Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Repeal of one gun a month law

Featured Replies

Saw this online from NBC news in Washington,

Virginia Woman Pleads Guilty to Multiple Handgun Purchases

 

Woman bought 31 handguns in two weeks to resell

 

(So they are finally starting to go after people that are breaking laws - its about time. The interesting point is the last line that says the VA law of one gun a month was repealed last year. Anyone know how that happened and could such a repeal happen in NJ?)

 

A Manassas woman pleaded guilty to violating federal firearms laws after buying 31 handguns over a two-week span at three Virginia gun shows.

 

Kimberly Dinkins, 41, pleaded guilty Thursday in federal court in Alexandria to dealing firearms without a license. She faces up to five years in prison.

 

Court records show that Dinkins resold all of the guns for a profit.

 

Federal law does not require a person to register as a firearms dealer for occasional private gun sales, but it does require a dealer's license if a person devotes significant time and energy to the sale of firearms with a primary goal of making a profit.

A Virginia law limiting individuals to one handgun purchase per month was repealed last year.

Federal law does not require a person to register as a firearms dealer for occasional private gun sales, but it does require a dealer's license if a person devotes significant time and energy to the sale of firearms with a primary goal of making a profit.

A Virginia law limiting individuals to one handgun purchase per month was repealed last year.

 

When is it actually determined that you have spent "significant time and energy"?

When is it actually determined that you have spent "significant time and energy"?

When you hit 31 :) She should have applied for her FFL.

It seems to me that we'll be lucky just to keep the laws we already have....repealing laws doesn't seem very likely in the current climate, unless it's part of a "compromise" in exchange for a new law.

 

Frankly, I'd rather focus on removing justifiable need to carry than removing OGAM. Unless of course removing OGAM also removes the Permit to Purchase a Handgun requirement as well (I always felt the pistol permits were just there to enforce OGAM). I HATE needing to ask permission 2 months in advance just to buy a handgun.

NJ does not grandfather anything so their logic is to Not repeal anything either with taxes or guns.

It seems to me that we'll be lucky just to keep the laws we already have....repealing laws doesn't seem very likely in the current climate, unless it's part of a "compromise" in exchange for a new law.

 

Frankly, I'd rather focus on removing justifiable need to carry than removing OGAM. Unless of course removing OGAM also removes the Permit to Purchase a Handgun requirement as well (I always felt the pistol permits were just there to enforce OGAM). I HATE needing to ask permission 2 months in advance just to buy a handgun.

 

Pistol permits have been around long before OGAM was passed, I say get rid of both.

 

 

Pistol permits have been around long before OGAM was passed, I say get rid of both.

 

I agree, scrap both of 'em....I just don't see any purpose AT ALL for the pistol permits besides being a means to enforce OGAM. I'm only 22 so I don't know the history firsthand...Anyone here know the supposed reasoning for pistol permits in the first place?

 

"Wanna buy a handgun? We'll take our sweet time approving you and then give you a 90 day window to buy one. After that, you automatically lose our trust again"

You need approval for the permit then again at time of sale with a nics check and some people have had a permit but denied at nics i think the p2p is a way of discouraging some people from buying handguns

 

Sent from my DROID RAZR using Tapatalk 2

 

 

Idk when I lived in va 4 years back it was ogam; but if you as I did have your ccw you could buy as many as you wanted

It seems to me that we'll be lucky just to keep the laws we already have....repealing laws doesn't seem very likely in the current climate, unless it's part of a "compromise" in exchange for a new law.

 

I could agree with this. But I wouldn't want a 5 round mag limit in exchange for CCW.

Idk when I lived in va 4 years back it was ogam; but if you as I did have your ccw you could buy as many as you wanted

 

I think certain people were exempted too, such as judges, cops, magistrates etc.

 

 

I could agree with this. But I wouldn't want a 5 round mag limit in exchange for CCW.

 

Oh jeez, me neither. The limit to 15 is bad enough, 10 is worse but at least stomach-able......5 is unacceptable.

 

I've seen discussion about a 5 round limit possibly applying to revolvers because of the phrase "ammunition feeding device," but it's my understanding that previous magazine limits only apply to semiautos. My question is, can the legislators somehow construe a double action revolver as a semiautomatic just because it's "one trigger pull, one shot" and the hammer auto cocks?

...My question is, can the legislators somehow construe a double action revolver as a semiautomatic just because it's "one trigger pull, one shot" and the hammer auto cocks?
Being the gods of our universe, and making up the rest of the shite they call our laws, would you be surprised if they did?? I certainly would NOT.

 

I agree, scrap both of 'em....I just don't see any purpose AT ALL for the pistol permits besides being a means to enforce OGAM. I'm only 22 so I don't know the history firsthand...Anyone here know the supposed reasoning for pistol permits in the first place?

 

"Wanna buy a handgun? We'll take our sweet time approving you and then give you a 90 day window to buy one. After that, you automatically lose our trust again"

 

I say scrape them also, but it's not about compromise, compromise's are just concessions.

 

 

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

it's not about compromise, compromise's are just concessions.

 

 

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

 

I don't want to make any concessions, but at some point we may have to look at damage control. Here's why: I don't think these Dems are going to let Newtown go to waste. They're going to try to capitalize on it as much as possible to pass as many laws as possible to curry favor with their anti-gun base.

