Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

legal to pin your own AR15 mags?

Featured Replies

  • Author

Three different things here.

1. The law does not say that a stock must be permanent. It states that it must not collapse or fold.

2. NJ law does not address a muzzle device; only that it must not be a flash hider or have a threaded barrel that accepts a flash hider. NFA Federal law states that permanently attaching a muzzle device to a threaded barrel eliminates the threads.

3. NJ specifically addresses making magazines compliant. See the following:

 

 

 

IMHO, if the magazine cannot be reverted back to a higher capacity, it is permanent. Reducing capacity by pinning is not legal.

 

the last line of your quote pretty much so says it and i dont see ya getting brownie points for both...

 

is a rivet a pin.. a black rivet in the bottom wouldnt be hideous..

i see quite a few 15/30 mags out there what has been done to make them "permanent"

 

it cracks me up because i could have 15 round pmags (if u can find em) un modified and slap extensions onto them in 2 second if i wanted but thats all legal...

  • Replies 73
  • Views 7.6k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

  • Author

That's of no relevance more me just talking out loud lol

 

Is a rivet then considered legal to the best of you knowledge

  • Author

http://midwestpx.com/product_info.php?cPath=27_78&products_id=356

 

how the heck do we have them as a vendor on here if they are supplying our entire community with illegal magazines???

 

im confused and i dont expect many responses to this as it is very contradicting to the entire discussion but if you wish to reply remember you can always PM me...

 

im confused and i dont expect many responses to this as it is very contradicting to the entire discussion but if you wish to reply remember you can always PM me...

Yea, you're right. You might not get any responses.

http://midwestpx.com...products_id=356

 

how the heck do we have them as a vendor on here if they are supplying our entire community with illegal magazines???

 

im confused and i dont expect many responses to this as it is very contradicting to the entire discussion but if you wish to reply remember you can always PM me...

 

Ty sells legal mags that are already pinned and assembled.

 

The rebuild kits are ok in some states (iirc California) to make modified mags out of.

  • Author

Ty sells legal mags that are already pinned and assembled.

 

The rebuild kits are ok in some states (iirc California) to make modified mags out of.

 

what is "ty"

  • Author

MidwestPX

 

ok a name...

 

alright so if he has them pinned and assembled why would it be illegal for me to do? thats where im not getting this whole thing??

 

and before you say it lol.. bring you guys up to speed.. the mags are NOT in nj they are in PA and will not be brought here till confirmed they are modified to meet the requirements of NJ law..

 

ok a name...

 

alright so if he has them pinned and assembled why would it be illegal for me to do? thats where im not getting this whole thing??

 

and before you say it lol.. bring you guys up to speed.. the mags are NOT in nj they are in PA and will not be brought here till confirmed they are modified to meet the requirements of NJ law..

I didn't read the entire thread before I answered your question in the wrong context.

I thought you were asking who "Ty" is...

I realize you were kind of asking who is he to sell us mags if they are technically "illegal"

Understood and I have no further answers lol

  • Author

I didn't read the entire thread before I answered your question in the wrong context.

I thought you were asking who "Ty" is...

I realize you were kind of asking who is he to sell us mags if they are technically "illegal"

Understood and I have no further answers lol

 

yes and no.. if this is illegal then why would this forum support it? i am missing something

 

but yes i was asking "who is ty" i thought it was an abrv not a name (like how i abbreviated abbreviation and now just wrote it out twice) lol

 

yes and no.. if this is illegal then why would this forum support it? i am missing something

 

but yes i was asking "who is ty" i thought it was an abrv not a name (like how i abbreviated abbreviation and now just wrote it out twice) lol

I believe it's because the water is soo grey....

Just like PK90 posted in regards to collapsible stocks... It doesn't state how it has to be modified, just as long as it doesn't collapse or fold.

I'm not familiar with the construction of a pinned pmag, but I'm under the assumption that the baseplate it modified to block it. If you remove the baseplate to unpin it may not be operable afterwards.

I have no clue though, just guessing.

I guess it all comes down the constructive intent.... You can buy illegal magazines and drive them back here, should the store that sold them to you have to card you? Should they be punished for you modifying or not modifying them?

I wouldn't want to be the test dummy in court though....

