Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Looking to meet min requirement for NJ Transport to PA

Featured Replies

So if your home (or business) in NJ is your legal place of possession, one would therefore assume it's O-K to transport back into NJ regardless of whether or not you pumped one down the pipe somewhere in PA? I'm getting a headache again trying to follow this.......

 

But from what I've read from you (Vlad) and Nappen, this entire point is moot......

 

Dave

  • Replies 80
  • Views 5.8k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

FOPA covers you in a place where you may legally possess and carry a firearm

Point A) Your home in NJ

 

to another place you can legally possess and carry a firearm..

Point B) PA

 

this all takes into account that the gun is being transported for a lawful purpose (self defense IS a lawful purpose in America) and the gun is being transported according to FOPA rules...

 

To humor everyone.. I called the NJSP firearms division once... I said.. I am going to PA for a week or so and bringing my handgun with me.. (notice I SPECIFICALLY told them I was NOT going to a range.. that I was NOT going to an exempted location... that I was just "going to PA").. I then went on to acknowledge that I understand NJ has VERY strict gun laws and I wanted to make sure I did not violate them.. the women said you just have to check with PA because I do not know the rules there.. but the gun has to be unloaded put in the trunk away from access... I said is there anything else I need to do? that is it? she said no just make sure you check the rules in PA.. she was honestly confused why I even needed to ask this.. I felt the same way asking it to be honest..

 

How can you for one second grant a state so much power as to trap your personal property.. that you own..

"oh that $900 handgun you purchased? Oh PA recognizes your freedom and allows you to carry it? too bad.. we are not letting you leave with it.. "

 

the state can not hold your friggin property.... you just have to follow the rules..

Sometimes we wonder why people think gun owners are crazy... let me show you why...

 

you take a totally NORMAL activity.. like carrying a gun for self defense..

and turn it into a 3 ring circus of confusing nonsense...

paranoid.... making up stories...

 

"you can carry a gun legally in PA if you stage the car like you are going to the range.. and then stop at a range take a picture with a newspaper proving you were at the range.. fire exactly 9 shots.."

 

are you serious... this is why people think we are crazy..

 

STOP ACTING LIKE A CRIMINAL

STOP ACTING LIKE GUNS ARE BAD

STOP ACTING LIKE YOU HAVE TO SNEAK AROUND WITH THEM

 

unload the gun.. put it in a case.. and call it a day..

So if your home (or business) in NJ is your legal place of possession, one would therefore assume it's O-K to transport back into NJ regardless of whether or not you pumped one down the pipe somewhere in PA? I'm getting a headache again trying to follow this.......

 

But from what I've read from you (Vlad) and Nappen, this entire point is moot......

 

Dave

 

read my above post..

 

I do NOT believe for one second you risk prosecution traveling from a state you can legally have a gun in.. back home to NJ..

I do NOT believe it is reasonable to surrender that level of control...

 

I believe you can leave the state with your property.. and I believe if you transport unloaded in the trunk.. and dont look like some gang banger.. or act like a lunatic when pulled over.. the chance of it even being an issue are about 0...

 

YES if you get pulled over coming back into NJ.. and you start stuttering sweating and acting all crazy with eyes darting around when talking to the cop.. then yeah there may be an issue.. but not because you have a gun.. because you are acting sketchy and have a gun..

FOPA covers you in a place where you may legally possess and carry a firearm

Point A) Your home in NJ

 

to another place you can legally possess and carry a firearm..

Point B) PA

 

this all takes into account that the gun is being transported for a lawful purpose (self defense IS a lawful purpose in America) and the gun is being transported according to FOPA rules...

 

To humor everyone.. I called the NJSP firearms division once... I said.. I am going to PA for a week or so and bringing my handgun with me.. (notice I SPECIFICALLY told them I was NOT going to a range.. that I was NOT going to an exempted location... that I was just "going to PA").. I then went on to acknowledge that I understand NJ has VERY strict gun laws and I wanted to make sure I did not violate them.. the women said you just have to check with PA because I do not know the rules there.. but the gun has to be unloaded put in the trunk away from access... I said is there anything else I need to do? that is it? she said no just make sure you check the rules in PA.. she was honestly confused why I even needed to ask this.. I felt the same way asking it to be honest..

