Skip to content
View in the app

A better way to browse. Learn more.

New Jersey Gun Forums

A full-screen app on your home screen with push notifications, badges and more.

To install this app on iOS and iPadOS
  1. Tap the Share icon in Safari
  2. Scroll the menu and tap Add to Home Screen.
  3. Tap Add in the top-right corner.
To install this app on Android
  1. Tap the 3-dot menu (⋮) in the top-right corner of the browser.
  2. Tap Add to Home screen or Install app.
  3. Confirm by tapping Install.

Reloading for pistol ammo, Is it worth it if I mostly shoot 9mm and .38 ammo?

Featured Replies

I was thinking about getting into reloading ammo. I mostly will be shooting 9mm and .38 special and .357 on occasion. I shoot .22 but won't be reloading that. lol

Currently shoot range indoor and outdoor mostly paper but will be shooting steel soon. 

My question is would it be worth it for me to reload only shooting such few calibers? The presses I was looking at were Dillion and Hornady. Is this overkill for my needs?

 

Also please give me some current prices for bullets, primers and other items I would need to get started for these calibers. 

I only shoot .223 and 9mm....but ask me how much ammo I have and how worried I was during all the panic.

If you shoot a lot it will be worth it over time.  Rite now is not the greatest time to get into reloading as presses, dies, and other supplies are somewhat scarce.  In an ideal world where you can get the supplies you need it is indeed cheaper over time.  Unfortunately relaoding components are up higher than they should be so it takes a bigger innitial investment and longer to see a savings.  I mainly reload 223, 308, and 40.  I can tell you that I saved a whole lot of money over the years.

Ken

Just recently started myself. I only load .45 and 9mm. The savings on ammo was not the deciding factor for me, although in time I will recoup my initial investment and start saving. The main reason I got into it was for steel. I don't see too many of the better shooters using factory ammo, it's amazing the difference in recoil between factory 9 and hand loaded 9. I'm not one of the better shooters (yet) but I went from bottom third to upper middle third as soon as I switched.

You may save in the long run but that not what it's about for me any way. Making loads to suit me and my guns and the satisfaction of doing it myself. Plus I find it very relaxing and it's something to do during the winter. I use Berry's plated bullets for all my auto loading hand guns and Meister hard cast lead bullets for my 38's and 357's Lee makes fine reloading equipment that is value priced. And you will have no problem selling it in case you don't take to reloading 

For me reloading is always worth it. I started with only 38/357 and 45ACP. Now I will load just about anything that can be reloaded. For example, I just finished reloading a lot of 1000 45ACP 200HP plated for just under $180. That's less than $9.00/box. For you, let's see. How many rounds a year do you plan on shooting? You say you only shoot 9mm and 38/357. I would go out on a limb here and say "yes" it will be worth it. The market is currently getting better. Buying larger lots of supplies is always the way to go. Try and find a member here that is close to you and can step up to the plate to give you a better idea if it would be worth it for you. If budget is a consideration then a single stage press combo with a $500 budget would be a good start. If the reloading quantity is large enough then moving directly to a progressive press would be a better move. I prefer Hornady and Dillon presses over the others, I really do not like Lee.

 

As an example, 9mm reloading for 1000 rounds of say 115 FMJ would be $90 for heads, $25 for powder and $35 for primers for a total of $150 or $7.50 a box.

 

No matter what save that brass. It is and will be valuable whether you reload or not.

 

Hard to go over everything in this thread. But for me it is worth it. I believe it will be for you too!

  • Author

For me reloading is always worth it. I started with only 38/357 and 45ACP. Now I will load just about anything that can be reloaded. For example, I just finished reloading a lot of 1000 45ACP 200HP plated for just under $180. That's less than $9.00/box. For you, let's see. How many rounds a year do you plan on shooting? You say you only shoot 9mm and 38/357. I would go out on a limb here and say "yes" it will be worth it. The market is currently getting better. Buying larger lots of supplies is always the way to go. Try and find a member here that is close to you and can step up to the plate to give you a better idea if it would be worth it for you. If budget is a consideration then a single stage press combo with a $500 budget would be a good start. If the reloading quantity is large enough then moving directly to a progressive press would be a better move. I prefer Hornady and Dillon presses over the others, I really do not like Lee.

 

As an example, 9mm reloading for 1000 rounds of say 115 FMJ would be $90 for heads, $25 for powder and $35 for primers for a total of $150 or $7.50 a box.

 

No matter what save that brass. It is and will be valuable whether you reload or not.

 

Hard to go over everything in this thread. But for me it is worth it. I believe it will be for you too!

Good stuff. Very informative.

Right now I am shooting about 250 rounds every other week. Once the new range around the corner from me opens I would like to go a couple times a week and probably do at least 300 rounds a week. I have been saving brass since my last visit but probably only have around a hundred shells. I saw a couple of Dillion presses on their site and they looked fool proof to use. At first I thought reloading was complicated and you had to measure powder and hand crimp things and it took hours for a box of ammo. I can't imagine a greater satisfaction for a shooter using rounds he made by hand. 

Good stuff. Very informative.

Right now I am shooting about 250 rounds every other week. Once the new range around the corner from me opens I would like to go a couple times a week and probably do at least 300 rounds a week. I have been saving brass since my last visit but probably only have around a hundred shells. I saw a couple of Dillion presses on their site and they looked fool proof to use. At first I thought reloading was complicated and you had to measure powder and hand crimp things and it took hours for a box of ammo. I can't imagine a greater satisfaction for a shooter using rounds he made by hand. 

Better make that frangible.. And check with Tom if your allowed to use your own reloaded ammo..

  • Author

Better make that frangible.. And check with Tom if your allowed to use your own reloaded ammo..

Negative on reloaded ammo. Tom said his insurance won't allow it. In fact from what I understand is that they won't even allow any boxed ammo as well. All range ammo must be bought from them. He did say he hopes to change this once they open. It will really hurt his memberships if it does not change. I got in pre construction so my membership was pretty low. Thinking about joining CJRPC in Jackson in the spring. 

Negative on reloaded ammo. Tom said his insurance won't allow it. In fact from what I understand is that they won't even allow any boxed ammo as well. All range ammo must be bought from them. He did say he hopes to change this once they open. It will really hurt his memberships if it does not change. I got in pre construction so my membership was pretty low. Thinking about joining CJRPC in Jackson in the spring.

 

That's crazy not even allowing boxed ammo. Nobody who shoots a lot will step foot in that place. I'm surprised they let you shoot your own guns with that policy in effect.

Negative on reloaded ammo. Tom said his insurance won't allow it. In fact from what I understand is that they won't even allow any boxed ammo as well. All range ammo must be bought from them. He did say he hopes to change this once they open. It will really hurt his memberships if it does not change. I got in pre construction so my membership was pretty low. Thinking about joining CJRPC in Jackson in the spring. 

that is pure horseshit.

I would tell him to f-off if I could not use ammo that I purchased elsewhere/reloaded myself.

Join the conversation

You can post now and register later. If you have an account, sign in now to post with your account.

Guest
Reply to this topic...

Recently Browsing 0

  • No registered users viewing this page.

Account

Navigation

Search

Search

Configure browser push notifications

Chrome (Android)
  1. Tap the lock icon next to the address bar.
  2. Tap Permissions → Notifications.
  3. Adjust your preference.
Chrome (Desktop)
  1. Click the padlock icon in the address bar.
  2. Select Site settings.
  3. Find Notifications and adjust your preference.