Just wondering if it's true that cowboy 357 loads have less recoil than standard 357.

Many of these cowboy loads have the same 158 grains.

Is it all hype or true?

Sure they both could have a 158gr bullet, but how much powder is behind a standard magnum load and a cowboy load?

From what I understand, cowboy loads are loaded "softer" with either a reduced charge or a softer shooting powder. Trail Boss is one that is used a lot for it. The bullet weight is the same (158gn) but the velocity is not. It will be traveling a lot slower. Not bad for summer time (just a t-shirt) but for winter with heavy jackets and such, maybe not such a good idea.

 

I also have to say that I agree with several "experts" out there that handloads for HD are not a good idea for a couple of reasons. 1 because the chance of it not going "boom" is greater with handloads, and 2 because from a prosecutorial/litigation standpoint, it gives the prosecution a LOT of room to make a case. You know "He loaded it for killing, your honor". Not good.

 

C

I recall hearing that there is no power factor in CAS - if someone on here is involved in it, would you please confirm or correct? Even if they do, it is a very low power factor. Even though I wouldn't want to be hit by any projectile launched from a firearm, cowboy loads are a poor choice for home/self defense.

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

On a slightly related note, I ordered some .38 special 158g LSWC reloads from Georgia Arms a few months ago. They came in 50 round bags that said "Cowboy action .38 special" or something similar on them. No mention of the "Cowboy" designation on the website.

It is very soft and very smokey.

I am not complaining at all, what with the $11 per 50 price tag, just saying.

I am saving them for outdoor shooting.

I would expect .357 Cowboy to also be soft and smokey.