 

How can you for one second grant a state so much power as to trap your personal property.. that you own..

"oh that $900 handgun you purchased? Oh PA recognizes your freedom and allows you to carry it? too bad.. we are not letting you leave with it.. "

 

the state can not hold your friggin property.... you just have to follow the rules..

Sometimes we wonder why people think gun owners are crazy... let me show you why...

 

you take a totally NORMAL activity.. like carrying a gun for self defense..

and turn it into a 3 ring circus of confusing nonsense...

paranoid.... making up stories...

 

"you can carry a gun legally in PA if you stage the car like you are going to the range.. and then stop at a range take a picture with a newspaper proving you were at the range.. fire exactly 9 shots.."

 

are you serious... this is why people think we are crazy..

 

STOP ACTING LIKE A CRIMINAL

STOP ACTING LIKE GUNS ARE BAD

STOP ACTING LIKE YOU HAVE TO SNEAK AROUND WITH THEM

 

unload the gun.. put it in a case.. and call it a day..

 

THANK YOU! THANK YOU! Wonderful post--we must have "doubled". I feel / think the same way you do!

 

I'm beginning to think it's a full moon or something--the Tin Hat Brigade is on Full ALERT, lol!

Wow..

 

Some of you look way to deep into things. Your making it 1,000,000,000,000,000,000x worse then it is. Follow the transport law, and you'll be fine. Not everyone is out to get you or your guns. Relax, take some deep breaths and calm down..

 

I've been stopped on my way to PA on 78w.

 

(License reg, insurance where ya going blah blah)

 

Trooper asked; Any weapons?

 

Me; Yes.

 

NJSP; Where is it located?

 

Me; A pistol, in a backpack, unloaded behind my rear seat and a knife with a seatbelt cutter and window break on my pocket.

 

NJSP; Why do you have in weapon in the vehicle today?

 

Me; I have a CCW permit and can carry in the state of PA.

 

NJSP; Fair enough, I'll run your info and as long as your clean you can move on, just slow down.

  • Author

 

 

I am not afraid transport to PA under FOPA and did so this weekend without "stopping at a range"

 

My personal stance on the issue is in line with what Halbautomitsch posted. Below at bottom is a PAFOA post of mine almost identical to Halbautomitsch's post.

 

This all started for me when I got a beat down for posting my intention to tranport to PA under FOPA. I got referred to As a Felon. Risking the well being of my wif and children, risking loosing my gun rights forev, ect. After being told by an entire forum I am wrong in my thinking I got to wondering what would be the Minimal amount of effort to stay technically legal under the accepted activity exemption ( hunting, target shooting) hence my question here. I doubt I am going to follow it but nice to know or be able to post the results of what I hoped to outcome of this topic here would produce for someone who was looking to meet NJ exceptions.

 

The whole thread is here:

http://forum.pafoa.org/concealed-carry-145/179068-concealed-carry-kids-summer-camp.html

 

Below is My PAFOA post that got me banned for life:

Just to clarify I called NJ State Police Firearms Division. But I agree there word is not law... However it does give insight as to how they might handle this. Maybe...

 

I realize there is risk involved here but how I mitigate is to travel with targets, spotting, scope and shooting glasses. If questioned on the way to PA I intend to go Target shooting, if questioned on the way back I intended to go target shooting but got a headache would be my defense. I think the intent is relevant in a court of law as much as the action. ( what if the range was closed, you forgot the ammo, ect)

 

The most important is to give the right answer when asked. "where are you coming from sir with those handgun in your trunk?" " I am coming from PA where I went to do some Target shooting, see my targets/scope officer"

Once in PA the directly to clause is not longer an issue until I cross back into NJ.

 

 

  • Author

Wow... I just read some of the additional comments posted this morning.. It is refreshing to see som many of you agree FOPA is all the coverage you need.

 

I felt like a leper at PAFOA. After banning me that posted a sticy forbidding anyone from discussing FOPA transport. They are afraid someone will get arrested and sue the forum for advising it was ok.

 

I also called the NJ state police last week. I told them I live in nj and got job in PA. I wanted to take my handgun to PA every day for self defense as I had a pa ccw. His initial answer was just keep it locked in the trunk.

