Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Legality of .22LR Pistol "AR" in NJ

Featured Replies

So in my other thread we discussed the legality of the S&W 15-22P and determined that it was illegal. Since I'm still looking for something similar, I came across the HK 416 .22 LR Pistol. I began talking to the shop owner and he swears up and down that this pistol is NJ legal. A cop was there at the shop as well and he concurred as well (but what does he know, right?). Since this pistol is very similar to the S&W 15-22P and that was determined illegal in NJ by the masses here, I need your thoughts on this HK before I pick it up. What say you? Magazine capacity is 10 rounds btw.

 

temporary_zpse2212103.jpg

 

Specifications

 

Caliber - .22 L.R.

Capacity - 10 or 20 rds

Mode of Fire - Semi-Auto

Barrel Length - 8.5 in (216 mm)

Barrel Twist - 1 in 13-3/4 in

Rifling Grooves - 6

Rifling Length - 13.78 in (350 mm)

Front Sight - Fixed - Removeable Post

Rear Sight - Adjustable - Windage & Elevation

Overall Length - 17.5 in (445 mm)

Overall Height w/Mag - 11.4 in (290 mm)

Overall Width - 3 in (75 mm)

Stock Style - N/A

Trigger Type - Single-stage

Trigger Pull - 6.6-9.9 lbs

Safety Type - Manual

Principal of Operation - Blowback

Muzzle Thread - M8x.75

Length of Pull - N/A

Sight Radius - 10 in (255 mm)

Diameter Rear Sight Aperture - .1 / .12 / 0.14 / 0.24 in

Front Sight Width - .06 in (1.5 mm)

Weight w/out Mag - 4.9 lbs (2200 g)

Weight of empty Mag20 - 6.8 oz (190 g)

Features

- Upper and Lower Metal Receivers

- RIS-Rail Interface System

- On-Rail Sights

 

illegal, the barrel shroud(handguards) and magazine outside the grip are your two evil features

  • Author

illegal, the barrel shroud(handguards) and magazine outside the grip are your two evil features

 

His response to the handguard issue, "It's not a handguard, it's a rail".

totally legal, but it needs to be in 556

It's not an arrest, it's a test case.

 

It is a shroud - you know, the shoulder thing that goes up.

 

Illegal.

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

It's not an arrest, it's a test case.

 

It is a shroud - you know, the shoulder thing that goes up.

 

Illegal.

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

 

This. Plus it's over 50oz (78.4oz)

His response to the handguard issue, "It's not a handguard, it's a rail".

 

NJ gives a partial definition of what they consider to be a shroud and it being a rail or not does not seem like it has any relevance..

 

(3) A shroud that is attached to, or partially or completely encircles the barrel and

that permits the shooter to hold the firearm with the non-trigger hand without being

 

burned;

 

NOT legal imo

 

 

His response to the handguard issue, "It's not a handguard, it's a rail".

 

His point? It has a shroud that completely encircles the barrel allowing you to hold the firearm with the non trigger hand without being burned. It's a barrel shroud for the purposes of the law.

 

Also is it under 50oz?

  • Author

It's more than 50 oz. I was just there talking to the guy again and I pointed out some of these items. I mentioned the weight, he said "its not a 223, it's a 22lr. Don't have to worry about that". I thought a pistol was a pistol, max weight of 50oz right? "not if its a .22". Ok, what about the shroud, can't have anything covering the barrel, he said the same thing again, ""its not a 223, it's a 22lr, I've had state police in here looking at this gun and they saw nothing illegal about it". So yeah, I think I'm going to stay away, even though there was a cop there before and he said it was fine. Who knows he could have been the owner's buddy or just clueless.

 

NJ, your restarted laws defeat me yet again...

 

"the shoulder thing that goes up"

"No, I don't know what a barrel shroud is"

 

In her legislation, but it's not important to know the details......

 

Didn't she also say the legislation included features from weapons that were used to kill police officers?

 

There's little hope for 'common sense' gun laws in NJ

Its very simply.

 

If you do not feel comfortable about its legality, then don't buy it.

 

Ten people will give you ten opinions, but at the end of the day, you are the owner.

 

My advice...do not take anyone's advice on this forum as factual. It will not hold weight in court. Most folks, if not all, already know that.

 

Good luck on your final decision!

It's more than 50 oz. I was just there talking to the guy again and I pointed out some of these items. I mentioned the weight, he said "its not a 223, it's a 22lr. Don't have to worry about that". I thought a pistol was a pistol, max weight of 50oz right? "not if its a .22". Ok, what about the shroud, can't have anything covering the barrel, he said the same thing again, ""its not a 223, it's a 22lr, I've had state police in here looking at this gun and they saw nothing illegal about it". So yeah, I think I'm going to stay away, even though there was a cop there before and he said it was fine. Who knows he could have been the owner's buddy or just clueless.

 

You can't really blame this one on the way the law is written. It is clarified in the NJAC and is pretty straightforward on what a disqualifying feature is. This gun clearly has three disqualifying features = shroud, weight, mag outside the grip. The guy behind the gun counter is an idiot and you should out him and/or the name of the LGS - he's going to get somebody jammed-up and I doubt he'll pay their attorney fees nor serve their time in jail. If you actually go back there again, ask him to show you in the law where it exempts rimfires - for that matter, make a little money and bet him he can't find it.

 

Know the law yourself and be comfortable with what you're buying. Do not depend on the LGS to be your source on what is and isn't legal (PX90 exempted, of course).

 

Adios,

 

Pizza Bob

Its very simply.

 

If you do not feel comfortable about its legality, then don't buy it.

 

Ten people will give you ten opinions, but at the end of the day, you are the owner.

 

My advice...do not take anyone's advice on this forum as factual. It will not hold weight in court. Most folks, if not all, already know that.

 

Good luck on your final decision!

 

there are some parts of the law that are opinion...

but some of it is VERY factual.. this is all factual.. the gun is not NJ legal..

"No, I don't know what a barrel shroud is"

 

In her legislation, but it's not important to know the details......

 

Didn't she also say the legislation included features from weapons that were used to kill police officers?

 

There's little hope for 'common sense' gun laws in NJ

 

It is so nice to go to a gun store and only worry about price. :)

Weight, weight, weight. This stops almost every "cool" handgun from being legal in nj. Includes the vz58 pistol currently being made. One exception was a 223 pistol, ar type that weighed 46 ounces.

Weight, weight, weight. This stops almost every "cool" handgun from being legal in nj. Includes the vz58 pistol currently being made. One exception was a 223 pistol, ar type that weighed 46 ounces.
you mean the carbon 15

Weight, weight, weight. This stops almost every "cool" handgun from being legal in nj. Includes the vz58 pistol currently being made. One exception was a 223 pistol, ar type that weighed 46 ounces.

 

Yes, but even those required running without a handguard (= shroud) to be legal

"No, I don't know what a barrel shroud is"

 

In her legislation, but it's not important to know the details......

 

Didn't she also say the legislation included features from weapons that were used to kill police officers?

 

There's little hope for 'common sense' gun laws in NJ

 

You DO realize that Idiot or not, Carolyn McCarthy had pretty much NOTHING to do with NJ's law...right??? The Federal Ban came several Years after NJ's was already in place

 

 

You DO realize that Idiot or not, Carolyn McCarthy had pretty much NOTHING to do with NJ's law...right??? The Federal Ban came several Years after NJ's was already in place

 

The ag's interpretation that er now use came in 96 though, correct?

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.