June 10, 201214 yr Since you are ONLY allowed to transport a handgun to places specifically allowed.. buying and selling, to the range, to a gunsmith, etc., if you have an out-of-state carry permit such as Utah, Florida, or Virginia, and you are en route to any state that lets you carry with that, is it technically unlawful for you to transport your firearm there, unless you are going to a range, etc.?
June 10, 201214 yr Interstate transport of firearms is protected by the Fed. Also, I don't think NJ could declare a place exempt or non-exempt if they don't have domain over said area (Utah, FL, etc).
June 10, 201214 yr To suggest that NJ law can force you to never leave the state with a firearm unless you go to an 'exempted' location, is asinine. NJ cannot govern actions in other states. So no, it is not technically unlawful. It isn't even technically illegal, if that is what you really meant. As stated, FOPA was designed for reasons like this.
June 10, 201214 yr FOPA was designed for passing through states with stricter laws than the origin and destination states. Legal at origin and legal at destination is part of FOPA but FOPA doesn't apply while you're in the origin state or destination state. I wasn't aware that buying or selling was exempt location. If you're in NJ and headed to exempt location... How do you prove it? Whether it's range, gunsmith or Virginia... It's up to you to prove your intentions. Time after time this same exact question comes up but time and time again, the point is missed. If you're in NJ with a gun and stopped by the police and your gun is discovered... Saying you're going to gunsmith, range or Virginia are all valid reasons to transport. It's up to you to prove your transportation exemption.
June 10, 201214 yr That is your opinion. My opinion is that FOPA does cover state of origin and destination, as long as your possession is legal at both places. Are you saying that he has to prove where he is going or he will be arrested?
June 10, 201214 yr Author So, if I am going to PA for a day of hiking and I choose to carry using my Florida Carry Permit, when I am driving through NJ to no specific destination in PA, just so I can strap it on once I get across the border, there is nothing NJ can do to me if I show them my carry permit and say I'm on my way to PA to exercise my 2nd Amendment right... I realize that the threat is miniscule if I am transporting properly, etc. and not stopped at Toy's R Us or something, or sitting in a school parking lot talking on my cell phone, but I am just wondering... And, how could you prove where you are going. Obviously if you were traveling east on 495 and you said you were going to PA that wouldn't fly...
June 10, 201214 yr Just say you are headed to a range in PA so that this thread doesn't go 20+ pages resulting in the same answers that has already been stated.
June 10, 201214 yr Author For me, specifically, it's not a big deal as I have a residence in PA, as well. But, I was just thinking about it. By the way, PK, maybe I overlooked it, but I don't remember this specific question being asked and/or answered. And, what's it to you if this thread continues? If it is redundant to you, etc., then don't read it.
June 10, 201214 yr FOPA was designed for passing through states with stricter laws than the origin and destination states. Legal at origin and legal at destination is part of FOPA but FOPA doesn't apply while you're in the origin state or destination state. . Stop spreading misinformation. FOPA doesn't say "origin state" or "desitination state". From the code itself. 18 USC § 921 DEFINITIONS The term “interstate or foreign commerce” includes commerc between any place in a State and any place outside of that State. 18 USC § 926A - Interstate transportation of firearms ...shall be entitled to transport a firearm for any lawful purpose from any place where he may lawfully possess and carry such firearm to any other place where he may lawfully possess and carry such firearm... Please read the thing you are referring to before posting incorrect assumptions about them. Whether it holds up or not, as you mentioned, is a different issue. But per FOPA, you ARE following federal law, and they SHOULDN'T be able to prosecute you. Can they? Sure. Will they? Maybe. Is the prosecution legal? Absolutely not. Are you legal? Yes! In case the code itself is too confusing. Interstate means anywhere in a state, and anywhere out of that state. So the interstate transportation of firearms would INCLUDE from NJ, to anywhere OUTSIDE of NJ. That whole travel, falls under Interstate transportation. Furthermore, FOPA specifically, says that you are okay, if you are traveling [interstate] where the carry and possession of a firearm is lawful when you start and finish your travel. You can lawfully carry and possess in your home in NJ, and if you have a carry permit in PA, you can lawfully possess and carry anywhere in PA. It further states that you are entitled to travel in accordance with this, for ANY LAWFUL PURPOSE. That would be a lawful purpose, so NJ exemption laws about transportation are NOT APPLICABLE! http://www.law.corne...de/text/18/926A http://www.law.corne...ode/text/18/921 Just say you are headed to a range in PA so that this thread doesn't go 20+ pages resulting in the same answers that has already been stated. Unfortunately that happens, because most of that is people having to correct misinformation that other people say. See above. The answer to the original question may be simple, but more often then not, there are answers given that are simply wrong. To prove a point, I'll play devils advocate. How probable is that answer (say going to range in PA) if you are stopped at 2am? Who's going to believe that then? And on and on it goes....