 

After I explained my concern about the allowed activities and I was not doing any of them we read the law together line by line.. He was trying to show me I could take it with me as he said but in the end said. The law does not provide for every possible scenario and I should consult a lawyer. I asked him if that meant it was illegal he said " I'm not saying that". I asked if he thought that. NJ police would make an arrest under this scenario? He said he most likely would not unless there was some other issue"..,

 

 

They banned you for that? Wow.

 

Well , welcome to this forum.

 

My brother has property in PA in Jim Thorpe where we are allowed to target practice , I have a PA CCW ( edited for correction , I am licensed to CCW in PA , as I have a Fla CCW) , and I often go to a gun store I like in PA. I plan to bring a few handguns there to get some gunsmithing work done this week. I have the utmost confidence that as long as I am transporting my handguns in an enclosed case unloaded I am FINE. I obey the transport laws in NJ and in PA. My starting point and end point are legal places for me to posses and use my gun . My intentions are legal. End of story!

you were banned because you did not stick to your guns.. no pun intended.. but the whole "i did some target shooting.. lying to the cops.. etc..." when you start down that road you are telling yourself you are in the wrong..

 

here is reality...

 

COULD a cop arrest you..

SURE.. a cop COULD arrest you for ANYTHING..

 

is it likely you would be arrested?

NO

 

is it likely you would be charged even if arrested?

NO

 

at the end of the day.. you are a law abiding citizen.. who has lived many years without criminal charges (or you would not legally have a gun)..

if you are carrying an unloaded handgun secured in your vehicle.. out of state.. my guess is in %99 of the encounters with police.. the conversation will end there.. and I ONLY say 99 because of that one in a million bat shit crazy cop you MIGHT encounter..

 

its your property.. you are LEAVING the state..

why does NJ law NOT state that it is OK?

 

because they KNOW that they lose control at the border.. and LOGIC tells us that there are other laws governing the transportation of firearms beyond a states border..

 

traveling WITHIN the stated.. from NJ to NJ then yes NJ law applies..

LEAVING the state.. FOPA applies... because NJ can not dictate your behavior in another state..

 

by the way.. your starting point.. IN YOUR HOME IN NJ... it IS legal to own and CARRY a firearm..

They banned you for that? Wow.

 

Well , welcome to this forum.

 

My brother has property in PA in Jim Thorpe where we are allowed to target practice , I have a PA CCW , and I often go to a gun store I like in PA. I plan to bring a few handguns there to get some gunsmithing work done this week. I have the utmost confidence that as long as I am transporting my handguns in an enclosed case unloaded I am FINE. I obey the transport laws in NJ and in PA. My starting point and end point are legal places for me to posses and use my gun . My intentions are legal. End of story!

I traveled to Maine several months ago with my guns to visit a friend and do some shooting. I did my due diligence,transported in a locked case and had a great time.No stress or over thinking. Sometimes we're the source of our own misery.

I stopped reading not even half way through the first page. :facepalm:

Did anyone bother answering the OP's question without judging him, questioning his intelligence, or bickering with another responder?

 

OP,

IMHO, you are being over-cautious. But I certainly understand where you are coming from. I do not know the area you are asking about very well, so I cannot answer your questions. However, there are some helpful people in the New Jersey Hometown Forum on AR15.com

 

OK, haters, Bring it on! :orc:

No hate. However, I think you should re-read the OP and the subsequent posts. I legitimately had NO idea what the OP was asking about with regards to "minimum requirement to transport from NJ to PA" Once it became clear that this discussion was about interstate transport and whether or not FOPA applies, he started to get some clear responses. It seems he was led down a path at the PA forum that his initial post was informed by. He had made assumptions that we could know what he was referring to because they(at the other forum) offered up their opinion as fact.

 

In the end, I think we got around to it.

wow..i didnt realize the level of paranoia was so high with some people here.

 

unload it, throw it in your trunk, drive to PA and dont worry about a damn thing.

Wow... I just read some of the additional comments posted this morning.. It is refreshing to see som many of you agree FOPA is all the coverage you need.

 

I felt like a leper at PAFOA. After banning me that posted a sticy forbidding anyone from discussing FOPA transport. They are afraid someone will get arrested and sue the forum for advising it was ok.

