something, but how the heck can something be both Mandatory, and "Voluntary"? Just goes to show you how bad the wording is in these laws...

If the serial number is different, then a new Permit is required. It is like you are getting new firearm.

 

However, one is exempt from the 30 day law, as it is being returned to the dealer for a replacement.. One could theoretically purchase an infinite number of firearms within 30 days if they have the permits, money, time and balls to do it.

 

Also, a new Permit is needed to get back one's previous purchased firearm that is now a consignment sale.

OP. I would hope that (so long as you have a good history with your local PD) you could get a PTPP and a 30-day exception in a couple of days. I would be very disappointed in any Chief who felt the need to put you through the full 30-to-90-day permitting process and then hold your feet to the fire on the 30-day rule under the circumstances that you describe; especially if you include photos/photocopies of all the evidence and a statement from your FFL.

 

Its worth a try.

So .. has anyone called the state police and asked them? They might have an opinion on the subject.

 

Tangentially, yes you can ship a handgun to repairs, or to a gunsmith yourself and then receive it back yourself. FEDEX/UPS have ways of dealing with this. Its been a while since I last did this, but you walk to a FEDEX/UPS counter (not at their "stores" through, a real one) you tell them you are shipping a firearm, show them is unloaded, and off it goes.

 

Of course then FEDEX/UPS leaves it on your doorstep unattended with no signature when they bring it back to you. What ? .. That's not the standard procedure? Oh.

So .. has anyone called the state police and asked them? They might have an opinion on the subject.

 

Tangentially, yes you can ship a handgun to repairs, or to a gunsmith yourself and then receive it back yourself. FEDEX/UPS have ways of dealing with this. Its been a while since I last did this, but you walk to a FEDEX/UPS counter (not at their "stores" through, a real one) you tell them you are shipping a firearm, show them is unloaded, and off it goes.

 

Of course then FEDEX/UPS leaves it on your doorstep unattended with no signature when they bring it back to you. What ? .. That's not the standard procedure? Oh.

 

PK90 hit the nail on the head with needing a permit, but being this scenario being exempt from the 30 day rule. I shipped a couple handguns last year from the UPS in Bridgewater and was not asked to unbox to show that they were clear. Just walked in, advised that I was shipping firearms, counter-guy checked the address (to verify they had an FFL on file for that address?), and off they went.

Yeah I have no idea what the current UPS counter dance is, if they follow it, or if they invent a new one for each customer or counter person. It has been 5-6 years since I had to ship mine back and forth.

  • Author

Vlad: The SP Firearms Unit in Trenton is the State Police. That's who my FFL checked with. They said new PPP required.

 

TheDon: I would hope so too. Expect I don't have a local PD and have to go through the local SP barracks to Trenton. Trenton just took four weeks to renew two existing PPPs. One of those will be used to get the M&P back. I will however inquire of the local sargeant when I apply for the next round of PPPs. It's clear now an extra valid PPP is never a bad thing to have on hand.

 

Regarding the 30 day rule, NJ 2C:58-3.i(5) provides an exemption:

 

"any transaction where the person has purchased a handgun from a licensed retail dealer and has returned that handgun to the dealer in exchange for another handgun within 30 days of the original transaction, provided the retail dealer reports the exchange transaction to the superintendent"

 

I was outside the 30 day window, so this didn't apply to me. But notice: this paragraph is only an exemption from the 30 day rule. It doesn't say you don't need a PPP for the new one.

Had this happen with my G30 back in 2003 with bad frame.. after 4 weeks Glock sent me one with a prefix in front of the SN..

 

Luckily I was on good terms with the secretary in my former NJ township.. :) had it in 2 days..

 

These days glock just sends you a certificate for a new glock to avoid these issues.

Vlad: The SP Firearms Unit in Trenton is the State Police. That's who my FFL checked with. They said new PPP required.

 

TheDon: I would hope so too. Expect I don't have a local PD and have to go through the local SP barracks to Trenton. Trenton just took four weeks to renew two existing PPPs. One of those will be used to get the M&P back. I will however inquire of the local sargeant when I apply for the next round of PPPs. It's clear now an extra valid PPP is never a bad thing to have on hand.

 

Regarding the 30 day rule, NJ 2C:58-3.i(5) provides an exemption:

 

"any transaction where the person has purchased a handgun from a licensed retail dealer and has returned that handgun to the dealer in exchange for another handgun within 30 days of the original transaction, provided the retail dealer reports the exchange transaction to the superintendent"

 

I was outside the 30 day window, so this didn't apply to me. But notice: this paragraph is only an exemption from the 30 day rule. It doesn't say you don't need a PPP for the new one.

 

 

 

It doesn't say you do either, does it?

