Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Maryland becomes "Shall Issue" on Aug 11( how about NJ???)

Featured Replies

If Maryland can go from almost non existent "May issue" like we here in NJ to "Shall issue" perhaps there is hope for us as well.

 

 

http://mobile.fredericknewspost.com/displayNews.htm?storyID=138666&IX=0

 

After reading this I joined the NJ2AS today. I had been wanting to join for awhile but made excuses to join next month, then the next. If there in anyone who can get us a win here in NJ it is the NJ2AS.

 

http://nj2as.com

 

Nah. NJ is "different" don't forget.

Stop smokin' those funny cigarettes! It will never happen!

The population density is too high, people would be killed in job lots. Blood in the streets and all that.

I think it is a major step in a long long journey for us in NJ. No state wanted to be the first of the "may issues" to do this complete change. Now that it's out of the way I think others may follow, and after some time NJ legislation will realize the world around them is in fact changing. I think MD breaking the ice and being so close to us Is definitely going to be part of the future arguments in favor of changing our state as well. And some may say it may not carry a huge impact, but it is impossible for politicians and judges to completely ignore. But there is still a long road ahead.

  • Author

All hope is not lost... SAF v NJ (MULLER et al v. MAENZA et )

 

 

 

I think it is a major step in a long long journey for us in NJ. No state wanted to be the first of the "may issues" to do this complete change. Now that it's out of the way I think others may follow, and after some time NJ legislation will realize the world around them is in fact changing.

 

I think dozens of "May Issue" states did this "complete change" over the past 20 years.

 

MD was one of the last, not the first. There aren't many left.

I think dozens of "May Issue" states did this "complete change" over the past 20 years.

 

MD was one of the last, not the first. There aren't many left.

 

@JFoster, and yes thats another one as of lately that is definitely a small step in the right direction for us. But as you say Mipafox, I don't have any hard facts on which states changed and when, I would love to be enlightened tho if you could inform us on which states were very very staunchly committed to "may issue" and changed. I joined the military at 18 and lived in North Carolina until about 2 years ago that's as far back as I have been concerned with this issue. But, when i refer to states that were a "May Issue" and did a "Complete Change" as you kindly quoted, I am not talking about midwest states that had the May Issue clause but still pretty much gave to a decent percentage of people. Im talking about states were "shall issue" basically means NO ISSUE or SLIM CHANCE ISSUE. I honestly don't think there have been that many of these states. Also when you slap a window of 20 years on anything, there is going to be lots of states that of course have changed gun laws or matter of fact any laws regarding anything and everything with a window that pig. So a window that big is sort of irrelevant. I dont think a state that changed their policy 20 years ago is in any way shape or form relevant to the political environment we are in now. States that have changed i would say in the last 5 years would be relevant to our case, and those i would suspect are VERY FEW. So a state doing so in this current environment is a sign of slight hope and definitely isnt going to be something thats ignored by decision makers. What they are going to ignore is the changes from states you speak of that happened 20 years ago, but not ones 1 year ago.

 

and as a note, i may come off as hostile but i debate often and it's all in good debate. i dont do the whole flame crap

I don't have any hard facts on which states changed and when, I would love to be enlightened tho if you could inform us on which states were very very staunchly committed to "may issue" and changed

 

ccw.gif

@Malsua, wow that awesome! Thank you for that, very informative. So it looks like 1990-1996 was when most of the states in the country changed into "shall issues". I would assume that a large majority of them still issued to most applicants regardless of their prior "may issue" status and just made the change since they were pro-gun states and mostly issuing anyways. That was probably the first time the issue even ever came to the courts or major politics and all the states that were going to change went and did so in a few big groups. Then the states that remained were those in which changing the law would be a more difficult issue. It was also at this time in which gun-violence in America became more public than ever, and strong oppositions towards the issue began to deepen amongst most of the may-issue states. The LA North Hollywood Bank shootout in 1997 and then Columbine Massacre in 1999.

 

Then since 2003 there has been about 2 states that have made the change. 2003 Time frame and soon after is most consistent with current thoughts on gun control opposed to 1990-1996. So any progress since 2003 is going to be more significant progress.

@Malsua, wow that awesome! Thank you for that, very informative. So it looks like 1990-1996 was when most of the states in the country changed into "shall issues"

 

Also keep in mind that this was the time when the Federal AWB was in full effect. If you can only sell guns with 10 round magazines, why not make the guns smaller? Why not make them thinner? Why not lobby state legislatures for carry so that you can keep selling guns?

 

I wouldn't be surprised if there was an economic component to this as well. That was around the time when smoking bans started up and states were losing money from tobacco sales. I'm sure that some of the money I sent to Florida went into the state coffers.

 

It kind of blows my mind that NJ would give up the potential for millions in revenue out of fear.

 

It seems like about roughly 5% of the population in any state chooses to carry in shall-issue states. If you figure that NJ has 1.2 million gun owners, that would equate to 60,000 carry permits. I would gladly pay $100 a year to carry in NJ which would equate to an extra $6,000,000 per year for the state. or roughly 120 new state troopers, or 171 new teachers.

Great Map, would love to see the impact to some of the crime statistics in each of the states Pre-Issue vs. Post Issue.

Great Map, would love to see the impact to some of the crime statistics in each of the states Pre-Issue vs. Post Issue.

 

I think statistics would not be good determining factors tho. Its not an isolated test environment where you can prove that cause A is directly related to effect B. Over thousands of factors influence crime, too many to determine if the spike or decrease in crime was influenced in a negative or even a positive way due to the law change. simple population increase raises crime for example

All hope is not lost... SAF v NJ (MULLER et al v. MAENZA et )

 

Means nothing!

All hope is not lost... SAF v NJ (MULLER et al v. MAENZA et )

Means nothing!

 

Que?

 

That is the case challenging NJ's carry law in federal court. You can't say it means "nothing". :punish:

That map is wrong new jersey was always in the red. And still is...... In the Red.

That map is wrong new jersey was always in the red. And still is...... In the Red.

 

I think you have a misunderstanding of what the colors mean. Red means that there is no legal possibility of carry, "justifiable need" or not. NJ has the possibility, it's just a very, very low chance of receiving one.

@Malsua, wow that awesome! Thank you for that, very informative. So it looks like 1990-1996 was when most of the states in the country changed into "shall issues". I would assume that a large majority of them still issued to most applicants regardless of their prior "may issue" status and just made the change since they were pro-gun states and mostly issuing anyways. That was probably the first time the issue even ever came to the courts or major politics and all the states that were going to change went and did so in a few big groups. Then the states that remained were those in which changing the law would be a more difficult issue. It was also at this time in which gun-violence in America became more public than ever, and strong oppositions towards the issue began to deepen amongst most of the may-issue states. The LA North Hollywood Bank shootout in 1997 and then Columbine Massacre in 1999.

 

Then since 2003 there has been about 2 states that have made the change. 2003 Time frame and soon after is most consistent with current thoughts on gun control opposed to 1990-1996. So any progress since 2003 is going to be more significant progress.

 

Big changes from may issue/no issue to shall issue came about in the 1991-1996 period because of Luby's massacre in Texas. And all the work done by Suzanna Hupp.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.