 

I also called the NJ state police last week. I told them I live in nj and got job in PA. I wanted to take my handgun to PA every day for self defense as I had a pa ccw. His initial answer was just keep it locked in the trunk.

 

After I explained my concern about the allowed activities and I was not doing any of them we read the law together line by line.. He was trying to show me I could take it with me as he said but in the end said. The law does not provide for every possible scenario and I should consult a lawyer. I asked him if that meant it was illegal he said " I'm not saying that". I asked if he thought that. NJ police would make an arrest under this scenario? He said he most likely would not unless there was some other issue"..,

 

I'd like to apologize if my post(s) offended you. It was not my intention. Today, we are calmer and now you have the NJSP to back up what we're saying here about FOPA. If the PA forum thinks they're right and the NJSP is wrong, well, I know who I would listen to.

Bottom line is there is no case law around FOPA being used as a defense in the situation of a HG being transported from one's home in NJ to PA for the purpose of legal CCW when being charged for unlawful possession of a HG while in NJ.

 

If NJ decided to try to prosecute someone under NJ law for unlawful possession of a HG while they are en-route to PA for legal CCW (in PA) of a HG, sure FOPA could be used during your trial while you are trying to prove that you are innocent. Remember, NJ gun laws... guilty before being proven innocent.. that is a fact.

 

What is unnerving, is that there is no prior case law on this matter, so whoever goes first will set that for us all. Its just that they will be staring down 10 years in pound town while they are trying to prove their innocence under FOPA with an NJ based judge and jury. Oh and sure you can appeal and take it up in Federal Court, etc. Just say goodbye to your savings, career, life, and whatnot.

 

Just food for thought. This is why I feel it is prudent to have a "going to a range" plan in place when transporting to PA.

Bottom line is there is no case law around FOPA being used as a defense in the situation of a HG being transported from one's home in NJ to PA for the purpose of legal CCW when being charged for unlawful possession of a HG while in NJ.

 

If NJ decided to try to prosecute someone under NJ law for unlawful possession of a HG while they are en-route to PA for legal CCW (in PA) of a HG, sure FOPA could be used during your trial while you are trying to prove that you are innocent. Remember, NJ gun laws... guilty before being proven innocent.. that is a fact.

 

What is unnerving, is that there is no prior case law on this matter, so whoever goes first will set that for us all. Its just that they will be staring down 10 years in pound town while they are trying to prove their innocence under FOPA with an NJ based judge and jury. Oh and sure you can appeal and take it up in Federal Court, etc. Just say goodbye to your savings, career, life, and whatnot.

 

Just food for thought. This is why I feel it is prudent to have a "going to a range" plan in place when transporting to PA.

 

Assume FOPA protects you. Assume the police and NJ courts/prosecutors agree that FOPA protects you. There will never be case law. Never, as it will never get to court.

I stopped reading not even half way through the first page. :facepalm:

 

and that is why you have no idea whats going on..

 

he asked for the minimum... and that is what he got.. there isn't one..

FOPA applies..

 

[/thread]

  • Author

I know I can have hallow points with me if going to the range or hunting but what about when traveling to PA while covered under FOPA?

 

I current carry hondady critical defense just to be safe because I was not 100% percent either way...

 

If a hallow point falls out of my range bag and I get stop cruising in NJ and the police see it in plain sight I would be screwed, correct?

 

 

 

OI! Here we go again!

I know I can have hallow points with me if going to the range or hunting but what about when traveling to PA while covered under FOPA?

 

I current carry hondady critical defense just to be safe because I was not 100% percent either way...

 

If a hallow point falls out of my range bag and I get stop cruising in NJ and the police see it in plain sight I would be screwed, correct?

......there you go again...... There is a convenient sticky on the right hand side of the main forum page, there you will find a simplified but comprehensive overview of NJ gun laws. Perhaps you should take the time to scan it.

Not that it is relevant because it is NYC, but is anyone familiar with beach v Kelly? A case where the nypd revoked the pistol license from a holder because he took his handgun to Vegas? NY supreme court upheld I believe. The finding was that his transport wasn't protected under FOPA

Not that it is relevant because it is NYC, but is anyone familiar with beach v Kelly? A case where the nypd revoked the pistol license from a holder because he took his handgun to Vegas? NY supreme court upheld I believe. The finding was that his transport wasn't protected under FOPA

 

I was staying out of this because the majority felt differently. But this is the way I read the FOPA.

