Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

S&W Model 10 revolvers on Buds Gun Shop

Featured Replies

Hey guys, just looking for some advice and guidance from some of you revolver afficionados... I was on the Buds Gun Shop website and saw a current deal for used S&W Model 10 revolvers... these are used police trade-ins.... Are these good revolvers? I own all semi-autos and have been thinking about getting a revolver. I really want an S&W 686... but for $269 these Model 10's look like a good deal. I know that these are just 38's, so can't shoot .357 with them as I would be able to with a 686. How do these revolvers compare size-wise to a 686? I have big hands... so not sure if these revolvers would be too small for me. They have both the round butt and square butt versions... not sure if one is better than the other. I have a couple of permits left that expire in August and not sure if I can come up with the funds for a 686 by then... so maybe one of these Model 10's might scratch the itch? What do you guys think? According to the website:

 

Yet another great Police Trade-In firearm from Budsgunshop.com

S&W Model 10 38sp Square Butt Grip.

Blue 4" Barrel 38 special caliber.

These guns are in 70%-80% with some holster wear, light scratches, and possibly very light surface rust on some guns from this lot.

6 shot capacity.

Very tight lockup and smooth Smith and Wesson trigger.

As always Budsgunshop.com guarantees function on these used revolvers.

 

http://www.budsgunshop.com/catalog/product_info.php/products_id/411545790

They are "The" S&W revolver. The only gripe I have with them is the sights, they are fixed and the rear is a groove in the top strap. But they are very solid and accurate

Model 10's are K-Frames which are smaller than the 686, which is built on an L-Frame. That being said, the grip frames are exactly the same size, so your hands wouldn't know the difference. They made model 10's in two barrel configurations - a highly tapered skinny barrel, called a pencil barrel and a heavy, bull barrel. If it is the latter, they are usually designated as: Model 10HB.

 

Round Butt, square butt, really doen't make much difference. The RB is a little bit more versatile, as RB enhances the carry characteristics and there are "conversion" grips - these are grips that fit the RB frame, but have the same outer dimensions as those grips used on SB frames.

 

Neither barrel configuration uses an ejector rod shroud.

 

The biggest drawback are the sights. These are fixed-sight guns. You have a squre-cornered trough cut in the top strap and a vestigal ramp up front on the HB, and a kind of half round with a flat facing the shooter blade, for a front sight on the pencil barrel. Adjustable sights on a Smith are more desireable - but the fixed sights are reflected in the price.

 

Police trades can be a good deal. They often may exhibit considerable holster wear, but have actually been shot very little - of course that is not always the case.

 

Ran across similar deal this AM on Model 64's (the stainless version of the Model 10HB). A fellow had five that he had hand-picked from a larger group (presumably police trade-ins). All had rubber grips - two Hogue square butt (or conversions), one Hogue RB, one Pachmayr gripper and one Uncle Mike's or factory. They were all DAO and all had bobbed hammers, He wanted $275 shipped to your FFL. Just throwing it out there as an alternative - I have no vested interest.

 

All of the above being said - if you truly want a 686, I don't think that you will be happy "settling" for a model 10 or 64, regardless of the cost saving.

 

JMHO.

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

  • Author

Thanks, guys, for the information. It is much appreciated. Yeah, the one thing I'm not too keen on are the fixed sights... I might just skip this deal and try to come up with a way to get the funds for a new 686. My permits don't expire till end of August so I have some time still.

Thanks, guys, for the information. It is much appreciated. Yeah, the one thing I'm not too keen on are the fixed sights... I might just skip this deal and try to come up with a way to get the funds for a new 686. My permits don't expire till end of August so I have some time still.

I was recently in a similar situation as well. I wanted the 686 but the cost was high and was thinking of going with a less expensive revolver. In the end I went with a 686. Just picked it up yesterday and I love it. Put about 40 rounds of .38 and 30 rounds of .357 through it and I liked it more and more after every shot I fired. If I had gone with a different gun I am convinced I would have been thinking about the 686 every time I fired it. The thought of that happening and my lack of faith in the stock market right now was all I needed to convince myself to spend the extra $ and get what I really wanted. My advice (for what it's worth) is to put the extra money together and get a real nice 686. I don't think you wil regret it but if you did for some reason you could probably get back close to what you paid. If you got a good deal to begin with.

Have you called around to check the used inventory at the local shops? I picked up a 686 @ the Bullet Hole a few months back for under $400. It was a consignment sale, I just happened to ask one day while I was there shooting. I've never shot a 10 so I can't compare but I can say the 686 is awesome, very accurate, and a ton of fun to shoot.

  • Author

Have you called around to check the used inventory at the local shops? I picked up a 686 @ the Bullet Hole a few months back for under $400. It was a consignment sale, I just happened to ask one day while I was there shooting. I've never shot a 10 so I can't compare but I can say the 686 is awesome, very accurate, and a ton of fun to shoot.

 

I remember you telling me about this a couple of months ago... What an awesome deal you got! Thanks for the suggestion... I can definitely try that out.

I got one. I bought it as a cheap 'F-YOU' to the State of NJ so I didn't waste a pistol permit. These are cop guns, so generally, they've been carried to hell and back but fired only once. The one I have locks up wonderfully and has little-to-no barrel wear. If this were any other state, I would just keep it in the car as a 'truck pistol'.

I have a early model 10 heavy barrel and the grip is much smaller than a 686. It has the stock wooden grips. If you have large hands, you'll need to change the stock grip to something like a Hogue.

I have a early model 10 heavy barrel and the grip is much smaller than a 686.

 

You can get any size grip that fits the grip ftrame, but the K, L & X-frame all have identical grip frames (RB to RB and SB to SB)

We have a K frame and an L frame (686) and I prefer the L frame because of weight. It's got a little more bulk than the K frame and so it feels more stable when shooting. They're both excellent revolvers, but IMHO the 686 is one of the nicest revolvers ever made. If you want one get it- it's worth it.

I bought a Model 64 from Buds, and I love it (it is a stainless Model 10). Mine turned out to be a 64-5 (last generation of forged parts, I lucked out). I love it, and do not regret it. I found it to be accurate enough with the stock sights, since at most I will be shooting is 50 yards. It had the VPA barcode sticker on it, which means it was from the Victoria Police Armoury.

 

Unless you really need the .357, I would just stick with the Model 10.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.