  • Author

No, it doesn't.

 

"So you've got to ask yourself a question: do you feel lucky today?"

 

In NJ, my question really is: "Do you feel infringed upon?"

 

I guess to many the answer is self-evident.

As far as private individuals shipping guns via the USPS - long arms are fine. Handguns can only be shipped via mail by an FFL.

 

Two things: 1) If the gun is going back for a warranty repair, most reputable manufacturers will send a call ticket so it can be shipped on their dime; and, 2) If you are going to be on the hook for transportation of a handgun, it is often times cheaper to pay an FFL their fee to ship it via mail, than for you to directly ship it via common carrier as both FedEx and UPS require (policy, not law) that it be shipped via air. Combined FFL fee + postage is often less than common carrier air freight.

 

And, yes, when a gun is coming directly back to you, they don't always require a receipt signature. I found my 624 sitting on my porch after it came back from a recall at S&W. Be aware.

 

Adios,

 

PIzza Bob

I don't think the statutes cover such a circumstance. The PPP is to purchase or receive a HG that you do not already possess. If you took one in for repair, and got one back of the same make/model, status quo is maintained. Nowhere in the statutes does it state you are bound by serial number except for the fact that it is recorded for the mandatory voluntary registration.

 

 

But the serial number also goes right onto PPP at the time of purchase. If your repaired gun has a new serial number, you are kind of.losing the paper trail of your purchase, no?

So .. has anyone called the state police and asked them? They might have an opinion on the subject.

 

ATF did. In the old days, manufacturers kept stocks of unserialized receivers. If a receiver had to be replaced, it was possible to destroy the old receiver, then place that serial number on a virgin receiver. In that case, it would be considered the same firearm. That is no longer the case, and it would be considered a new transaction, as is leaving a wepaon on consignment. It also may explain some unserailized 1911's of WWII vintage that were suspected of being made of parts taken from the factories by workers a part at a time.

 

 

Of course then FEDEX/UPS leaves it on your doorstep unattended with no signature when they bring it back to you. What ? .. That's not the standard procedure? Oh.

 

These shiopments require an adult signature and cannot be left on a doorstep.

These shipments require an adult signature and cannot be left on a doorstep.

 

Mine was

Then it was done wrong.

 

Just saying that it doesn't mean it doesn't happen, and apparently it's more common than you would think. Sounds like Vlad G had the same experience and just think of the relatively small sample you are drawing from here. I mentioned it only because people should be aware that it does happen. I even requested that S&W notify me when the gun was to be return shipped - that didn't happen either. Surprise!

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

These days glock just sends you a certificate for a new glock to avoid these issues.

 

Not to be a ball-buster, but I wonder what other manufacturers out there have such a certificate system in-place, and what kind of numbers (frame-wise) are we talking about? Do THAT MANY of them (Glocks) break to the point of needing replacing? Not trying to stir the pot, just wondering out-loud....

But the serial number also goes right onto PPP at the time of purchase. If your repaired gun has a new serial number, you are kind of.losing the paper trail of your purchase, no?

 

You don't need a paper trail to legally own a gun, but it is a good idea to have one.

 

As I said in my original post, being our PPP's are also a "form of register" , I said it was a good idea regardless if it is required by law to use another PPP for the new serial number frame. Probably good to notify the NJSP that the old frame was kept by the manufacturer as well.

 

 

Not to be a ball-buster, but I wonder what other manufacturers out there have such a certificate system in-place, and what kind of numbers (frame-wise) are we talking about? Do THAT MANY of them (Glocks) break to the point of needing replacing? Not trying to stir the pot, just wondering out-loud....

 

I kinda thought the opposite actually, it can't be cost effective to fully replace a faulty pistol, I figured there couldn't be too many comin back if that's glock policy

Not to be a ball-buster, but I wonder what other manufacturers out there have such a certificate system in-place, and what kind of numbers (frame-wise) are we talking about? Do THAT MANY of them (Glocks) break to the point of needing replacing? Not trying to stir the pot, just wondering out-loud....

 

Not sure. But in my case (this was just about a year ago) I had to send my Glock 21SF 1913 rail pistol to Glock for a broken ambi mag release. The Glock tech called me a week later and said he can fix it or replace the frame with a new standard 21SF frame. I opted for the new frame well knowing I would need a new PP to get it back. Funny thing is I went down to the PD with my PP from the original purchase of this pistol and told them the story and that I needed a new PP to get my pistol back. They told me I would be fine because Glock will just put your serial # on the new frame. I already knew they didn't do that and I asked if I can just can an extra PP then. Sure, here ya go--Thanks. Fastest PP I ever got (15min). Or maybe it had something to do with me having a folder 4" thick of PP copies in their file drawer.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.