 

The way I read it, the FOPA provides a resident from one state an affirmative defense against prosecution for a firearms violation while traveling through another state. The way I read it, the FOPA does not provide any protection to the traveler in either the originating or the destination states. Therefore, the FOPA would have no applicable provision for a person traveling from NJ to PA because he is subject to the firearms laws of both states while he is in those states. In the example of traveling from NJ thru NY to PA, I can only see the FOPA providing protection in NY.

 

IMHO, the examples cited of NJSP troopers letting people go are just examples of cool LEO who understand us and what we do, and they understand a person able to obtain a CCW permit is not a bad guy. They are using the FOPA as an excuse to let it slide. However, if you happen to win the Trifecta of an anti-gun trooper + an anti-gun persecutor + an anti-gun judge... I fear that you will lose.

 

I am not a lawyer, but I play one on TV.

 

The way I read it, the FOPA provides a resident from one state an affirmative defense against prosecution for a firearms violation while traveling through another state. The way I read it, the FOPA does not provide any protection to the traveler in either the originating or the destination states.

 

If that is the case, then please explain how people who bring handguns to the airport for travel out of state are not arrested on the spot? Newark airport is not an exempted location in NJ. According to this logic, there would be a lot of criminals on this forum, myself included. Legal at your origin (Home)? Yes. Transported properly while en route? Yes. Legal at destination (PA)? Yes. That's it guys. No need to make it any more difficult.

 

IMO of course lol.

If that is the case, then please explain how people who bring handguns to the airport for travel out of state are not arrested on the spot? Newark airport is not an exempted location in NJ. According to this logic, there would be a lot of criminals on this forum, myself included. Legal at your origin (Home)? Yes. Transported properly while en route? Yes. Legal at destination (PA)? Yes. That's it guys. No need to make it any more difficult.

 

IMO of course lol.

 

The FAA provides for it.

 

ETA:

I am not trying to make this difficult. I just don't like you telling people who come to this forum for information that the FOPA will protect them when it does not.

 

Precise example of the FOPA: The FOPA provides someone from VA driving to VT with an affirmative defense from from prosecution in the anti-gun states like MD, NJ, and NY as he travels through those states. The person is still subject to the laws of VA and VT.

 

Show me the black letters from the law that say differently.

:facepalm:

 

Paul, you keep doing the facepalm. Please elaborate. How the heck can the FOPA (a Federal law) apply to a NJ citizen while he is in NJ?

The Federal govenment cannot override state laws as they apply to the citizens.

 

ETA:

Specifically. If you are pinched by an ant-gun LEO enroute to PA and charged with illegal posession of a handgun under NJ statutes, how can your lawyer introduce the FOPA as an affirmative defense at your trial?

I think it is worth adding, that I always take my pistol with me when I travel to any state that recognizes my FL CCW. I transport it as specified in the FPOA. I do this because I believe that I have a greater chance of getting killed in an auto accident during the trip than getting pinched on a handgun violation.

 

I agree 100% with vladtepes:

STOP ACTING LIKE A CRIMINAL

STOP ACTING LIKE GUNS ARE BAD

STOP ACTING LIKE YOU HAVE TO SNEAK AROUND WITH THEM

 

I am just addressing the misinformation of the FOPA protecting you in NJ

listen here is the bottom line..

 

FOPA can either protect you in your state of origin, or it can not....

 

if it starts at your front door, then you are protected

*going to PA

*flying out of an airport

*going to a shooting comp in another state

 

if FOPA does not start till you leave your home state...

you could NEVER legally leave the state with a gun unless you were going DIRECTLY to a place of exemption....

 

FOPA does not apply till you leave the state.

then the moment you walk up to ticket counter at the airport and say I would like to check my handgun for my week long trip to FL

FL is not a place of exemption...

so at that moment at the counter while still in NJ it would ILLEGAL..

 

unless of course FOPA starts at your literal place of origin...

then you are as logic dictates.. protected the moment you walk out the door..

 

you can NOT have it both ways.. FOPS either protects you when you walk out the door or it doesn't..

 

nothing in NJ laws talks about airports.. or week long trips..

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.