Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

How did this go under the radar? NY decriminilizes Child porn?

Featured Replies

I haven't heard too much about this, but I saw someone mention it, and looked it up on google, not too many sources reporting on it (by that, I mean sources like CNN, MSNBC, Fox, etc.)

 

From what I gathered, it's something like viewing is okay, downloading isn't. Still, isn't this sort of crazy?

 

http://www.thirdreport.com/third-report.asp?storyid=1272

Did they stop teaching journalists that they are supposed to cite sources or something? The article doesn't give one bit of factual evidence for its claims...

  • Author

Did they stop teaching journalists that they are supposed to cite sources or something? The article doesn't give one bit of factual evidence for its claims...

 

I just looked for one of the first articles, there are a few on there, but it really wasn't something I wanted to google.

http://www.thirdrepo...sp?storyid=1272

This is really the only thing I found. I'll use other search engines to see what I can turn up on this.

 

Forgot the quote:

 

Washington, DC – In response to the ruling of the New York Court of Appeals yesterday decriminalizing the purposeful viewing of child pornography on the Internet, Patrick Trueman, President of Morality in Media issued the following statement:

Child pornography is the photographic record of the sexual abuse of a child so it is a singular outrage that the highest court in New York State has decriminalized the act of viewing of child pornography by computer.

Children live with shame and hurt from knowing that a record of their abuse circulates on the Internet. Each time these photos are viewed, the child is revictimized. Some children never recover from the experience.

Child pornography should be treated as a very serious violation of the human dignity of the victims and those who take enjoyment from the despicable act of viewing such material should be harshly punished. What the New York court has done is to give permission to pedophiles and child molesters to continue the sexual molestation and recording of child sex abuse.

Edited by mgralley

Wow, just wow. I'd like to see a justification for this and the only remote, very very remote possibility is people who might click a link that directs you to something you didn't want to see in the first place, but other than that, I see no reason for this at all.

 

Oh and before any of you say anything, think of how many of you goggled up Dicks Sporting Goods (or what yo though would locate it) or tried to type what you though the URL was and didn't find what you were looking for on your first attempt. :icon_mrgreen:

You can watch all the kiddie porn you want but that ar better not have a flash surpressor. F**k new York.

Wow a lot missinformation and gut reactions in this thread. First, NY didn't decriminalize anything, it was a court ruling which is now followed buy NY actually changing the law to make more sense. Secondly the all the media has covered it, here is Reuters, if you didn't see it then I have no idea where you get your news.

 

I think the justification for the court decision is avoiding making accidental felons. Everyone has a gut reaction to child exploitation and most people will go to great length to stomp it out, but with like everything else we can over legislate something "for the children". There are three cases where this breaks down

 

If someone casually browsing for porn (weather you agree or not, the internet has pretty much made up its mind about that, and so has the supreme court) and unintentionally comes across something underage. Is that actress under age of or age? Can you tell? Is the viewer now a felon or not? The second case is someone actively hunting down the purveyors of child pornography. If you are a concerned parent tracking down perverts, and a lot of cases are found be parents not police, as soon as they view the offending evidence they are ALSO a felon. The third case, which had lots and lots of cases attached to it lately, has been teenagers sending naked pictures to each other over email or phone. We all know teenagers have sex, right? You think they might be naked, when they do it? Because we don't consider consensual sex between teenagers statutory rape, but if they send each other pictures, now they are felons for viewing child pornography.

 

So you might disagree with this decision, but in the last few years there have been a number of cases through the courts and news covering the issues above, and the law is not as crazy as it sounds. As you may note they changed it to make sure it only covers "knowingly access with intent to view any obscene performance which includes sexual conduct by a child less than sixteen years of age" which means it still does it job without actually being a trap, because that "knowingly" solves a lot of problems.

Well they need to get it set up quick. Last thing we need is a pervert haven next door

You do realize there is still a federal law that says exactly the same thing, and this mostly a political thing as no matter what NY does, it still a federal felony, right?

Which with the right scum bag lawyer could lead to something being tied up in the courts arguing whether it's ok or not.

I don't really get it. It seems to me that for a change our legislative/judicial system worked as designed. Lawmakers write bad law, courts throw it out, lawmakers write good law fixing the problem and still covering the issue. What is the problem again?

OK, here is the deal.

 

The court ruled that simply having 'child porn' in your computers memory cache alone is not enough for a conviction. The person must have been intentionally downloading it. Think of it this way. You get a computer virus, and this stuff pops up. Even though you immediately close out, it is still saved, unknowingly to you, on your computers memory. Are you guilty of a crime? Before, yes you were. This ruling says that isn't enough.

 

How many of you know for certain that there is nothing like this on your computer now? I bet most of you cannot answer that questions definitively.

Also take note that simply deleting the cache doesn't remove the files, it just tells windows to forget it saved something at that location...

Wow, just wow. I'd like to see a justification for this and the only remote, very very remote possibility is people who might click a link that directs you to something you didn't want to see in the first place, but other than that, I see no reason for this at all.

 

Oh and before any of you say anything, think of how many of you goggled up Dicks Sporting Goods (or what yo though would locate it) or tried to type what you though the URL was and didn't find what you were looking for on your first attempt. :icon_mrgreen:

 

I think you pretty much nailed it. You accidentally clicked a link. Or someone accidentally clicked a link. Or your wi-fi was open. You can always make a plausible argument for something where you aren't keeping a stash of downloaded porn, and the only records are ISP history of visited addresses and an identified modem. With the downloaded stash, the number of plausible stories goes down a lot because you have someone who owns a computer, and a pile of evidence that is most definitely NOT accidental. Most of the reasonable doubt circumstances that COULD lead to that scenario without the computer owner bieng complicit in the act will leave evidence usable in a defense, and claims to the contrary are possible to build a case against form a prosecution standpoint.

 

My guess is that this is not referring to case law, but rather someone has gotten all pissy about a particular case or a successful appeal and are trying to claim it is the new law. The reality is the courts can afford to prosecute a common pattern of cases not likely to stand up on appeal.

 

Edit: OK nevermind, for some reason when loading this only the first few posts rendered and I missed the reast of the posts.

Which with the right scum bag lawyer could lead to something being tied up in the courts arguing whether it's ok or not.

 

So it's ok for us to pursue our constitutional rights to keep and bear arms, but it's not ok for alleged criminals to pursue their right to representation by an attorney? We can't have it both ways. Either our constitution and laws apply to all of us, or none of us. We devalue our own position when we try to keep others from pursuing their rights.

Did they stop teaching journalists that they are supposed to cite sources or something? The article doesn't give one bit of factual evidence for its claims...

 

It's not an article anyone wrote. It's the repeating of a press release, so no editorial thought at all.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.