June 10, 201214 yr Real simple... The argument for or against FOPA protecting you at the origination and destination states all hinges around the definition on what "place" means in the wording. Some think it is as granular as your home/property, some feel it is the state in which you are starting or ending up as a whole. The bottom line is that there is no case-law available to clarify this. For me, I play it safe when it comes to HG's and traveling out of state. I always have a "plan" to go directly to a range while having the HG in a locked box while in NJ. I consider FOPA as my emergency catch net for the 'just in case'... That being said, IMO the best thing you can do if you do get pulled over and somehow LE finds that you are transporting a HG is to keep silent, let them arrest you if they must and contact a competent lawyer.
June 10, 201214 yr Real simple... The argument for or against FOPA protecting you at the origination and destination states all hinges around the definition on what "place" means in the wording. Some think it is as granular as your home/property, some feel it is the state in which you are starting or ending up as a whole. The bottom line is that there is no case-law available to clarify this. For me, I play it safe when it comes to HG's and traveling out of state. I always have a "plan" to go directly to a range while having the HG in a locked box while in NJ. I consider FOPA as my emergency catch net for the 'just in case'... That being said, IMO the best thing you can do if you do get pulled over and somehow LE finds that you are transporting a HG is to keep silent, let them arrest you if they must and contact a competent lawyer. Not really. By your logic you could never return to NJ with a handgun either, even if you are going to an exempted location. Because the second you enter NJ, you are not at that exempted location, and are breaking NJ law. But in actuality it is pretty clear, and I even quoted a definition that shows this. But using circular logic always works...
June 10, 201214 yr Not really. By your logic you could never return to NJ with a handgun either, even if you are going to an exempted location. Because the second you enter NJ, you are not at that exempted location, and are breaking NJ law. But in actuality it is pretty clear, and I even quoted a definition that shows this. But using circular logic always works... You are going to and from the range, when entering NJ you are coming "from" a range out of state going to your home in NJ.
June 10, 201214 yr Point ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ ^ Dan
June 10, 201214 yr By the way, PK, maybe I overlooked it, but I don't remember this specific question being asked and/or answered. And, what's it to you if this thread continues? If it is redundant to you, etc., then don't read it. Enjoy. Your answer is in here. I stopped keeping track last year. 9/24/2011 transport question 9/12/2011 Going to the Range without my COE 9/10/2011 Question about transporting 8/14/2011 vacation shooting 8/9/2011 Can I bring guns over state lines for target shooting? (NJ to PA) 8/8/2011 Transportation question 8/6/2011 FID Card question.... :-/ 8/2/2011 Transportation Question 3 7/28/2011 Transportation Question 2 7/25/2011 How do you transport guns, mags and ammo to the range? 7/13/2011 transport question 5/21/2011 transport Laws - Range bag, handgun in bag 4/4/2011 firearms transport 2/27/2011 Firearm transport while on foot (without CCW permit) 1/29/2011 transport handgun to parents' house from out-of-state for 1 week sta 1/4/2011 Authorization to transport Handgun to a Range 12/23/2010 FID for transport? 12/21/2010 transport Statute 12/12/2010 (Another) Transportation Thread 12/11/2010 Transportation 8/25/2010 transport to PA 7/14/2010 nj transport laws 7/12/2010 How strict is the "transport directly to and from the range" 3/30/2010 transport question 2/15/2010 How to transport firearms AND ammo? 2/9/2010 I understand that Transportation of hollow point ammo is 1/4/2010 transport Pistol to range questions 7/13/2009 transport and use hollow point ammunition in New Jersey! 4/23/2009 How do you transport your firearm(s) to and from the range?
June 11, 201214 yr IMO............Our elected officials ars so out of control trying to control everything NJ citizens do that they make criminals out of all of us.......shameful.
June 11, 201214 yr IMO............Our elected officials ars so out of control trying to control everything NJ citizens do that they make criminals out of all of us.......shameful. +1
Join the conversation
You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.