"Technically" they require the magazine to be permanently altered from the manufacturer. However, using a roll pin that is a little shorter in length then the width of the mag will work if you set it a bit. Then take some epoxy of the same color and fill the holes on each side of the mag so you can't see the pin protruding out. Then use a super fine nail file to remove the excess epoxy till its a flat surface.

The other option is using two rivets that go straight through the magazine housing. Check out www.colddeadhands.com for NJ's own Arms and Ammo. Click on accessories. Look for the AR 15 round mags.

 

  • Author

"Technically" they require the magazine to be permanently altered from the manufacturer. However, using a roll pin that is a little shorter in length then the width of the mag will work if you set it a bit. Then take some epoxy of the same color and fill the holes on each side of the mag so you can't see the pin protruding out. Then use a super fine nail file to remove the excess epoxy till its a flat surface.

The other option is using two rivets that go straight through the magazine housing. Check out www.colddeadhands.com for NJ's own Arms and Ammo. Click on accessories. Look for the AR 15 round mags.

 

i actually thought of exactly what you said!! to epoxy over the roll pin

 

1. it will look better (although i used black roll pins and you can barely tell)

2. it would make it a little more "permanent" (although the only thing stopping me is if i ever have to prove it, at least now you can barely se the roll pin)

 

also not questioning you in a challenging way but more of a curious way.. you seem very confident this is a completely legal solution. do you have any proof or experience? anything?)

There is no mention in the law of who must do the alteration; only that it must be permanent so that the magazine holds (and feeds) no more than 15 rounds. .

Tell them to try take it apart and/or load it. Doubt anyone will take a challenge that far.

 

 

i actually thought of exactly what you said!! to epoxy over the roll pin

 

1. it will look better (although i used black roll pins and you can barely tell)

2. it would make it a little more "permanent" (although the only thing stopping me is if i ever have to prove it, at least now you can barely se the roll pin)

 

also not questioning you in a challenging way but more of a curious way.. you seem very confident this is a completely legal solution. do you have any proof or experience? anything?)

 

 

Sent from John's iPad 2 via Tapatalk HD

Typos courtesy Apple...

The thing I've wondered about is how would one pin a magazine and still be able to disassemble the thing to clean it or replace a worn spring. I could use epoxy, pins, rivets and a spot welder to my hearts content but I'd like to be able to service the things if need be.

  • Author

Tell them to try take it apart and/or load it. Doubt anyone will take a challenge that far.

 

 

 

 

Sent from John's iPad 2 via Tapatalk HD

Typos courtesy Apple...

 

you could only hope right!!

  • Author

The thing I've wondered about is how would one pin a magazine and still be able to disassemble the thing to clean it or replace a worn spring. I could use epoxy, pins, rivets and a spot welder to my hearts content but I'd like to be able to service the things if need be.

 

and that is how we stimulate the economy, throw away-buy new

 

you can still clean them.. but you cant CLEAN them ya know.. only good thing is how reliable the pmag is

The thing I've wondered about is how would one pin a magazine and still be able to disassemble the thing to clean it or replace a worn spring. I could use epoxy, pins, rivets and a spot welder to my hearts content but I'd like to be able to service the things if need be.

 

Ditto

this is kind of blowing my mind...

 

just one last time...

 

in NJ.. ANY mag that holds more than 15 rounds is illegal by default...

you cant have it in any way...

 

if a magazine is modified so that it no longer has the capacity to hold more than 15 rounds.. . then it is no longer a "high capacity magazine"

 

a magazine that is modified in a non permanent way MAY still have the capability to accept more than 15 rounds... if it does.. and a prosecutor can demonstrate that in court.. you likely lose..

 

the solution.. is to permanently modify is so that the magazine could NEVER hold more than 15 rounds..

the reason that a brake.. and a stock are different is because NJ defines things in different ways..;. hi cap mag is defined specifically.. so you must play according to that definition...

 

 

also JUST hypothetically.. the reason that a retailer can sell mags to NJ with or without meeting the standard.. is because magazines are not federally controlled items.. so I do not think they technically need to abide by NJ law when selling magazines....

  • Author

the reason that a brake.. and a stock are different is because NJ defines things in different ways..;. hi cap mag is defined specifically.. so you must play according to that definition...