 

In the past, the Dems have cried "compromise" and just taken rights away as a one-way street, but I don't think *all* compromises are concessions if we get something in return. For instance, I'd be willing to have NICS incorporate a mental health record search in addition to its current criminal record search. It shouldn't affect us law-abiding citizens too much (only make the NICS check take 2 seconds longer), and it might actually do some good (remember, the VA Tech shooter passed a NICS check because of inter-agency failure to communicate).

 

In return, they could remove the "justifiable need to carry" clause, or revamp the transportation laws so we aren't forced to live in a network of exemptions.

 

How would you feel about that?

I'll pass on the compromise. I've never since NJ holdup their end.

 

 

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD

I'll pass on the compromise. I've never since NJ holdup their end.

 

 

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk HD

 

^^^ This. ^^^

 

 

Sent from my iPad using Tapatalk

I don't want to make any concessions, but at some point we may have to look at damage control. Here's why: I don't think these Dems are going to let Newtown go to waste. They're going to try to capitalize on it as much as possible to pass as many laws as possible to curry favor with their anti-gun base.

 

In the past, the Dems have cried "compromise" and just taken rights away as a one-way street, but I don't think *all* compromises are concessions if we get something in return. For instance, I'd be willing to have NICS incorporate a mental health record search in addition to its current criminal record search. It shouldn't affect us law-abiding citizens too much (only make the NICS check take 2 seconds longer), and it might actually do some good (remember, the VA Tech shooter passed a NICS check because of inter-agency failure to communicate).

 

In return, they could remove the "justifiable need to carry" clause, or revamp the transportation laws so we aren't forced to live in a network of exemptions.

 

How would you feel about that?

 

You never compromise. Compromise for these people is for you to give something and for them to give nothing. Their goal is ZERO guns in private hands, they will never give you anything.Thinking otherwise is fooling ourselves.

Considering how the legislature responded during the rally, not sure you want to open this up right now.  You might go O-GAY.

I don't want to make any concessions, but at some point we may have to look at damage control. Here's why: I don't think these Dems are going to let Newtown go to waste. They're going to try to capitalize on it as much as possible to pass as many laws as possible to curry favor with their anti-gun base.

 

In the past, the Dems have cried "compromise" and just taken rights away as a one-way street, but I don't think *all* compromises are concessions if we get something in return. For instance, I'd be willing to have NICS incorporate a mental health record search in addition to its current criminal record search. It shouldn't affect us law-abiding citizens too much (only make the NICS check take 2 seconds longer), and it might actually do some good (remember, the VA Tech shooter passed a NICS check because of inter-agency failure to communicate).

 

In return, they could remove the "justifiable need to carry" clause, or revamp the transportation laws so we aren't forced to live in a network of exemptions.

 

How would you feel about that?

 

Isn't the mental health background check completed during initial FID and subsequent P2P applications? Theoretically, that could mean two mental health checks within 90 days (assuming P2P is valid for 90 days). That seems like a waste of time and money, and will make the wait for FID and/or P2P even longer.

 

Also, I would be very concerned about what the state would consider to be a "mental health issue," that's a very slippery slope. What is the definition? Could we as a like-minded group even agree on a definition?

 

I say no compromise. NJ is all ready highly regulated, there is no reason to add more roadblocks for law-abiding citizens. As has been stated multiple times, by definition criminals don't follow the law so additional firearm laws will do absolutely nothing to curb crime. Quite honestly, I am amazed at the number of people who don't seem to understand that concept---including our politicians.

Isn't the mental health background check completed during initial FID and subsequent P2P applications? Theoretically, that could mean two mental health checks within 90 days (assuming P2P is valid for 90 days). That seems like a waste of time and money, and will make the wait for FID and/or P2P even longer.

 

Yes, it is. I say scrap the FID/P2P applications, and just put the mental health stuff in NICS instead. Way faster, way less messy, way cheaper.

 

Also, I would be very concerned about what the state would consider to be a "mental health issue," that's a very slippery slope. What is the definition? Could we as a like-minded group even agree on a definition?

 

I don't know what the definition is. I say we use whatever definition is currently used during the "Mental Health Records Search" currently performed with FPID/P2P. If it needs to be changed, let's find out more and talk about.

 

I say no compromise. NJ is all ready highly regulated, there is no reason to add more roadblocks for law-abiding citizens. As has been stated multiple times, by definition criminals don't follow the law so additional firearm laws will do absolutely nothing to curb crime. Quite honestly, I am amazed at the number of people who don't seem to understand that concept---including our politicians.

 

You're 100% correct about the roadblocks, everyone on this forum has been through them. The anti's idea of "compromise" is just to strip rights and I do not support that.

 

However, I think we would all benefit if the mental health check was removed from FID/P2P and incorporated into NICS instead. The mental check would take less time and shorten the wait time in NJ.

 

(At the federal level, the pro-gun side could accept this to take other anti-gun items off the table.)

You never compromise. Compromise for these people is for you to give something and for them to give nothing. Their goal is ZERO guns in private hands, they will never give you anything.Thinking otherwise is fooling ourselves.

 

 

You're right, this is how the anti-gun side uses the word "compromise." We have to highlight this point, and remind the media what compromise actually means - that we get something in return.

 

Fooling myself? I prefer to think that I'm still slightly optimistic. I think discussing what we want in return for passage of some bills that might actually help (mental health checks could help if done properly) will be more effective than shouting "COLD DEAD HANDS!"

 

I don't think the time for "Cold Dead Hands" has come quite yet.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.