 

 

also JUST hypothetically.. the reason that a retailer can sell mags to NJ with or without meeting the standard.. is because magazines are not federally controlled items.. so I do not think they technically need to abide by NJ law when selling magazines....

 

i can not confirm nor deny that said vendor does it one way or another, if they did it the way that i said and that it showed in the video (no clue just found it on the tube of yous) and you and a few others who clearly know more about the law than i and others do and you are saying that that is clearly illegal... then how in the hell does this community continue to allow them to continue to be a vendor!?!?! knowing that every order they are potential shipping you federal imprisonment???

 

did i miss a HINT HINT/ WINK WINK somewhere along the line...

Look, this is a gray area because the statute says not a heck of a lot besides the capacity must be no more than 15. Temporary blocks have been both officially ok and officially forbidden. The details are in the administrative guidelines.

 

The reality is if it gets to arguing, with the right tools you can make a 40 rounder out of multiple ten rounders. So at some point you will have to argue what is permanent or not.

 

The federal mag ban was written more intelligently because it addressed manufacture as well as possession.

  • Author

Look, this is a gray area because the statute says not a heck of a lot besides the capacity must be no more than 15. Temporary blocks have been both officially ok and officially forbidden. The details are in the administrative guidelines.

 

The reality is if it gets to arguing, with the right tools you can make a 40 rounder out of multiple ten rounders. So at some point you will have to argue what is permanent or not.

 

The federal mag ban was written more intelligently because it addressed manufacture as well as possession.

 

part of my point, how far from experience does the law go to decide it is "permanent"... are they gonna take my mags to a torture test lab?!?! nothing is permanent i am a master technician in the eyes of BMW and very good with my hands and brain.. NOTHING is permeant to me lol...

 

i will roll the dice with this one, if everyone else has them the same way im not going any further

 

the real solution to this problem is fixed with a new zip code

Look, this is a gray area because the statute says not a heck of a lot besides the capacity must be no more than 15. Temporary blocks have been both officially ok and officially forbidden. The details are in the administrative guidelines.

 

The reality is if it gets to arguing, with the right tools you can make a 40 rounder out of multiple ten rounders. So at some point you will have to argue what is permanent or not.

 

The federal mag ban was written more intelligently because it addressed manufacture as well as possession.

 

there is no test case for what we are discussing.. therefore no one knows the answer...

 

with that said..

nowhere that I am aware of states that temporary blocking is legal...

there are on the other hand instances where temp blocking is specifically stated as being NOT ok...

 

so

nowhere does the state say temp is OK...

wording states permanently modified to 15 is OK...

 

with those facts.. there is only one conclusion to draw.. and that is this..

 

while there has never been a test case in NJ regarding modified magazines.. it is reasonable to believe that if you own a mag that still possesses the capability to hold more than 15 rounds (meaning the ability has not been permanently removed) then you run the risk of being that test case...

 

there is really nothing more to it than that... I would love to tell you a roll pin is OK.. but IMO it is not... as it can easily be removed thus allowing the mag to hold more than 15 rounds.. meaning the magazine still has the capability to accept more than 15 rounds.. and thus is still an illegal high capacity magazine (in NJ)

Double post. Whoops.

 

I don't mind buying a new magazine if an old one is toast, but it's the principle. A spring is cheap.

 

Also, I want to buy a straight USGI 20 rounder to use with my 16A1 AR I'm building. I would buy and pin it in the United States then bring it home. I just don't want to trash it in the future because I can't replace a worn or broken spring.

 

I could design something Permanent that allows spring replacement, but I would have to NOT attach the spring to the follower. The follower would merely sit on the spring. Not sure if that would cause problems.

I agree with there being a lot of grey area. That goes for most of the way NJ firearms laws are written. Hence this thread.

 

That being said, epoxying the roll pins in place is going to be pretty darn permanent especially if you can't even see where they are located.

 

Well, you might want to hold off on pinning them to 15 anyway. See where Christie goes with our new bills. Not to mention, Cryan's newly introduced refined NJ assault weapon ban calling for 7 rounds in rifles!!!

So the real question is..(. Maybe Ty can chime in here ) is it possible to alter the Midwest pmags so that they will accept and feed 30 rounds again?? Wouldn't that make them illegal ?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.